What's new

The Taliban Take Kunduz: An Eyewitness Account

pakistani342

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jan 20, 2013
Messages
3,485
Reaction score
6
Country
United States
Location
United States
Article here, excerpts below:


The Diplomat’s Sanjay Kumar spoke to Ehsan, an Afghan government official in Kunduz, who due to security reasons has chosen not to reveal his real name and occupation. He describes the situation in the city.

The Diplomat: How serious is the situation in Kunduz?

Ehsan: The situation is very serious. Everyone who can be considered allied to the government, be it international NGO workers, government servants, army personnel, and police are trapped inside the city. The whole population is trapped. The Taliban is busy looting the government buildings, but so far they have not harmed the local people. They are mixing with local people and trying to take them into confidence. The insurgents are hiding in people’s houses.

Have they captured the whole city or part of it?

The city itself is now under the control of the Taliban. Only the airport, which is located outside the city, is still in government hands. Now the army, the government officers and the city administration are at the airport. The city is completely under the control of the Taliban. There was hardly any coordinated resistance from the government against the Taliban. The insurgents entered the city without many losses. Even the state governor (of Kunduz Province, eds.) is not in the city; he is in Tajikistan.

How you think the government is going to control the situation?

I don’t think they can control the situation now. Had they tried to control the situation earlier they could have secured the city. They had plenty of time. From three o’clock this the morning, when the attack started, until half-past-three in the afternoon they had time to take the initiative in securing the city, but the still Taliban managed to defeat them. The government had plenty of time to send troops from Kabul or many other places but they failed. Now it’ll be very difficult for the government to attack a city populated with thousands of civilians without causing significant collateral damage. These Talibs are hiding inside people’s houses and it will not be easy to segregate the population from the insurgents. I’ve heard that the government is planning to attack the city in the night, but I am not sure how they are going to manage that.

If the Taliban is mixed up with the local population how is the government going to control that?

So far, the Taliban have tried to stay on good terms with the local population, but in the long run they are not going to be that lenient. No one can leave the city. Under the Taliban, everyone becomes a spy. If the city remains in Taliban hands there will undoubtedly many civilian casualties.

How did people react when the Taliban took the city?

People are welcoming them now because they are afraid of the Taliban. If they don’t welcome them, they could be killed.

Do you think that Afghanistan needs international forces to stem the tide of growing Taliban resistance?

Only the intervention of the international forces could salvage the situation. I am not confident about the local Afghan National Army’s ability to recover the lost ground. If the local forces intervened, there could potentially be many civilian casualties. Only international forces can handle the situation.
 
Bottom Line : Afghan Army is a joke.

What I think some folks forget is that the development of a soldier starts even before the womb. The socioeconomic conditions the child is born into, the education he/she has, the nutrition he/she has when growing up, the education, etc. etc.

ANSF has severe problems but what would you expect, Afghanistan has been ravaged now by almost 40 years of instability.
 
What I think some folks forget is that the development of a soldier starts even before the womb. The socioeconomic conditions the child is born into, the education he/she has, the nutrition he/she has when growing up, the education, etc. etc.

ANSF has severe problems but what would you expect, Afghanistan has been ravaged now by almost 40 years of instability.
Sadly, the times Afghanistan has been stable have been few and far between. This situation has been going on for centuries.

If the ANA can't get the city back quickly, it'll be (sadly) the first of many to fall. International forces may end up having to go back in.
 
US should have listened to good advise from old friend, taken OBL without fighting and helped the then Afghan government in reforms. At one tenth the cost of war, zero loss of life and the same time frame, Afghanistan would have been a much better and peaceful country, but cowboys are cowboys and they need to shoot at every problem, even if the problem is an irritant fly sitting on their own foot.
 
Back
Top Bottom