What's new

Aftermath of disaster and conflict: Army filling the void in Swat

VelocuR

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jun 4, 2009
Messages
6,188
Reaction score
5
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
Army eyes permanent bases in Swat


MINGORA: New threats risk delaying a handover to civilian leaders in Pakistan’s Swat valley, where the army remains in force two years ago after stamping out a Taliban insurgency and restoring peace.

After years of violence, a military offensive and devastating floods, Pakistani tourists this summer started coming back to the lush valleys, bubbling rivers and superb mountains of the famed northwestern district.

But if the scenery hasn’t changed, visitors from Islamabad, Lahore or Karachi need to negotiate a more recent fixture: the omnipresent uniformed soldiers and beige military vehicles.

"The clear air, the countryside, the luxury homes are better than ordinary camps". says a student Iftikhar Ali.

In the summer of 2009, the army sent 30,000 troops into battle against Taliban fighters controlled by Maulana Fazlullah, who since 2007 had terrorised people with a campaign of beheadings, violence and attacks on girls’ schools.

By July 2009 the army declared the region back under control and said the rebels had all been killed, captured or had fled.

Since then, Swat has lived in peace. There has been no deadly attack since a suicide bombing in the main town of Mingora in July 2010.
But two years on, there are still more than 25,000 soldiers in Swat filling the void left by years of conflict.

Former administrative offices, luxury homes or hotels with panoramic views … from Mingora to the northern reaches of the valley, the army has requisitioned dozens of buildings to house its troops.

Some make fun of the prolonged stay in a beautiful landscape with a climate far less punishing than the heat-blasted plains of the south.
“They’re taking advantage. The clear air, the countryside, the luxury homes are better than ordinary camps,” smiles Iftikhar Ali, 24, a student in the suburbs of the town of Madyan.

Everyone knows, however, that the army came to save them twice in the last two years: in kicking out the Taliban and during floods last year, which cut off 80 per cent of the population of Swat from the rest of the country.

“The army did a lot for us. They cleared roads, rebuilt bridges, gave us food rations, while the government was all promises and didn’t give us a single penny,” said Mohammed Iqbal, who sells clothes in Behrain, a tourist town partly devastated by the floods.

But the population of Swat, for a long time an autonomous princely state and without any military bases before 2009, is getting tired of the overt military presence, particularly the numerous checkpoints which hinder free movement.

Sardar Ali, 30, a worker in Mingora, acknowledged that checkpoint practices had eased in recent months, but said he was still fed up.
“Soldiers don’t listen to people’s complaints. Sometimes they are brutal and cruel, they beat people who rush to go through, even when it is for a medical emergency,” he told AFP.

“The army should stay in Swat, because the Taliban can come back. But soldiers have to stay in cantonments, not on the streets,” said Inayat Ur Rehman, a 40-year-old peasant, a view shared by a number of Swatis.

The army says 80 per cent of its checkpoints have been dismantled or handed over to police in the last year. It also insists it will hand over control to the civilian administration.

The army has ruled Pakistan for more than half its existence, most recently from 1999 until 2008, when the current civilian government was elected.

General Javed Iqbal, commander of the area, talked about a civilian transfer within “several months” as part of a “gradual process” in which “several steps still have to be taken”.

But it seems a return to normal could take much longer.
The army is planning to move into three or four cantonments, says Iqbal. The construction of the buildings alone, will take two years.

Then there is a spike in unrest in the neighbouring district of Dir, where the Taliban assaulted a police post in early June killing 10 policemen.

Dir borders the Afghan provinces of Kunar and Nuristan where a number of security officials believe Fazlullah and some of his fighters sought refuge.

“I am concerned,” admits Iqbal. “It is going to impact the process, but will not derail it.”

The head of the civilian administration in Swat, Kamran Rehman, says he is ready to take over immediately, but that it’s up to the army.
“Maybe in the coming one year,” he mused.

But one security official dismissed that out of hand. “My guess is it will take two or three more years,” he said.

:cheers:
 
my Tax !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:sick:
 
my Tax !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:sick:

You regret your taxes being used for reconstruction, elimination of terrorists and maintaining security and vigilance against a return of the terrorists?

BTW, on a related note, interesting that it is the FATA and Dir regions bordering Afghanistan, where US forces are ostensibly deployed to 'control terrorism', that the terrorists appear to be the hardest to stamp out, since they flee to Afghanistan to shelter and find sanctuary, and then regroup and return and attack Pakistan, while the US/ANA Military and intelligence does essentially nothing.

Well, they do a little better than 'nothing', the US has dismantled its existing bases and check-posts in Eastern Afghanistan to make it easier for the terrorists to find sanctuary in Afghanistan and carry out cross-border raids into Pakistan.

The CIA may even be supporting/perpetrating some of these terrorist raids into Pakistan through its 'paramilitaries', as revealed in Wikileaks.
 
my Tax !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:sick:

Feel sorry for you that your tax will be used to kill/capture your brother in arms, the taliban.

Hope Imran Khan& tehreek Insaf guys start to give their taxes to the Taliban instead of the state and hopefully you guys and your families would love to serve under the Taliban rule.
 
You regret your taxes being used for reconstruction, elimination of terrorists and maintaining security and vigilance against a return of the terrorists?

BTW, on a related note, interesting that it is the FATA and Dir regions bordering Afghanistan, where US forces are ostensibly deployed to 'control terrorism', that the terrorists appear to be the hardest to stamp out, since they flee to Afghanistan to shelter and find sanctuary, and then regroup and return and attack Pakistan, while the US/ANA Military and intelligence does essentially nothing.

Well, they do a little better than 'nothing', the US has dismantled its existing bases and check-posts in Eastern Afghanistan to make it easier for the terrorists to find sanctuary in Afghanistan and carry out cross-border raids into Pakistan.

The CIA may even be supporting/perpetrating some of these terrorist raids into Pakistan through its 'paramilitaries', as revealed in Wikileaks.

being tax payers, we have all the rights to question and challenge the misuse of our tax money,

read the article....
 
Pakistan should have built such bases long time ago after all it is a part of Pakistan and the Pakistan Army should install bases wherever it sees fit.
 
Good development. The army's presence should not fade away from Swat.

We do need permanent bases there to ensure that these insurgents do not return, and if they even try, they'll die.

It's understandable that people get fed up of going through all these heavily guarded checkpoints almost daily, but better to be safe than sorry.

Hopefully the tourism in Swat, as of now, can make solid inroads and flourish in the years to come.

It is a victory for all Pakistanis, to see people enjoying the beauty and nature of Swat once again. From being a warzone to going back to its original status.

The transition from the army to government/police institutions will take some time, but I for one think that the army's presence is necessary and vital for the coming years, untill we are sure these insurgents are eradicated from our soil.

1 suicide attack / bomb blast can be a huge setback, and our security forces working together with the locals there should do all they can to prevent it.

Pakistan Zindabad! :tup:
 
Army needs to maintain its permanent presence to makee sure the people of the area and Pakistan at large have a lasting peace and there are no terrorist havens.

All terrorists that were involved in destroying schools should be pursued and brought to justice. Great News.
 
Feel sorry for you that your tax will be used to kill/capture your brother in arms, the taliban.

Hope Imran Khan& tehreek Insaf guys start to give their taxes to the Taliban instead of the state and hopefully you guys and your families would love to serve under the Taliban rule.

I am sure none of the Tehreek - i - Insaaf members "side" with terrorism , TTP etc. I am sure you know that quite well. Proposing talks instead of military operations is never a wrong idea.

As for the taxes , they are there to pay for our security & military should and will use it in the rightest possible way. Swat should have had a military base ages ago , its something that has been long overdue.

Regards:
 
“The army did a lot for us. They cleared roads, rebuilt bridges, gave us food rations, while the government was all promises and didn’t give us a single penny,” said Mohammed Iqbal, who sells clothes in Behrain, a tourist town partly devastated by the floods.


Pardon my ignorance....but didnt the government order the Army to eliminate the terrorists...or the Army decided on its own....If the government ordered Army..then why this feeling amongst general populace ?
 
Feel sorry for you that your tax will be used to kill/capture your brother in arms, the taliban.

Hope Imran Khan& tehreek Insaf guys start to give their taxes to the Taliban instead of the state and hopefully you guys and your families would love to serve under the Taliban rule.

While Leader's statement wasn't very pleasant, I think it isn't very mature of you either to draw your opinion about a whole political party based on one guy's opinion.
 
Pardon my ignorance....but didnt the government order the Army to eliminate the terrorists...or the Army decided on its own....If the government ordered Army..then why this feeling amongst general populace ?

Because the Government is not stepping up and taking over security and reconstruction responsibilities, and the Government's past record, even in peace time, does not inspire confidence in its abilities.

Contracting reconstruction projects out to Military organizations is one thing, but when the entire effort is put in the hands of the military rather than coordinated through the civilian government (local, provincial or Federal) then what exactly is the point of having a civilian government?

Might as well remove the middle men of the 'elected representatives' and simply hand over control to the Army.
 
being tax payers, we have all the rights to question and challenge the misuse of our tax money,

read the article....

What exactly do you not agree with, in terms of how your tax money is being utilized in Swat?
 
What exactly do you not agree with, in terms of how your tax money is being utilized in Swat?

have you bothered yourself reading the article?? there is No need to have 2-3 new cantonments, just like there was no need for new GHQ. Its waste of Investor's money !!
 

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom