What's new

Shocked to learn: Canada’s first Afghan MP actually born in Iran

Zibago

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Feb 21, 2012
Messages
37,006
Reaction score
12
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Shocked to learn: Canada’s first Afghan MP actually born in Iran
o-MARYAM-MONSEF-facebook-640x320.jpg

OTTAWA: Championed by Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau as the nation’s first Afghanistan-born lawmaker, Maryam Monsef said Thursday she was shocked to learn she was actually born in Iran.

The 31-year-old democratic reform minister is the youngest member of Trudeau’s cabinet.

His Liberals held her up as an example of the country’s strength of diversity, a bright, young refugee from Afghanistan who traveled around the world, including partway by donkey, to find safety and make a new home in Canada.

US President Barack Obama picked up on this during a visit to Ottawa in June, highlighting her roots and dramatic journey in a speech to parliament.

In a statement, Monsef blamed the contradiction of this key narrative that she had nurtured since entering public life on her mother, saying the information had been withheld from Monsef and her two sisters.

Monsef said she pressed her mother about it after the Globe and Mail newspaper dug it up as part of an investigation into the family’s elusive past.

She said she had been “led to believe for my whole life” that she was born in Afghanistan but in fact was born in Mashhad, Iran, about 200 kilometers (125 miles) from the Afghan border.

“My sisters and I asked my mother why she never told us we were born in Iran,” Monsef said.

“She told us she did not think it mattered. We were Afghan citizens, as we were born to Afghan parents, and under Iranian law, we would not be considered Iranian citizens despite being born in that country.”

Setting the record straight, Monsef explained that her parents had fled fighting in their hometown of Herat in Afghanistan and found safety across the border in Iran.

After some back and forth, and the death of her father, the family eventually fled the Taliban in Herat and traveled by donkey to Islamabad, Pakistan and beyond, before eventually landing 20 years ago in Montreal, where they claimed asylum. –AFP
http://www.samaa.tv/international/2...anadas-first-afghan-mp-actually-born-in-iran/
@django @The Sandman @PaklovesTurkiye @pakistani342 @DESERT FIGHTER
 
. .
I was in a Afghan restaurant the other day and the afghanis in the restaurant have their extended family living in Pakistan and they have Pakistani passports as well! They go to Pakistan embassy not Afghan embassy!!

Did they have Modi's picture as the last Afghan King in their restaurant?
 
. . . .
No instead of Pakistan it says pashtunistan

lol -- I'll take that ... they can call it poultry farm as long as it is a confederation

... mmm I'm not a Pakistani citizen anymore .... sorry I can't help you here.
 
. .
lol -- I'll take that ... they can call it poultry farm as long as it is a confederation

... mmm I'm not a Pakistani citizen anymore .... sorry I can't help you here.
Hello mr roster
 
. . .
Rooster -- Rooster

Not Roster -- a Roster is

excel1_big.png
a typing mistake when i was on 3g its not easy to edit comment when you turn off java to save data :D

Topic
I m sure despite using Pakistan to go to Canada she will teach hr kids nothing but hatred for Pakistan and will support every single anti Pakistan bill and movement
 
.
a typing mistake when i was on 3g its not easy to edit comment when you turn off java to save data :D

Topic
I m sure despite using Pakistan to go to Canada she will teach hr kids nothing but hatred for Pakistan and will support every single anti Pakistan bill and movement

I was just kidding.

On this topic -- I haven't really payed much attention it -- but I'm curious what the hoopla is: she was born in Iran and not Afghanistan to refugee Parents. The should be nothing wrong with that. Why are people calling for her resignation?
 
.
I was just kidding.

On this topic -- I haven't really payed much attention it -- but I'm curious what the hoopla is: she was born in Iran and not Afghanistan to refugee Parents. The should be nothing wrong with that. Why are people calling for her resignation?
I posted ot just to show how despite using Pakistan as a gateway the Afghan leave no stone unturned to harm directly or indirectly
 
.
What sort of route did she take? So she was born in Iran after the family had fled herat, then went to Islamabad on a donkey from Herat? So the family went from Iran to Herat to move to Islamabad? And then to the West?
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom