What's new

Give us any Muslim name’: How authorities tried to build a false spy case against Nambi Narayanan

Imran Khan

PDF VETERAN
Joined
Oct 18, 2007
Messages
68,815
Reaction score
5
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
‘Give us any Muslim name’: How authorities tried to build a false spy case against Nambi Narayanan
In his memoir, the scientist who was falsely accused of selling secrets from ISRO programmes recalls the brutal and malicious interrogations he faced.
stutsgplef-1536912466.jpg

Former ISRO scientist Nambi Narayanan | Vicharam/Wikimedia Commons
11 hours ago
Nambi Narayanan & Arun Ram
The first to interrogate me were the ones who called themselves Satya and Dharma; two other men in vests and shorts stood behind me. It did not take long before I realised the two men had taken positions behind me to land blows on the small of my neck.

The senior began thus: “You are a brilliant scientist, an excellent manager, a national asset. So why did you do this?”

“What did I do?”

“Espionage.”

“What espionage?”

He cleared his throat. “Mr Nambi...sorry, Dr Nambi...”

“No, I am not Dr Nambi, mister suits me fine.”

“That’s okay, you are as good as a doctor,” the man assumed a satirical tone. “Now tell me why did you do this crime?”

“Please understand,” I replied. “I have done no crime. What is it that you really want?”

“Don’t bullshit. If you confess, your life will be easy; otherwise we know how to make you confess.”

That was the first sign of a threat.

“What is my crime?”

“You don’t know?” Now he stood up and sat down again. “We have proof that you sold the nation’s secrets, rocket technology to Pakistan. Now we want to hear that from your mouth. Tell us how did you do it? How much filthy money did you get?”
At this point, three others walked into the room. One wore a grey safari suit and was introduced by a thin, short person as “the biggest man in IB”.

Then suddenly, the thin man with a poke-marked face shouted at me. “You bastard, do you know what the charges against you are?” When I replied in the negative, he pulled out a paper from his file and started reading out the charges. I had sold sensitive rocket technology to Pakistan. This is an offence under the Official Secrets Act, punishable with a fourteen-year sentence.

Advertisement
Then, pointing to the “biggest man in IB,” he continued: “This great man has come all the way to hear it from your mouth. He reports directly to the most powerful person in the country. He has to return to Delhi soon, so you better confess everything now.”

It would occur to me only much later that the “biggest man in IB” was not really one, it was M K Dhar, the joint director of IB.

Now, I replied calmly: “I have nothing to tell you than the fact that I am innocent. This must be a misunderstanding.”

“No,” he barked. “We understand everything clearly. Now, tell us when did you first meet Mariam Rasheeda?”

“I never met her.”

“How dare you lie? She has told us everything. Come on, tell us the truth before we turn brutal. Accept everything or else you are gone.”

“Please believe me,” I said in a matter of fact tone. “I have never met these Maldivian women you are talking about. I don’t even know how they look. How can they say I met them?”

Advertisement
“If you continue to deny, I will bring Fauziyya here and make her slipper you. And that photograph will appear in all the newspapers.”

My mind was racing. What would be their motive? Why would the Maldivian women say they had met me?

The “biggest man in IB” and his associates soon left, and the prime interrogator continued.

“It is not just those two ladies who have confessed; your subordinate Sasikumaran also has. Now don’t try to hide anything.”

“What did you say?” I almost jumped from my chair. “Sasi has confessed? What is it that he has confessed?”

“So you are worried, Mr Nambi...” he smirked. “Sasi has told me everything...details of the drawings and documents of rocket science that you passed on to Pakistan through him, the several meetings you all had in Madras and Trivandrum, and how many millions of dollars you received.”

Advertisement
“See,” I assumed my calm posture again, “I don’t know what Sasi has told you and why. I am not worried about that. The point is that I have done no crime. I just don’t understand what you are talking about.”

It must have been night by then. A boy brought me some rice and sambar. I did not touch the food. Now, the two men left the room; another duo took over.

“Tell us, why did you do this?”

This set of interrogators were fresh, but the questions were as tired as me.

“You sold drawings of India’s Vikas engine and cryogenic engine to Pakistan,” said one.

“You clearly don’t understand rocket science. There are no classified drawings and no drawing has gone out of ISRO. Even if some get the drawings, they can’t make such an engine without active collaboration with us for several years. If you don’t know, India doesn’t have a cryogenic engine; we are still struggling to make one.”
“So you agree that you gave some drawings and documents?”

“No, I said nobody will buy your drawings and documents because nobody can make a rocket out of those papers. Do you know how we acquired the technology of the Viking/Vikas engine you are talking about? We spent 150 man years with French scientists at their facility in Vernon, France under a legal contract. We had hands-on training in everything including fabrication, assembly, testing and result analysis. In spite of all this we took more than sixteen years to make a Vikas engine. It is just not possible to transfer rocket technology by selling drawings and documents. Nobody will buy that.”

Advertisement
“Why not?” Now my interrogator was sounding not just absurd, but impervious to scientific explanation. “If Pakistan wants to duplicate Viking engine, can’t they do it using the drawings you gave?”

“Believe me,” I tried one last time to drive sense into this man who I was not sure was genuinely dull or just acting stupid, “drawings are not sufficient to make rockets.”

“You mean drawings are useless? Then why do you have them?”

“No, I said they are not sufficient. In the development of a rocket or an engine, drawings are but a minor part. Conceptual drawings are available in textbooks and journals. Nobody will pay money to buy them.”

A new team that came after the DIG’s lightning visit was more brutal. One of them shouted, “Get up, you bastard! You don’t deserve to sit anymore.” I stood up. I’d had no food all day. I had kept asking for water, which they gave. Now they stopped giving me water. They threatened to take me to a torture cell somewhere in Pathankot or Kashmir, where they said I could be killed and my body thrown away, without anyone asking any questions. “We would say that you escaped from our custody,” one of them said.

Advertisement
I visualised being killed and my body being thrown into snow- covered wilderness. And then, images of my father crossed my mind. I remembered his advice. If you face a crisis, he had told me as a child, be prepared for the worst. That night’s questioning by teams that came in shifts, not allowing me to sit or sleep for more than thirty hours, drained me. At one point, I felt a sense of coldness seeping into my body from the cement floor.

I felt dizzy, and thought it must be approaching death. It was easy to yield to it, end it all. For a moment I thought I should let myself go. But I fought back. I summoned that last warmth leaving my body, took deep breaths and stood my ground.

I spoke.

“You guys are committing a big crime, and you will be punished for this.”

Having bounced back from a point of ultimate submission to fate to a state of inevitable fight-back, I continued, “I will not leave you. Remember, you too have families.”
Suddenly I found myself threatening my torturers. Was that a flash of fear that crossed one of the faces?

Advertisement
“But you don’t know who we are, even if you do get out alive,” said one of them.

I said I would make sketches of each one of them, identify them, and hunt them down one by one.

Then one of them said in a tone of mock politeness, “Sir, we are doing our duty. If what you think is the truth and you stay vindicated, you can slap us with your slippers.”

Twenty-two years later, I have kept my slippers for them.

“When did you first meet Mohammed Aslam of Pakistan?” Now, what was this, I wondered.

“Who is Mohammed Aslam?”

“Don’t act. We know you are good at acting.”

“Honestly, I don’t know any Aslam.”

“Ok, let me help you.” The interrogator moved his chair forward, leaned a bit, and cleared his throat, and continued. ‘Mohammed Aslam is a well-known nuclear scientist from Pakistan. He came to India and struck a deal with you for rocket technology in 1985. Now accept it.”

Advertisement
I shook my head.

“I don’t know any Mohammed Aslam. But I want to know why Pakistan would send a nuclear scientist to get rocket technology. What’s the connection here? If India wants to do espionage on Pakistan, would it send APJ Abdul Kalam or U R Rao for that? Wouldn’t it be safer to send an unknown person? Does your story make sense to yourself ?”

The two men were by now appearing to be comical. They looked at each other, nodded their heads and continued. “You are right. We were only trying to see your reaction to such a statement. So you say it must be an unknown person. Who was that?”

It was now getting clear to me that these intelligence bureau men with visibly low intelligence had woven a story or an imaginary case of spying, but it was riddled with holes. They were seeking information to add muscle to that weak skeleton, with basic information about our working style and contacts. They wanted names, incidents and connections between them. They were constantly amending their story of fiction, and, in fact, I was inadvertently helping them make these changes to make their version a slightly less absurd one. I decided to stop clarifying and educating these morons, and stick to bare answers.

Advertisement
They kept asking for the name of the “unknown person”, I repeated that I had met no such person.

“Mr Nambi, you think you are smart,” he said. “But you should understand that we are smarter. We have more than twenty-five years of experience in interrogation. We have cracked tougher nuts than you. We pray for our daily bread while you bastards sell national secrets to enemies to amass wealth.”

The scene here was deteriorating rapidly – and violently.

Now two others entered the room. One, a short dark man in spectacles, came straight to me and started hitting me on the face. I stood still, receiving the blows. Nobody, not even my father had ever hit me. My mind was drifting in a sea of humiliation, confusion and sadness. I felt no physical pain.

The man who hit me shouted if I am afraid of anyone. The other officer sprang up with an answer: “Yes”.

Advertisement
I looked into his eyes and corrected him: “No”.

The man in spectacles looked bewildered, stared me for a moment and walked away with his associate.

The Panama smoker came near me and whispered: “Why are you getting bashed up? Why don’t you tell us the truth and be spared?”

“Because I don’t know any such person or any such deal.”

Now he was feigning to be helpful. “Don’t worry. You just give us any name. Give us a Muslim name.”
There, I thought, he was letting me in to the layers of his imaginary spy story. When I stood my ground, the officer said if I don’t go by their story line I would be handed over to some other team which would take me to Pathankot in Punjab. There, he threatened, I would be shot dead and the media will be told that I was killed in an encounter while trying to escape from the investigating team.

I asked for water.

“Unless you confess you are not going to get a drop of water,” he said. “You third rate criminal,” now shouted the subordinate officer, “you want water?”

Advertisement
My tormentors have taken out third-degree measures, I realised.

I had a choice: To stand by my innocence or yield to their designs. I was helpless, I may even be shot dead in Pathankot. But how can I tell myself, leave alone this bunch of goons who masqueraded as IB officials, that I could do anything against my mother land? After all, it was Vikram Sarabhai’s dreams and convictions that I followed to serve my country. I cannot let down Sarabhai, my father, my gurus and myself. I resolved to die if that was the way out of this mess.

The subordinate was holding a glass of water a couple of feet away from me, as if to lure me into parroting their cock-and-bull story. I got up from my chair.

“I don’t want water. I don’t want to sit any longer. I will stand here, without food or water, till you agree that I have done nothing wrong.”
Now the interrogators appeared to have been tired of making me tell things that went with their story line; so they decided to give a gist of their story so that I merely agreed. Having decided not to question or correct them, I listened as they gave me an outline of their creation:

The six accused in the ISRO spy case – Mariam Rasheeda, Fauziyya Hassan, D Chandrasekhar, D Sasikumaran, S Nambi Narayanan and SK Sharma – worked as a group and transferred rocket technology to Pakistan. Raman Srivastava was the leader of the gang that met on 24 January 1994 at Hotel Madras International and struck a deal with Zuheira, a Sri Lankan woman who acted as a conduit. Mariam and Fauziyya were funded by a Maldivian banker.

On 24 September 1994, money changed hands at Hotel Luciya, Trivandrum. Nambi Narayanan’s son Sankara Kumar received the money and handed it over to Sasikumaran at his house. This money was meant for floating a company to produce bullet-proof materials for export by Srivastava. Thomas

Kurisinkal, an industrialist based out of Cochin, was financing the operations. Aleksey Vasin, an officer of the Russian space agency Glavskosmos was involved in the transfer of technology. The plan was to use the drawings and produce Viking engine in North Korea with the help of Russian scientists. A company, a joint venture, was to be floated by Pakistan and Germany. These rockets were to be taken to Pakistan. Indonesia and Brazil were also involved in the deal.

When they summarised the story, I was not sure if I had to laugh or cry. Probably sensing that I was silently ridiculing the lack of logic in their concocted tale, the senior officer became blunt.

Advertisement
“Mr Nambi, we know nothing of this sort happened, but we want this story corroborated by you. All you have to do is mention the name of a Muslim friend.”

The cycle continued, with me naming Abdul Kalam and then Abubaker, my childhood friend who years later had come to me for help to get a job for his son in ISRO. I had told him that I would try if he qualified the written test. The boy did not.

All the while I was on my foot, refusing to take a chair, food or water. The two principal tormentors left and another man, who I reckoned as a Research and Analysis Wing (R&AW) officer, came in.

“You need not lie, just tell what you know. Also remember that we (R&AW and IB) submit different, independent reports to the higher ups. So be bold and tell the truth.”

I told him I have so far said nothing but the truth. After he left, however, I felt reassured. Also, sad that my organisation, ISRO, had not officially condemned our arrest. I wondered what Vikram Sarabhai would have done in these circumstances.

wjxlfmmwjf-1536930313.jpg

Excerpted with permission from Ready To Fire: How India And I Survived the ISRO Spy Case, Nambi Narayanan and Arun Ram, Bloomsbury.

Support our journalism by subscribing to Scroll+ here. We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
 
.
ISRO spy case: How a scientist cleared his name and continues to fight
Narayanan describes what he went through in his autobiography, Orbit of Memories. He suggests a motive for why he was framed, writing that he suspects the CIA was behind the false case.
nambi-narayanan.jpg

X
Nambi Narayanan in New Delhi on Tuesday. (Photo: Anil Sharma)
ROCKET SCIENTIST Nambi Narayanan has been fighting legal battles since 1994, first to clear his name in an espionage case, then for compensation and now for action against the police officers who had implicated him. Having had his name cleared after the CBI closure report in 1996 declared the spy case false, and his compensation upheld by the Kerala High Court in 2012, the former ISRO scientist is waiting for the Supreme Court to rule on action he has demanded against the police officers. On Tuesday, the Supreme Court reserved its judgment on his plea.

How it began
The “ISRO spy case” dates back to October 20, 1994, when Kerala police in Thiruvananthapuram registered a case against Mariam Rasheeda, a Maldivian national, under Section 14 of the Foreigners Act 1946 and Section 7 of the Foreigners Order, 1948. The initial charges were of overstaying in India following the cancellation of her flight to Maldives. Following her interrogation, police made out a case that she had contacted ISRO space scientists who were suspected of having transferred cryogenic engine technology to Pakistan through her. The following month, police registered another case against ISRO scientists D Sasikumaran and Narayanan, Russian Space Agency Glavkosmos’s India representative Chandrasekhar, Maldivian national Fauzia Hassan, and Bangalore-based labour contractor S K Sharma.

READ | ISRO spy case dented scientist’s reputation, will order damages: SC

The case was initially probed by Inspector S Vijayan. A special team headed by DIG Siby Mathew arrested Narayanan and others. The police case was that Narayanan and Sasikumaran had passed on secret documents to other countries, especially Pakistan. They accused Chandrasekhar, Sharma, and inspector-general of Kerala police Raman Srivastava of passing on secrets of the Aeronautical Defence Establishment, Bangalore. They alleged that Chandrasekhar, Sasikumaran and the two Maldivian women had met secretly to exchange papers and money. The arrested scientists were grilled by Intelligence Bureau sleuths, including Gujarat-cadre IPS officer R B Sreekumar, who was then IB additional director in Kerala.

Srivastava’s name created a political flutter as the IPS officer was known to be close to then Congress chief minister K Karunakaran. Under pressure from within the party led by rival A K Antony and Congress coalition partners Muslim League and Kerala Congress(M), Karunakaran was forced to step down in March 1995.

Probe & closure
Within 20 days of the case being registered, the probe was handed over to the CBI. In 1996, it submitted its closure report in the chief judicial magistrate’s court in Kochi, saying that the allegations of espionage were unproved and false. The court admitted the closure report, leading to the discharge of all those who had been implicated.

ALSO READ | CIA plot implicated me in spy case: Ex-ISRO scientist Nambi Narayanan says in autobiography

The CBI submitted that Mathew had indiscriminately ordered the arrest of the scientists and others without conducting a thorough interrogation or adequately verifying disclosures. The agency said it had not recovered any evidence from the ISRO or the money allegedly paid to the accused by their foreign contacts.

The CBI report also blamed the Intelligence Bureau for conducting the probe in an unprofessional manner. The IB did not verify the statements of the accused, which the CBI said could have saved the reputation of the scientists. The IB did not share with the Kerala police the basis of their allegations against Srivastava, the CBI said.

Continuing battle
The CPM-led government, which assumed office in May 1996, ordered a reinvestigation. Narayanan and others challenged this in Kerala High Court, which refused to stay the government order for reinvestigation. Narayanan then appealed in the Supreme Court, which quashed the state government order in 1998.

Subsequently, Narayanan moved the National Human Rights Commission seeking compensation of Rs 1 crore from the Kerala police officials who had implicated him. In 2001, the NHRC ordered interim relief of Rs 10 lakh. In 2006, the state government challenged it in in the high court, which in 2012 upheld Narayanan’s contention and ordered the government to give him interim relief of Rs 10 lakh. In October 2013, the then Congress-led government decided to give the compensation.

The scientist
In 2015, Narayanan approached the Supreme Court seeking criminal and disciplinary action against Kerala police officials led by Siby Mathew. A former DGP, Mathew had taken voluntary retirement in 2011 and gone on to become the state’s chief information commissioner. This is the ruling Narayanan is waiting for. His career cut short on account of the case, Narayanan describes what he went through in his autobiography, Orbit of Memories. He suggests a motive for why he was framed, writing that he suspects the CIA was behind the false case. He suspects a conspiracy to sabotage India’s progress in making a cryogenic rocket, and notes that the spy case put India behind by 15 years in cryogenic technology. The beneficiaries of the delay were the US and France, he writes, demanding a probe into the alleged conspiracy.

Must Watch


SC awards Rs 50 lakh to scientist for arrest in false Isro spy case ..



Read more at:
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/...ofinterest&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=cppst
 
. .
Conditional Study

1- So if they think ISI get some technology from them, its mean they are try to find alternative man against Kalboshan Yadive to show the world. :smokin:

2-Probably they interrogated him in the sense of cross checking, :lol:.

3- Why Pakistan investing for seeking from India, even in this technological era studies are available to designing any thing.

4- Probably this man showoff his creepy story to the world.:taz:
 
.
@Imran Khan , many scientists in BARC and ISRO died mysteriously inlast 15 years and some projects were totally sabotaged .... this cryogenic engine project of ISRO was one such case and it was huge controversy in Kerala in 1994 .... Americans are more interested in BARC and ISRO .... so they are doing , to save their country's interest by sabotaging the important projects
 
. .
@Imran Khan , many scientists in BARC and ISRO died mysteriously inlast 15 years and some projects were totally sabotaged .... this cryogenic engine project of ISRO was one such case and it was huge controversy in Kerala in 1994 .... Americans are more interested in BARC and ISRO .... so they are doing , to save their country's interest by sabotaging the important projects

India is the only country where Patriots who are doing great national service are fixed by filthy politicians and sold out traitors.
Nambi was a national asset & with meticulous planning towards a specific goal, he was destroyed. More importantly more than his personal loss, this resulted a national catastrophe for India.

So, who were these people who did this? Oh they achieved what they wanted, which is sabotage, so, who are these people who could so blatantly target one of the topmost scientists of India so easily?
How is it that as a nation we are accepting a slap on the wrist of these traitors? And more importantly how is it that we are OK with not knowing who the people behind the scenes are?

The same thing happened with Col Purohit.
He was a national asset and dutifully destroyed for a purpose.
Even in this case how is it that our national conscious allows us to sit quiet and not wanting to know the perpetrators?
 
.
India is the only country where Patriots who are doing great national service are fixed by filthy politicians and sold out traitors.
Nambi was a national asset & with meticulous planning towards a specific goal, he was destroyed. More importantly more than his personal loss, this resulted a national catastrophe for India.

So, who were these people who did this? Oh they achieved what they wanted, which is sabotage, so, who are these people who could so blatantly target one of the topmost scientists of India so easily?
How is it that as a nation we are accepting a slap on the wrist of these traitors? And more importantly how is it that we are OK with not knowing who the people behind the scenes are?

The same thing happened with Col Purohit.
He was a national asset and dutifully destroyed for a purpose.
Even in this case how is it that our national conscious allows us to sit quiet and not wanting to know the perpetrators?
This is why India should not stay together. Corrupt Politicians and Bureaucrats only grow stronger as time goes by.
 
.
This is why India should not stay together. Corrupt Politicians and Bureaucrats only grow stronger as time goes by.
No it should be the other way around India should be staying together even stronger,corrupt are there in every country even in small countries what we need is a system where the corrupt politicians know if they do something wrong they will be made to answer and punished accordingly.
 
.
No it should be the other way around India should be staying together even stronger,corrupt are there in every country even in small countries what we need is a system where the corrupt politicians know if they do something wrong they will be made to answer and punished accordingly.
No politician is going to introduce a strict system. Does not matter what they claim before an election.

Smaller nations are less corrupt and well administered. North Indian corruption culture is being forced upon rest of us.

Most corrupt politicians and bureaucrats happen to be Northies. These Bhaiyyas IAS officers who prefer to be posted in western and southern India are more dangerous than corrupt politicians.
 
.
No politician is going to introduce a strict system. Does not matter what they claim before an election.

Smaller nations are less corrupt and well administered. North Indian corruption culture is being forced upon rest of us.

Most corrupt politicians and bureaucrats happen to be Northies. These Bhaiyyas IAS officers who prefer to be posted in western and southern India are more dangerous than corrupt politicians.
Your solution is like burning the house to kill the rat.thats the easiest and stupid thing to do,you don't burn your house to kill a rat
 
.
Your solution is like burning the house to kill the rat.thats the easiest and stupid thing to do,you don't burn your house to kill a rat
Oh really?

Only region is which is going to burn in that scenario is North India. Western and Southern India is better off without North India.

Are you a North Indian bhaiyya?
 
.
Oh really?

Only region is which is going to burn in that scenario is North India. Western and Southern India is better off without North India.

Are you a North Indian bhaiyya?
I am not a north Indian but it's part of my India too
 
.
I am not a north Indian but it's part of my India too
Now you're caught. You indeed are a Northie.

North Indians are responsible for sorry state of India. You can try to deflect the blame. But you won't change the truth.
 
. .
Back
Top Bottom