Calcutta Roars: Threats Modi on Rohyangas

[hussain0216]

Hindu, Muslim, Christian, Sikh, Jain, Zoroastrian-Parsi, Buddhist, Jew and many tribal religions live in India, without any persecution of following a faith, some religions are born in India.

We accepted many persecuted people in the past including BD's, we have no problem accepting Rohingya, provided they don't pose a security threat to India. Unfortunately that's not the case here.

Next issue is the insurgency, the leader of the ARSA have ties with JuD in Pakistan. Another no-no for India. We already have enough troubles.

As for Myanmar, I don't think they will accept any of the Rohingyas in the near future with China in it's back, so it's really a done deal for them. No point in blaming Suu kyi it's a military in disguise country.

Do you not read comments by indians at all?

Forget indian news sources or even PDF you can read their views on this very thread, this page

Being blind is one thing but being blind and stupid is criminal

YOU are the next Rohingya and the same excuses will be used against you that you are defending here today

 

[Areesh]

We don't want them here... its our country... our rules.. if you guys are so much in love with these self proclaimed refuges.. bring them to a country that was created for Muslims in south Asia... LOL

Your sanghi state doesn't want muslims. Not even there own. The drama of secular republic of India is falling apart.

 

[third eye]

muslims are creating problems in India too, its time we give them same treatment as myanmar is giving to rohingyas.

Then Muslim free India is the way to go, I suppose? Since you keep dodging my question on whether you accept them as part of the nation or not. Go ahead and start doing what Myanmar does to Rohingyas.

Thats is a silly question if you ask me. Muslims have shared this land with Hindus & Sikhs for centuries, its their land too so there is no question of Muslims being or not being a part of the nation.

Having said that, in India change happens through the ballot & no other means. People / party with higher No of votes calls the shots whether we like it or not. The next constant is that the Constitution is Supreme, no person / party can be above that. Nor can any community.

Muslims like all other Indian have to abide by the book . What I think @Winter Soldier implies is that those who choose to defy the Book & thereby the State need to get the dose. If thats what he meant, I agree with him.

 

[Areesh]

constitution is for ppl inside the country not for outsiders. Given that pakistan was specifically created for muslims please fulfill your duty of taking in all the affected muslims if not very reason for creation of your country would become void.

And for people inside the country there is gujarat, muzaffarnagar, hashimpura, Mumbai riots etc etc.

Pakistan was created for Muslims of Indian subcontinent. Not for the whole world. Despite that Pakistan has done more for muslims all over the world than anyone else.

Why is it hurting you so much ?
We have enough of them & want no more.

The Constitution did not make India a Dharamshala. EU nations too have secular constitutions, they too have had enough.

Not hurting me anymore. Just saying your dislike for those refugees is because of your sanghi nature and not because of some security threats.

 

[third eye]

Not hurting me anymore. Just saying your dislike for those refugees is because of your sanghi nature and not because of some security threats.

You are entitled to your view just as I am to mine.

There is no dislike for refugees , its just that ' their land , their rules".

Just as Pak as mentioned by you was not created for Muslims of the world but of the Indian Sub Continent , nor is India meant to be the universal Dharamshala for displaced of the world.

Its strange while on one hand you hide behind your POV yet you deny others their own.

 

[Chhatrapati]

Time is changing. You can see people like @Winter Soldier is advocating massacre of Indian Muslims and communists.

Why do you look surprised? Don't see such hate in every society. Let him live in his bubble, behind a computer, where it is safe and jerkoff to his dream of Hindu Rashtra. I tend to ignore such poor souls.

Do you not read comments by indians at all?

Forget indian news sources or even PDF you can read their views on this very thread, this page

Being blind is one thing but being blind and stupid is criminal

YOU are the next Rohingya and the same excuses will be used against you that you are defending here today

Of course I do read them. It has given me a weird satisfaction when reading all these guys go mental.

From what I see, there is a large swarm of these kinds in PDF, come on it's a nation of 1.3 billion. There will be a few hundred thousands who have extremist views.

About being the next Rohingya, hmm I don't think that's the case with India. Most of you guys base the opinion on these ragtag sanghis on PDF. I've quite a few Sanghi friends who are reasonable, whom I have a civilized argument.

In PDF I learned to enjoy the idea of having someone on the other side, hating you and can't do anything about it rather than bang their keyboard. What do you think @Joe Shearer ?

 

[Mage]

Why do you look surprised? Don't see such hate in every society. Let him live in his bubble, behind a computer, where it is safe and jerkoff to his dream of Hindu Rashtra. I tend to ignore such poor souls.

That's right......but still openly advocating massacre is a bit too much. But yeah quite common in PDF.

What I think @Winter Soldier implies is that those who choose to defy the Book & thereby the State need to get the dose. If thats what he meant, I agree with him.

You read his post and so did I. And I think we both understand English enough to make sense of it. So you don't need to add your thought to his post. So sparing your own thought, tell me do you agree with what he wrote?

 

[Joe Shearer]

Whats he so hyper about ?

Instead of rabble rousing whats stoping him from helping those in need like the Skihs have quietly done with no fanfare ?

http://indianexpress.com/article/in...border-to-provide-langar-to-refugees-4839349/

Short answer: he (the roaring hero far away from any danger) is not a Sikh.

Time is changing. You can see people like @Winter Soldier is advocating massacre of Indian Muslims and communists.

How does that specimen represent Indian opinion? We are not managed by saffron netizens. Not yet.

Do you not read comments by indians at all?

Forget indian news sources or even PDF you can read their views on this very thread, this page

Being blind is one thing but being blind and stupid is criminal

YOU are the next Rohingya and the same excuses will be used against you that you are defending here today

They are NOT typical Indians.

Just as you are not a typical Pakistani. For which, if I were not agnostic, I would be thanking God on my knees, fasting.

Why do you look surprised? Don't see such hate in every society. Let him live in his bubble, behind a computer, where it is safe and jerkoff to his dream of Hindu Rashtra. I tend to ignore such poor souls.



Of course I do read them. It has given me a weird satisfaction when reading all these guys go mental.

From what I see, there is a large swarm of these kinds in PDF, come on it's a nation of 1.3 billion. There will be a few hundred thousands who have extremist views.

About being the next Rohingya, hmm I don't think that's the case with India. Most of you guys base the opinion on these ragtag sanghis on PDF. I've quite a few Sanghi friends who are reasonable, whom I have a civilized argument.

In PDF I learned to enjoy the idea of having someone on the other side, hating you and can't do anything about it rather than bang their keyboard. What do you think @Joe Shearer ?

I think you have put it brilliantly. @third eye, hope you agree.

 

[Mage]

How does that specimen represent Indian opinion? We are not managed by saffron netizens. Not yet.

I did not say he represents India's opinion. What I did say is there are people like him who advocate such things. He is not the only one you know. There certainly is a sizeable Indian population with deep hatred for Muslims, I think.

 

[Joe Shearer]

I did not say he represents India's opinion. What I did say is there are people like him who advocate such things. He is not the only one you know. There certainly is a sizeable Indian population with deep hatred for Muslims, I think.

Not sizeable, and without the power to do anything about their hatred except cowardly mass assaults or hit-and-run raids. They represent a fringe element that has suddenly got power after nearly 65 years of being barely tolerated, and they are paying off a lot of their old scores. I am confident that we will get back to the earlier balance that we had.

 

[Homo Sapiens]

Why do you look surprised? Don't see such hate in every society. Let him live in his bubble, behind a computer, where it is safe and jerkoff to his dream of Hindu Rashtra. I tend to ignore such poor souls.



Of course I do read them. It has given me a weird satisfaction when reading all these guys go mental.

From what I see, there is a large swarm of these kinds in PDF, come on it's a nation of 1.3 billion. There will be a few hundred thousands who have extremist views.

About being the next Rohingya, hmm I don't think that's the case with India. Most of you guys base the opinion on these ragtag sanghis on PDF. I've quite a few Sanghi friends who are reasonable, whom I have a civilized argument.

In PDF I learned to enjoy the idea of having someone on the other side, hating you and can't do anything about it rather than bang their keyboard. What do you think @Joe Shearer ?

Are you Indian Muslim?

 

[third eye]

So you don't need to add your thought to his post. So sparing your own thought, tell me do you agree with what he wrote?

I tagged him for a reason . Let's wait till @Winter Soldier responds.

There isn't a train to catch . Give a man time to respond.

I think you have put it brilliantly. @third eye, hope you agree

Bang on !

Well said @SOUTHie

 

[Mage]

I am confident that we will get back to the earlier balance that we had.

Reason for such confidence?

 

[Joe Shearer]

Reason for such confidence?

That neither India, nor the Hindu community within India, is naturally a hate-filled country, nor a hate-filled community. That only a fringe element is filled with hate, and they are known and increasingly feared, disliked, and shunned.

 

[Mage]

That neither India, nor the Hindu community within India, is naturally a hate-filled country, nor a hate-filled community. That only a fringe element is filled with hate, and they are known and increasingly feared, disliked, and shunned.

Hmm.... @Loafer @ranjeet @SarthakGanguly @CBU-105 @Skull and Bones