Senators say CPEC turned into ‘China-Punjab’ corridor

Zaneesh852 said:

Like how?


Well FATA is itself to blame, have producer more insurgents throughout history than intellectuals.

Click to expand...

if we follow a true federal system then yes we can have a good representation ... all the ethnics should be given equal number of seats in parliament and in senate.... now dont you think its wrong that winning in one province gin Punjab only gives mandate to PMLN to make federal gov ?? wheras in other provinces their seats are not in great numbers .... we must give equal share to every1 ...

Manidabest said:

if we follow a true federal system then yes we can have a good representation ... all the ethnics should be given equal number of seats in parliament and in senate.... now dont you think its wrong that winning in one province gin Punjab only gives mandate to PMLN to make federal gov ?? wheras in other provinces their seats are not in great numbers .... we must give equal share to every1 ...

Click to expand...

They are in Senate where each province holds equal seats, but allowing 60% to share the same portion as 12% is injustice to 60%. Punjab has the largest population and thus is naturally the King Maker.

Punjab has 60% or 40% or 80% it doesnt matter they should have equal share ....baloch, pashtoons,sindhis,gilgit baltistanis are represented as a nation in Pakistani federation based on their ethnicity not based on their population

Manidabest said:

Punjab has 60% or 40% or 80% it doesnt matter they should have equal share ....baloch, pashtoons,sindhis,gilgit baltistanis are represented as a nation in Pakistani federation based on their ethnicity not based on their population

Click to expand...

why? The same was done to East Pakistan by the West Pakistan...If ethnicity is the issue then Pukhtuns are different from Hazaras and Balochistan having Brohis, Pukhtons,Hazaras,Uzbiks,Balochs and Punjabis all in it? How would that work out? For example, do we have equal share for provincial budget for hazara belt in KPK? and likewise in other provinces? You're trying to make things difficult for you by making an argument which doesn't hold weight.

Zaneesh852 said:

why? The same was done to East Pakistan by the West Pakistan...If ethnicity is the issue then Pukhtuns are different from Hazaras and Balochistan having Brohis, Pukhtons,Hazaras,Uzbiks,Balochs and Punjabis all in it? How would that work out? For example, do we have equal share for provincial budget for hazara belt in KPK? and likewise in other provinces? You're trying to make things difficult for you by making an argument which doesn't hold weight.

Click to expand...

well i just made a statement but to come to a solution we as Pakistanis need to think about it and come out with a solution for all the ethnics to have equal representation either it means more provinces or coming on unified solution of distributing resources but equal representation is must ....

Manidabest said:

well i just made a statement but to come to a solution we as Pakistanis need to think about it and come out with a solution for all the ethnics to have equal representation either it means more provinces or coming on unified solution of distributing resources but equal representation is must ....

Click to expand...

I am asking does same thing happen in KPK what you're advocating so vigorously?

well i say is that either address the concerns of minorities in provinces under the federal constitution or make new provinces simple based on ethnicity not based on religion

Manidabest said:

well i say is that either address the concerns of minorities in provinces under the federal constitution or make new provinces simple based on ethnicity not based on religion

Click to expand...

Which province is expected to be made on religion in Pakistan?

i mean sect base...

china has need a transit rout from kashghar to gawadar .china,s own costel area is 3500 mile far from kashghar. pakistani costel area gawadar is 1500 mile far from kashghar .china need direct rout from kashghar to gawadar. pakistani politetions passes this direct rout through pakistan,s big cities which is dangerous for our people as security and defense point of view.otherwise it increase the distance between kashghar& gawadar which will not acceptable for china because china need quick response from kashghar to gawadar.

OK

Faiez said:

This my suggestion for the CPEC route to make it fair for all of the provinces of Pakistan:

Click to expand...

Few observations
> It hardly touches FATA
> Karachi, Lahore are not touched
> It ends up in Skardu (which you labelled as China)

Anyways nice effort

Here is my suggestion. Make a ten lane highway in Western Corridor and link it to Central Asian states.

Realizing Pakistan's Geo-Political Importance

What are we missing here now?

Here's fresh example of Hypocritical Politics on CPEC by KPK's political elite




Both happened on the same day.