Attack on Hindus: India takes up issue with Bangladesh.

[dray]

And it is normal tradition in every Islamic country

That's the whole point........and that's why it is pointless to take up such issues with an Islamic country.

 

[Homo Sapiens]

If someone else is doing anything wrong ,it doesnt make u also do that..its totally ur decision to either choose the correct path or join them..india raised this topic with bangladesh..either bangladesh accept it of refuse it..why to drag others ??

Point one.For the attack on Hindus or any other form of communalism,we will continue to fight on our own volition,whether India shows concern or not.

Point two.Recent sporadic attack on Religious minority,blogger,foreigners were done by small group of militant who are mostly decimated by now.

Point three.Incidence in BD have no relation with the event in myanmar.I mentioned myanmar in the context of Indian hypocrisy of selective concern.

Point four.India itself somewhat contributed to the sporadic small scale attack or threat towards the Bangladeshi Hindu community.Bangladeshi Hindus already have tendency to migrate to India with or without threat.Repeated Indian declaration in media about welcoming Hindu refugee from Bangladesh have made things worse.Some wicked people have interpreted this as the opportunity to grab the properties of Hindu people by staging small scale attack,like breaking idols in the middle of night or eve teasing on girls or hurling one or two cocktail.Those criminal knows,Hindus will run towards border with the slightest provocation and they can grab his properties.I am not judging hindu community for their tendency to flight rather than resistance,but we should consider another fact,Indian muslims will either fight or die,but never flee to Pakistan or Bangladesh no matter what,even after Gujarat massacre, when 2000 muslims were burned to death,not a single Gujarati muslim gone to Pakistan or BD.But this is totally different in case of Hindus,they will run away at the first shot hearing.And India is exacerbating this tendency by wide open welcome.Hindus are taking India as their ultimate refuge in case of any inconvenience and criminals are plying with this mentality.That's why recent uptick on sporadic small scale attack on Hindus.I hope you understood my points.

 

[Nilgiri]

That's the whole point........and that's why it is pointless to take up such issues with an Islamic country.

Pointless to pursue sure. But it makes sense to keep BD mindful by warning it. Its more to get the reaction that several BD people already posting than to actually carry out programs to address the issue (which would be futile without passing several red lines currently).

 

[Zabaniyah]

Point four.India itself somewhat contributed to the sporadic small scale attack or threat towards the Bangladeshi Hindu community.Bangladeshi Hindus already have tendency to migrate to India with or without threat.Repeated Indian declaration in media about welcoming Hindu refugee from Bangladesh have made things worse.Some wicked people have interpreted this as the opportunity to grab the properties of Hindu people by staging small scale attack,like breaking idols in the middle of night or eve teasing on girls or hurling one or two cocktail.Those criminal knows,Hindus will run towards border with the slightest provocation and they can grab his properties.I am not judging hindu community for their tendency to flight rather than resistance,but we should consider another fact,Indian muslims will either fight or die,but never flee to Pakistan or Bangladesh no matter what,even after Gujarat massacre, when 2000 muslims were burned to death,not a single Gujarati muslim gone to Pakistan or BD.But this is totally different in case of Hindus,they will run away at the first shot hearing.And India is exacerbating this tendency by wide open welcome.Hindus are taking India as their ultimate refuge in case of any inconvenience and criminals are plying with this mentality.That's why recent uptick on sporadic small scale attack on Hindus.I hope you understood my points.

It is true that many Hindus in Bangladesh have a '2nd home' sort of relation in India. But I never really thought of it that way. Just because they may have a 2nd home abroad doesn't justify attacks on them. It shouldn't. It's not just India, but people have 2nd homes abroad like in Malaysia and other countries. They can move in and out of the country as they please. Do their properties get attacked? I don't think so.

But interesting nonetheless. It is ironic to see Hindus of Bangladesh feel that way considering that they were a foremost part of the Language Movement which lead to later events.

At least those attacks in Bangladesh didn't leave thousands dead if you know what I mean.

All citizens of a country regardless of caste, religion, or race must have security. No exceptions. That is one of the foremost principles of a republic.

 

[livingdead]

India cannot tell bd what she should do, but nothing wrong in showing concern... especially in private(this came up in a reply to specific question in Lok Sabha, but I dont think govt of India has publicly said anything to BD)...
I dont believe hindus are worse off in BD than muslims are in India... whatever we know about bd comes from mouth of hindus there and we just believe it.

 

[TopCat]

India cannot tell bd what she should do, but nothing wrong in showing concern... especially in private(this came up in a reply to specific question in Lok Sabha, but I dont think govt of India has publicly said anything to BD)...
I dont believe hindus are worse off in BD than muslims are in India... whatever we know about bd comes from mouth of hindus there and we just believe it.

This is a globalized world. If human rights are violated to a certain extent, not only India but any country, group or even a person can raise concern. I dont think status of hindus in BD should warrant any concern.

 

[chandrak]

Point one.For the attack on Hindus or any other form of communalism,we will continue to fight on our own volition,whether India shows concern or not.

Point two.Recent sporadic attack on Religious minority,blogger,foreigners were done by small group of militant who are mostly decimated by now.

Point three.Incidence in BD have no relation with the event in myanmar.I mentioned myanmar in the context of Indian hypocrisy of selective concern.

Point four.India itself somewhat contributed to the sporadic small scale attack or threat towards the Bangladeshi Hindu community.Bangladeshi Hindus already have tendency to migrate to India with or without threat.Repeated Indian declaration in media about welcoming Hindu refugee from Bangladesh have made things worse.Some wicked people have interpreted this as the opportunity to grab the properties of Hindu people by staging small scale attack,like breaking idols in the middle of night or eve teasing on girls or hurling one or two cocktail.Those criminal knows,Hindus will run towards border with the slightest provocation and they can grab his properties.I am not judging hindu community for their tendency to flight rather than resistance,but we should consider another fact,Indian muslims will either fight or die,but never flee to Pakistan or Bangladesh no matter what,even after Gujarat massacre, when 2000 muslims were burned to death,not a single Gujarati muslim gone to Pakistan or BD.But this is totally different in case of Hindus,they will run away at the first shot hearing.And India is exacerbating this tendency by wide open welcome.Hindus are taking India as their ultimate refuge in case of any inconvenience and criminals are plying with this mentality.That's why recent uptick on sporadic small scale attack on Hindus.I hope you understood my points.

Not going into deep..but will point out a thing here..its called system and belief on good governence..even muslim get targeted in 2002 riots (they knew y riots happened) but can u tell any more continuous incidence to torture them or tease them ?? None so y they sud leave..people only leave their homegrounds when things turn out of control , when they start to feeling insecure for their life and their loved one lives DUE To CONTINUOUS REPEATED ASSAULTS AND INCIDENCE that finally let them make choice of leaving everything behind..
Doesnt matter hindu or muslims its human being tendency..if muslims in gujrat will started to targeted daily ,u can assume that they can nt stay for even a month..why only gujrat in any part of india..still with modi tell me any incidence where mashids were burned, poor muslims family were targeted in his 2.8 years of rule..

 

[TopCat]

Not going into deep..but will point out a thing here..its called system and belief on good governence..even muslim get targeted in 2002 riots (they knew y riots happened) but can u tell any more continuous incidence to torture them or tease them ?? None so y they sud leave..people only leave their homegrounds when things turn out of control , when they start to feeling insecure for their life and their loved one lives DUE To CONTINUOUS REPEATED ASSAULTS AND INCIDENCE that finally let them make choice of leaving everything behind..
Doesnt matter hindu or muslims its human being tendency..if muslims in gujrat will started to targeted daily ,u can assume that they can nt stay for even a month..why only gujrat in any part of india..still with modi tell me any incidence where mashids were burned, poor muslims family were targeted in his 2.8 years of rule..

Economics played a big role in hindu migration.
Let me give an example. You wont find a single landless hindu in Bangladesh. We have river erosion and thousands of families become landless every year. Where did all those landless hindus gone? They just claimed refuge in India blaming persecution.

 

[chandrak]

Economics played a big role in hindu migration.
Let me give an example. You wont find a single landless hindu in Bangladesh. We have river erosion and thousands of families become landless every year. Where did all those landless hindus gone? They just claimed refuge in India blaming persecution.

Yaar if they are happy let them be..y even this is a matter of dicsussion?? We r talking about humans they are free to live the life the way they want too..even from india people migrate to usa,britain etc ever seen anybody complainig..?? Even if the muslims of india want to go and live the life in pakistan or bangladesh we dont have any problem..bcz after all its their decision who m i or anyone to force them for our own decision?? If bangladeshi hindues are migrating then whats the problem ? Y in return their homes are getting burned , their properties are getting looted?? same thing happened in kashmir , the kashmiries thought that if they will attack hindues and make them flee ,they can get control over their properties , lands but u tell what they got in return , 30years of army rule, endless killings of their kins ,bullets ,pallets ..does those small lands and properties were more valuable then happy life for their upcoming generations?? They also thought initially every best way to proof them good but never thought that this may to happen else they wudnt have done something like this at first place..
Thats y its said be right ,do right bcz nobody knows what lies in path of darkness ...

 

[Homo Sapiens]

India cannot tell bd what she should do, but nothing wrong in showing concern... especially in private(this came up in a reply to specific question in Lok Sabha, but I dont think govt of India has publicly said anything to BD)...
I dont believe hindus are worse off in BD than muslims are in India... whatever we know about bd comes from mouth of hindus there and we just believe it.

Ideally every country should tell if there any human rights violation is happening anywhere in the world.This is the only way to prevent its violation.Evil thrives in this world because most countries like most of the individual among us thinks,this is not my problem.So they hand wash from their responsibility.

Problem is, Indian concern is very selective.EU also showed concern about the security of Hindu community,not only that for also other religious minority,LGBT community,Bloggers,minority muslim sects in BD.They also showed concern for Myanmar,Palestine,Darfur,Sri Lanka and many many other places.They criticize countries like Russia,China harming their business interest.They also criticize member state like Hungary,Poland for their authoritarian tendency.So they have a principle,values for which they stand up and even willing to suffer loss.They sanctioned myanmar when China,India made lucrative deal with junta.I know EU is not totally perfect but they try to promote basic human rights principle both within and outside EU border.When India will be like EU,not only showing concern for own religious group,but for every group in distress,when Indian will scrutinize its own position on religious,ethnic minority within India itself then we can take Indian concern with good,open heart.

 

[Russell]

Disclaimer: I've not read the OP and most definitely not any posts in this thread -

But, here's my two cents.

I get why India would want to comment - hey, if we as Muslims can scream about the ummah and Muslims in x,y,z country - why can't a Hindu majority India do the same for Hindus in other countries???

But - this is where, I think India and Indians miss the point. Their complaints/concerns actually do more harm to the Hindus in Bangladesh than good. The f-ing mullahs and bigots (be they non bearded bastards living in the west or those still living in Bangladesh) have since independence worked to disenfranchise Hindus and minorities in this country. Any time anything happens - Hindus are asked to prove their loyalty - and even then, they are told to 'go BACK to India' at the drop of a hat...

Go back? Back where? This country/land - warts and all is theirs too...yet, these evil bastards constantly prey on them.

So - India speaking up for them, sadly does them more harm. What needs to happen is those of us who think of Hindus as brothers, need to actually stand by them. Not just condemn the cave monkeys, but do something to reassure our hindu brothers and sisters - this is their home...this is where they belong.

 

[livingdead]

Disclaimer: I've not read the OP and most definitely not any posts in this thread -

But, here's my two cents.

I get why India would want to comment - hey, if we as Muslims can scream about the ummah and Muslims in x,y,z country - why can't a Hindu majority India do the same for Hindus in other countries???

But - this is where, I think India and Indians miss the point. Their complaints/concerns actually do more harm to the Hindus in Bangladesh than good. The f-ing mullahs and bigots (be their non bearded bastards living in the west or those still living in Bangladesh) have since independence worked to disenfranchise Hindus and minorities in this country. Any time anything happens - Hindus are asked to prove their loyalty - and even then, they are told to 'go BACK to India' at the drop of a hat...

Go back? Back where? This country/land - warts and all is there's too...yet, these evil bastards constantly prey on them.

So - India speaking up for them, sadly does them more harm. What needs to happen is those of us who think of Hindus as brothers, need to actually stand by them. Not just condemn the cave monkeys, but do something to reassure our hindu brothers and sisters - this is their home...this is where they belong.

I dont think govt of India has made any public statement... the concern was conveyed to the bd govt in private.. and we know now because it came up as a question in parliament which govt is required to answer.