A Muslim Woman who teaches Kirtan...

[StingRoy]

There are a number of other issues of matter in this article:....

Are you kidding?
You shouldn't be online. Being on the internet is bad for your health. There are a lot of blasphemous activities going on out here.

 

[Multani]

Ohh God *facepalm*


1.You are surfing the internet, Google adds appear on the sides often have women without covering their heads.

2.When you turn on computer a music plays

3.Internet is full of ****, (Contact me in PM if want some cool websites)

4.Internet is product of US the biggest killers of Muslims or the 2nd after Muslims themselves.

5. Lots of pictures on the banner the banner of this sitemust also be declared harm.

6 and most Important You are embarrassing me. and the kind of rules you are explaining are extremism to me. All rules for women and men can roam around like sanndh (bull).

Your post has a lot of other issues side tracking from the issue of this thread, about this Muslim woman in Kashmir engaging in non-Muslim prayers.

I am talking about basic fiqh of hijab, that Muslims teach their 7 year old's or should teach them like what is awraa of a woman and a man.

In Pakistan, a lot of women do hijab, because they have great respect for the Sunnah of our Habeeb sallAllaho alaihi wa sallam.

If one goes to Hajj, he has to learn the basic fiqh of Hajj, so that he could perform its blessed duties properly, and similarly for awraa of the body too.

 

[Prometheus]

Your post has a lot of other issues side tracking from the issue of this thread, about this Muslim woman in Kashmir engaging in non-Muslim prayers.

I am talking about basic fiqh of hijab, that Muslims teach their 7 year old's or should teach them like what is awraa of a woman and a man.

In Pakistan, a lot of women do hijab, because they have great respect for the Sunnah of our Habeeb sallAllaho alaihi wa sallam.

If one goes to Hajj, he has to learn the basic fiqh of Hajj, so that he could perform its blessed duties properly, and similarly for awraa of the body too.

could you plz write in simple language...............half of things are going over my head????????

 

[mjnaushad]

Your post has a lot of other issues side tracking from the issue of this thread, about this Muslim woman in Kashmir engaging in non-Muslim prayers.

I am talking about basic fiqh of hijab, that Muslims teach their 7 year old's or should teach them like what is awraa of a woman and a man.

In Pakistan, a lot of women do hijab, because they have great respect for the Sunnah of our Habeeb sallAllaho alaihi wa sallam.

If one goes to Hajj, he has to learn the basic fiqh of Hajj, so that he could perform its blessed duties properly, and similarly for awraa of the body too.

My post have nothing tracked out of this thread.....

I just proved these rules apply for women only.You want to put them in the house with nothing to do so you are practically saying we should put 51% of our population to cook food for the rest of 49% and dont interact with the outer world.

How about if someone don't want to comply with these rules and say i am better as Christian then according to your sharia he/she should be killed.? Anything taken to the extreme will turn bad brother. be it any religion or anything. Hindu extremist killed Muslims, Christian extremist killed hell lot of jews, Jew extremist = Palestine. Muslims extremist well do i have to give any example.

Moderation and toleration is the way forward and coexist. Let us be at it. or atleast let others to practice it.

 

[Multani]

My post have nothing tracked out of this thread.....
.

what you said is all irrelevant stuff

who is talking about besieging women in homes?

Muslim women have been warriors! businesswomen, scholars of Islam, even awliya like

Sayyida Rabia al Adawiyya al Basri raziAllahu anha

The Quran al Majeed Says that Allah has given the mother jannat under her feet, and the the mother is in equal terms of work as any man while she rears her children. She keeps the Deen Alive.

 

[jayron]

could you plz write in simple language...............half of things are going over my head????????

Exactly.. but I can make out its something hard core.

 

[jayron]

Muslims artists, musicians, weavers etc have been involved in temple activities for centuries. Its not a big deal.

Traditional Tamil nadaswaram music in temples are usually played by muslims.
Muslims make the sacred fabric and garland for temples.
Hindus go and play in Darghas and they even have Hindu festivals to celebrate historical islamic figures.

This how India is for the most places.

 

[sensenreason]

assalamu álaykum naushad brother

At least we should ourselves know the rulings of Shariat. That is the major issue today. Muslims engage in dunyavi knowledge and neglect the Islamic Sciences, of which a dozen are major. One is fiqh under which this issue of a Muslim engaging in non-Muslim prayer comes. It would have been a different matter if she were singing hindu idol worshipping hymns.

In Pakistan, the Shariat Courts follow rulings as Based in the Hanafi madhab, as that is the madhab of the vast majority of ahlesunnat in the country. The ruling of illegality on this issue in the case of Christians or Jews is very Stern [assuming Sikhs do believe in One God and are not idol worshippers like hindus]

InshaAllah taála I will provide a detailed reference.

Is music actually considered haraam in Islam? Is talking also taken in the same light?

 

[Muhammad-Bin-Qasim]

Is music actually considered haraam in Islam? Is talking also taken in the same light?

Talking? What do you mean?

Music... There is difference of opinion on the issue... but as I understand it in an Islamic State music is permitted...

However this lady is in a totally different league here... Would someone post some lyrics from a Kirtan on this forum... We could see if it is similar to Qawali or not...

 

[Prometheus]

Talking? What do you mean?

Music... There is difference of opinion on the issue... but as I understand it in an Islamic State music is permitted...

However this lady is in a totally different league here... Would someone post some lyrics from a Kirtan on this forum... We could see if it is similar to Qawali or not...

as far I knew considerable part of Guru granth sahib is contributed by Muslim religious persons.....................and kirtan is based on abstract from Guru Granth Sahib.

No need to curse the lady...............also curse those great muslims

 

[Awesome]

assalamu álaykum naushad brother

At least we should ourselves know the rulings of Shariat. That is the major issue today. Muslims engage in dunyavi knowledge and neglect the Islamic Sciences, of which a dozen are major. One is fiqh under which this issue of a Muslim engaging in non-Muslim prayer comes. It would have been a different matter if she were singing hindu idol worshipping hymns.

In Pakistan, the Shariat Courts follow rulings as Based in the Hanafi madhab, as that is the madhab of the vast majority of ahlesunnat in the country. The ruling of illegality on this issue in the case of Christians or Jews is very Stern [assuming Sikhs do believe in One God and are not idol worshippers like hindus]

InshaAllah taála I will provide a detailed reference.

Depends what is being said, doesn't it? Ever heard the Christian, Amazing Grace or Hallelujah? Doesn't seem bad at all and is extremely pleasant to the ears.

Likewise there are even a few Hindu bhajans that may be listenable, like Om Jai Jagdish Hare. Except for one controversial paragraph that goes like Mata Pita Tuma mere... Otherwise its just praise to God.

God knows best, but I feel if you're praising him, not talking of violence against the innocent, and talking about good things all n all, there shouldn't be a problem.

 

[Capt.Popeye]

Muslims artists, musicians, weavers etc have been involved in temple activities for centuries. Its not a big deal.

Traditional Tamil nadaswaram music in temples are usually played by muslims.
Muslims make the sacred fabric and garland for temples.
Hindus go and play in Darghas and they even have Hindu festivals to celebrate historical islamic figures.

This how India is for the most places.

Music knows no limits, divisions or boundaries.
Having said that, let me make a small suggestion to you:
Please google "Man Kunto Maula"; it is a a Qaul (devotional music). There are many versions available on YouTube sung by musicians like Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan, Abida Parveen and so many other musicians. Try to listen to as many of them as you can. You may not understand even a word, but will not stop you from appreciating what you hear. (i understand very little) but that is no deterrent. The wonder of it all is even a Non-Believer in anything or everything will find something beautiful there.

 

[Durran3]

The blessed Qurán al Kareem is the Eternal Speech of Allah Subhanahu wa taála. Its us Muslims who read and memorize it, if we call ourselves Muslims.

Which Muslim will think of stopping other Muslims from reading the Quran al-Majeed?

No one said Muslims are afraid of reading other books. The issue is of engaging in non-Muslim prayers, which falls under the jurisdiction of fiqh, as Pakistan is an Islamic State, and Islam is the state religion.

Would you quit imposing your views on others or tell us how they should be? Again like mnsaushad said... Thekedari ka kaam choro. You know nothing about the individual so stop labeling her

 

[mughaljee]

what should i say ?

 

[Awesome]

Music knows no limits, divisions or boundaries.
Having said that, let me make a small suggestion to you:
Please google "Man Kunto Maula"; it is a a Qaul (devotional music). There are many versions available on YouTube sung by musicians like Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan, Abida Parveen and so many other musicians. Try to listen to as many of them as you can. You may not understand even a word, but will not stop you from appreciating what you hear. (i understand very little) but that is no deterrent. The wonder of it all is even a Non-Believer in anything or everything will find something beautiful there.

I wonder if its the same as Salman Ahmed's (of Junoon) "Man gum sum Maula".