What's new

Search results

  1. H

    Ram Jethmalani's comments anger Saudi ambassador

    Hi MadDog, Thanks for your quotes. IMHO, religion is (or, at any rate, should be) a science, and as any scientist knows, not all scientific contributions are equally credible or inspired. Then there are the issues of authenticity, and of accuracy of translations. Anyway, your quotes do not...
  2. H

    US's dalliance in Beijing is short-lived

    One year since 26/11, and there is no sign that the trial of the accused is going to start. Meanwhile Hafeez Saeed continues to go around preaching Jihad against the Kaffirs. Bhadrakumar has a very naive outlook.
  3. H

    Shiv Sena activists attack Indian TV channels

    He is a highly corrupt individual with no loyalty to anything. Will rake up any emotional issue that is not receiving enough attention from the political system.
  4. H

    Wasted youth: Reflections on the British Council report

    British Council: Pakistan facing 'frightening' demographic disaster - Telegraph Excerpts: One third of Pakistanis aged 18 to 29 who were surveyed believe in sharia, or Islamic law half have “a great deal of confidence” in religious-based education; just one third advocate democracy...
  5. H

    Facebook friendship turns into India-Bangladesh love story

    Well at least it's good that both are of the same religion, otherwise it would cause further trouble. Zubair should consider going to Bangladesh as a Ghar-Jamai.
  6. H

    TTP Taliban armed with Israeli weapons

    This is regarding the Samjhauta attack: U.N. sanction on Lashkar operative a blow to Pakistan Purohit is in jail for some other crimes, however.
  7. H

    5 Pak army officers linked to Headley, arrested

    Difficult to say as of now that the State is behind this. However, it does go pretty high up - these are elite folks. Headley alias Daoud Gilani is the son of a diplomat who was married to an American lady, and Tawahhur Rana's two brothers are Brigadiers in the Pk army.
  8. H

    NWFP History: Referendum and the Pakhtunistan demand

    The demand for Pakistan was strongest in the Muslim-minority area of UP. The people of Muslim majority areas that presently comprise Pakistan never had any fear of Hindu domination in a united India. Therefore such fears had to be artificially created through propaganda, rioting and Direct...
  9. H

    NWFP History: Referendum and the Pakhtunistan demand

    Tch, tch, it really is the simplest explanation. It becomes a "convoluted conspiracy theory" only for those wanting to studiously ignore lots of very well-established data. The general consensus within the Congress was a big-tent approach; what they did not want to do was to recognize communal...
  10. H

    NWFP History: Referendum and the Pakhtunistan demand

    Excerpts from "The Invention of Pakistan: How the British Raj Sundered" by Karl E. Meyer, World Policy Journal, Spring 2003. http://www.worldpolicy.org/journal/articles/wpj03-1/meyer.pdf
  11. H

    NWFP History: Referendum and the Pakhtunistan demand

    That's where Occam's razor comes in. Ultimately it is for the individual to decide what theory best explains the undeniable facts. The polar opposite of the Muslim League was the Hindu Mahasabha (not the Congress or the RSS, by the way). Jinnah and Nehru were both beneficiaries, and both were...
  12. H

    NWFP History: Referendum and the Pakhtunistan demand

    All of science is a "thesis", i.e. interpretation of data. So is Sarila's work. And the data he uses is very sound. I'm not denying that Pakistan was a culmination of a movement. The fanaticism that Jinnah was exploiting in the service of the British has been present since before British rule...
  13. H

    NWFP History: Referendum and the Pakhtunistan demand

    ^^^ Thus we see how the referendum in NWFP was only a very small part of overall British plans. I pretty much agree with Sarila - only caveat being that Pakistan was created by the Brits to put a check not only on the USSR - but also on (and primarily on) independent India. Pakistan can...
  14. H

    NWFP History: Referendum and the Pakhtunistan demand

    One has to be aware of the larger geopolitical goals of the British. The best study of this is "The Shadow of the Great Game – The Untold Story of India’s Partition" by Narendra Singh Sarila. Here is a review - well worth reading in full...
  15. H

    Islamabad is desperate for indian support in its civil war against the Taliban

    Unnecessarily provocative title. Pk is not asking for Indian help and India need not make any unwanted gratuitous offers.
  16. H

    NWFP History: Referendum and the Pakhtunistan demand

    Relevant to this topic is the book "Facts are Sacred" by Wali Khan. Book desription: An excerpt: This books is available online at Facts Are Sacred by Wali Khan
  17. H

    Kashmir | News & Discussions.

    One loose comment by a misguided individual does not become the "Indian sentiment".
  18. H

    Kashmir | News & Discussions.

    Operations far worse than Gaza happened in East Pakistan and Balochistan.
  19. H

    Sane Indian Cautions Against "Unconcealed Delight"

    Wait a minute, Pk is suffering from a thousand cuts, but there is no indication that India has anything to do with it.
  20. H

    Indian task force suggests inflicting ‘economic pain’ on Pakistan

    This is complete non-news. Planners routinely think about all kinds of contingency scenarios, including identification of targets. There was no need, however, for this report to be made public. I'd be very surprised if Pakistan Army hasn't produced similar internal reports.
Back
Top Bottom