What's new

Chinese Space Station: Why US Remains ‘Highly Apprehensive’ Of Tiangong & Fears Ceding Military Edge To Beijing

beijingwalker

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Nov 4, 2011
Messages
65,195
Reaction score
-55
Country
China
Location
China
Chinese Space Station: Why US Remains ‘Highly Apprehensive’ Of Tiangong & Fears Ceding Military Edge To Beijing


BySakshi Tiwari

January 9, 2022

China has announced that its space station, which will provide a bird’s-eye view of Earth and one that is widely seen as a vital strategic asset in space, will become operational this year, according to media reports.

The China Aerospace Science and Technology Corporation (CASTC) announced on January 5, that the country will finish construction of the space station, named Tiangong, in 2022.

By the time Tiangong becomes fully operational, China will be the only country to have its own space station as the existing International Space Station (ISS), a collaborative effort involving multiple stakeholders including NASA (United States), Roscosmos (Russia), JAXA (Japan), ESA (Europe), and CSA (Canada), will complete its service life.

The Chinese Space Station (CSS), which is under development, has been a talking point in the US military circles and the scientific community.

On January 6, with its massive robotic arm, the Chinese space station successfully grasped and transferred a cargo spacecraft. The 47-minute maneuver was the first test of Tiangong’s 10-metre (33-foot) robotic arm.

“The mission proved the mechanical arm’s ability to handle high loads and assessed the feasibility and effectiveness of using it to maneuver a portion of the space station while in orbit.

Tiangong_Space_Station-China-e1640745975974.png

Tiangong Space Station – China

The achievement has prepared the door for more in-orbit assembly work to begin later this year in preparation for the construction of the space station”, according to CGTN, China’s state-owned TV channel.

Why Is The Robotic Arm A Cause Of Concern?
The robotic arm of the space station initially held on to the Tianzhou 2 cargo spacecraft, which was docked at the Tianhe core module during the test.

The Tianzhou 2 was then released from its dock and moved in a circle by the arm before being rejoined and docked at the Tianhe again. Tianhe is placed at the center of the space station and performs control and management functions.

According to China Manned Space Programme, Tiangong’s robotic arm is capable of lifting objects weighing up to 20 tonnes and can move about outside the station.

In September last year, the cargo spacecraft Tianzhou 2 performed an automatic release and re-dock at the Tianhe core module. However, it was the first time when it was moved around using the robotic arm.

The Chinese astronauts had also gone on spacewalks after the core module Tianhe was launched into orbit in April last year to work on the robotic arm and guarantee that it was operational.

Smaller versions of Tiangong’s robotic arm have been installed on China’s “scavenger satellites” to collect and direct space debris so that it can burn up in the Earth’s atmosphere. China has launched several scavenger satellites over the last decade.

Nevertheless, the robotic arm technology has sparked fears in the United States about its military potential. Ever since the technology was demonstrated by China, the US has expressed fears about the Chinese equipment interfering with American satellites.

Earlier, James Dickinson, Commander of the US Space Command, had told a Congressional hearing that the technology “could be used in a future system for grappling other satellites”.

FDpcCU1XoAE1J5h

The robotic arm of Tiangong Space Station (CSS) is seen from the Tianhe core module.

His comments had come in the backdrop of China launching a satellite called Shijian-21 with a robotic arm, as previously reported by Fox News. Dickinson also talked about another Chinese satellite, Shijian-17.

Dickinson told Congress in April last year that spacecraft like the Shijian-21 is part of an effort by China to seek “space superiority through space and space-attack systems.”

“Space-based robotic arm technology could be used in a future system for grappling other satellites”, he was quoted as saying by Washington Times.

In the case of a war, he claimed that the combatants would spend the first few minutes attempting to sabotage their adversary’s communication systems, such as America’s GPS.

This observation by American Space Commander indicates that a scenario where war between the two adversaries escalates and involves space combat is a possibility that is being considered in the United States even as it has flagged the militarization of space.

Interestingly, the International Space Station, of which the United States itself is a part, has had the robotic arm for a long time. Two robotic arms have long existed on the ISS: Canadarm 2 and the Japanese Experiment Module Remote Manipulator System. On the US and Japanese modules, both are critical for berthing visiting vehicles and grappling external payloads.

space-china-e1638424251837.jpg

File Image: Chinese Space Station

Two more robotic arms, the European Robotic Arm and Gitai S made their space flight to the ISS as recently as 2021.

So while the Americans already have access to this advanced and crucial space technology, its apprehension about Chinese technology appears unfounded.

The Space Race Heats Up
This year, the space race between the US and China is likely to heat up. China Aerospace Science and Technology Corporation revealed on its social media account that it has more than 40 space launches scheduled for 2022, including six manned space missions, as previously reported by the EurAsian Times.

The mission for 2022 will be “very arduous” and the number of space launches continues to remain high, the company said. “We need to fully complete various aerospace tasks, ensure the complete success of major flight test missions and accelerate the development of China as a space power,” the company chairman Wu Yansheng was quoted as saying.

China has made great progress in space programs in recent years after investing substantially. It had never conducted more than 10 launches a year until 2007. However, it has gained traction since then, launching 152 satellites in the past five years, more than any other country.

China surpassed the United States, the long-time leader in the industry, in terms of launches in 2018 and 2019. In 2020, the US recaptured the top position, with 44 launches compared to China’s 39.

Additionally, China and Russia have announced a collaborative effort to build a lunar base by 2027, eight years earlier than initially intended, in parallel to America’s $100 billion Artemis mission to return humans to the moon by 2025.

 
.
On January 6, with its massive robotic arm, the Chinese space station successfully grasped and transferred a cargo spacecraft. The 47-minute maneuver was the first test of Tiangong’s 10-metre (33-foot) robotic arm.

According to China Manned Space Programme, Tiangong’s robotic arm is capable of lifting objects weighing up to 20 tonnes and can move about outside the station.

Interestingly, the International Space Station, of which the United States itself is a part, has had the robotic arm for a long time. Two robotic arms have long existed on the ISS: Canadarm 2 and the Japanese Experiment Module Remote Manipulator System.

Pretty good start for a first gen arm. Not quite as big or as strong as the original first gens on the Space Shuttles.
 
Last edited:
. .
You don't even have a space station, no arms needed without a body.

Well I guess the world is unhappy the US and Russia switched modes from being just an exclusive "me" with space stations to a "we".

List of countries that visited the ISS
US
Russia
Japan
Canada
Italy
France
Germany
Belgium
Brazil
Denmark
Great Britain
Kazakhstan
Malaysia
Netherlands
South Africa
South Korea
Spain
Sweden
UAE

List of countries visiting Tiangong
China
 
.
Well I guess the world is unhappy the US and Russia switched modes from being just an exclusive "me" with space stations to a "we".

List of countries that visited the ISS
US
Russia
Japan
Canada
Italy
France
Germany
Belgium
Brazil
Denmark
Great Britain
Kazakhstan
Malaysia
Netherlands
South Africa
South Korea
Spain
Sweden
UAE

List of countries visiting Tiangong
China
Tiangong is a Chinese space station. ISS is so called internaitonal space station, it's not US', don't try to brag about it as if it's yours.
 
. .
Tiangong is a Chinese space station. ISS is so called internaitonal space station, it's not US', don't try to brag about it as if it's yours.

Apparently your reading comprehension is faulty since that is not what I said

Well I guess the world is unhappy the US and Russia switched modes from being just an exclusive "me" with space stations to a "we".
 
.
Apparently your reading comprehension is faulty since that is not what I said
But what he says is true. There is no US space station, US is a step below China. Can't even make complete space station completely by yourself. The core module is made by Russian. Did the fact trigger you? :enjoy:

China space station complete made by China and our solar panel draw more power than ISS despite being much smaller.

I still remember somebody Mars mission to send rovers need Russian main engine but try to brag as complete US effort. :rolleyes:

Let me remind you again, Tianwen mission used Chinese YF-170 engine. :enjoy:
 
.
Can't even make complete space station completely by yourself.

Um....you are forgetting something


and speaking of not being able to build something yourself...what about that Shenzhou spaceship which is based on the Soyuz...even your spacesuits look like the Russian Soyuz ones.


dayphoto-2018-05-17.jpg

Shenzhou suit


Shenzhou suit
Two astronauts photographed at time of Shenzhou 4 launch.
The Shenzhou flight suits were reverse-engineered from the Russia Sokol suit. The suits are designed to protect the astronaut in the event of cabin depressurization, and not for use in extra-vehicular activity.
Gross mass: 15 kg (32 lb).

In April, 1992 the Russian Zvezda institute sold to China a single Sokol space suit for $50,000 cash. This single example was torn down, reverse engineered, and became the suit for the Chinese Shenzhou program. The suits cost $15,000 apiece to produce in China.

:enjoy:
 
Last edited:
.
Um....you are forgetting something


and speaking of not being able to build something yourself...what about that Shenzhou spaceship which is based on the Soyuz...reven your spacesuits look like the Russian ones.
LOL.. Skylab is not even a complete space station. Just a demonstration module, the core module is much inferior and low tech which cannot compare to current ISS one. If so, why ask Russian to build the core module for ISS? Maybe then u start to claim RD-180 engine is also American build? Or simply US buy it becos its cheap to mask US inferiority. :lol:
 
.
LOL.. Skylab is not even a complete space station. Just a demonstration module, the core module is much inferior and low tech which cannot compare to current ISS one.

It was launched in 1973 and inhabited for 171 days...which is longer than your current Tiangong space station (and the previous TWO you have had).

skylab.png
 
Last edited:
.
lol this argument because a one off my first gen was better than your first gen.

Just let it be. US is ahead of China in space technology and experiences. We don't yet have as much resources as USA and certainly started out later than they have.

20 years is a lot of 50 years (40%) but 20 years is increasingly smaller proportion as time goes on.

ISS is very much more American than anyone else's lets be honest. We don't have as much available resources compared to USA + western Europe + Japan + South Korea + Cananda + Australia. Spending too much on improving China's space programs to the point of competing with USA + allies is not sensible. It is a slow marathon of progress in China's view. China cannot and probably should not be trying to outcompete USA for programs but for militarizing space, it is a different matter of security. There is not that much gain in creating very small and first step settlements on Moon or Mars. Besides like I said, USA is further ahead, richer, more available technologies already developed and also more experience.

What China should do is concentrate on technology so that is maintains a steady forward speed. If that is good enough to eventually be caught up or whatever then great. There are much more important priorities than space programs for China. Using space for military and countering US space military forces is necessary but civilian programs operate on different speed and priorities.

Already we see China devote lots of resources to have starting programs which also serve as basis for creating somewhere and something to test other developments with for example in communication field and even software.
 
.
It was built in 1973 and inhabited for 171 days...which is longer than your current space station has been inhabited...
LOL.. Sourgrape loser. Our Chinese Space station inhabitation is still counting. And it surpass to 172 days, will you come to this thread and admit your inferiority. Before you want to brag how long your US astronaut stay in ISS. Let me remind you, its ISS and not USS. There is simply no comparison.



Days occupied85 days, 23 hours and 14 minutes[4]
(Shenzhou 13)
176 days, 13 hours and 22 minutes

:enjoy:
 
.
What US achieved in the past remains in the past. US doesnt have its own space station now is a matter of fact. no one can deny it.
 
.
What US achieved in the past remains in the past. US doesnt have its own space station now is a matter of fact. no one can deny it.
Having your own space station costs money and US is short of that...
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom