Search results

Thats interesting. Pashto and Balochi are Indo-Iranian languages together with the indo aryan languages. But thats still yallah. Maybe it is retarted to create a new language. But first mother tongues should be national languages of Pakistan. The lingua franca/unity language which is today...

No, thats all. Thanks for asking. :-)

a) Ya Allah and not "Ya alla" Even google knows that. b) What did you then mean by "Islamic emirates of lost Al Arbi or al Persian al Bakistan" Again whats wrong with arabic language? Why is Urdu more important?

His name is الله or Allah. Subhanahu wa ta3la. Also there is no such thing as "Islamic emirates of lost Al Arbi or al Persian al Bakistan" Not even in Arabic. And whats wrong with Arabic? Arabic is language of Islam, Quran, and Prophet Muhammad saw.

Thats offensive. Watch your tone. Thats more reasonable. But I don't like to see English as national language. Mother tongues or provincial languages should be national languages and be protected. Switzerland has also German, French, Italian and Romansh as national languages. I wonder how they...

Yes there are couple of issues with priority first. But that doesn't mean to ignore everything else.

Well Pakistanis are Punjabis, Pashtuns, Kashmiris, Sindhis and Balochis. Which is also the meaning of Pakistan (P=Punjab, A= Afghania, K= Kashmir, S= Sindh, TAN= Balochistan = Pakistan = land of the pure) The 5 mother tongues should be made to national languages of Pakistan. The unity language/...

Identity of whom? For sure not of Pashtuns, Punjabis, Sindhis, Balochis, Kashmiris etc. = Pakistanis

What does &^%$# claim mean? Yes you are right about history and literature. But by creating a pakistani language (like I said in my first post) you can use history and literature of all 5 ethnic languages of Pakistan. Point is mixture of all the mother tongues of Pakistan. And also literature...

Well, no. Most people are able to understand and speak Urdu. But only as secondary. Many people who didn't visit school can't even speak Urdu. Which happens mainly in rural areas. Thats like going to Germany, Italy or Spain. And nearly every corner understands and speaks English because it is...

So you consider Urdu as your language and ignore the languages of your ethnic group? In Europe people also learn as secondary language English. But speak German, French, Italian, Spanish etc. as mother tongues. They consider these as their languages because these are the languages of their...

Thats very unfortunate and should be stopped. We Pakistanis are Pashtuns, Punjabis, Sindhis, Balochis, Kashmiris etc. They are our languages and our identity. I agree languages are not that easily created. But people want to get rid of foreign words in their languages all the time. For example...

No thanks. No need for more mongol empires. Pakistan was occupied by three mongol empires (Ghengiz Khan, Timurids and the Mughals). And Mughals ruled only mainly in eastern Pakistan (especially Lahore), elsewhere they were not present. They have more to do with your country. Urdu speakers can...

Oh excuse me, did I ask anything about India/dravidia. I'm sorry that I posted the thread in Pakistan social Issue and name of the thread is Would the creation of a new national language work for Pakistan? Again excuse me if it confused you.

For older generation it would be more difficult, but for younger generation it would be easy. Sry this is no problem/thread for you.

Many people discussed whether Urdu should be replaced with Persian or Arabic etc. Because to be honest Urdu has nothing to do with Pakistan and the British made Urdu to the national language of Pakistan since occupation before occupation it was Persian. Still today Urdu remains national language...

Are you retarted? They are from Pakistan and belong to the ethnic groups of Pakistan (Punjabis, Sindhis, Pashtun, Baloch, Kashmiris etc.) = hence their light skinned appearence. Pakistanis under British occupation (or your fake term "undevided India" lol) were also Punjabis, Pashtuns...

Than speak Pakistani Arabic. ;)

Than learn it. :smart:

In my opinion Pakistan's mother tongues (Pashto, Punjabi, Sindhi, Balochi and Kashmiri) should be made to national languages, Urdu should be replaced with Arabic, so it is secondary language or lingua franca, and English should be removed as official language only a voluntary language. So arabic...