What's new

Amit Shah condemned after he called Mahatma Gandhi ‘chatur baniya’

ashok321

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Nov 1, 2010
Messages
17,940
Reaction score
4
Country
Canada
Location
Malaysia
http://indianexpress.com/article/in...baniya-tha-he-knew-congress-weakness-4696862/

http://www.jantakareporter.com/india/mahatma-gandhi-chatur-baniya/129800/

baniya.png


BJP President on Friday called Mahatma Gandhi a chatur baniya (a cunning trader), a reference to the mercantile caste to which he was born.

Shah said that Gandhi had rightly advised dissolution of the Congress after Independence.

Addressing a select audience of “prominent citizens” here yesterday evening, Shah also said the Congress was not rooted in any ideology or principles and was sort of a “special purpose vehicle” to secure freedom.


In remarks that raised the hackles of the Congress, which demanded an apology from Shah as well as Prime Minister Narendra Modi, the BJP president went on term Mahatma Gandhi a “bahut chatur baniya”, a very shrewd baniya.

“The Congress party… was constituted as a club by a British man. It was later converted into an organisation engaged in freedom struggle,” Shah said.

It had in its fold both right and left-leaning people like Maulana Azad, Pandit Madan Mohan Malaviya and many others, he said.

West Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee too demanded apology from the BJP president, often notorious for his provocative and senseless remarks.

CPI general secretary S Sudhakar Reddy demanded that Shah seeks an apology for making the “derogatory” remarks.

Former CPI (M) general secretary Prakash Karat also hit out at Shah, saying his remark reveals “the contempt the BJP- RSS has for Gandhiji”.

“Rather than fighting casteism, they (BJP) identified even the father of the nation with his caste. This shows the character and ideology of the ruling party and its president.

Where will these people take the country?” party spokesperson Randeep Surjewala asked.

“We demand that Amit Shah, BJP and Prime Minister Narendra Modi apologise to the country, the families of freedom fighters and every citizen for insulting the freedom movement… and the father of the nation,” he said.

Twitter users too slammed the BJP president, who was accused of being involved in a series of fake encounters and even barred from entering his own state. Shah was acquitted both by the CBI and the Supreme Court in controversial circumstances.

Also Read: Amit Shah lost his cool when told by colleagues that demonetisation had backfired

Many reminded him about his alleged criminal past while others felt that he had simply gone too far in his hatred for Congress party.



Gandhi would have laughed at 'chatur baniya' remark: Mahatma's grandson:
 
The same party that slaughters cows which mahatma considered as god is talking about insulting him!!!

o_Oo_Oo_O:what::what::what::what:
 
but ...... but ........ but ....... Gandhi called himself a "greedy Baniya" :lol:

DB884gdUQAArBmE.jpg
 
Chutar? what does that mean? I am afraid its a bad choice of word for a leader !
 
Chutar? what does that mean? I am afraid its a bad choice of word for a leader !

Chatur means 'smart'.
Now calling someone smart is also an insult as per our Indian Seculars.
 
Chatur means 'smart'.
Now calling someone smart is also an insult as per our Indian Seculars.

"Chatur" means "shrewd"
 
Chatur means 'smart'.
Now calling someone smart is also an insult as per our Indian Seculars.
Bad days for Ghandi like people then.
 
He was clever that is why he asked for dissolution of Congress after 1947 .But didnt worked out .
 
Chutar? what does that mean? I am afraid its a bad choice of word for a leader !
What do you expect from a tadipaar criminal... These Sanghis always had malice for Gandhi.
 
Gandhi is certainly not the hero he is made out to be. Although he did made a lot of contributions to free the subcontinent from the Brits. Which everyone should recognize. That being said I see nothing wrong with Shah's statement. I have no business here. Just felt like saying what I said.
 
Fyi modi and shah are banyas too.
 
Fyi modi and shah are banyas too.

Shah is a bania who claims to be a Jain. Modi is a Teli Ghanchi which is supposed to be sudra. Is he also a bania?
 
Shah is a bania who claims to be a Jain. Modi is a Teli Ghanchi which is supposed to be sudra. Is he also a bania?
Jains too have a caste system.MOST Jains are either Kaishtrya or Bania. They marry within their caste. Even VHP chief and Hindutva icon Pravin Togadia is a jain. Shah is a baniya surname.

Modi is a bania surname. Banias who were involved in oil business came yo be known as ghanci telis. Modi granted obc status to ghanchi telis when he was the CM of Gujrat.
 
Back
Top Bottom