What's new

Kashmir will Never be a Part of Pakistan - Sushma Swaraj

Muslims can do whatever they want but its a genuine question. If areas of Kashmir are holy to Hindus just as Mecca and Medina are to Muslims, would Muslims feel the need to vacate the land if the majority population was Hindu?
You are just trolling and you have no knowledge of hindu religion then. The holy site of Hindus in river Ganges.
 
You are just trolling and you have no knowledge of hindu religion then. The holy site of Hindus in river Ganges.

Well according to Hindus here and that I've met, the Amarnath Cave and Vaishno Devi are two of many religious sites
 
Muslims can do whatever they want but its a genuine question. If areas of Kashmir are holy to Hindus just as Mecca and Medina are to Muslims, would Muslims feel the need to vacate the land if the majority population was Hindu?

Muslims would not worry about safety of the Kabbah by the way. So your question is totally irrelevant.

Blame Hanuman or whatever he should have promised you safety of hindu sites.

And before Messenger Muhammad (Peace be upon him) the residents of those cities were idol worshiping infidels.
 
Well according to Hindus here and that I've met, the Amarnath Cave and Vaishno Devi are two of many religious sites
So each site cannot be that important. Furthermore, they can be allowed to visit after Kashmir joins Pakistan. Pakistan has religious sites for Sikhs and they visit every year similarly for Budhs and they visit every year.

Muslims would not worry about safety of the Kabbah by the way. So your question is totally irrelevant.

Blame Hanuman or whatever he should have promised you safety of hindu sites.

And before Messenger Muhammad (Peace be upon him) the residents of those cities were idol worshiping infidels.
I have report this troll you should also do the same.
 
As far as I observed Jenah and Nehru had a pact back in 1947 ... which base on that People of Kashmir has to decide whether they want to join Pakistan or be independent through a referendum ...
 
Muslims would not worry about safety of the Kabbah by the way. So your question is totally irrelevant.

Blame Hanuman or whatever he should have promised you safety of hindu sites.

And before Messenger Muhammad (Peace be upon him) the residents of those cities were idol worshiping infidels.

Well there have also been instances where Mecca and Medina have been targeted by Muslims themselves, such as the Grand Mosque seizure of 79' and the recent bombings earlier this month in Medina. Didn't seem like Allah helped at all. Btw my question still remains
 
So each site cannot be that important. Furthermore, they can be allowed to visit after Kashmir joins Pakistan. Pakistan has religious sites for Sikhs and they visit every year similarly for Budhs and they visit every year.

Isn't that subjective? I thought Pakistan's decision was to let Kashmiris have their own country. I'm just trying to see the rationality behind this
 
Well there have also been instances where Mecca and Medina have been targeted by Muslims themselves, such as the Grand Mosque seizure of 79' and the recent bombings earlier this month in Medina. Didn't seem like Allah helped at all. Btw my question still remains

There is difference between a hindu and a Muslim, I don't need to tell you that or do I.
 
There is difference between a hindu and a Muslim, I don't need to tell you that or do I.

My question still hasn't been answered you guys seem to sidetrack it for obvious reasons. And yes I know the difference between Hindus and Muslims, I'm trying to understand the logic here
 
My question still hasn't been answered you guys seem to sidetrack it for obvious reasons. And yes I know the difference between Hindus and Muslims, I'm trying to understand the logic here

Your analogy ............... does that even deserve a logical answer?

You want an answer to how would Muslims feel if hindus invade Makkah and Madina and you thought you would have offended them by bringing in Kabba. You must be some idiot who chose to register with Muslim name on this forum.
 
Your analogy ............... does that even deserve a logical answer?

You want an answer to how would Muslims feel if hindus invade Makkah and Madina and you thought you would have offended them by bringing in Kabba. You must be some idiot who chose to register with Muslim name on this forum.

Amarnath and Vaishno Devi are two prominent holy sites among various others spread over S. Asia. How would Muslims feel if not only Hindus but if Christians or Jews had planted themselves in Mecca and Medina and demanded their own territory? And yes I'm an ex-Muslim living in the comfort of the United States to practice whatever I want without being prosecuted
 

Back
Top Bottom