What's new

Archaeologists discover huge ivory factory in Pakistan's ancient Bhanbhore city

Kailash Kumar

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Oct 8, 2018
Messages
4,643
Reaction score
-1
Country
Suriname
Location
Netherlands
Archaeologists discover huge ivory factory in Pakistan's ancient Bhanbhore city

February 20, 2020

1980716-281226941.jpg

Italian and Pakistan archaeologists visit ancient Bhanbhore city on February 8, 2020

KARACHI: Archaeologists from Italy and Pakistan believe that the discovery of a large elephant ivory stock in Bhanbhore seems to suggest that there was a big factory for the commodity in the area, officials said on Thursday.

An ancient city located about 65 kilometers east of Karachi, Bhanbhore provided a gateway to Arab conquerors who arrived in South Asia hundreds of years ago and dominated the region.

2_16_1.jpg

Italian and Pakistan archaeologists visit ancient Bhanbhore city on February 8, 2020

“Technical experts of archaeology from Italy and Pakistan have come to the conclusion that Bhanbhore was a trade and industrial city where a big factory of elephant ivory existed,” Sindh’s Director Heritage Muhammad Shah Bukhari told Arab News on Thursday, adding that the findings were disclosed in a technical seminar in Karachi a day earlier.

Sharing the findings with the participants of the technical seminar on Wednesday, Italian archaeologist Dr. Simone Mantellini said that the antiquities recovered from Bhanbhore included 6,675 ivories, the largest such recovery anywhere in the world. “Nowhere else in the world have ivories been found in such a large quantity. Ivories were found in Iraq but those were small in number,” Mantellini said, adding that such a huge recovery proved there was a factory for the commodity in the city.

3_12_1.jpg

Italian and Pakistan archaeologists visit ancient Bhanbhore city on February 8, 2020

The first excavation survey of Bhanbhore was carried out by Sindh’s Department of Archaeology and Museums in 1965. More recently, the government launched another round of exploration in 2012 in collaboration with Italian and French missions in Pakistan.

After each excavation, Bukhari added, a technical study was done by the Italian mission in collaboration with the Department of Culture, Tourism, Antiquities of the University of Khairpur, Sindh University, and Bahria University.


Bhanbhore and Arabs

Bhanbhore is said to have witnessed several political upheavals since its emergence in the first century BCE. Yet, the place was immortalized by an Arab general who changed the course of history by invading this town.

Long before the mighty Indus river meandered away from the settlement, forcing the residents of Bhanbhore to abandon their dwellings, Muhammad bin Qasim, an Umayyad warrior, defeated Sindh’s Brahmin ruler, Raja Dahar, in 711 CE and conquered large swathes of land. Today, Pakistan’s second busiest harbor, Port Qasim, is named after the Arab general.

“The south gate of Bhanbhore Fort from which Muhammad bin Qasim entered the citadel was later called the ‘gateway of Islam’ in South Asia,” Qazi Asif, a researcher, said.

Although a French archaeologist, Monique Kervran, says her findings of Bhanbhore confirm that Debal – ruled by Raja Dahar – and Bhanbhore are names of the same place, Dr. Asma Ibrahim, a Pakistani archaeologist, says her research unearthed an underwater city nearby that was most likely Debal.

“The excavation work is still to be carried at the [underwater] city some 12 kilometers from Bhanbhore in the sea where a panel of Kufic inscription – along with one big and one small mosque – has been found,” she told Arab News.

The outline of the underwater city, she added, could be observed between 6 am and 8 p.m. on the 20th and 21st of a lunar month.

Ibrahim, whose research is yet to be published, informed that the excavated material of glass from Bhanbhore confirmed that it was imported from the Middle East since there was no kiln in this region in olden days.

“It was one of the major industrial and trade centers of the world,” she said, adding: “While the archaeological sites in Bhanbhore await more excavation, there are strong imprints of Arab Muslims.”

https://www.arabnews.pk/node/1630711/pakistan
 
Archaeologists discover huge ivory factory in Pakistan's ancient Bhanbhore city

February 20, 2020

1980716-281226941.jpg

Italian and Pakistan archaeologists visit ancient Bhanbhore city on February 8, 2020

KARACHI: Archaeologists from Italy and Pakistan believe that the discovery of a large elephant ivory stock in Bhanbhore seems to suggest that there was a big factory for the commodity in the area, officials said on Thursday.

An ancient city located about 65 kilometers east of Karachi, Bhanbhore provided a gateway to Arab conquerors who arrived in South Asia hundreds of years ago and dominated the region.

2_16_1.jpg

Italian and Pakistan archaeologists visit ancient Bhanbhore city on February 8, 2020

“Technical experts of archaeology from Italy and Pakistan have come to the conclusion that Bhanbhore was a trade and industrial city where a big factory of elephant ivory existed,” Sindh’s Director Heritage Muhammad Shah Bukhari told Arab News on Thursday, adding that the findings were disclosed in a technical seminar in Karachi a day earlier.

Sharing the findings with the participants of the technical seminar on Wednesday, Italian archaeologist Dr. Simone Mantellini said that the antiquities recovered from Bhanbhore included 6,675 ivories, the largest such recovery anywhere in the world. “Nowhere else in the world have ivories been found in such a large quantity. Ivories were found in Iraq but those were small in number,” Mantellini said, adding that such a huge recovery proved there was a factory for the commodity in the city.

3_12_1.jpg

Italian and Pakistan archaeologists visit ancient Bhanbhore city on February 8, 2020

The first excavation survey of Bhanbhore was carried out by Sindh’s Department of Archaeology and Museums in 1965. More recently, the government launched another round of exploration in 2012 in collaboration with Italian and French missions in Pakistan.

After each excavation, Bukhari added, a technical study was done by the Italian mission in collaboration with the Department of Culture, Tourism, Antiquities of the University of Khairpur, Sindh University, and Bahria University.


Bhanbhore and Arabs

Bhanbhore is said to have witnessed several political upheavals since its emergence in the first century BCE. Yet, the place was immortalized by an Arab general who changed the course of history by invading this town.

Long before the mighty Indus river meandered away from the settlement, forcing the residents of Bhanbhore to abandon their dwellings, Muhammad bin Qasim, an Umayyad warrior, defeated Sindh’s Brahmin ruler, Raja Dahar, in 711 CE and conquered large swathes of land. Today, Pakistan’s second busiest harbor, Port Qasim, is named after the Arab general.

“The south gate of Bhanbhore Fort from which Muhammad bin Qasim entered the citadel was later called the ‘gateway of Islam’ in South Asia,” Qazi Asif, a researcher, said.

Although a French archaeologist, Monique Kervran, says her findings of Bhanbhore confirm that Debal – ruled by Raja Dahar – and Bhanbhore are names of the same place, Dr. Asma Ibrahim, a Pakistani archaeologist, says her research unearthed an underwater city nearby that was most likely Debal.

“The excavation work is still to be carried at the [underwater] city some 12 kilometers from Bhanbhore in the sea where a panel of Kufic inscription – along with one big and one small mosque – has been found,” she told Arab News.

The outline of the underwater city, she added, could be observed between 6 am and 8 p.m. on the 20th and 21st of a lunar month.

Ibrahim, whose research is yet to be published, informed that the excavated material of glass from Bhanbhore confirmed that it was imported from the Middle East since there was no kiln in this region in olden days.

“It was one of the major industrial and trade centers of the world,” she said, adding: “While the archaeological sites in Bhanbhore await more excavation, there are strong imprints of Arab Muslims.”

https://www.arabnews.pk/node/1630711/pakistan

Are they sure it ain't from Zardari era. A lot of factories were closed at that time.
 
SO much megafauna has gone extinct from Pakistan...Tigers,Lions,Elephants,Rhinos,leopards,cheetahs...... one can only weep

at least snow leopards and various types of bears are still there

Leopards are still found in every province and territory of Pakistan, though no where near as abundantly as before. Punjab, Balochistan, Sindh, KPK, GB, AJK all have populations.

Asiatic Cheetahs were thought to have been extinct in Balochistan but there still are occasional confirmed sightings, tracks and carcasses found there.

Might not be the case for long for either of them if we keep on with the idiocy with which we treat our wildlife.
 
Archaeologists discover huge ivory factory in Pakistan's ancient Bhanbhore city

February 20, 2020

1980716-281226941.jpg

Italian and Pakistan archaeologists visit ancient Bhanbhore city on February 8, 2020

KARACHI: Archaeologists from Italy and Pakistan believe that the discovery of a large elephant ivory stock in Bhanbhore seems to suggest that there was a big factory for the commodity in the area, officials said on Thursday.

An ancient city located about 65 kilometers east of Karachi, Bhanbhore provided a gateway to Arab conquerors who arrived in South Asia hundreds of years ago and dominated the region.

2_16_1.jpg

Italian and Pakistan archaeologists visit ancient Bhanbhore city on February 8, 2020

“Technical experts of archaeology from Italy and Pakistan have come to the conclusion that Bhanbhore was a trade and industrial city where a big factory of elephant ivory existed,” Sindh’s Director Heritage Muhammad Shah Bukhari told Arab News on Thursday, adding that the findings were disclosed in a technical seminar in Karachi a day earlier.

Sharing the findings with the participants of the technical seminar on Wednesday, Italian archaeologist Dr. Simone Mantellini said that the antiquities recovered from Bhanbhore included 6,675 ivories, the largest such recovery anywhere in the world. “Nowhere else in the world have ivories been found in such a large quantity. Ivories were found in Iraq but those were small in number,” Mantellini said, adding that such a huge recovery proved there was a factory for the commodity in the city.

3_12_1.jpg

Italian and Pakistan archaeologists visit ancient Bhanbhore city on February 8, 2020

The first excavation survey of Bhanbhore was carried out by Sindh’s Department of Archaeology and Museums in 1965. More recently, the government launched another round of exploration in 2012 in collaboration with Italian and French missions in Pakistan.

After each excavation, Bukhari added, a technical study was done by the Italian mission in collaboration with the Department of Culture, Tourism, Antiquities of the University of Khairpur, Sindh University, and Bahria University.


Bhanbhore and Arabs

Bhanbhore is said to have witnessed several political upheavals since its emergence in the first century BCE. Yet, the place was immortalized by an Arab general who changed the course of history by invading this town.

Long before the mighty Indus river meandered away from the settlement, forcing the residents of Bhanbhore to abandon their dwellings, Muhammad bin Qasim, an Umayyad warrior, defeated Sindh’s Brahmin ruler, Raja Dahar, in 711 CE and conquered large swathes of land. Today, Pakistan’s second busiest harbor, Port Qasim, is named after the Arab general.

“The south gate of Bhanbhore Fort from which Muhammad bin Qasim entered the citadel was later called the ‘gateway of Islam’ in South Asia,” Qazi Asif, a researcher, said.

Although a French archaeologist, Monique Kervran, says her findings of Bhanbhore confirm that Debal – ruled by Raja Dahar – and Bhanbhore are names of the same place, Dr. Asma Ibrahim, a Pakistani archaeologist, says her research unearthed an underwater city nearby that was most likely Debal.

“The excavation work is still to be carried at the [underwater] city some 12 kilometers from Bhanbhore in the sea where a panel of Kufic inscription – along with one big and one small mosque – has been found,” she told Arab News.

The outline of the underwater city, she added, could be observed between 6 am and 8 p.m. on the 20th and 21st of a lunar month.

Ibrahim, whose research is yet to be published, informed that the excavated material of glass from Bhanbhore confirmed that it was imported from the Middle East since there was no kiln in this region in olden days.

“It was one of the major industrial and trade centers of the world,” she said, adding: “While the archaeological sites in Bhanbhore await more excavation, there are strong imprints of Arab Muslims.”

https://www.arabnews.pk/node/1630711/pakistan

Good find but a poor grasp of history. Islam, Muslims, and Arabs arrived in Sindh long before Ummayad Army. The Arabs were known to frequent Sindh for trade both before and after the Ummayad invasion and Sindis are also known to travel to Arabia/Hejaz. People who opposed the Ummayad regime and managed to escape their persecution are believed to have sought refuge in Sindh and had been provided asylum by the rulers there. This is believed to be one of the reasons Ummayad governor Hajjaj Bin Yousif sought to occupy Sindh. Interestingly, the asylum seekers continued to seek refuge in Sindh even after the Ummayad occupation.

Additionally, I do not think Muhammad Bin Qasim came for tableegh either. In fact, conversions to Islam were banned by the Ummayad ruler Al-Walid and Hajjaj Bin Yousif throughout the Ummayad occupied territories to increase jizya collection. Sindh may be Babul-e-Islam but I do not believe the credit for it lies with the Ummayads.

As far as the archaeological history is concerned, according to Captain James McMurdo's assessment, in his Dissertation on the Indus River, at the time the Ummayads had invaded Sindh, there was no city at Debal. It was barren sandy land. Presence of piracy in the area would have also rendered it an unlivable place for the urban population. There was an ancient city of Bhambhor but whether it was situated at Debal or not, or even if it existed any more at the time, is disputed. Though, the Arab administration does appear to have resettled Bhambhor after the occupation.

A small take away; the battle between the Ummayad forces and Rao Dahir took place at Alor (now Rohri), not at Debal/Bhambhor. Alor had been Sindh's capital for quite a long time.
 
Last edited:
SO much megafauna has gone extinct from Pakistan...Tigers,Lions,Elephants,Rhinos,leopards,cheetahs...... one can only weep

at least snow leopards and various types of bears are still there
Also humans.

Good find but a poor grasp of history. Islam, Muslims, and Arabs arrived in Sindh long before Ummayad Army. The Arabs were known to frequent Sindh for trade both before and after the Ummayad invasion and Sindis are also known to travel to Arabia/Hejaz. People who opposed the Ummayad regime and managed to escape their persecution are believed to have sought refuge in Sindh and had been provided asylum by the rulers there. This is believed to be one of the reasons Ummayad governor Hajjaj Bin Yousif sought to occupy Sindh. Interestingly, the asylum seekers continued to seek refuge in Sindh even after the Ummayad occupation.

Additionally, I do not think Muhammad Bin Qasim came for tableegh either. In fact, conversions to Islam were banned by the Ummayad ruler Al-Walid and Hajjaj Bin Yousif throughout the Ummayad occupied territories to increase jizya collection. Sindh may be Babul-e-Islam but I do not believe the credit for it lies with the Ummayads.

As far as the archaeological history is concerned, according to Captain James McMurdo's assessment, in his Thesis on Indus River, at the time the Ummayads had invaded Sindh, there was no city at Debal. It was barren sandy land. Presence of piracy in the area would have also rendered it an unlivable place for the urban population. There was an ancient city of Bhambhor but whether it was situated at Debal or not, or even if it existed any more at the time, is disputed. Though, the Arab administration does appear to have resettled Bhambhor after the occupation.

A small take away; the battle between the Ummayad forces and Rao Dahir took place at Alor (now Rohri), not at Debal/Bhambhor. Alor had been Sindh's capital for quite a long time.
Source please
 
Also humans.


Source please

There are several. Most of the works were done by Arab scholars themselves. But if you want the comprehensive (yet concise) knowledge base in one place I recommend the book/thesis "Arabs in Sindh: 712-1026 AD" by John Jahangir Bede. He has covered some of the major historical sources who have written about the conquest of Sindh. In fact, there is a complete chapter by Bede covering the Arab, Persian, Ghaznavid and even Chinese sources who have written about Sindh, both before and after the conquest by the Ummayads. Bede's book is now available in Pakistan thanks to Endowment Fund Trust of Sindh. If you want to go directly into the Arab sources start with Ahmed Ibn Jabir al-Baladhuri's book "Kitab Futuh al-Buldan." There are two volumes of the book and, I believe, the chapter on the conquest of Sindh is in the second volume. al-Biruni is also known to have written a little bit about Sindh and its conquest, possibly in his book "Tahqiq ma li'l-Hind." Of course, the most popular source is the "Chachnama" aka "Fatahnamah. The book is a translation by Ali Kufi. No one knows who the original author was. A more modern work/analysis on Chachnama is done by Manan Ahmed Asif in his book "A Book of Conquest: The Chachnama & Muslim Origins in South Asia." Captain James McMurdo's "Dissertation on the River Indus" (written in 1834) is more of a geographical study but he deliberates on some interesting points that put the historical narrative in perspective as well. Similarly, Major General M. R. Haig's "The Indus Delta Country: A Memoir" is another book to look into. His work appears to comprehensively cover the history and geography of Sindh, though I must confess that I have not read the book even as it sits in front of me right now. This one should be easy to find as well, again thanks to Endowment Fund Trust of Sindh. For local sources, I would recommend Hassam-ud-Din Rashidi, his brother Ali Muhammad Rashidi, and Dr Nabi Baksh Khan Baloch. Though I am unsure if the Rashidi brothers have written extensively on the Arab conquest of Sindh.

If you can wait for a few years I might right up a book on the subject myself. Then you can read that :)
 
Last edited:
SO much megafauna has gone extinct from Pakistan...Tigers,Lions,Elephants,Rhinos,leopards,cheetahs...... one can only weep

at least snow leopards and various types of bears are still there

The Indus: where it has helped sustain civilization in lower delta it has also brought dissolution and destruction. Before the advent of the canal system, the Indus remained untamed and moody diverting itself away from the very civilizational settlements, plants, and animal lifeform it helped sustain. It abandoned the Mo'an Jo Daro in ancient times. It abandoned the city of Khudabad as well during the Kalhoro period. Kalhoras finally settled a city around Neron Kot area in Sindh where the Indus sustained itself. The city is now known as Hyderabad. Then came canal systems, which ensured the river remained where it was. Needless to say, canals and dams have brought their own problems to wildlife.
 
Additionally, I do not think Muhammad Bin Qasim came for tableegh either. In fact, conversions to Islam were banned by the Ummayad ruler Al-Walid and Hajjaj Bin Yousif throughout the Ummayad occupied territories to increase jizya collection. Sindh may be Babul-e-Islam but I do not believe the credit for it lies with the Ummayads.

Zia took this fairy tale of ummayds being the servants of Islam to another level but in reality its Balochistan which deserves to be called babul Islam as far as sub continent is concerned
 
Zia took this fairy tale of ummayds being the servants of Islam to another level but in reality its Balochistan which deserves to be called babul Islam as far as sub continent is concerned

So much to say on your first line but I am afraid discourse would turn into a misdemeanour by some. Anyway, Balochistan was a disputed territory between Sindh and Persia. According to Chachnama (I believe), Rai Sahiras II of Sindh is believed to have died in a battle against the Persians in Makran in an attempt to secure Balochistan's territory [though Wikipedia states he died fighting against the King of Nimruz (Afghanistan)]. In any case, Sindh had its territories as far as Persia to the West and across Multan in the North, where it was at conflict with Kashmiri empire. I am unsure of the history of large swaths of Balochistan once Persia fell to the Muslims but generally, Hind-wa-Sindh (Indian subcontinent) began in Sindh (which extended to Multan) for the Arabs and Persians. Thus, the land was referred to as Bab al-Islam.
 
Last edited:
SO much megafauna has gone extinct from Pakistan...Tigers,Lions,Elephants,Rhinos,leopards,cheetahs...... one can only weep

at least snow leopards and various types of bears are still there
Brilliant comment. On a lighter note another thing missing from Pakistan are the shareefs. They can be found in Harrods
 
SO much megafauna has gone extinct from Pakistan...Tigers,Lions,Elephants,Rhinos,leopards,cheetahs...... one can only weep

at least snow leopards and various types of bears are still there

Elephants were always farmed in past here and never part of the natural habitat,same with Rhino.
Lion family(Cougars,Jaguars,Mountain cat,Leapords) are still found today in the north however numbers depleted over time..
Tiger ive never heard of ..
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom