What's new

Pakistani image on an Afghan campus

Devil Soul

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jun 28, 2010
Messages
22,931
Reaction score
45
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Pakistani image on an Afghan campus
By Our Correspondent
Published: December 19, 2016
4SHARES
SHARE TWEET
MAZAR-E-SHARIF: During a recent visit to the Balkh University in this northern city in Afghanistan, students were found to be critical of Pakistan’s polices, but many had positive observations and called for more Pakistani scholarships and greater people-to-people contacts.

Interactions with local people dispelled certain notions prevalent in Pakistan about northern parts of Afghanistan.

The enigma of Pak-Afghan relations

Incidentally, this correspondent encountered just one student among a group as large as 80 students at the university had lived in Peshawar as a refugee, but everyone else knew Pakistan very well and were aware of Islamabad’s policies about Afghanistan.

Unlike Afghan government leaders, students presented a balanced approach towards Pakistan; they did not just confine themselves to leveling allegations against Pakistan but they were thankful to Pakistan for building the university’s Liaquat Ali Khan Engineering Faculty. The block was built with Pakistani assistance to Afghanistan amounting to more than $18 million.

“I and my fellow students are grateful to Pakistan for contributing to building this university in Balkh province. But, this is not enough; we need help to improve information technology and other departments too,” Mohammed Humayoon, a student studying Uzbek language and arts said during a question-answer session.

Highlighting “great difficulties faced by (the Afghan) people in acquiring Pakistani visas,” he urged the governments of the two countries to improve transit trade, adding that goods from Pakistan could be used to bolster links with the Balkh province.

The interaction with students was part of an unofficial track-II dialogue titled ‘Beyond Boundaries’ during which students frankly discussed various issues with Pakistani and Afghan participants.

Appreciating Pakistan for helping Afghan refugees for nearly 40 years, Farzana, a student of the engineering department, said: “We are surprised at the recent treatment of Sharbat Gula in Pakistan. Can you explain why this was done?”

Rebuilding relations with Afghanistan

Pakistan deported Sharbat Gula, the green-eyed Afghan poster girl of yesteryear, after keeping her for 15 days in jail on charges of possessing fake identity papers.

Nagina Akhtar, who studies in the political science department, said that she firmly believed in improving people-to-people contacts.

Zakir Adeeb, a student of the university’s engineering department, said: “The problem lies with both governments. We, the people, want to improve communication and education in general. We are grateful to Pakistan for providing help to this university.” He also asked about Pakistan’s plans regarding peace-building and the future of Afghanistan.

Zikarullah, a student of the political science department, asked: “We are optimistic about improving relations between the two countries. But, I would like to ask … what is the Pakistan government doing in limiting and countering (the influence of) radical madressahs involved in terrorism?”

A female student, Neela from the English literature department, asked about opportunities available in Pakistan, especially for women students from universities in Mazar-e-Sharif.

Another female student, Nagina, who is studying law and political science, said: “The core problem affecting Pakistan and Afghanistan is political.”

Published in The Express Tribune, December 19th, 2016.
 
“I and my fellow students are grateful to Pakistan for contributing to building this university in Balkh province. But, this is not enough; we need help to improve information technology and other departments too,” Mohammed Humayoon, a student studying Uzbek language and arts said during a question-answer session.

A very just request but problem is that Kabul had already refused recent $500 mil offer.
 
I say Pak should focus on building itself up. Once it is a developed nation, it would command respect. Right now no matter how much u help Afghans, they seem to spit in ur face every chance they get.
 
We have to face the reality that neither Pakistan nor Afghanistan can have a prosperous future without cooperation. We do not just share a border. We share history, religion and a large part of shared culture as well. Our salvage and way out of this current mess is hidden in strong people to people contacts without corrupt politicians charging us against each other.
 
It is good Pakistan is contributing in Afghanistan's education. Educated and peaceful Afganistan is key to peaceful Pakistan.
 
I say Pak should focus on building itself up. Once it is a developed nation, it would command respect. Right now no matter how much u help Afghans, they seem to spit in ur face every chance they get.
Other than maintaining good relationships, countries also invest to protect their own interests. It is best for Pakistan to maintain good relationship with Afghan people.
 
We have to face the reality that neither Pakistan nor Afghanistan can have a prosperous future without cooperation. We do not just share a border. We share history, religion and a large part of shared culture as well. Our salvage and way out of this current mess is hidden in strong people to people contacts without corrupt politicians charging us against each other.
That would be ideal...but that's all it is...idealistic.
It's not at all realistic bcuz u can't change Afghan culture/mentality/lack of education. They have a largely tribal culture. Large masses of them are herded by key influential ppl(people in power). So even if the public doesn't think too badly of us it still makes no difference bcuz the goons on top are on India's payroll.
They have had some sort of a grudge against Pakistan since day 1. Maybe hungry for more territory? Wanted access to the ocean? Whatever the reason they always make Durand line an issue even though it's plain and simple. Using that they brainwash their public against Pakistan to justify their own failings and that brings us to where we are.

If they had even an ounce of common sense(as a nation), they would've seen that blaming other nations(Soviets, US, Pak) wouldn't solve their problems. They've been failing for decades bcuz of their own fault. So just let them be and focus on ourselves instead.

Other than maintaining good relationships, countries also invest to protect their own interests. It is best for Pakistan to maintain good relationship with Afghan people.
Good relationships can be maintained without giving millions of dollars that can be used at home for education/welfare/healthcare etc. Interests can be secured in other ways too.
 
Interactions with local people dispelled certain notions prevalent in Pakistan about northern parts of Afghanistan.

Northen and western Afghans (non-pashtuns) being enemies of Pakistan is just establishment propaganda. You see many Pakistanis on this forum held same opinion. When the facts are

1. Afghanistan till recently was ruled by dictator like pashtun nationalist leaders. Afghan pashtun population % isn't much higher then punjabi % in Pakistan, yet in Pakistan there has been many leaders/dictators from different backgrounds. Remember they don't even have provinces that have autonomy to certain degree like in Pakistan.

2. Since they toke their non-pashtun compatriots for granted, all they could think off was how to get back lands their former king sold to British. If Queen wanted they could have brought more land as long as Kabul king palace was left alone. You can't blame Pakistan for that.

3. ISI supported islamists against semi secular afghan nationalist pashtun leaders. Later on same ISI will support afghan pashtun taliban against ANA in civil war. This literally divided Afghanistan without changing borders, bit like India in Bangladesh situation. So ANA hating Pakistan doesn't really surprise me.

I've seen many tv programs where both afghan pashtuns and afghan tajik/hazaras interact with Pakistanis. Former tend to be melo dramatic while later more rational.
 
Last edited:
pakistani elite (read punjabi) are scared of Pusthun nationalism. in the uber run pusthuns are going to unite. Pakistani elite would like it to be within Pakistan. i take it to be wishful thinking.

it is similar to creation of Germany and Italy nation states in 19th century Europe.
 
pakistani elite (read punjabi) are scared of Pusthun nationalism. in the uber run pusthuns are going to unite. Pakistani elite would like it to be within Pakistan. i take it to be wishful thinking.

it is similar to creation of Germany and Italy nation states in 19th century Europe.

And India will be divided in 50 countries as it was supposed to be if British didn't come.
 
And India will be divided in 50 countries as it was supposed to be if British didn't come.
Ghenda bhayyajee,,,if u come to think of it,,eventually it will.but thn yahi hona hai for most of south asia,,bus is purey story me aap logo ka no. sabse pehle ana hai:D
Ps- if brits didnt come,,,ahh,,bhayyajee if mohmd qasim didnt come, south asia wudnt have witnessed this saas bahu series for 70yrs
 
Last edited:

Back
Top Bottom