ChinaIndia first broke the Tacit that's why PLA made tent

[Sashan]

BCS PLA think that the purpose of making tent is very clear for India army, and if you read news carefully， India gorv had said "we will check whether what we did some thing made misunderstanding"

The current Indian government is a dove and its position will hardly satisfy even a rational Indian in many situations - why should Indian government be apologetic if they understood the question what @IBRIS and myself are raising here. And this is after the Chinese have built excellent infrastructure on their part both in the AP section and in Akshai Chin in the past couple of decades - So why a tent should bother the Chinese and take it as a mark of aggression?

 

[xuxu1457]

The current Indian government is a dove and its position will hardly satisfy even a rational Indian in many situations - why should Indian government be apologetic if they understood the question what @IBRIS and myself are raising here. And this is after the Chinese have built excellent infrastructure on their part both in the AP section and in Akshai Chin in the past couple of decades - So why a tent should bother the Chinese and take it as a mark of aggression?

That's another thing, India can buid anything out red line, China can build anything out green line; If China or India build anything between red and green line, will sure make another tense. If PLA made a tent can make India so tense, India not make a tent but a fixed post Raki Nala, PLA will feel more tense. Why India feel so tens for PLA's tent and ask Why China feel tense for INdia making fixed post

 

[Psyops]

Indians tried another forward policy 50 years on after 1962 and got burnt again by the PLA. When will they ever learn.

 

[ILLUMINATO]

In the past, PLA and India army Cross-patrol between red line and green line, India army never pass the green line, PLA never pass the red line, India should remove the fixed post, this is wake-up memories of the forward policy of PLA, very similar to the forward policy

The map which you posted has distance of 10 km between red and green line at the farthest point but our officials are claiming that you are 19 km. inside that green line that makes your position at 9km inside Indian territory from red line itself.

I opin map is bogus.

 

[3Idiots]

Indians tried another forward policy 50 years on after 1962 and got burnt again by the PLA. When will they ever learn.

China tried to brow beat us way back in 1962.. resulted in failure.

These pinpricks don't affect Indian resolve, even remotely.

China earns nothing from its latest tantrums ...

 

[Sashan]

That's another thing, India can buid anything out red line, China can build anything out green line; If China or India build anything between red and green line, will sure make another tense. If PLA made a tent can make India so tense, India not make a tent but a fixed post Raki Nala, PLA will feel more tense. Why India feel so tens for PLA's tent and ask Why China feel tense for INdia making fixed post

Even the green line and red line should not have been there(and that the fault entirely lies with government of India for its dovish attitude) - the dispute is Mcdonald line/Karakoram range vs Johnson line(includes Akshai Chin) - So the Raki Nala is well south of either of these lines - So the Chinese should not have issue at all.


So here is the basic fact - China layed highways and other infrastructure in the disputed region - Akshai Chin and the government of India kept quiet all along. Now when Indian army raised a tent, it has become a huge issue - That is where most Indians are upset and I am happy that media has blown this issue wide open so that the Government of India can't appear meek.

 

[3Idiots]

The map which you posted has distance of 10 km between red and green line at the farthest point but our officials are claiming that you are 19 km. inside that green line that makes your position at 9km inside Indian territory from red line itself.

I opin map is bogus.

Yeah the source of those "images" reveal them to be more like fanboyish... chinese have developed a "photoshop" industry. It is just a product of that.

The "story" put up .. even if assumed true for a sec ... has holes and makes china look bad.

If India put up some "new" tents.. china should have raised them via the established mechanism. It couldn't do that because India didn't setup any "tents".

It's china which has harmed and indeed violated existing agreements by unilaterally setting up a tented post.

Indian govt has wisely not gone for a tit-for-tat.

This act of china hampers further discussions to a solution .. and shows negatively upon them.

 

[Psyops]

China tried to brow beat us way back in 1962.. resulted in failure.

These pinpricks don't affect Indian resolve, even remotely.

China earns nothing from its latest tantrums ...

Oh no? You sure about that kid?

All of India has been running around like headless chooks blaming and fighting each other.

We are inside Indian territory and you have done jack all about it.

 

[3Idiots]

Oh no? You sure about that kid?

All of India has been running around like headless chooks blaming and fighting each other.

We are inside Indian territory and you have done jack all about it.

It's china which has ended up looking stupid, courtesy the measured and mature response of the Indian govt.

These things didn't work for china in 1962 or 1987 .. and won't work now either.

 

[Cyberian]

From Google Maps

Depsang Plains

The incident appears to have occured in the highlighted red area. Notice the Shahi Kangri Mountain to the South-West

As you zoom in further, Google Maps also registers this area as a Military Area.

The following has been listed as a TAC HQ according to Wikimapia.

Nearby cities: Raja Iftikhar Abad, Chorbat, Hassanabad, Sooq Balghar Bridg
Coordinates: 35°17'27"N 77°57'48"E

 

[newdelhinsa]

As the pics shown , China clained the red line as LAC， while India clained the green line as LAC.
However, both have Tacit: both sides don't make fixed post at this small disputed area. Even look at ntensive posts nere the red line(ITBP post, Daulat Beg Oldi, Leh, Indian Army post), but now, look at inner the red line, India made a new fixed post:Raki Nala(in the PLA clained LAC), PLA worry about India want another forward policy， so PLA made tent nere Raki Nala, India should remove the Raki Nala post then PLA will remove tent.
In the past, PLA and India army Cross-patrol between red line and green line, India army never pass the green line, PLA never pass the red line, India should remove the fixed post, this is wake-up memories of the forward policy of PLA, very similar to the forward policy

Oh Chini has developed a new theory out of his bird brain after picking a map posted in Indian media.

 

[Sashan]

Oh Chini has developed a new theory out of his bird brain after picking a map posted in Indian media.

Mate - not needed. Xuxu1457 is one level headed member.

 

[xuxu1457]

The map was first shown by India media, in order to make it clear I choose this, bcs all Chinese maple are not in English. I think that if India army not remove the fixed post, PLA will make the tent to be a fixed post too.

 

[black_jack]

We are only 500 meters away from chinese tents and DBO is about 16km away from the airstrip. It's still in Indian Armies control that is why there still isn't any gun battle taken place yet. Huge Army convoys and anti air batteries have been spotted entering Ladakh few days ago. So we can expect some sort of good news soon.

Please don't post anything about deployment of army units.

 

[xuxu1457]

India first made a post at A, then PLA made tent at B, India went on made rents at C to against PLA
Photo of A,fixed post made by India army: