What's new

DFA: No Philippine apology necessary for incident with Chinese ship

gpit

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Mar 24, 2007
Messages
3,954
Reaction score
0
DFA: No PHL apology necessary for incident with Chinese ship - Nation - GMA News Online - Latest Philippine News

KIMBERLY TAN, GMA News
10/20/2011 | 08:34 PM

The Department of Foreign Affairs (DFA) on Thursday said there is no need for the Philippine government to issue an apology for the Navy's accidental ramming of a Chinese vessel earlier this week.

“No apologies were necessary and none was given," Foreign Affairs Secretary Albert del Rosario said in an interview on Thursday.

He issued the statement after the Department of National Defense said that Navy chief Vice Admiral Alexandar Pama immediately ordered the Navy to send an apology to the Chinese Embassy after it accidentally rammed a Chinese vessel which was towing smaller boats off Reed Bank in the West Philippine Sea (South China Sea) on Tuesday morning.

"I think there was already an apology to the Chinese Embassy here in Manila. It's in the form of incident information to the Chinese Embassy here. At the same time, we are saying that the damage is not intentional. The minor incident was unfortunate, that was a result of unforeseen circumstances," said Defense spokesman Zosimo Paredes.

Secretary del Rosario also said there was no need for the apology because it was the Chinese vessel that veered into Philippine territory.

“As I understand it, there was a Chinese fishing vessel towing 35 unmanned dinghies that strayed in our waters," he said.

No casualties

Earlier, Paredes explained the Navy ship BRP Rizal was patrolling Reed Bank when it spotted a Chinese fishing vessel Tuesday morning suspected of poaching.

He said BRP Rizal encountered a problem with its steering mechanism and got entangled with one of the small boats, which then resulted in the accidental ramming.

Paredes said there were no casualties.

“The disposition of the small boats left will be in accordance with a legal process," said del Rosario.

The Philippine government has maintained that the Reed Bank is part of the Kalayaan municipality in western Palawan, the territory within the Spratly Islands claimed by the country.

The Reed Bank is about 80 nautical miles west of southwestern Palawan province and is within the country's 200-nautical mile exclusive economic zone, according to the DFA.

Both China and the Philippines are claimants to the disputed Spratlys, a chain of islands and islets believed to be rich in oil and mineral deposits. Also laying claim to the Sprtalys in part or as a whole are Taiwan, Malaysia, Vietnam, and Brunei. — ELR, GMA News

-----------------

Well, this serves as a crispy slap on China's face. CPC fools see another eye-opener.

China's "peaceful rise" is flawed logically and doesn't work: I (the Philippines) ram your sh!t out, and see how you can still manage your peaceful crap with you. LOL!
 
Well, this serves as a crispy slap on China's face. CPC fools see another eye-opener.

China's "peaceful rise" is flawed logically and doesn't work: I (the Philippines) ram your sh!t out, and see how you can still manage your peaceful crap with you. LOL!

You are so ridiculous, how could we don't do so, you are the one violated our national sovereignty and provoked us first, why do we have to apologize but you? And the thing apply the same for Vietnam either, stop stealing our islands and you will be safe again.

This is the apology:

Philippine Military (World's 31th strongest army) - YouTube
 
filipnos and viets should stop fighting amongst them and unite against chinese hegemmony...you are members of asean..you can sort things aamongst yourselves...
 
filipnos and viets should stop fighting amongst them and unite against chinese hegemmony...you are members of asean..you can sort things aamongst yourselves...

Vietnam and Philippine both are members of ASEAN and we will work together for our future.
 
filipnos and viets should stop fighting amongst them and unite against chinese hegemmony...you are members of asean..you can sort things aamongst yourselves...

Thanks friend, we Philippines and India are the most purest democracy in the world, we will stand up together to against any aggressive from evil communists around the world, I do feel very sympathy to Indian for living next to the big bad bully China, if in the future the U.N. needs, we will send forces to help you in any cases the Chinese invading India.

Please support us fighting against those evil invaders in South China Sea and help human erase the last commies existence on earth.
 
Vietnam and Philippine both are members of ASEAN and we will work together for our future.

Yes, you bet. Little wonder why they don't back your call for a united stance against China. Because they know you are worse of a threat to their sovereignty :lol:

Philippines arrests 122 Vietnamese fishermen | Inquirer Global Nation
MANILA, Philippines – Philippine police and military arrested 122 Vietnamese for illegal fishing on Monday in the biggest haul of foreign fishermen in recent memory, a police commander said.

The Vietnamese were arrested aboard seven fishing boats off the western Philippine island of Palawan, where many foreigners have been apprehended for illegal fishing over the years, said Chief Superintendent Artemio Hicban.

Vietnam latest news - Thanh Nien Daily | Philippines probing shooting accusations by Vietnamese fishermen: report
The Philippine government is investigating accusations by Vietnamese fishermen that Philippine forces shot and wounded them while fishing off the East Sea, according to a news report by GMA News.

Plus the fact that you have so many guard towers in the seas around them :azn:
 
Yes, you bet. Little wonder why they don't back your call for a united stance against China. Because they know you are worse of a threat to their sovereignty :lol:

Philippines arrests 122 Vietnamese fishermen | Inquirer Global Nation


Vietnam latest news - Thanh Nien Daily | Philippines probing shooting accusations by Vietnamese fishermen: report


Plus the fact that you have so many guard towers in the seas around them :azn:


The Philippines is a founding member of the United Nations;[1] it has been an elected member of the Security Council[2] and has participated in FAO, International Labor Organization (ILO), UNESCO and World Health Organization. Like most nations, the Philippines is a signatory of Interpol. The Philippines is a member of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations, East Asia Summit, and the Latin Union. It was formerly a member of the now-defunct SEATO. Declaring itself as independent of any major power block of nations, the Philippines is a member of the Non-Aligned Movement.
...

Since the end of the Cold War relations between the Philippines and Vietnam have warmed rapidly. Today the Philippines and Vietnam are economic allies and have a free trade deal with each other. Both nations are a part of Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) and Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC). The Philippines and Vietnam have conducted joint military exercises together in the South China Sea and are trying to find ways to turn the Spratly Islands from an area of conflict to an area of cooperation.

http://http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_relations_of_the_Philippines
 
The Philippines is a founding member of the United Nations;[1] it has been an elected member of the Security Council[2] and has participated in FAO, International Labor Organization (ILO), UNESCO and World Health Organization. Like most nations, the Philippines is a signatory of Interpol. The Philippines is a member of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations, East Asia Summit, and the Latin Union. It was formerly a member of the now-defunct SEATO. Declaring itself as independent of any major power block of nations, the Philippines is a member of the Non-Aligned Movement.
...

Since the end of the Cold War relations between the Philippines and Vietnam have warmed rapidly. Today the Philippines and Vietnam are economic allies and have a free trade deal with each other. Both nations are a part of Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) and Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC). The Philippines and Vietnam have conducted joint military exercises together in the South China Sea and are trying to find ways to turn the Spratly Islands from an area of conflict to an area of cooperation.

http://http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_relations_of_the_Philippines

Tsk tsk, citing wiki again :no:

Reality is very different however as indicated by more recent examples posted below:

Philippines arrests 122 Vietnamese fishermen | Inquirer Global Nation
MANILA, Philippines – Philippine police and military arrested 122 Vietnamese for illegal fishing on Monday in the biggest haul of foreign fishermen in recent memory, a police commander said.

The Vietnamese were arrested aboard seven fishing boats off the western Philippine island of Palawan, where many foreigners have been apprehended for illegal fishing over the years, said Chief Superintendent Artemio Hicban.

Vietnam latest news - Thanh Nien Daily | Philippines probing shooting accusations by Vietnamese fishermen: report
The Philippine government is investigating accusations by Vietnamese fishermen that Philippine forces shot and wounded them while fishing off the East Sea, according to a news report by GMA News.
 
Tsk tsk, citing wiki again :no:

Reality is very different however as indicated by more recent examples posted below:

I don't think such accident is seriously effected to relation of neighbor countries. Think about your Chinese fishermen who violated to the S Korea sea or Japan's sea territory recently.
 
Back
Top Bottom