What's new

Bangladesh too will to have to pay dearly for the saffronisation of West Bengal

Brother, what's the opinion of Bangladeshi Muslims on Indian Muslims? Do you support the merger or not?
Riyaz, We don't support any merger with Bangladesh, Sri Lanka,Nepal, Burma,Bhutan or any other country for that matter. This is not East and West Germany. About Bangladesh, What about the political turmoil witnessed throughout history with Pakistan and Arab friendly military backed Govt in most of the tenure.

Referendum 2020.
Merge bangaldesh with India to form joint bengal.
Why don't you merge Pakistan with Bangladesh
 
.
It do not need to be a rocket scientist to realize that since 2011 population in all these entities increased.
Unless there is any rocket science involved the population growth rates of both countries would have been equivalent.
Screenshot_2019-06-22-13-24-27-055_com.android.chrome.png


Population density of 1029/km² for WB versus 1106/km² for BD, don't see WB winning this contest.
population density in Bangladesh in 2019 is 165,000,000/148,460=1111 per sq. km which is less than West Bengal
 
.
Partition was good for Pakistan and Bangladesh Muslims, we got political and economic independence and freedom from hindu oppression:tup: although muslims remaining behind in india got weak and preyed upon by hindus, but the same would have happened to us if we stayed.
Partition was good for Indian Hindus. More Hindus are migrating from Bangladesh and Pakistan to India then Indian Muslims going to Pakistan and Bangladesh
 
.
Unless there is any rocket science involved the population growth rates of both countries would have been equivalent.View attachment 566259

Population density of 1029/km² for WB versus 1106/km² for BD, don't see WB winning this contest.
1106/sq. km is for 2018 estimate when Bangladesh had 163 million people. For the sake of argument accept that Bangladesh has 1106/sq. km and West Bengal has 1029/ sq. km. With 1106/sq. km Bangladesh is suffocating and West Bengal with 1029/sq. km is just a normal Indian state? I do not find Indians of other states who live in West Bengal are fleeing due to suffocation. Nor West Bengal within India has reputation of being horribly overpopulated. This is the state which is feeding other Indian states with rice, potato, tea and other agri products. So why you have such a horrible perception about Bangladesh? Is the difference between 1029 and 1106 is too big?
 
Last edited:
. . .
Unless there is any rocket science involved the population growth rates of both countries would have been equivalent.View attachment 566259

Population density of 1029/km² for WB versus 1106/km² for BD, don't see WB winning this contest.

In 2018 West Bengal has population of 9.98. Cr which translates to 1125/km square population density which is higher than Bangladesh. Hope you have got it. Don’t compare 2011 density of West Bengal with 2019 density of Bangladesh.
 
.
Brother, give up your hatred for Islam and Muslims.
Merger is good for everyone.
You want to increase the Muslim percentage in India, that's why you advocate merger but why as a Hindu he should support that? Nobody in the world want to live as a minority or want to delude majority status. But some people in this world has to live as a minority. this is the hard fact. That's why secularism is the best. If you are so much insecure as a minority in India then migrate to other Muslim country or make a Ghar Wapsi. I think Indian Hindus will embrace you with open arms.
 
.
You want to increase the Muslim percentage in India, that's why you advocate merger but why as a Hindu he should support that? Nobody in the world want to live as a minority or want to delude majority status. But some people in this world has to live as a minority. this is the hard fact. That's why secularism is the best. If you are so much insecure as a minority in India then migrate to other Muslim country or make a Ghar Wapsi. I think Indian Hindus will embrace you with open arms.
Brother, why are you so angry?
Earlier you asked me to commit suicide. Now to turn a murtad.

Which Muslim country is going to accept 25 crore of us? who is going to provide money to migrate?

Why you let nationalism blind your heart? We Muslim Indians love Muslim Bangladeshis like our own. You should do the same.

I have also said this to Pakistani brothers. That if India was not partitioned muslims would have been a majority by now.
 
.
Which Muslim country is going to accept 25 crore of us? who is going to provide money to migrate?
Not 25 crore, it is more like 18 or 19 crore. And not all of them are as insecure as you and need migration. You seems to be a special case.
I have also said this to Pakistani brothers. That if India was not partitioned muslims would have been a majority by now.
No, not majority. Muslims would had 32 percent of total population by now and Hindus at 64 percent. And majority status may have never come because Muslim birth rate is rapidly converging with Non Muslim birth rate. Bangladeshi Muslims have already birth rate slightly lower than Indian Hindus. Indian Muslim birth rate is also rapidly falling and converging with hindu rate.
 
Last edited:
.
Brother, why are you so angry?
Earlier you asked me to commit suicide. Now to turn a murtad.

Which Muslim country is going to accept 25 crore of us? who is going to provide money to migrate?

Why you let nationalism blind your heart? We Muslim Indians love Muslim Bangladeshis like our own. You should do the same.

I have also said this to Pakistani brothers. That if India was not partitioned muslims would have been a majority by now.
Either you are projecting a fake persona or you are too insecure Indian Muslim.
You should make it clear to yourself Bangladeshis do worship idol of ethnicity more than anything.They would only come to you,when there is no refuge left elsewhere.Stop wasting your time.
 
.
West Bengal with 1029/sq. km is just a normal Indian state?
No, it's not, WB is a diseased state lagging behind. Other Indian states have leapfrogged WB, which was once the power center of India. This is because of decades of misrule, misguided youths lured towards communism, and some other factors. Now that the state is finally looking to shed its past baggage, people with vested interests have problems with it.
I do not find Indians of other states who live in West Bengal are fleeing due to suffocation.
Did the Bengalis in my state flee during bongal kheda andolan? Or during the time when insurgency was at its peak. Outsiders were targeted but they didn't leave.
This is the state which is feeding other Indian states with rice, potato, tea and other agri products.
FALSE with a capital F. Punjab, Haryana, Chattisgarh, AP, Assam are all agri rich states, WB is no exception.
So why you have such a horrible perception about Bangladesh?
I don't, i have problems with illegal Bangladeshis in my state, but that's that. We want Bangladesh to fare well in all spheres, that would be good for our region.

Changes taking place in WB polity should be none of Bangladesh's concern, it is India's internal problem.
 
.
No, it's not, WB is a diseased state lagging behind. Other Indian states have leapfrogged WB, which was once the power center of India. This is because of decades of misrule, misguided youths lured towards communism, and some other factors. Now that the state is finally looking to shed its past baggage, people with vested interests have problems with it.
I was not talking about misrule or other stuff. My reasoning was related with population density. I do not find other Indians are fretting over West Bengal population density, that why I called 'normal'
Did the Bengalis in my state flee during bongal kheda andolan? Or during the time when insurgency was at its peak. Outsiders were targeted but they didn't leave.
Again it was related to population density. Why are you now changing the goal post?
FALSE with a capital F. Punjab, Haryana, Chattisgarh, AP, Assam are all agri rich states, WB is no exception
Again related to population density. West Bengal has similar population density of Bangladesh still it is exporting agri products like Rice, potato, Tea to other Indian state and people are not suffocating there due to population density. So why you lot of Indian fret over Bangladeshi population density or predicting all those doomsday scenarios like crores of Bangladeshi will flood India due to population pressure?
 
.
Changes taking place in WB polity should be none of Bangladesh's concern, it is India's internal problem.

Just as india interferes in BD politics we also have the same rights to interfere in yours.

It is time for BD to pressure directly the surrounding indian states if Modi will not take action to cool communal rhetoric.

You can live in your fantasy if you believe BD do not have any leverage in what goes on in WB, Tripura, Asam, Bihar and beyond.

However BJP rhetoric vis-a-vis Bangladesh is nonsense and is for domestic consumption. The leadership of both nation irrespective of political parties fully understand that synergistic cooperation helps both nations.

Life will continue and muslim bengalis will continue in india without much change
 
.
So why you lot of Indian fret over Bangladeshi population density or predicting all those doomsday scenarios like crores of Bangladeshi will flood India
I can only speak for myself. I don't want my state to become another Bangladesh or West Bengal. Seven decades of infiltration into Assam and the explosive population growth rate of the Bengali Muslims, and yet our population density is a third of yours in BD and in WB. This is because we Assamese alone have been taking countervailing measures with little help from the Muslims, it has come at a great cost though, districts that were Assamese majority during independence have become Muslim predominant now. Our government back them failed to take lessons from your country or Bihar or WB, that's why we have elected BJP to mitigate some of the changes. @Riyaz Syed @mb444
 
.
Back
Top Bottom