Behaviour of Indian Minister with a Muslim Actor.

[Bang Galore]

There's a difference between the two scenarios. Muslims don't slaughter or eat beef to mock hindus. It is because they are supposed to do it on eid, religiously. Its not like they keep an 'in your face' attitude and say do what you can do about it I'm sure they are aware of what the hindu faith says and try to keep it low profile to co exist with people of completely different faith. This is something that should be understood. On the other hand french were doing it intentionally to mock Muslims and earn money of it. These are two absolutely different situations.

Motive is irrelevant, the right to do something is not restricted by what your motive may be. It is connected to whether it is allowed or not. There is no rule that mandates Muslims eating beef, including on Eid. The act, one can argue, offends Hindus (I'm no fan of beef bans, for economic & other reasons, my arguments are to raise uncomfortable questions of those arguing it on the grounds of impropriety) and therefore should not be done. The counter argument can only be that it does not matter if offense is caused, that Muslims (& others) have a right to offend Hindu sentiments because they don't subscribe to that faith. That then leaves it open to the question I raised about causing offense to Muslims. Many Hindus might find Muslims taking offense on the matter of cartoons as silly as many Muslims might find about Hindu aversion to eating beef. Muslims cannot decide what may constitutes an offense to the Hindu faithful just like the reverse.Once you go down that road, there is no way back. The state then has to decide whether it accepts the French/European position that everyone should be free to do whatever even if causes offense to some or go by the Indian position of prohibiting some things on the logic that law & order can be affected.

 

[Shot-Caller]

Motive is irrelevant, the right to do something is not restricted by what your motive may be. It is connected to whether it is allowed or not. There is no rule that mandates Muslims eating beef, including on Eid. The act, one can argue, offends Hindus (I'm no fan of beef bans, for economic & other reasons, my arguments are to raise uncomfortable questions of those arguing it on the grounds of impropriety) and therefore should not be done. The counter argument can only be that it does not matter if offense is caused, that Muslims (& others) have a right to offend Hindu sentiments because they don't subscribe to that faith. That then leaves it open to the question I raised about causing offense to Muslims. Many Hindus might find Muslims taking offense on the matter of cartoons as silly as many Muslims might find about Hindu aversion to eating beef. Muslims cannot decide what may constitutes an offense to the Hindu faithful just like the reverse.Once you go down that road, there is no way back. The state then has to decide whether it accepts the French/European position that everyone should be free to do whatever even if causes offense to some or go by the Indian position of prohibiting some things on the logic that law & order can be affected.

Then good luck co-existing with other faiths. This mind set has already made India a ticking time bomb waiting to explode.

 

[Bang Galore]

Then good luck co-existing with other faiths. This mind set has already made India a ticking time bomb waiting to explode.

Your argument is false. You cannot claim special treatment to any one faith, either you show respect to the feelings of others or you don't take offense when your own faith is disrespected. No other way. Your post is well reflective of your mind set and you don't need me to tell you where that has taken Pakistan.......

 

[Shot-Caller]

Your argument is false. You cannot claim special treatment to any one faith, either you show respect to the feelings of others or you don't take offense when your own faith is disrespected. No other way. Your post is well reflective of your mind set and you don't need me to tell you where that has taken Pakistan.......

The simple thing is let people eat what they want to eat. There are many british nationals who are muslims. Should they start asking to ban pork? There is a way to co exist which obviously lacks in you people. Go wait for next communal rights don't tell me where my mindset has taken Pakistan. We don't put hurdles in minorities ways for practicing their religions.

 

[Bang Galore]

The simple thing is let people eat what they want to eat. There are many british nationals who are muslims. Should they start asking to ban pork? There is a way to co exist which obviously lacks in you people. Go wait for next communal rights don't tell me where my mindset has taken Pakistan. We don't put hurdles in minorities ways for practicing their religions.

Beef eating is not part of your religion, it is just a food source. Your argument of people eating whatever they want, that is disingenuous. You evaded the wider question of respect for religious faiths but even within the narrow definition, no one allows people to eat whatever they want. There are rules & restrictions in most countries, some may want to eat tigers or bears, dogs, cats, monkeys chimpanzees, unlikely that they will be allowed to. Even if they want to farm it. Live with it. Or not. I don't care really, except that I enjoyed exposing the hypocrisy of your arguments.

The rest of your gibberish is best tried on others here, doesn't work on me.

 

[Shot-Caller]

Beef eating is not part of your religion, it is just a food source. Your argument of people eating whatever they want, that is disingenuous. You evaded the wider question of respect for religious faiths but even within the narrow definition, no one allows people to eat whatever they want. There are rules & restrictions in most countries, some may want to eat tigers or bears, dogs, cats, monkeys chimpanzees, unlikely that they will be allowed to. Even if they want to farm it. Live with it. Or not. I don't care really, except that I enjoyed exposing the hypocrisy of your arguments.

The rest of your gibberish is best tried on others here, doesn't work on me.

You talk like you matter . Extremist shiv sena supporter, you don't. No matter how much you people try to masquerade yourselves the filth of your thoughts exposes your kind. Hypocrisy is claiming to be a secular democratic state and then taking such extreme steps.

 

[Hyperion]

From recent news, it seems that it was all pork-nihari!

If India wants to ban beef, its their issue. We should issue special visas for those who want to come and eat beef nihari, lets make money out of it.

 

[Bang Galore]

You talk like you matter . Extremist shiv sena supporter, you don't. No matter how much you people try to masquerade yourselves the filth of your thoughts exposes your kind. Hypocrisy is claiming to be a secular democratic state and then taking such extreme steps.

Hypocrisy is when you pretend that you are reasonable & you seek to know opposing viewpoints when actually your mind is already filled with hate. I have no illusions of how much I matter, I know that on Indian matters, I certainly matter more than you.

 

[Kaniska]

Acting smart? I know why we seperated from India. Just that every time I look at Indians I find another reason to be proud of Pakistan.

You are not understanding about statements...Never mind....Your statements is like, i keep on saying to other countrymen as i love India because, India has IPL........Then others would start thinking, without IPL, Can not i be an Indian??,...

The Indians can't even take care of their people, with 600 million of them starving and don't have toilets, but apparently want cows to have full luxury... Indian logic

Unfortunately, it is the same way, like yours where religious matters are key where you consider Arabs are more pious people than someof your countrymen( Just look at your country men post)...So in the same vein, some section of India is still in 15th century mode where rather than fighing poverty and as you rightly said , fighting to provide toilets, we fight about beef and pork and all these non issue stuff..

 

[Xenophon]

There is a need to save this animal from disrespect in many ways. As a first steps,

1- Ban its slaughtering (Done)
2- Make sure it is never hungry, government of India should allocate funds for that
3- Create Gao Asharams where unattended cows could be kept, all across the country
4- For their physical wellbeing, a separate Gao-Health Department can be created who would pay periodic visit to these centres and look after ageing or sick cows.
5- Cows approaching their age need to be moved to resting places
6- Cows cannot be buried in the ground and in order to give them a respectable departure, seperate burning places can be created.
7- Sparate cow-temples or cow-semetries can be crated where their ashes are kept.
8- A National database can be crated for living and dead cows, for the benefit of people who live far way and are not able to offer their homage to these cemeteries in person.
9- Ministry of Cow Affairs is a democratic need in this regard.
10- India should also offer few words for these cows in their literature, poems and cultural songs.
11 - To make rest of the world respect this sacred animal, India should shape its diplomacy to maximise that. India can also reduce its diplomatic relationship with countries who are slaughtering cows.

These are just few suggestions which I could think of and which in my humble opinion will give comfort to the animal. This is not a trolling attempt neither it is meant to be taken negatively.. may be it sounds too much but it is with the betterment of Cow at heart.

What if they gt overpopulated?
What you gonna feed them ?
These animal's reproduction rate are much higher then human .
For your last point .what do the people of arab and nothern areas eat if they dont eat meat?

 

[RealNapster]

I mean no offense but this is unsustainable.. they can ban slaughtering of cows for a few years only.. and then they will find this sacred animal being humiliated and dying on the roads, on the railway tracks in the middle of fields eaten by vultures.

This rule "" ban on slaughtering Cow"" is for others (Indian Muslims) , not for them (Gao maata protectors) .. Level of hypocrisy ...
India World's Top Beef Exporter Despite New Bans on Slaughtering Cows
Amid cry for beef ban, meat exports from India on a rise | The Indian Express

 

[Post Colonnial]

Or the more likely scenario is thats how screwed up in the head they actually are.

nah, it is just to irritate yall

 

[Roybot]

From recent news, it seems that it was all pork-nihari!

Some of it could be donkey and dogs too

 

[Chanakya's_Chant]

Some of it could be donkey and dogs too

Police seize 1,600kgs of donkey, horse meat in Lahore raid

 

[Xenophon]

Eid ul Adha is coming .we should take a snap of millions of slaughtered cow and send it to our neighbor .

Manufacturers of burnol will be very thankful to us .