Indians are giving the same stories as they taught it to afghans.
Remember Torkham Gate Skirmishes fiasco, Afghans were claiming that Gate construction ha stopped and there will b ni more gate and cease fire has been called and all is ok for us and at the end what happened...
You are mistaken here. It was started bec of road but ended up on holding the area. Chinese said they will talk about road only when Indians will withdrew. Indian said they will only withdrew if both will go back to 300meters.
m i right @beijingwalker @wanglaokan @nair
Chinese are claiming some kind Pyrrhic victory here.
Where as the facts here are -
1. Indians walked into Chinese territory of their own accord and walked out of their own accord. Despite tons of Chinese warnings.
How they walk out of their own accord. by MEA of Inida Both partied to go back...
Stand off started bec of road but currently the issue was India was in disputed area. So there was no mentioning of the road. It will come on later stages but for now it was more into holding the territory.
Let me ask straight.
Does India Forces withdrew only ? Yes/No
Chinese and Indian Force withdrew Together? Yes/No
Chinese are still patrolling the same area? Yes/No
Does Withdrawal Definition is "leave or cause to leave a place or situation". ? Yes/No
Let me ask straight.
Does India Forces withdrew only ? Yes/No
Chinese and Indian Force withdrew Together? Yes/No
Chinese are still patrolling the same area? Yes/No
Does Withdrawal Definition is "leave or cause to leave a place or situation". ? Yes/No
Let me ask straight.
Does India Forces withdrew only ? Yes/No
Chinese and Indian Force withdrew Together? Yes/No
Chinese are still patrolling the same area? Yes/No
Does Withdrawal Definition is "leave or cause to leave a place or situation". ? Yes/No
Let me ask straight.
Does India Forces...
Which both sides? Chinese are patrolling and India patrol withdrew? So thats what china was demanding.
Can you Patrol on AJK? Yes patrolling does esnure sovereignty of the state. CDI
You didn understand forget about the road for now. How both sides withdrew when chinese still holding it and patrolling it.
The argument was on Doklam land. Currently it wasnt about road. Indian wanted both Armies to withdraw and go back. BUT BUT chinese still patroling and indian went back...
You are assuming alot of things your self. Where it has mentioned that they will not build the road. Chinese said they consider it as their sovereign land. they are currently patrolling it. So can you explain in simple english when both armies withdrew as by Indian login then how come Chinese...
Who are those sources for arnab bhosaywami?
No mention of Mutual Withdrawal, No mention of Road. by both MEAs. Seems at last Indians Screwed themselves.
Let me ask in simple English what kind of withdrawal it is? when Chinese are still patrolling. So by common sense it means only Indian...
When Chinese are still patrolling the area. then in which dictionary withdrawal mean patrolling the same area. What kind of bulshiit Logic you guys have.
Like You know we both withdrew but hey they are still patrolling over there. oh no thats all right they still withdrew.
Bec m sure u will not believe Pakistanis or Chinese thats why i needed to bring your own people opinion. Any where it has mentioned that they will build the road or Chinese has withdrawn together with Indian Patrol.
As far i believe now there will be discussion between China and India...
You are concluded it so quickly. The current scenario is Indian patrol withdrew while Chinese are still patrolling until further comments from FO by Chinese or India you can not claim that road construction has been stopped. Chinese said they will only talk about road until india will withdraw...
Lets analyse it
So the current status is:
1) Indian Army has been withdrawn
2) Chinese Army is still patrolling the area
3) Road construction status is "pause" or halted for now.
Let analyse it with Demands made by both china and india.
India demanded:
1) Both parties to go back and...