Altaf demands at least 20 administrative units in Pakistan

[Hyde]

Everybody demands for more provinces but no practical work on ground

Shall we only talk about the matter over and over again?

 

[pak-marine]

He can demand all he wants but the elite powerful feudal lords will never let this happen. Sindhi nationalists have started protests PTI should work with MQM to pass land reforms bill in the NA .. Wonder what's stopping is ego or if they are afraid of loosing credit

 

[PurpleButcher]

Every division should be made a province.

Number of ministries/province must be restriced to max 5. otherwise we will have an army of VVIPs

Center must only have Defence,Finance and Foreign Ministries. Rest should be given to divisions

Also enough with this Federal area bulshit.. no fata just small divisions

Pakistan should become the United States of Paksitan

 

[ice_man]

very valid DEMAND.

however, will never happen reason is simple they all are scared of losing their grip on power.

Imagine 10 provinces all of a sudden Punjab & sindh are at the level of KPK in terms of provincial power. these politicans will all lose the power they enjoy compared to ministers or political parties of kpk.

only thing which can be done is after 18th amendment all provinces get fair share in NFC.

those funds and resources should be utilized well. no one ever asks for audit of where provinces spend there money that they get.

hence audit of every province a must.

make federal government only responsible for security of the nation and foreign policy.

 

[saiyan0321]

Very reasonable demand as long as the provinces are based on administration basis and not nationalistic basis. This can allow more developed cities in pakistan and will allow fairer representations from all of pakistan.

 

[Horseman]

Hypocrisy at its worst.

 

[Peaceful Civilian]

View attachment 58708
Hypocrisy at its worst.

Issue is the civil war after Bilawal said that he will not allow to divide sindh at any cost... Also May be due to Karachi issue, if they get separate province then they will demand new country ... While i believe, you have right to demand separate country & live freely there. No blockage of youtube, daru in public markets, night clubs etc

 

[Patriots]

Issue is the civil war after Bilawal said that he will not allow to divide sindh at any cost... Also May be due to Karachi issue, if they get separate province then they will demand new country ... While i believe, you have right to demand separate country & live freely there. No blockage of youtube, daru in public markets, night clubs etc

What a logic dude ... If Karachi will become province then it will be demanded as separate country ... I think 6 provinces should be made within Sindh .. So it means that all 6 provinces will be made later separate countries ..........

 

[Imran Khan]

Issue is the civil war after Bilawal said that he will not allow to divide sindh at any cost... Also May be due to Karachi issue, if they get separate province then they will demand new country ... While i believe, you have right to demand separate country & live freely there. No blockage of youtube, daru in public markets, night clubs etc

sirf daru or clubs ke liye mulk nhi tora jata yaar

 

[Kabira]

Except sindh and karachi, every other province should be divided into 3 or 4 provinces.

Why not Sindh?

 

[Samandri]

Why not Sindh?

Because MQM are supporting demands of new provinces, to pave the way for their own Karachi or Mohajiristan province. Sindhis will feel that they are deprived of a port city and business centre. Sindhis would protest against it and mohajirs would reteliate through violence. So its better to keep sindh intact. But if it has to be partitioned, it shouldnt be partitioned along linguistic lines. Division of sindh should be such that sindhi majority districts should be attached to karachi city , making it province with sindhi majority i.e a city shouldnt become a province. Those who give example of singapore, have no respect for sindhis and their sensitivites. If Hazara or seraikistan are demanding to be separate provinces then it makes sense. Historically hazara e karlugh (present day hazara plus attock) and multan always have been separate provincs of mughal empire and before. Rest of KPK can be divided into south, central and northren provinces. Balochistan can be divided into quetta (former british balochistan), kalat and makran.

 

[Patriots]

Because MQM are supporting demands of new provinces, to pave the way for their own Karachi or Mohajiristan province. Sindhis will feel that they are deprived of a port city and business centre. Sindhis would protest against it and mohajirs would reteliate through violence. So its better to keep sindh intact. But if it has to be partitioned, it shouldnt be partitioned along linguistic lines. Division of sindh should be such that sindhi majority districts should be attached to karachi city , making it province with sindhi majority i.e a city shouldnt become a province. Those who give example of singapore, have no respect for sindhis and their sensitivites. If Hazara or seraikistan are demanding to be separate provinces then it makes sense. Historically hazara e karlugh (present day hazara plus attock) and multan always have been separate provincs of mughal empire and before. Rest of KPK can be divided into south, central and northren provinces. Balochistan can be divided into quetta (former british balochistan), kalat and makran.

Do you know that Karachi is not the part of Sindh historically that's why Sindhi was not a dominating community over here .......

 

[Samandri]

Do you know that Karachi is not the part of Sindh historically that's why Sindhi was not a dominating community over here .......

Debal - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

[farhan_9909]

I don't know but this guy is talking sense from the past few months.

 

[pkuser2k12]

Good to see that youthias are not opposing this demand.

uncle g pti has already passed resolution to make Hazara a new province PTI took practical steps and as usual the ppp waderars and pmln industrialists setting in national assembly are in no mood to pass it in the national assembly .


Resolution to create Hazara province passed
March 22, 2014
Resolution to create Hazara province passed



Hazara province resolution: ‘PTI did its part, ball now in PML-N’s court’
March 27, 2014
Hazara province resolution: ‘PTI did its part, ball now in PML-N’s court’ – The Express Tribune


Hazara province is roughly 1/3 of kpk province

and according to ANP and PPP passing of this resolution is THE proof that PTI is anti pukhtoon