What's new

Developing ICBMs ‘unsuited for India’s interests’ in the world

Status
Not open for further replies.

Neo

RETIRED

New Recruit

Joined
Nov 1, 2005
Messages
18
Reaction score
0
Monday, April 16, 2007

Developing ICBMs ‘unsuited for India’s interests’ in the world

* Defence organisation plans to build an ICBM with a range of 15,000 kilometres to match Chinese ICBMs

NEW DELHI: Buoyed by the successful test of a missile that can hit China, India says it can extend its nuclear range beyond Asia, but experts say it is unlikely to take such a step for fear of upsetting the West.

The launch on Thursday of the intermediate-range Agni-III missile capped New Delhi’s drive to produce a device capable of striking targets 3,500 kilometres inside China, which has an unresolved border dispute with India. The government’s Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) now says it now has the technology to build Inter-Continental Ballistic Missiles (ICBM) that would extend nuclear-armed India’s reach beyond Asia.

“We have achieved the capability to make missiles with a range of 5,500 kilometres but the decision to develop an ICBM has to be taken by the political leadership,” DRDO chief M Natarajan told reporters in New Delhi on Friday. Natarajan, India’s chief military scientist, said a day after the Agni-III’s test flight that the DRDO, which launched India’s guided missile development project in 1983, had already begun to design an ICBM.

“DRDO scientists are working on miniaturising systems of Agni-III so that a third stage can be squeezed into the 16-metre-long missile to enable it to go up to 5,500 kilometres with the same 1.5-tonne payload,” he said.

Agni-III project chief Avinash Chander told AFP that a second test of the intermediate-range missile would take place either in August or October. DRDO sources said the agency, which is also jointly developing a supersonic cruise missile with Russia, would seek New Delhi’s clearance before it actually began building an ICBM prototype after the second Agni-III test.

India started working secretly on nuclear weapons after China conducted its first atomic test in 1964 - two years after Beijing fought a brief but bloody border war with its neighbour. New Delhi detonated its first atom bomb in 1974 and, 24 years later, declared itself a full-fledged nuclear weapons state following a series of tests including that of a 46-megatonne-yield thermo-nuclear device.

Former DRDO chief K Santhanam said while India was capable of building an ICBM, production of one “would unnecessarily affect ties” between India and the United States, which in 2005 agreed on a historic civilian nuclear energy deal.

“Even in its wildest dreams, India does not plan to be a global superpower but in the regional perspective a 3,500-plus-kilometre range IRBM is enough to deter adventurism from across our two borders,” Santhanam said, referring to Pakistan and China.

Since the subcontinent’s 1947 independence, India has fought three wars with Pakistan, which declared itself a nuclear weapons state after carrying out copycat tests in 1998.

“Given our robust economic growth, resurgent markets and our nuclear-tipped stockpile of (1,000-kilometre-range) Agni-Is and (2,000-kilometre) Agni-IIs, we should be satisfied as a leading regional power,” Santhanam said.

Kapil Kak, director of the independent Centre for Strategic Studies think-tank, agreed.

“Given the international security situation and emerging power configurations, a programme to develop ICBMs is definitely unsuited for India’s interests,” he said.

“It would raise hackles in the US,” said Kak, a former air marshal.

Sources say the DRDO’s most treasured dream - denied in public - remains the development of an ICBM with a range of 15,000 kilometres, already christened Surya or sun, to match Chinese DF-3 ICBMs that can hit US cities.

http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2007\04\16\story_16-4-2007_pg4_15
 
.
Ofcourse we dont need missiles that can target the US. What we do need are the missiles that can target any part of China from any part of Indian mainland. That itself would mean a HUGE coverage area...

India’s secret ICBM ambitions


Official Indian sources say India is capable of building an ICBM with a range of 5,500 km, but some dream a rocket that could reach 15,000 km. The development worries China, but New Delhi downplays the issue saying that it is only pursuing its own security. Meanwhile scientific work continues.

New Delhi (AsiaNews/Agencies) – India can extend the range of its nuclear range beyond Asia. The announcement was made by the Indian government's Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) which said that it had the technology to build inter-continental ballistic missiles (ICBM) that could extend nuclear-armed India's reach even beyond Asia. For some India harbours a secret ambition to develop an ICBM that could reach the United States.

“We have achieved the capability to make missiles with a range of 5,500km but the decision to develop an ICBM has to be taken by the political leadership,” DRDO Chief M. Natarajan said.

Last Thursday, the DRDO test-fired the intermediate-range Agni-III missile which has a range of 3,500 km (2,200 miles) and can carry a 1.5-tonne nuclear or conventional payload. This is within striking distance of Beijing and Shanghai.

India’s other long-time rival Pakistan was already vulnerable to India’s Agni-I (700-800 km range) e Agni-II (more than 2,000 km range).

Agni-III project Chief Avinash Chander said that a second test of the intermediate-range missile would take place in August or October.

Referring to Pakistan and China, former DRDO Chief K. Santhanam said that “India does not plan to be a global superpower but in the regional perspective a 3,500-plus-kilometre range IRBM (intermediate-range ballistic missile) is enough to deter adventurism from across our two borders.”

Commenting on the development, official sources said that the test was carried out with the tacit approval of the United States which looks favourably to India’s power as a counterbalance to China.

In Beijing authorities reacted by saying that they hope that a country as important as India would work to maintain and promote peace and stability in the region.

In order to allay any concern, New Delhi said that the new missile was not intended to threaten any country but only to increase its national security.

China and North Korea helped Pakistan develop the Shaheen 2 missile which has a range of more than 2,000 km. The rocket was tested in March 2004 and puts the whole of India within a striking distance.

India started working secretly on nuclear weapons after China conducted its first atomic test in 1964—two years after Beijing fought a brief but bloody border war with its neighbour.

New Delhi detonated its first atom bomb in 1974 and in 1998 declared itself a full-fledged member of the nuclear weapons state club.

For some experts the DRDO's dream—denied in public—remains an ICBM with a 15,000 km range, named ‘Surya’ or Sun, that could strike US cities. (PB)

http://www.asianews.it/index.php?l=en&art=9007&size=A
 
.
The new Agni 3 if comes online will by the very laws of physics will be a ICBM in the lines of French M51. (they are both dimensionally quite fro-fro)
 
.
Since the subcontinent’s 1947 independence, India has fought three wars with Pakistan, which declared itself a nuclear weapons state after carrying out copycat tests in 1998
.

I love this PAkistan is a copy cat.while india was the original nuclear weapon state.

And i doubt india will build a longer range missile.As Agni111only flew cause of American Help.extensive help that is.:rofl:
 
.
Cheetah,

I think the authour meant tit for tat tests. Or something to that effect. Not copied Nuclear Devices.
 
. .
ICBM is a media obsession, 'can target US' and all those jingoistic stuff.

India's priority should be is to get a sub launched CM and BM ready.
 
. .
We don't need ICBMs man. There's no point of such stupid articles. What's the need to reiterate it when we've got all our threats covered. We don't have friction with anyone in the West (except a slight estrangement with Italy which is minimal).

Why should we build ICBM? China made ICBMs because of the ideological war of cold war. We're neutral and we don't have any issues with them. 5,000 Km- 7,000Km Ballistic missiles max are fine enough.
 
.
Nuclear submarines are a better idea for "Second strike" capability, so that no one will attempt a first-strike nuclear attack to take out all the land-based silos.

In that context, ICBM's are useful in that they increase the range of the Nuclear submarines.
 
.
Mods close this thread.
No Point in discussion.
 
.
I think we should build ICBM and launch it but should not put under production phase or induction phase. :smokin:
Finally we don't need them!!
 
.
I think looking at present geostrategis scenarious the role of nuclear weapon itself is uncalled for becuase they are just to destructive so by this logic India shold have not developed N-power in the fist hand...the world is becoming more and more competetive and we need not to worry about west because the day India becomes a major player(by 2020 when its GDP will reach $3.5 trillion mark)..west will start running after India and its emotional love for for snake charmers and holy cows will vanish seeing an ICBM and 5th gen fighter aircraft!!!
 
.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom