What's new

Pakistan decides not to move ICA against Nimo Bazgo project

third eye

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Aug 24, 2008
Messages
18,519
Reaction score
13
Country
India
Location
India
Daily Times - Leading News Resource of Pakistan


ISLAMABAD: The federal government had decided not to file a lawsuit in the Permanent Court of Arbitration-International Court of Arbitration (PCA-ICA) in Hague regarding its concerns and grievances over the controversial 45MW Nimoo Bazgo hydroelectric power project, sources in the water sector informed Daily Times on Tuesday.

Regarding the 45MW controversial Nimoo Bazgo project on River Indus, Pakistani authorities were likely to lose the case before filing a lawsuit in the PCA-ICA to address the issue.

This development became mature after the recent secretary-level talks, which were held in Delhi, when Indian authorities took a strong position to defend their stance on certain hydropower projects, however Pakistani authorities couldn’t clearly present their point of view.

It was further revealed that Indian authorities had completed the 45MW Nimoo Bazgo hydropower project and power generation from the project had started.

Sources further revealed that Indian authorities had also laid a document before Pakistani authorities, which reportedly allowed India to construct the controversial Nimoo Bazgo run-of-the-river project with a no-objection certificate inked by the former environment secretary.

The sources further maintained that the former environment secretary had played an important role in acquiring a Carbon Credit Certificate for India for Nimoo Bazgo project, which later on became a reason of early completion of the controversial project by Indian authorities.

Reliable officials in the Water and Power Ministry said on condition of anonymity that Prime Minister’s Special Assistant on Water Resources Kamal Majeedullah had already hinted at malafide intentions of some officials involved in the matter.

Sources said the Water and Power Ministry and its subordinate institutions had completed the paper work for filing a lawsuit in the PCA-ICA, but after the recent development, the federal government had in principle taken a decision to step back from its stance. Former water and power minister Naveed Qamar – who had expressed concerns over the inquiry report of a commission which he had himself established under the chairmanship of Water and Power Development Authority (WAPDA) Secretary Muhammad Imtiaz Tajawar to probe the alleged misconduct of former Indus water commissioner Jamat Ali Shah – had formed a special committee to investigate the matter.

However, the special committee is yet to show any noticeable progress and apparently the file of the probe has been closed.

The inquiry conducted by WAPDA secretary had maintained that the former Indus water commissioner, Shah, had not played his due role and had remained silent about the Nimoo Bazgo project (built by India during 2002-2009), and had not raised any objections during the Pakistan-India meetings at the level of Permanent Indus Waters Commission. The 57-metre-high controversial Nimoo Bazgo hydroelectric power project is being developed in the Leh district on the River Indus. Additionally, the 42-metre-high Chuttak hydroelectric project is also being completed on the River Suru, a tributary of the Indus in the Kargil district of Indian-held Kashmir.

The controversial Nimoo Bazgo power project is a run-of-the-river project on the river Indus, situated at village Alchi, 70 kilometres from Leh in the state of Jammu and Kashmir.

The project was conceived on July 1, 2001, approved on June 8, 2005, and construction began on June 9, 2005.
 
Indian authorities took a strong position to defend their stance on certain hydropower projects, however Pakistani authorities couldn’t clearly present their point of view.
Thi had always remained bane for pakistan that they lack water experts and hydrologist who can understand the Complex technicalities and intricacies of the dams and IWT.During one of the visits of the Syed Jamat Ali Shah when he was PPIC when discussions were still going on over the Baglihar issue. Indian PIC decided to take them to IIT Roorkee to the Hydrological Institute to show them the technical model of the BHEP. At the end of the meeting, the PPIC Syed Jamat Ali Shah openly declared that they could not understand most of the technical matters. This news Item corroborates those facts now when Jamat Ali Shah says:

Syed Jamaat Ali Shah said the two sides did not trust each other. “We want to get at least drinking water from the Ravi, Sutlej and Bias. When we last tried negotiating it, India wanted water from the Chenab. It also did not discharge its Ravi water, saying Pakistan is wasteful of its resources and cannot be trusted.”
He said when Pakistan asked for early information on water discharge so it could compile flood warnings, the Indians sought water from the Chenab and Indus.
He said that Pakistan lacked water experts. “We do not have a single international water expert in Pakistan. We always seek help from England or the US. We cannot negotiate with India unless we increase capacity,” he said.
“How can anyone from our government talk about water as an economic resource with [Indian Prime Minsiter] to Manmohan Singh? He has a PhD in economics; no one in our government does,” he said.

India-Pakistan issues: Forget Kashmir, terrorism. Worry about water – The Express Tribune

Seems like same is the case here with Nimo Bazgo project.Sensing india is on strong technical and legal footing pakistan govt. has decided against appealing this project at ICA.otherwise it too would have been redux of BHEP.
 
Probably they realized that their case was not strong enough !
 
After beating chests for tens of pages and threats look like they are back to where they started from . They do not stand a chance in front of legal and technical aspects and also Indian Diplomacy Skills :)
 
No some pakistani Dalal is acting on behalf of India. :rofl:
 
Probably they realized that their case was not strong enough !
Its most Likely PPIC is learning from BHEP and kishanganga(probably) debacle.Last time this happened all the blame was put on syed jamat ali shah and to save his skin he had to seek asylum in canada.
 
This is what Happens when u base ur aspirations and demands of Illogical philosophical agenda.

Pakistani is by the Philosophers,off the philosophers ,for philosophers.
 
After beating chests for tens of pages and threats look like they are back to where they started from . They do not stand a chance in front of legal and technical aspects and also Indian Diplomacy Skills :)
Its more to do with legal and technical scientific skills about dam engineering and water resources.And IIT Roorkee is premium in this feild even before it was given IIT state from during the days of Roorkee used to conduct its own entrance tests and which supposed to be even tougher than IIT's entrance test.
 
Its most Likely PPIC is learning from BHEP and kishanganga(probably) debacle.Last time this happened all the blame was put on syed jamat ali shah and to save his skin he had to seek asylum in canada.

Agreed .

Pakistan knows well that India is building these projects well within its legal rights and there is not a chance for Pakistan to win the case . Pakistan would only embarrass itself further had it pushed ahead with the case at ICA .
 
Its difficult to believe that Pak lacks the expertise to understand such issues.

Its not rocket science and is available the world over. If in doubt a good international consultant would help.
 
Its difficult to believe that Pak lacks the expertise to understand such issues.

Its not rocket science and is available the world over. If in doubt a good international consultant would help.
They always use UK/USA water expert as mentioned by Ex-PPIC Syed Jamat Ali shah in report i posted above.

“We do not have a single international water expert in Pakistan. We always seek help from England or the US.

If you listen to Pakistani water experts like Arshad Abbasi,Shamsul Mulk you 'll get the clear pic.


 
Last edited by a moderator:
Its difficult to believe that Pak lacks the expertise to understand such issues.

Its not rocket science and is available the world over. If in doubt a good international consultant would help.

I dont think that's the problem , the problem is Pakistan's good consultants know that India have built these projects well within their rights and Pakistan would be humiliated in case they press a case in ICA against India since their position is very weak. Thats why Pak is not going ahead with the charges
 
World bank will do only these things.
1) design is ok.
2)Design should be changed slightly
 
Singe this Thread is based on Cold Bloody Facts so No pakistani will respond here , while the thread on India refusing to give Stats of It's river , you will find them camping there .
 
Singe this Thread is based on Cold Bloody Facts so No pakistani will respond here , while the thread on India refusing to give Stats of It's river , you will find them camping there .
Main hoon na.....:pakistan::pakistan::pakistan:
 

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Military Forum Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom