Gandhi, Jinnah and others

[queerbait]

i have this genuine question to pakistanis.....what are tought about the freedom struggle.i mean in pakistani school history textbooks , there must be some chapters about independence movement....about the role of jinnah , gandhi , lal bhadu shastri, frontier gandhi...and others.i mean do they tech about dandi march , khilafat movement etc.

 

[Kaniska]

Leave this topic man....this is really very boaring....Do you think that they are relevant in 21st century...??? South Asian people should really come out of their painful past...

 

[Myth_buster_1]

i have this genuine question to pakistanis.....what are tought about the freedom struggle.i mean in pakistani school history textbooks , there must be some chapters about independence movement....about the role of jinnah , gandhi , lal bhadu shastri, frontier gandhi...and others.i mean do they tech about dandi march , khilafat movement etc.

Dear Indians and Pakistanis,

Jinnah and Ghandi were British products/tools who served the interest of imperialist British Empire because the Brits may be gone but their shadows inform of their system still lives on. YOU GUYS ARE FOOLS!

I may expect Indians to follow their British masters system but not Pakistan.

 

[third eye]

Dear Indians and Pakistanis,

Jinnah and Ghandi were British products/tools who served the interest of imperialist British Empire because the Brits may be gone but their shadows inform of their system still lives on. YOU GUYS ARE FOOLS!

I may expect Indians to follow their British masters system but not Pakistan.

Everyone born during the Brit era could be classified as British Products.

As far as being tools, they must be the only tools created by them who worked to dismantle their empire.

I am surprised to read such remarks from a Pakistani on Jinnah.

 

[Myth_buster_1]

Everyone born during the Brit era could be classified as British Products.

As far as being tools, they must be the only tools created by them who worked to dismantle their empire.

I am surprised to read such remarks from a Pakistani on Jinnah.

Sir you are missing the point. You should know how muslim hindus and sikhs were treated during 1800s independence movement because the british had NO INTENTION of exiting. The Britis were never defeated its us who were fooled to believe in their game. The process of pak-indo independence or any other nation ruled by Brit was a long period of time and had enough time and enough power to ELIMINATE such elements IF they posed any threat to the EMPIRE!.

 

[third eye]

Sir you are missing the point. You should know how muslim hindus and sikhs were treated during 1800s independence movement because the british had NO INTENTION of exiting. The Britis were never defeated its us who were fooled to believe in their game. The process of pak-indo independence or any other nation ruled by Brit was a long period of time and had enough time and enough power to ELIMINATE such elements IF they posed any threat to the EMPIRE!.

I am sorry I havent understood the point you are trying to make.

Could you elaborate ?

As far as I know the only activity that took place towards overthrowing the Brit yoke in 1800's was the mutiny of '57.

The Sikhs sided with the Brits then.

 

[Srinivas]

Sir you are missing the point. You should know how muslim hindus and sikhs were treated during 1800s independence movement because the british had NO INTENTION of exiting. The Britis were never defeated its us who were fooled to believe in their game. The process of pak-indo independence or any other nation ruled by Brit was a long period of time and had enough time and enough power to ELIMINATE such elements IF they posed any threat to the EMPIRE!.

Wrong mate, Britain gave independence to India because of world war 2 and the changes aftermath, The independence movement lead by Gandhi only increased pressure.

It was Nazis that did the damage to Britain and there by indirectly helped south Asian people .

 

[Rusty]

Wrong mate, Britain gave independence to India because of world war 2 and the changes aftermath, The independence movement lead by Gandhi only increased pressure.

It was Nazis that did the damage to Britain and there by indirectly helped south Asian people .

People don't seem to understand this but this is very true.
The British has no plans to leave India, it was only after WW2 that they were forced to leave.

 

[RajputWarrior]

People don't seem to understand this but this is very true.
The British has no plans to leave India, it was only after WW2 that they were forced to leave.

Wait I thought India didn't exist prior to 47'. You guys have a weird sense of history when it suits you

 

[Rusty]

Wait I thought India didn't exist prior to 47'. You guys have a weird sense of history when it suits you

You are just being obtuse for the sake of annoying me

You know very well that I meant the British Raj
Unless you think the Republic of India has existed for thousands of years and Asoka was the first PM of it

 

[RajputWarrior]

You are just being obtuse for the sake of annoying me

You know very well that I meant the British Raj
Unless you think the Republic of India has existed for thousands of years and Asoka was the first PM of it

Whatever suits your lack of history

 

[Rusty]

Whatever suits your lack of history

Honestly I was going to reply to you but then I realized that even most Indians would agree with me on how dumb you sound right now. So I will just leave it at that.

 

[RajputWarrior]

Honestly I was going to reply to you but then I realized that even most Indians would agree with me on how dumb you sound right now. So I will just leave it at that.

I could disprove you with facts, however that would be going off topic. And we all know "Republic of India" didn't exist before 47'. You've got to be a real dumb @ss to even make that statement.

 

[Icarus]

The OP's question has remained unanswered and thus I feel compelled to make this last post on this thread.

Yes, Pakistani textbooks teach all the way from the Indus Valley Civilization to relatively recently (2005 to my knowledge).

Thread Re-Closed