What's new

Russia Begins Deporting Tajiks Amid Diplomatic Row

Dance

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jul 20, 2010
Messages
4,850
Reaction score
0
DUSHANBE, Tajikistan (AP) — Russia began deporting Tajik migrants Tuesday, the first in a wave of expulsions in apparent retaliation for the jailing of a Russian pilot in the Central Asian nation, officials in Tajikistan said.

The spat threatens to imperil the livelihood of thousands of Tajik laborers and stir discontent in a country struggling to protect its border with Afghanistan. The former Soviet nation's economy relies heavily on the remittances provided by the many hundreds of thousands of Tajiks working in Russia.

Over the past year, Moscow has been attempting to strong-arm Tajikistan into permitting Russian border troops to resume patrols of the rugged 1,350-kilometer (840-mile) frontier with Afghanistan.

Tajik authorities have responded testily to such overtures, which they view as an attempt by the Kremlin to dilute their country's sovereignty. Russia, meanwhile, grumbles that Tajik troops are not up to stemming the huge flow of heroin streaming north from Afghanistan.

This latest tit-for-tat dispute will likely undermine efforts to deepen cooperation on enhancing regional security.

Tajikistan's migration service said 11 Tajiks were set to fly out from Moscow on Tuesday after authorities ruled they had violated migration rules. They were among about 300 Tajiks detained in recent days.

Vladimir Lobanov, acting head of a detention center in Moscow, confirmed that some of the detained Tajiks have been deported and preparations were being made to deport the others.

The detentions immediately followed the convictions last week of pilots Vladimir Sadovnichy and Estonian citizen Alexei Rudenko, who were arrested in Tajikistan in March after landing two cargo planes for refueling while flying from Afghanistan to Moscow.

A Tajik court found them guilty of illegally flying into Tajikistan and smuggling aircraft parts, and sentenced them to 8 1/2 years in prison. Their two An-72 aircraft were seized.

The case has provoked a xenophobia-tinged uproar in Russia.

"The decision to deport several hundred Tajik migrants is an utterly inept and illegal move," said Arkady Dubnov, who writes on Central Asia affairs for Russian daily newspaper Moskovskiye Novosti. "This looks like an attempt to appeal to chauvinistic sentiments" ahead of Russia's parliamentary elections in December.

President Dmitry Medvedev has denied the deportation of Tajik workers is linked to the pilots' conviction, but has hinted at more possible expulsions. Russian chief sanitary inspector Gennady Onishchenko on Monday proposed banning Tajik migrants because he said they are often carriers of tuberculosis and AIDS.

Tajikistan, a mountainous largely Muslim nation of 7 million people that won independence in 1991, has been battling to restore its economy since a brutal civil war in the 1990s that claimed more than 60,000 lives. The World Bank says about half of Tajikistan's people live in poverty.

The anemic pace of recovery has over the years generated a vast exodus of workers, likely counting more than 1 million — most now living in Russia.

Karomat Sharipov, who represents Tajik migrant workers in Moscow, said he worried that if the dispute was not resolved as many as 1 million citizens of Tajikistan and also Uzbekistan could be sent home to uncertain futures. He warned that some could turn to terrorism.

"In three months they won't have flour, sugar or butter," Sharipov said at a news conference in Moscow. "They will go to the mountains. They will go and join the Taliban."

While no big economic prize, Tajikistan holds strategic importance for Russia.

Russia's 201st Motorized Rifle Division, comprising roughly 7,500 servicemen, is based in three garrisons in Tajikistan, and the Russian military also has a space-tracking facility in the Pamir mountains.

In March, Medvedev announced that a deal is be signed in 2012 for Russia to extend the presence of those troops by 49 more years.

Souring ties could derail that plan. Some fear an escalation in the row could compel Russia to adopt even more punitive measures, such as increasing fuel export duties or limiting the flow of cash transfers.


Russia Begins Deporting Tajiks Amid Diplomatic Row : NPR
 
Tajikistan appeared ready to cave in to Kremlin pressure Tuesday, as prosecutors asked a court to reduce harsh sentences against a Russian pilot jailed on murky charges last week with an Estonian colleague.

At the same time — in what looked like an attempt to save face — Tajik officials opened a case against the pilots' employer, a Russian citizen Moscow says will never be extradited.

Jailing pilots Vladimir Sadovnichy, of Russia, and, Alexei Rudenko, of Estonia, for 8 1/2 years for smuggling and illegal border crossing, was too severe, said Shokhrun Radzhabov, a spokesman for the Tajik Prosecutor General's Office.

"Taking into account the pilots' personalities and the fact that they are citizens of Tajikistan's strategic partners, the prosecution requests the regional court to mitigate punishments," Radzhabov said Tuesday, Interfax reported.


He did not say what punishment prosecutors would consider fair.
Read more: Tajiks Ready to Back Down on Pilot | News | The Moscow Times
The Moscow Times
 
The youth of Russia has become quite racist and skinheads run around in all cities like no other place within Europe. The Kremlin might have just saved these Tajik's lives.
 
what makes you think russia is more racist than any other place in europe?
 
what makes you think russia is more racist than any other place in europe?

Neo-Nazi groups are sharply on the rise as compared to anywhere else. Also the Neo-Nazi leaders have presence in the government.
 
Considering Russia has been persecuted by nazis a lot. Its very strange that neo-nazis are the strongest there. But sadly, this is the reality.
 
Neo-Nazi groups are sharply on the rise as compared to anywhere else. Also the Neo-Nazi leaders have presence in the government.

Neo Nazi groups are on the rise everywhere. What makes Russia special?

I don't think the United Russia party is Neo Nazi. It's might be a bit Nationalist but not necessarily racist. Which is the Neo Nazi party in Russian politics?
 
Neo Nazi groups are on the rise everywhere. What makes Russia special?

I don't think the United Russia party is Neo Nazi. It's might be a bit Nationalist but not necessarily racist. Which is the Neo Nazi party in Russian politics?

I don't have too much info, but this is what I got from this documentary.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Neo Nazi groups are on the rise everywhere. What makes Russia special?

I don't think the United Russia party is Neo Nazi. It's might be a bit Nationalist but not necessarily racist. Which is the Neo Nazi party in Russian politics?

Russia: Far-Right Nationalists And Neo-Nazis March In Moscow

MOSCOW — Thousands of far-right nationalists and neo-Nazis marched through Moscow on Friday calling on ethnic Russians to "take back" their country, as resentment grows over dark-complexioned Muslim migrants from Russia's Caucasus and the money the Kremlin sends to the restive region.

Some 5,000 people, mostly young men wearing medical masks and balaclavas, marched through a working-class neighborhood of gloomy apartment buildings on the outskirts of the capital. They chanted "Russia for Russians" and "Migrants today, occupiers tomorrow," along with anti-Muslim and anti-Semitic slurs and obscenities.

Some raised their hands in a Nazi salute as hundreds of police officers stood shoulder-to-shoulder along the street, which was blocked to traffic.

"All Russian people are on the march – football fans, skinheads, national socialists," said Dmitry Demushkin, a longtime activist who now leads a group called Russkiye, or Russians. "We have to show what our nation is demanding."

Demushkin is a former leader of the Slavic Union, a neo-Nazi group that was banned last year as extremist, along with the Movement Against Illegal Migration.

Violent xenophobic groups have flourished in Russia over the past two decades. Their members kill and beat non-Slavs and anti-racism activists and crudely denounce the influx of immigrants from the Caucasus and from Central Asian countries that were once part of the Soviet Union.

Since Vladimir Putin came to power in 2000, they have drawn moral support from his efforts to rebuild a strong Russian state. After two terms as president, Putin moved into the prime minister's office, but an election in March is expected to hand him a third presidential term.

Following a clash last December between police and thousands of football fans and other extremists just outside the Kremlin walls – and an unprecedented outbreak of hate crimes – the government has taken a tougher line against the groups. But their virulent hatred is proving hard to combat.

Many Russians share the anti-migrant sentiment, and even those who would not describe themselves as racist are increasingly resentful of the hefty subsidies sent to the Caucasus, particularly to Chechnya. The money is intended to bring stability after years of war, but the region remains deeply impoverished while Chechen leader Ramzan Kadyrov flaunts his wealth.


"Stop feeding the Caucasus" was one of the catchphrases of Friday's march. It was printed on banners and repeated by speakers – including popular anti-corruption whistleblower Alexander Navalny, who originally came up with the phrase.

Navalny's description of Putin's United Russia party as the "party of swindlers and thieves" has also stuck.

"This is our country, and we have to eradicate the crooks who suck our blood and eat our liver," Navalny, a lawyer, yelled to the cheering crowd. "Down with United Russia! Down with the party of crooks and thieves!" he shouted.

The phrases coined by Navalny have helped to unite a broad protest movement and become so popular that both Putin and President Dmitry Medvedev have felt compelled to address the criticism and defend their policies in the Caucasus as vital to Russia's security.

The so-called Russian March has been held annually since 2005 on a new national holiday created to replace celebrations of the 1917 Bolshevik Revolution.

The new holiday was usurped by far-right nationalists, whose first rally in 2005 led to the shocking sight of thousands of skinheads marching through central Moscow with their hands raised in a Nazi salute and shouting obscene racist slogans.

The following year the march was banned, but nationalists marched anyway and clashed violently with police. Since 2007, the Russian March has been relegated to areas outside of the capital's center.

Marches also took place Friday in other cities across the country, drawing hundreds of participants.

Tens of thousands of skinheads, neo-Nazis and far-right nationalists are active in Russia, according to analysts and polls. They advocate exclusive rights for ethnic Russians, who comprise two-thirds of the population of 142 million. More than 100 ethnicities account for the remaining third, including dozens of ethnic groups from the mountainous and predominantly Muslim Caucasus region.

Last year, some 320 ultranationalists were convicted of hate crimes, including several teenage gang members that stabbed or beat to death dark-skinned non-Russians, according to independent human rights watchdog Sova.

Russia: Far-Right Nationalists And Neo-Nazis March In Moscow
 
I don't have too much info, but this is what I got from this documentary.


the main difference i suppose is that some of the neo nazis are a bit more uncivilized in russia. Though i've no doubts uncivilized neo nazis exist in a lot of other places.

the same arguments could be applied everywhere.

any statistics?

---------- Post added at 02:04 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:03 AM ----------

Russia: Far-Right Nationalists And Neo-Nazis March In Moscow

MOSCOW — Thousands of far-right nationalists and neo-Nazis marched through Moscow on Friday calling on ethnic Russians to "take back" their country, as resentment grows over dark-complexioned Muslim migrants from Russia's Caucasus and the money the Kremlin sends to the restive region.

Some 5,000 people, mostly young men wearing medical masks and balaclavas, marched through a working-class neighborhood of gloomy apartment buildings on the outskirts of the capital. They chanted "Russia for Russians" and "Migrants today, occupiers tomorrow," along with anti-Muslim and anti-Semitic slurs and obscenities.

Some raised their hands in a Nazi salute as hundreds of police officers stood shoulder-to-shoulder along the street, which was blocked to traffic.

"All Russian people are on the march – football fans, skinheads, national socialists," said Dmitry Demushkin, a longtime activist who now leads a group called Russkiye, or Russians. "We have to show what our nation is demanding."

Demushkin is a former leader of the Slavic Union, a neo-Nazi group that was banned last year as extremist, along with the Movement Against Illegal Migration.

Violent xenophobic groups have flourished in Russia over the past two decades. Their members kill and beat non-Slavs and anti-racism activists and crudely denounce the influx of immigrants from the Caucasus and from Central Asian countries that were once part of the Soviet Union.

Since Vladimir Putin came to power in 2000, they have drawn moral support from his efforts to rebuild a strong Russian state. After two terms as president, Putin moved into the prime minister's office, but an election in March is expected to hand him a third presidential term.

Following a clash last December between police and thousands of football fans and other extremists just outside the Kremlin walls – and an unprecedented outbreak of hate crimes – the government has taken a tougher line against the groups. But their virulent hatred is proving hard to combat.

Many Russians share the anti-migrant sentiment, and even those who would not describe themselves as racist are increasingly resentful of the hefty subsidies sent to the Caucasus, particularly to Chechnya. The money is intended to bring stability after years of war, but the region remains deeply impoverished while Chechen leader Ramzan Kadyrov flaunts his wealth.


"Stop feeding the Caucasus" was one of the catchphrases of Friday's march. It was printed on banners and repeated by speakers – including popular anti-corruption whistleblower Alexander Navalny, who originally came up with the phrase.

Navalny's description of Putin's United Russia party as the "party of swindlers and thieves" has also stuck.

"This is our country, and we have to eradicate the crooks who suck our blood and eat our liver," Navalny, a lawyer, yelled to the cheering crowd. "Down with United Russia! Down with the party of crooks and thieves!" he shouted.

The phrases coined by Navalny have helped to unite a broad protest movement and become so popular that both Putin and President Dmitry Medvedev have felt compelled to address the criticism and defend their policies in the Caucasus as vital to Russia's security.

The so-called Russian March has been held annually since 2005 on a new national holiday created to replace celebrations of the 1917 Bolshevik Revolution.

The new holiday was usurped by far-right nationalists, whose first rally in 2005 led to the shocking sight of thousands of skinheads marching through central Moscow with their hands raised in a Nazi salute and shouting obscene racist slogans.

The following year the march was banned, but nationalists marched anyway and clashed violently with police. Since 2007, the Russian March has been relegated to areas outside of the capital's center.

Marches also took place Friday in other cities across the country, drawing hundreds of participants.

Tens of thousands of skinheads, neo-Nazis and far-right nationalists are active in Russia, according to analysts and polls. They advocate exclusive rights for ethnic Russians, who comprise two-thirds of the population of 142 million. More than 100 ethnicities account for the remaining third, including dozens of ethnic groups from the mountainous and predominantly Muslim Caucasus region.

Last year, some 320 ultranationalists were convicted of hate crimes, including several teenage gang members that stabbed or beat to death dark-skinned non-Russians, according to independent human rights watchdog Sova.

Russia: Far-Right Nationalists And Neo-Nazis March In Moscow

Thousands of neo-nazis. What's so special about that?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
the main difference i suppose is that some of the neo nazis are a bit more uncivilized in russia. Though i've no doubts uncivilized neo nazis exist in a lot of other places.

the same arguments could be applied everywhere.

any statistics?

---------- Post added at 02:04 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:03 AM ----------



Thousands of neo-nazis. What's so special about that?

"Tens" of thousands.....if that's not an indicator, i dont know what is...
 
tens of thousands of racists/nazis in a country in Europe. What country would you say it is?
 
tens of thousands of racists/nazis in a country in Europe. What country would you say it is?

Russia. If you're curious, i suggest you look it up. Neo nazism in Russia is a bit different.
 

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom