What's new

Pakistan Can Overcome Energy Crisis With US Help on Shale Gas

RiazHaq

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Oct 31, 2009
Messages
6,611
Reaction score
70
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
Pakistan has over 50 trillion cubic feet of shale gas reserves, according to the US Energy Information Administration (EIA) estimates. It's enough to energize Pakistani homes, businesses, power plants, CNG vehicles, fertilizer plants and factories for 25 years at a rate of 2 trillion cubic feet of consumption per year at half the currently agreed price of imported gas from Iran, an agreement the US strongly opposes. It will also save Pakistanis hundreds of billions of dollars in foreign exchange.

The relevant question here is whether America is willing offer through its oil and gas companies the necessary investment and the advanced technology to quickly and profitably develop shale gas fields in Pakistan in exchange for abandoning the Iran-Pakistan gas pipeline?

Shale%2BGas%2BPakistan.png


Shale gas revolution began a few years ago when an American named George P. Mitchell defied the skeptics and fought his opponents to extract natural gas from shale rock. The method he and his team used to release the trapped gas, called fracking, has paid off dramatically. In 2000, shale gas represented just 1 percent of American natural gas supplies. Today, it is over 30 percent and rising.

Up until 2009, the US was the largest importer of Qatari LNG. However, the discovery of development of shale gas has caused a glut in the US. The Qatari LNG imports are no longer needed and the gas prices have plummeted in the United States. Qatari oil minister was quoted by Bloomberg as saying that 60 percent of Qatari LNG exports “moved to the east” in 2009.

Increased production of gas from shale in the US has created a huge new supply, pushing down gas prices from $13/BTU (million British thermal units) four years ago to just $4.23/BTU today, even as the price of oil has more than doubled. By contrast, the Iran pipeline gas formula links the gas price to oil prices. It means that Pakistan will have to pay $12.30/BTU at oil price of $100/barrel, and a whopping $20/BTU for gas if oil returns to its 2008 peak of $150/barrel.

To encourage investment in developing domestic shale gas, Pakistan has approved a new exploration policy with improved incentives as compared with its 2009 policy, a petroleum ministry official said recently. Pakistan Petroleum is now inviting fresh bids to auction licenses to explore and develop several blocks in Dera Ismail Khan (KPK), Badin (Sind), Naushero Firoz (Sind) and Jungshahi (Sind), according to Oil Voice.

Under the new policy, exploration companies will be offered 40-50% higher prices for the extracted gas compared with the $4.26/Btu price announced in Exploration and Production Policy 2009. Companies which succeed in recovering gas from tight fields within two years will get 50% hike over the 2009 price and if it takes more time they will get only a 40% hike on the 2009 price. As an added incentive, the leases for the fields will now be for 40 years instead of 30 in the 2009 policy, the official said.

Even with the higher prices for the tight gas offered to the exploration companies, it is estimated that Pakistan will have to pay a maximum of $6.50/Btu for the gas compared with $12.30/Btu for gas imports, according to a report by Platts.

Pakistan should ask the Obama administration to help fund and develop shale gas in exchange for abandoning the Iran-Pakistan gas pipeline. It will be a historic win-win for both nations, as historic as the US aid to Pakistan for Green Revolution in 1960s. Pakistanis will get relief from the severe energy crisis which affects almost everyone in the country. The US energy companies will create thousands of American jobs and make a huge profit in the process with the potential bonus of largely neutralizing the strong anti-American sentiments in the country.

Haq's Musings: US Can Help Pakistan Develop Shale Gas
 
Umm.. no thanks. I think we have learned our lessons relying on the U.S.

Methods:

- Energy crisis can be solved by having a strong law and order. P.S. Karachi steals 55% of whole nations electricity...

- Setup joint projects with China. We share the same border....

- Start building wind turbines. This is probably the cheapest method. Gwadar or cities with high winds guarantees to generate electricity the most.

- Promote and reward University students to develop alternatives.... This way there is competition to succeed in a particular field and to hunt for best science students on national level
 
Umm.. no thanks. I think we have learned our lessons relying on the U.S.

Methods:

- Energy crisis can be solved by having a strong law and order. P.S. Karachi steals 55% of whole nations electricity...

Karachi 'steals' 55% of whole nations electricity? Can you post anything at all to prove that or is that a wild wild....exponentially wild guess?

Electricity theft is a rampant problem in Punjab more then Sindh. It should be strongly discouraged, perpetrators should be given exemplary punishments. But stupid comments should be avoided.
 
We have much more the capacity then our requirements and I know that before the new powerplants that are being set up in recent years the capacity in Pakistan was about 19300+MW where the requirement was 17000MW. Now the install capacity might be increased to 23000+ MW, which is still more that what we require. The thing the GoP and other stake holders need to do is to provide gas and fuel on tax free basis to them to generate electricity so that these can be utilize in house hold, industry and on other areas as well. :pakistan:
 
We have been hearing about US help on energy since 2001, it never happens.
 
Umm.. no thanks. I think we have learned our lessons relying on the U.S.

Methods:

- Energy crisis can be solved by having a strong law and order. P.S. Karachi steals 55% of whole nations electricity...

- Setup joint projects with China. We share the same border....

- Start building wind turbines. This is probably the cheapest method. Gwadar or cities with high winds guarantees to generate electricity the most.

- Promote and reward University students to develop alternatives.... This way there is competition to succeed in a particular field and to hunt for best science students on national level

Pakistan is in a very serious energy crisis...it needs solar, wind, hydel, thermal, gas, etc etc to dig itself out of a deep dark hole.

Each nation does what it must for its own interest to serve its needs. US and Pakistan are no different.

Within the last few years, the US shale gas contribution has gone from 1% to over 30% of total natural gas produced in America. The same can be accomplished in Pakistan if US agrees to support development of shale gas in Pakistan in exchange for dropping Iran pipeline. And it'll be a lot cheaper and also reduce dependence on foreign sources.

If the Iran-Pakistan pipeline ever gets funded, it'll take at least two years to deliver gas to Pakistan while risking crippling US sanctions on Pakistan as well.

Production in Northeastern Pennsylvania recently passed 2 Bcf/d, up from just 0.4 Bcf/d at the start of 2010. In Southwestern Pennsylvania, production is over 0.8 Bcf/d, more than three times the level at the beginning of 2010.
In West Virginia, production has grown over 40% since January 2010 and recently surpassed 1 Bcf/d.

US needs Pakistan's help in Afghanistan and to isolate Iran. American petroleum companies need to make profits for their shareholders, and America needs to create jobs for its people.
 
Umm.. no thanks. I think we have learned our lessons relying on the U.S.

Methods:

- Energy crisis can be solved by having a strong law and order. P.S. Karachi steals 55% of whole nations electricity...

- Setup joint projects with China. We share the same border....

- Start building wind turbines. This is probably the cheapest method. Gwadar or cities with high winds guarantees to generate electricity the most.

- Promote and reward University students to develop alternatives.... This way there is competition to succeed in a particular field and to hunt for best science students on national level

For us to date coal and hydroelectricity are the cheapest forms of energy available.One just has to use the huge reservoirs available.Until we get ourselves able to build more nuclear reactors.

total-cost-electricity-production-per-kwh.jpg


Comparing Energy Costs of Nuclear, Coal, Gas, Wind and Solar
 
We have been hearing about US help on energy since 2001, it never happens.

Are you forgetting massive US help to Pakistan to bring about the Green Revolution in 1960s?

Pakistan should ask the Obama administration to help fund and develop shale gas in exchange for abandoning the Iran-Pakistan gas pipeline.

It will be a historic win-win for both nations, as historic as the US aid to Pakistan for Green Revolution in 1960s. Pakistanis will get relief from the severe energy crisis which affects almost everyone in the country. The US energy companies will create thousands of American jobs and make a huge profit in the process with the potential bonus of largely neutralizing the strong anti-American sentiments in the country.
 
Great blog Mr. Haq... I 100% am agreeing with you on this...

But one problem, doing this can pollute groundwater
 
For us to date coal and hydroelectricity is the cheapest form of energy available.One just has to use the huge reservoirs available.Until we get ourselves able to build more nuclear reactors.

total-cost-electricity-production-per-kwh.jpg


Comparing Energy Costs of Nuclear, Coal, Gas, Wind and Solar

Hydro is seasonal. Coal is the cheapest but it's hard to get financing for it because of environmental concerns.

You need cheap gas to have reliable power generation capacity....domestic Pakistani shale gas at about $4-6 per million BTU can do it....the Iranians want $11-12 per mBTU and Qataris are demanding $18 per mBTU for LNG. Oil is closer to $20 per mBTU.

Great blog Mr. Haq... I 100% am agreeing with you on this...

But one problem, doing this can pollute groundwater

All energy production involves environmental risks which need to be controlled through regulations and enforcement. The upside for shale gas is that it burns a lot cleaner than oil and coal.

Here's an excerpt of a paper on fracking:

The rapid development of shale gas resources in the past few years has already dramatically affected U.S. energy markets—lowering energy prices and carbon dioxide emissions—and could offer an affordable source of low-carbon energy to reduce dependence on coal and oil.1 However, the development of shale gas has been linked to a range of local environmental problems, generating a public backlash that threatens to bring production to a halt in some regions. While hydraulic fracturing in particular has been the focus of much controversy, our analysis indicates that the most significant environmental risks associated with the development of shale gas are
similar to those associated with conventional onshore gas, including gas migration and groundwater contamination due to faulty well construction, blowouts, and above-ground leaks and spill of waste water and chemicals used during drilling and hydraulic fracturing.
Many technologies and best practices that can minimize the risks associated with shale gas development are already being used by some companies, and more are being developed. The natural gas industry should work with government agencies, environmental organizations, and local communities to develop innovative technologies and practices that can reduce the environmental risks and impacts associated with shale gas development. Stronger, fully-enforced government regulations are needed in many states to provide sufficient protection to the environment as shale gas development increases. In addition, continued study and improved communication of the environmental risks associated with both individual wells and large scale shale gas development are essential for society to make well-informed decisions about its energy future.

http://www.worldwatch.org/files/pdf/Hydraulic Fracturing Paper.pdf
 
PAKISTAN can make it's own electricity with out any help.

I know one student of Punjab University went to Dr. Asim's office with his electricity's production project on very cheap rates and he was kicked by Dr.Asim and the very next day went to India for some energy treaty.
 
hmmmm US only helps Pakistan on media nothing in practical soo Pakistan can do it on her own we just need good leadership & vision.
 
No doubt potentially there is sufficient Frac gas both in India as well as in Pakistan with China having the largest deposits in the world. But one must understand what is really involved in extracting the Frac/Shale gas. The process is called hydofracking. Basically it involves injecting huge amount of water underground to break the solid rock and release trapped gas. Therefore extraction of Shale gas causes deep concerns over underground water pollution specially the dissolution of hydrogen sulphide present in the gas in water.

Thus there are two major problems:

1. Pakistan does not have the horizontal drilling and hydrofracking technology to extract shale gas and we need foreign help. USA is leader in this technology and even China is utilizing US help in this regard. With all the anti US feeling in Pakistan, will US be willing to help? And if it were to happen, how would my emotionally charged countrymen react to US presence? Remember despite all the load shedding, we don’t want to build Kalabagh dam.

2. Jury is still out as to whether the benefits from shale gas are worth the problems caused by the associated water pollution. In the UK an attempt to extract shale gas in Wales was abandoned on account of environmental concerns.

Besides, it would take at least three years before any concrete benefits are visible. IPI pipeline route is quicker.

On the other hand Dr Mubarkmands team has demonstrated UCG technology at Thar lignite field but Pakistan has no funds to buy the small power plant. How would we procure enormous funds for producing shale gas?

Regret to say that there is no easy solution to Pakistan’s energy crisis.
 
Dude why don't you look at returns. You might run out of coal, nuclear, and natural gas. Solar and Wind is free at the end of the day and also sustainable!!!

Let's wait for the PM to write a letter to the Swiss government ,so that we can buy those toys for you.
So far it's not affordable.
 

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom