What's new

Facebook and Google remove 'offensive' India content

fd24

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jun 23, 2011
Messages
5,864
Reaction score
0
Facebook and Google say they have complied with an Indian court directive and removed "objectionable" material.

They are among 21 web firms, including Yahoo and Orkut, facing a civil suit in Delhi accusing them of hosting material that may cause communal unrest.

A criminal case of similar allegations is due to be heard next month.

Judges have threatened to block sites that fail to crack down on offensive content, but many firms say it is impossible to pre-filter material.

Late last year, Communications Minister Kapil Sibal met officials from Google, Facebook and other websites and said the government would introduce guidelines to ensure "blasphemous material" did not appear on internet.

The Delhi High Court last month asked Facebook and Google India to "develop a mechanism to keep a check and remove offensive and objectionable material from their web pages" or "like China, we will block all such websites".

'Constitutional issue'


The civil case being heard in Delhi on Monday was filed by Muslim petitioner Mufti Aizaz Arshad Kazmi, who alleged the companies were hosting material intolerant to religious sentiment.

Google and Facebook told the court they had complied with an earlier order by a Delhi district court judge to take down certain material.
Google said: "This step is in accordance with Google's longstanding policy of responding to court orders."

Facebook India said it had also filed its compliance report.

Facebook, Google, Yahoo, Microsoft and others all argued that no action should be taken against them.

But the judge insisted the 22 firms should provide a written reply within 15 days detailing the removal of the material.

A second, criminal case - brought by Hindu journalist Vinay Rai - is scheduled to be heard next month, with leading company executives summoned to appear.

However, a Delhi High Court judge will rule next week on an appeal by the firms involved for the case to be quashed.

A spokesman for Microsoft said it had "filed an application for rejection of the suit on the grounds that it disclosed no cause of action against Microsoft".

Google India has argued that it is not feasible to pre-monitor material posted by "billions of people across the globe".

Google lawyer, NK Kaul, said in an earlier court hearing that the issue also related "to a constitutional issue of freedom of speech and expression, and suppressing it was not possible as the right to freedom of speech in democratic India separates us from a totalitarian regime like China".

Facebook says policies are in place that enable people to report abusive content.

In December, Mr Sibal said: "My aim is that insulting material never gets uploaded. We will evolve guidelines and mechanisms to deal with the issue. [The companies] will have to give us the data, where these images are being uploaded and who is doing it."

BBC News - Facebook and Google remove 'offensive' India content
 
india is trying to silence its own citizens from calling for help against the human rights abuses in their country through facebook and google -- underclass kept in perpetual starvation / prejudice, occupation of Kashmir and repression of independence groups in the northeast.
 
Good for their country, can a dumb Pakistani PM do this, yesterday he was asking Pakistanis to look at democracy in india, will he act like his favorite democratic leaders & force google & facebook to remove offensive content against Pakistan on their websites. I bet offensive materials against Pakistan is huge than that of india.
 
Goes to show how Anti muslim and pro non muslim these companies are..If it was a material which offended muslims,they would never have removed it....
But then there are Burger Bachay among us who will die without Facebook..Their distress was evident when PTCL blocked FB on acertain well known event Held on the said website..which FB did not remove until they milked the situation and muslims started leaving the website..
Also goes to show how Divide we are..we muslims cant agree on anything ever.
 
Goes to show how Anti muslim and pro non muslim these companies are..If it was a material which offended muslims,they would never have removed it....
But then there are Burger Bachay among us who will die without Facebook..Their distress was evident when PTCL blocked FB on acertain well known event Held on the said website..which FB did not remove until they milked the situation and muslims started leaving the website..
Also goes to show how Divide we are..we muslims cant agree on anything ever.

Did you not read this?

The civil case being heard in Delhi on Monday was filed by Muslim petitioner Mufti Aizaz Arshad Kazmi, who alleged the companies were hosting material intolerant to religious sentiment.
 
india is trying to silence its own citizens from calling for help against the human rights abuses in their country through facebook and google -- underclass kept in perpetual starvation / prejudice, occupation of Kashmir and repression of independence groups in the northeast.


Idiotic brainwashed robot who can repeat only one line which saved in thier memory card.
 
india is trying to silence its own citizens from calling for help against the human rights abuses in their country through facebook and google -- underclass kept in perpetual starvation / prejudice, occupation of Kashmir and repression of independence groups in the northeast.
Look someone is talking about human rights. The above BOLD letter is for those military less tibetians who are killed brutally by your govt and your are invading other country mainland borders and you are talking about so called HUMAN RIGHTS and INDEPENDENCE.
No offense but its your communism govt who made you that way that you are right and other are wrong. You supposed to be a senior member so try to be like one. ( NO OFFENSE )
 
india is trying to silence its own citizens from calling for help against the human rights abuses in their country through facebook and google -- underclass kept in perpetual starvation / prejudice, occupation of Kashmir and repression of independence groups in the northeast.

Time to ask for fresh material from CPC, troll.
 
india is trying to silence its own citizens from calling for help against the human rights abuses in their country through facebook and google -- underclass kept in perpetual starvation / prejudice, occupation of Kashmir and repression of independence groups in the northeast.

You just speak the bitter truth.:tup:
 
You just speak the bitter truth.:tup:

what sort of person you are? On one hand, you are praising indian goverment decision. And on other hand, such idiotic post. Is it neccessary in this topic?. Are you alright?
 
india is trying to silence its own citizens from calling for help against the human rights abuses in their country through facebook and google -- underclass kept in perpetual starvation / prejudice, occupation of Kashmir and repression of independence groups in the northeast.

Hahahahahahaha! Nice one. :D


Ohh wait. You were serious? :O
You didn't even read the article. Did you? :D "The Delhi High Court last month asked Facebook and Google India to "develop a mechanism to keep a check and remove offensive and objectionable material from their web pages" or "like China, we will block all such websites".

So technically speaking China's the one who want's oppress/silence, abuse the human rights and started this trend. Btw 'Hungvu' means 'To sh*t' in my language. :P Not even joking and that's what you seem to be doing everywhere. :)
 
india is trying to silence its own citizens from calling for help against the human rights abuses in their country through facebook and google -- underclass kept in perpetual starvation / prejudice, occupation of Kashmir and repression of independence groups in the northeast.

Bravo Bravo...What a Glorious Comments from Maoland
 
Back
Top Bottom