What's new

Bangladesh remains main source of Infiltrations into India - The Diplomats

Riyad

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Jul 30, 2015
Messages
1,525
Reaction score
-5
Country
Bangladesh
Location
Bangladesh
THE PULSE | SECURITY | SOUTH ASIA

Bangladesh Remains Main Source of Infiltrations Into India

India’s multipronged approach to reducing infiltration from Bangladesh includes the construction of a border fence.
Rajeev Bhattacharya

By Rajeev Bhattacharya
August 18, 2021
Bangladesh Remains Main Source of Infiltrations Into India

Bangladeshi infiltrators after their apprehension in India.

Credit: Border Security ForceADVERTISEMENT

Bangladesh continues to be the main source of infiltrators into India, according to official Indian data.

India’s Minister of State for Defense Ajay Bhatt told parliament recently that there were 441 infiltration attempts made along the India-Bangladesh border in the first six months of 2021. He said that 740 infiltrators from Bangladesh were apprehended and one was killed by the security forces.

Infiltration attempts from other neighboring countries into India were far lower. While there was no infiltration attempt along the disputed India-China border, there were 33 instances along the border with Pakistan, which led to 11 persons being killed and 20 infiltrators being taken into custody, according to the report of the Security Forces and Ministry of Home Affairs.


The statement further disclosed that 11 persons were nabbed while making efforts to enter India from Nepal. And unsurprisingly, there was a sudden spurt in the influx from Myanmar after the military coup six months ago. An estimated 8,486 persons crossed over to India from Myanmar, of whom 5,796 were pushed back.

Excepting the situation of Myanmar, Bangladesh has been the source country of most infiltrators into India. The latest figures indicate that this decades-old trend continues to hold.

India and Bangladesh share a 4,095-kilometer-long border or which around 1,116 kilometers is riverine. Bangladesh is surrounded by five Indian states – West Bengal, Assam, Meghalaya, Mizoram, and Tripura – on three sides.

Cross-border crimes and infiltration from Bangladesh have prompted the Indian government to adopt a multi-pronged approach to checking illegal activities, while increasing surveillance along the border.

DIPLOMAT BRIEF
WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
N
Get briefed on the story of the week, and developing stories to watch across the Asia-Pacific.
GET THE NEWSLETTER
Efforts are underway to complete the border fence and install floodlights and high-tech surveillance equipment along the frontier. In addition to upgrading the intelligence setup, authorities have enhanced coordination among state governments on the Indian side of the border.

ADVERTISEMENT

Technological solutions are being utilized on a pilot basis for vulnerable areas where physical fencing was found to be unfeasible. A smart fence has been installed on a 60-kilometer-long stretch of the border in Assam’s Dhubri district following the launch of a similar project along the India-Pakistan border in Jammu and Kashmir.

According to officials from India’s Border Security Force (BSF), which is responsible for guarding India’s border with Bangladesh, there are many gaps in the border management system that facilitate infiltration and cross-border crimes such as cattle smuggling and drug and human trafficking.

Many stretches of the border are yet to be fenced. According to former BSF Additional Director General P. K. Mishra, “Completely sealing the border is impossible as there are several villages located close to the border where demarcation of ‘a no-man’s-land’ is unfeasible.”

Mishra identified Nadia, Murshidabad, and Malda in West Bengal as some of the “hotspots” for illicit activities along the border.

Figures on Bangladeshi infiltration into India that were released by the home ministry earlier this year indicate that the number has fluctuated over the past five years. In 2016, the total number of Bangladeshis apprehended while crossing into India was 1,601. After falling to 907 and 884 in 2017 and 2018, respectively, the numbers went up to 1,109 in 2019 and again dipped to 955 in 2020.

In these five years, the maximum number of infiltrators was apprehended in West Bengal followed by Tripura. There were no instances of infiltration into Mizoram, which shares a border with the Chittagong Hill Tracts in Bangladesh.

Bangladesh used to be reluctant to accept that its citizens are unlawfully settling and taking up menial jobs in India. However, in the past several years, it has begun to accept the deportation of nationals who have completed their jail sentences and who were willing to return to their home country.

Infiltration is a major issue in several Indian states. The northeastern state of Assam was rocked by a six-year-long agitation four decades ago primarily to get the government to identify and deport illegal immigrants from Bangladesh. A controversial register of citizens called the National Register of Citizens was compiled as well to deter foreign nationals from acquiring Indian citizenship and settling down in the troubled state.

Only last month, police in India’s southern state of Tamil Nadu launched a crackdown against illegal Bangladeshi settlers who are reportedly emerged as a “security threat.” They had settled down in five districts in the state and were posing as natives from the state of West Bengal.
 
Last edited:
THE PULSE | SECURITY | SOUTH ASIA

Bangladesh Remains Main Source of Infiltrations Into India

India’s multipronged approach to reducing infiltration from Bangladesh includes the construction of a border fence.
Rajeev Bhattacharya

By Rajeev Bhattacharya
August 18, 2021
Bangladesh Remains Main Source of Infiltrations Into India

Bangladeshi infiltrators after their apprehension in India.

Credit: Border Security ForceADVERTISEMENT

Bangladesh continues to be the main source of infiltrators into India, according to official Indian data.

India’s Minister of State for Defense Ajay Bhatt told parliament recently that there were 441 infiltration attempts made along the India-Bangladesh border in the first six months of 2021. He said that 740 infiltrators from Bangladesh were apprehended and one was killed by the security forces.

Infiltration attempts from other neighboring countries into India were far lower. While there was no infiltration attempt along the disputed India-China border, there were 33 instances along the border with Pakistan, which led to 11 persons being killed and 20 infiltrators being taken into custody, according to the report of the Security Forces and Ministry of Home Affairs.

The statement further disclosed that 11 persons were nabbed while making efforts to enter India from Nepal. And unsurprisingly, there was a sudden spurt in the influx from Myanmar after the military coup six months ago. An estimated 8,486 persons crossed over to India from Myanmar, of whom 5,796 were pushed back.

Excepting the situation of Myanmar, Bangladesh has been the source country of most infiltrators into India. The latest figures indicate that this decades-old trend continues to hold.

India and Bangladesh share a 4,095-kilometer-long border or which around 1,116 kilometers is riverine. Bangladesh is surrounded by five Indian states – West Bengal, Assam, Meghalaya, Mizoram, and Tripura – on three sides.

Cross-border crimes and infiltration from Bangladesh have prompted the Indian government to adopt a multi-pronged approach to checking illegal activities, while increasing surveillance along the border.

DIPLOMAT BRIEF
WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
N
Get briefed on the story of the week, and developing stories to watch across the Asia-Pacific.
GET THE NEWSLETTER
Efforts are underway to complete the border fence and install floodlights and high-tech surveillance equipment along the frontier. In addition to upgrading the intelligence setup, authorities have enhanced coordination among state governments on the Indian side of the border.

ADVERTISEMENT

Technological solutions are being utilized on a pilot basis for vulnerable areas where physical fencing was found to be unfeasible. A smart fence has been installed on a 60-kilometer-long stretch of the border in Assam’s Dhubri district following the launch of a similar project along the India-Pakistan border in Jammu and Kashmir.

According to officials from India’s Border Security Force (BSF), which is responsible for guarding India’s border with Bangladesh, there are many gaps in the border management system that facilitate infiltration and cross-border crimes such as cattle smuggling and drug and human trafficking.

Many stretches of the border are yet to be fenced. According to former BSF Additional Director General P. K. Mishra, “Completely sealing the border is impossible as there are several villages located close to the border where demarcation of ‘a no-man’s-land’ is unfeasible.”

Mishra identified Nadia, Murshidabad, and Malda in West Bengal as some of the “hotspots” for illicit activities along the border.

Figures on Bangladeshi infiltration into India that were released by the home ministry earlier this year indicate that the number has fluctuated over the past five years. In 2016, the total number of Bangladeshis apprehended while crossing into India was 1,601. After falling to 907 and 884 in 2017 and 2018, respectively, the numbers went up to 1,109 in 2019 and again dipped to 955 in 2020.

In these five years, the maximum number of infiltrators was apprehended in West Bengal followed by Tripura. There were no instances of infiltration into Mizoram, which shares a border with the Chittagong Hill Tracts in Bangladesh.

Bangladesh used to be reluctant to accept that its citizens are unlawfully settling and taking up menial jobs in India. However, in the past several years, it has begun to accept the deportation of nationals who have completed their jail sentences and who were willing to return to their home country.

Infiltration is a major issue in several Indian states. The northeastern state of Assam was rocked by a six-year-long agitation four decades ago primarily to get the government to identify and deport illegal immigrants from Bangladesh. A controversial register of citizens called the National Register of Citizens was compiled as well to deter foreign nationals from acquiring Indian citizenship and settling down in the troubled state.

Only last month, police in India’s southern state of Tamil Nadu launched a crackdown against illegal Bangladeshi settlers who are reportedly emerged as a “security threat.” They had settled down in five districts in the state and were posing as natives from the state of West Bengal.

great problem , govt should do something by giving them long term working visa .
 

Is India's lack of toilets a cultural problem?

Why India Struggles to Tackle Its Toilet Challenge
reported
mods should stop trolls from derailing the thread .
 
great problem , govt should do something by giving them long term working visa .

Give Bangladeshis visa free access. Why do we need visa to travel India? We should be allowed only by our passports. We will not complain about India anymore. :P

Bangladeshis who infiltrate India are poor economic migrants. Since India is just across the border they find it easy to move there. The border can not be sealed totally because of porous border.
 
India propagates a lie and than starts believing in it. Over 100,000 Indians are working in Bangladesh , so 600 infiltrates mean nothing.

To be honest in the current situation the migrant follow is reverse. More people want to goto BD from India to find jobs.
 
India propagates a lie and than starts believing in it. Over 100,000 Indians are working in Bangladesh , so 600 infiltrates mean nothing.

To be honest in the current situation the migrant follow is reverse. More people want to goto BD from India to find jobs.
Whatever makes you feel good.
Working legally with a visa is different from infiltration. There is no record of such a person if he's illegal, making them a menace.
 
Lookey lookey,

RaJEEV Bhattarcharya lol.

Do you know how comfortable it is to live in BD? Even our poorest elaqas have better living standards.
 
India propagates a lie and than starts believing in it. Over 100,000 Indians are working in Bangladesh , so 600 infiltrates mean nothing.

To be honest in the current situation the migrant follow is reverse. More people want to goto BD from India to find jobs.

Great if illegal indians are working in bangladesh , expell them immediately

:D :D:D:D:D:D
 
Last edited:
Insulted Other Member/Nationality
Give Bangladeshis visa free access. Why do we need visa to travel India? We should be allowed only by our passports. We will not complain about India anymore. :P

Bangladeshis who infiltrate India are poor economic migrants. Since India is just across the border they find it easy to move there. The border can not be sealed totally because of porous border.
Electric rickshaws have killed bangladeshi options in India ,only bangladeshi women can find some "work":lol: here now.
 
How did they measure penis size? Did they measure samples?

It says Indians have bigger size, Pakistanis have 1 cm shorter size than Indians. Bangladeshis have 1 cm shorter size than Pakistanis.

13 cm Indians, 12 cm Pakistanis and 11 cm Bangladeshis on average.
5BB365E8-7E61-469D-A4D9-04ABBFB20408.gif

Don't want to derail the thread but believe it or not this convo happened already and this was not true, infact it became a joke

Hell I remember posters posting research paper, data graphics and all kinds of things

I think it was @waz who also did it lol, but let's not go there, it won't end well for the thread or the guy who posted it to score points, it'll back fire on the poor guy lol
 
Last edited:
India: Turning the Bangladeshi border into a political issue
By Syamantak Ghosh (New Delhi)| 21.07.2021
DW.com


Two people walk through guarded gate painted with colors of Indian flag. In front of gate is a long barrier and signs saying stop

Bangladeshis illegally crossing the border into India has become an increasingly fraught political issue. But experts warn that it is being politicized for electoral gain.
Although people have always crossed from Bangladesh into India, the issue has become a much more central topic since Narendra Modi's Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) came to power in 2014.
It was the BJP that initiated a new Indian Citizenship Amendment Act in 2019, according to which Hindu migrants are given the status of refugees. Muslims, on the other hand, are either punished or sent back to Bangladesh or other neighboring countries.
BJP leaders also played up the crossings as a key issue during recent local elections.
According to statistics from the the Indian Border Security Force (BSF) and National Crime Record Bureau, 1,115 Bangladeshis were taken into custody near the border for lacking proper permits during 2020, up to mid-December. In the same period, 3,173 people were arrested for attempting to illegally cross the border from India into Bangladesh.

The two South Asian neighbors share a 4,096-kilometer (2,545-mile) border. The line runs through five Indian states: West Bengal, Assam, Tripura, Meghalaya and Mizoram. According to local media, the BSF has identified half of the border as vulnerable to crossings either due to the lack of fencing or bodies of wat
"You don't need any data to know that many Bangladeshis work in India," an expert on Indo-Bangladeshi refugee policy Suchandra Ghatak told DW.
"But this context can't be seen politically: It is rather the socio-economic condition of the subcontinent that has given birth to such a situation. The political parties use this issue for their own short-term gain," she said.
Allauddin (name changed) came to India from the Bangladeshi district of Khulna, close to India's West Bengal, a few years ago.
"Since India is a big country, unskilled job options are much greater here than in Bangladesh," Allauddin told DW. He possesses an Indian ID — Aadhar card — and owns two vans in India. Some of his family also lives with him.

Chhobi Sikdar (name changed) came from the same area to India in the 1980s. She escaped domestic violence and crossed the border to search for a different life. She received her legal documents in India a decade later.
"People do earn good wages in Dhaka. But it is easier to come to Kolkata than Dhaka because of the distance. And doing odd jobs in Kolkata is easier for her because nobody knows her here," Chhobi told DW.
The political campaign over illegal immigration
The debate over border crossings continues to stoke interest while Indian police and security forces continue to capture illegal migrants. The arrest of three members of the Bangladesh-based terrorist group Jamaat-ul-Mujahideen (JMB), caused a particularly big stir.
Indien-Bangladesch Grenze

Large sections of the long Indo-Bangladeshi border are very difficult to monitor
"This issue is never seriously discussed when the authorities of the two concerned governments meet," India-based human rights activist Ashish Gupta told DW.
"The lack of discussion itself indicates that the issue of Bangladeshi migrants is completely political. Had it not been so, then the case would have been dealt with differently."
During the last joint meeting between border guard officials from the two countries, the Bangladeshi side claimed that there is no major economic migration into India.
"The GDP growth rate of Bangladesh is now on an upward trend and the per capita income is close to $2,300 (€1,955). So, there is no reason really for Bangladeshis to cross the border to seek jobs or for any other reasons," Shafeenul Islam, director-general of Border Guards Bangladesh (BGB), told a joint press conference.
He also claimed that border guards on both sides are now being more vigilant.
Migrants facing new challenges
Refugee policy expert Ghatak also believes that things have become more difficult for migrants.
"Previously the situation was different. The borders were not that strict. There were many who would cross the border in the morning, entering India for work and going back to Bangladesh in the evening. Now such things are not possible. So people find other ways," Ghatak said.

"Now there is evidence that Bangladeshis enter with a visa valid for one year. Then they start working in the unorganized sector and never go back. But can you call this infiltration? They did not cross the border illegally," she added.
India-based border activist Kiriti Ray told DW that the problem has to be solved differently.


"This crisis cannot be solved politically. Bangladeshi workers should be treated like migrants from Nepal and Bhutan in India. If the state-authorized their job in India, then the problem might be solved. One cannot forget the history of unplanned partitions. And the ethos of the people from both sides of the border," Ray said.
 
Back
Top Bottom