Youthink: Madressah students, the other breed

[ajpirzada]

By Nosheen Abbas
Saturday, 09 May, 2009 | 11:31 AM PST |

The word ‘Taliban’ has both an academic and political connotation. The academic meaning stands for students of madressahs and the political describes those who are militant Jihadist— File/Reuters

‘They call everyone else a kaafir,’ said a typically conservative looking young man at an anti-Taliban protest in Islamabad the other day. Sporting a skull cap, a beard and ankle high shalwaar— he spoke confidently, ‘They are against everything— the State, the Constitution and the judiciary and what’s worse is that they use guns to achieve their goals.’

Contrary to what many urban dwellers think about the ‘religiously’ attired people, there are numerous religious schools and organizations that stand against the philosophy of the Taliban.

The word ‘Taliban’ has both an academic and political connotation. The academic meaning stands for students of madressahs and the political describes those who are militant Jihadists. The political Taliban predominantly hold Deobandi views. Among these are the banned Lashkari-i-Jhangwi, Harkatul Ansar and Jaishi-i-Muhammad. However, the Taliban do not represent the entire range of the Deobandi school.

’You know even though these groups say they are Deobandis, using violence to propagate the faith is completely against our school of thought. It is very wrong and we do not agree with their killings; I don’t think Taliban are Muslims; they are enemies of this country and are trying to tarnish the image of Islam; the government should have given these people more attention and recognized their talent; the common people are mistreated and the country is not functioning according to the laws of Islam; that is why all of this is happening,’ said Ms Zebunnisa, the vice-principal of Ashraful Uloom, a girls madressah in Islamabad.

In order to gather the views of the other gender, I went to a boys madressah affiliated with a private schools network tucked way on the outskirts of Islamabad near Bhara Kahu, called the Islamic Institute of Islamic Sciences situated in a green opening of surrounding hills, a serene setting to contemplate the teachings of Islam. It is spread out on a generous plot of land with enough space for a football ground and dorms. Through the ogee arched windows I could see some boys studying and others strolling around, but no one seemed distracted by our presence or the fact that I was the only woman on the campus and neither did I feel awkward. I was shown to the principal’s office, a small humble working station. I wasn’t allowed inside the campus. The vice-principal apologised saying that the boys would feel awkward. It was a clean and well organised school, conscious of cleanliness.

Five students showed up for the interview, which included students from bachelor and primary grades. Soon they set aside their reserve and opened up feeling more comfortable in my presence, even laughing as I joked about my unfortunate inadequacy to word my thoughts in Urdu. As we began talking, I realised they weren’t as hesitant to talk about sensitive issues as I had expected. Nonetheless they did have reservations about certain issues we talked about.

Khurram Nadeem Abbasi spoke defensively but continued to explain his opinion about the Taliban. ‘Even though some of the Taliban are said to be from the Deobandi school of thought, that doesn’t mean they are following the right path of Islam. Islam is based on peace and not violence.’

’It’s sad that just because a bearded man blows himself up— all bearded looking people are looked at in a suspicious way,’ he continued.

Talking about women was a dicey issue I felt. I asked them about why women are always targeted by extremists and their thoughts in relevance to the atrocities committed against them. Sajjid Shah believed that the issue of women was like ‘making a mountain out of a mole hill’. In response I then asked his thoughts about the Taliban’s statement of caging women indoors and only allowing them to leave their homes for Haj. ‘That’s quite unreasonable. Islam encourages women to be educated, of course within the bounds of Islam and in purdah. But in today’s times it is nonsensical to close women up; this country will only progress if women are at par with men in various fields,’ he responded.

They also talked about the causes that were driving people into the arms of the extremist groups. Lack of social justice was recognised as the major cause. ‘The problem of terrorism stems from extreme poverty. The government has failed to give people their basic rights and these poor people are pushed to the last resort of committing suicide thinking that they are doing it for a great cause.’

Mr Abbasi spoke about responsible journalism and the need to prevent public incitement. ‘It is the media’s role to remain consistent. In the case of the Lal Masjid for example at first they were condemning them but then they started sympathizing with those who were being killed during the operation; this isn’t right and the media has to remain consistent, especially in times of crisis.’

The religious students I spoke to made a point to mention that they strongly believed in the Constitution and in the ideology behind the creation of Pakistan as an Islamic republic where Muslims could lead their life according to their belief. But Pakistan was not to be a theocracy as the Quaid-i-Azam categorically said on a number of times. Perhaps this last point the students had no appreciation of.

Abu Bakr, a bright boy of class 8 from the boys’ madressah, spoke fluent English and expressed his opinion about the destruction caused by the Taliban. ‘I think there is not a single Pakistani who says that terrorism is right because it is damaging our country and as far as I am concerned I’m really conscious about what is happening to my country.’

There will always be grey areas when it comes to religion. But in a time when we need general consensus against extremists, it is important to separate the extremist fringe from the truly devout Muslims who believe in tolerance, peace and compassion for all mankind.
DAWN.COM | Pakistan | Madressah students, the other breed

 

[muse]

An unfortunagte example of Pakistan's disconnect, it's distance from the world -- "Go Taliban Go" -- the confusion among some now is whether this is an expression of support or is it, for some Pakistanis, an expression of disaproval of the Talib?

It is clearly a disappoval of the Talib, but one wonders why such ideas are actually vetted through advertising companies - had it been vetted as it should have the "Go Taliban Go" (Pakistan specific English - Paklish) might have been effective in projecting not just a local but a global message as well.