Afghan woman shot, blinded, for getting a job

[jamahir]

lol and we all know the level of journalism in india which is even worst than gutter.

Sorry are you crazy ? I said, and you can seen in the OP, that TOI quoted Reuters which is not an Indian agency.

 

[xyx007]

Such reports from Indian media against the Afghan Taliban rely on clichés cited from another report that is prepared without evidence. Most of these reports base themselves on anecdotal evidence taken from newspaper reports and political statements, and none of these reports verifies the allegations from ‘the supposed victims and so-called perpetrators. In these reports, claims are tautological and make circular arguments based on unverified/unverifiable secondary sources, as Indian Media always do. Millions of accounts in social media associated with Hindu extremist groups in India are the most active in spreading such allegations and they pick this allegation search in google and make it top trends.

 

[Baby Leone]

Sorry are you crazy ? I said, and you can seen in the OP, that TOI quoted Reuters which is not an Indian agency.

that is what i said indians are famous world wide for deceiving and manipulating actual news. further the Reuters only explained the news where Taliban didnt took any responsibility but the filthy indian OP in his rhetoric at the end blamed Taliban which suits indian filth that is called indian gutter journalism.

 

[hussain0216]

It's Afghanistan yes but where does the Taliban's ideology come from ?


The Taliban are very "progressive" hence dearly loved by the "democracy" spreading Western governments.

What Taliban?


It's afghans being afghans

 

[Death Professor]

extreme hijabi people like Yvonne Ridley

True Islam

So your issue is with hijab? Should I quote Quran with context? It would turn into a religious discussion, which I don't intend to start.

The Taliban was partly birthed by these same "invading forces".

So? they were fighting an invasion from another country, they appreciated US help. Now they are fighting US, they don't want to be invaded. And they have the full right to defend THEIR LAND.

the woman victim in the OP is Afghan.

And as I and many other have pointed out it might be a family issue.

So are the eleven executed women I spoke of. It is these innocent Afghans who don't like the Taliban and want them to be removed.

Media will portray them to be bad because it's their current narrative. The same media was portraying them as heroes during Soviet invasion. So no it doesn't matter what media reports, the actual truth is on the ground and you and I can't put a judgment on them based on just the media. Have to be on the ground to know the truth.

I desire for communism to govern India.

Eating beef is not all there is to being progressive.

GL with that. Very realistic and approachable desire. /s
And yes, eating beef comes in basic human rights. I can eat whatever the f. non-human thing I want. Government shouldn't be the one banning it, unless that creature is about to get extinct, harmful for humans or is the cause of death and viruses.

The Taliban are regressive, anti-human people.

Your subjective opinion doesn't matter one bit.

 

[jamahir]

and none of these reports verifies the allegations from ‘the supposed victims and so-called perpetrators.

Further the Reuters only explained the news where Taliban didnt took any responsibility

From the OP :

She and local authorities blame the attack on Taliban militants

She said that he provided the Taliban with a copy of her ID card to prove she worked for police and that he had called her throughout the day she was attacked, asking for her location.

Ghazni's police spokesman confirmed they believed the Taliban were behind the attack

What Taliban?

It's afghans being afghans

The SPA ( Solidarity Party of Afghanistan ) is also an Afghan group but with progressive and contrasting ideas to the Taliban.

But will the Western governments leave the SPA behind in charge of Afghanistan ?

So your issue is with hijab? Should I quote Quran with context? It would turn into a religious discussion, which I don't intend to start.

Maybe a simple hijab, maybe not at all. I can counter quote, which I have before.

But certainly not a centimeters thick "hijab" which Erdogan's wife wears or Yvonne Ridley wears.

But I agree, religious matters are not allowed on the forum.

And they have the full right to defend THEIR LAND.

Defend "their land" by oppressing their own people ? What logic is that ?

Your subjective opinion doesn't matter one bit.

So whose matters ?

Media will portray them to be bad because it's their current narrative.

So who originated that strange phrase "The good Taliban" ?

The same media was portraying them as heroes during Soviet invasion.

1. The Soviet Union did not invade but came to assist a brotherly country just like how Russia is currently assisting Syria.

2. An actual invasion is like how NATO + GCC invaded Libya.

Muslim shopkeeper beats up roadside Hindu diya vendor and his family in Agra

Here's some Dharmic anti-Muslim kindness on display in Delhi :

 

[hussain0216]

The SPA ( Solidarity Party of Afghanistan ) is also an Afghan group but with progressive and contrasting ideas to the Taliban.

But will the Western governments leave the SPA behind in charge of Afghanistan ?

Of course not, it's a not existent entity

 

[jamahir]

Of course not, it's a not existent entity

Approx 30,000 members is non-existent for you ?

The reason that Western governments will not leave behind the SPA in charge of governance is because the SPA is progressive, leftist, socialist. Simple.

 

[hussain0216]

Approx 30,000 members is non-existent for you ?

The reason that Western governments will not leave behind the SPA in charge of governance is because the SPA is progressive, leftist, socialist. Simple.

Yep that's pretty much non existent

Taliban will have more fighters in one province then that

 

[jamahir]

Yep that's pretty much non existent

Taliban will have more fighters in one province then that

So quantity should matter over quality ?

Does that mean I should stop supporting the Indian socialists, communists and progressives and start supporting the BJP because it has 180+ million members and the former have lot, lot less members ?

Taliban having more members shouldn't be the issue. Taliban should be removed. The Western countries can take them in since they support them so much. So many Afghans must be silently sick and tired of the Taliban.

 

[hunter_hunted]

It is really really easy to pin every crime on Taliban , i know taliban are no saints and who is saint in this world. Its just like Endians every pin every nonsense on Pakistanis, There need to be investigation before blaming others

 

[hussain0216]

So quantity should matter over quality ?

Does that mean I should stop supporting the Indian socialists, communists and progressives and start supporting the BJP because it has 180+ million members and the former have lot, lot less members ?

Taliban having more members shouldn't be the issue. Taliban should be removed. The Western countries can take them in since they support them so much. So many Afghans must be silently sick and tired of the Taliban.

The Taliban has massive support

If the people wished the Taliban gone they would have no ability to function inside AFGHANISTAN

 

[Gangetic]

No evidence it's the Taliban but did you know that Afghanistan has hundreds of different militant groups/gangs?

https://twitter.com/x/status/1326277191110365184

 

[jamahir]

The Taliban has massive support

If the people wished the Taliban gone they would have no ability to function inside AFGHANISTAN

Firstly, why are you fixated on legitimizing the anti-human Taliban despite them being involved in the crime in the OP ?

Secondly, you should visit the website of SPA ( here ) and see what the progressive activists among the Afghans understand about their society and what they want and whom they consider as criminal ( Taliban, ISIS, Hekmatyar, Sayyaf etc ).

No evidence it's the Taliban but did you know that Afghanistan has hundreds of different militant groups/gangs?

https://twitter.com/x/status/1326277191110365184

But the Taliban is the most dominant. The woman victim in the OP says her shooters / stabbers are the Taliban.

 

[hussain0216]

Firstly, why are you fixated on legitimizing the anti-human Taliban despite them being involved in the crime in the OP ?

Secondly, you should visit the website of SPA ( here ) and see what the progressive activists among the Afghans understand about their society and what they want and whom they consider as criminal ( Taliban, ISIS, Hekmatyar, Sayyaf etc ).



But the Taliban is the most dominant. The woman victim in the OP says her shooters / stabbers are the Taliban.

SPA is non existent

It's like saying we should put the afghan Boy scouts in charge of Afghanistan

This was not done by Taliban

This was afghans being afghans



The Taliban has mass support across Afghanistan, no peace is possible unless the Taliban come on board and are represented