Honour killing? Afghan student shot dead in UP

[Filmmaker]

responsibility goes to ISI,

 

[Paan Singh]

responsibility goes to ISI,

may be ..to destroy indian afghan relations..

 

[Avisheik]

Why kill the afgan kid?? Didnt the relatives of the girl attend college or high school? Young people tend to have feelings for the opposite sex. Its natural. But it doesnt mean you should kill them just for liking a person.

 

[LURKER]

That entire meerut ghaziabad belt is a hotbed of crime. I have a friend studying in that college and its not uncommon there to try to kill someone over love disputes. In this case it was girl's brothers. Try talking to a girl u can end up getting beaten either by her boyfriend or relatives. Use of small arms in petty disputes in colleges and university is normal.

 

[harpoon]

responsibility goes to ISI,

We will give 'credit' where it is due.

 

[Doctor09]

sad incident ..... if they love each other then their parents should marry them ,,, killing is not a solution of this problem

 

[harpoon]

sad incident ..... if they love each other then their parents should marry them ,,, killing is not a solution of this problem

Dude in SA, Marriage is considered a union of 2 families rather than 2 individuals and honor killing is a side effect of that concept.

 

[Manas]

very sorry..i think problem was hindu muslim love and love with foreigner..

Girls name is Monika and brother's name is Robin . I don't think they are hindus by religion .

Then there someone called Faheem , name sounds muslim being associated with the murder .

 

[Developereo]

Some more honor killings

Dad who killed daughter's boyfriend to serve 18 months - Saskatchewan - CBC News

Daughter testifies that father killed her boyfriend | CTV News

Pahrump man shoots, kills daughter's boyfriend - www.ktnv.com

Oh, wait, these were just "crimes of passion"....

 

[Doctor09]

Dude in SA, Marriage is considered a union of 2 families rather than 2 individuals and honor killing is a side effect of that concept.

if both families leave their ego behind and accept the love of their children then the families can be united and the lovers too .... then there will be no side effect ..

 

[harpoon]

if both families leave their ego behind and accept the love of their children then the families can be united and the lovers too .... then there will be no side effect ..

Never gonna happen..atleast in the immediate future.

 

[Bang Galore]

Never gonna happen..atleast in the immediate future.

It will happen & faster than anyone thinks. This is the last gasp from people who see the ground slipping from beneath their feet. There will be an odd murder but I will wager that it would pale when confronted with the overwhelming number that will get their way, idiotic behaviour notwithstanding

 

[Doctor09]

Never gonna happen..atleast in the immediate future.

but hope for good

 

[Abingdonboy]

India is a secular, pluralist country- such heinous crimes are a fly in the face of what makes India great. The backward nonsense spread in parts of rural India must be stamped out.


If ever there was an oxymoron: "honour" killing.


There is no honour in cold-blooded, unessercary MURDER.



RIP to the sad, unfortunate victim. Hope the SCUM who committed the crime rot in Hell.

 

[anonymus]

this honor killing is a big nuisance in rural areas of up,rajasthan and haryana.....

if you dont like your sis falling in love with someone just shut her in her room and dont let her go out....she is as much to be blamed as the guy after all they were both in love....

Some Questions from my side

Does the fact that you gave birth to someone or are related to someone by blood give you a right over that person's life?

Does a parent who believe that they have a right to control even the most intimate decision of their children?

What is honour?

A Child does not come to this world on his own.It is a conscious decision of parents to have a child.Since the parents invest a lot of economic and emotional resources in raising a child it is imperative for child that it look after his parents when they are old and retired.But the parents have no moral right to lay claim over the life of person which include the choice of spouse as a child is conceived either through a concious decision or in lust.A child is not born out of his free will but due to sexual act both parents indulged in.

Now every person has a right to make his decision.While this is applicable for couples this is also applicable for parents.Therefore if the parents or brothers do not support their children/siblings choice the can snap their familial ties but any coercion is Illegal and Immoral.The people thinking this way does not deserve to become parents and should have remained virgins.

Now regarding honour.What is honour?According to me honour derives from a set of values and rules that a person have to differentiate between good an bad,the rules that he follow to regulate his behaviour.A solider who provide medical aid to wounded enemy.A person who helps people in distress is acting honourably.Honour is an internal construct.It could be violated if the person acts in discordance of his values.The person who has such a fragile conception of honour that it could be violated by some external event were never honourable.Honour for them was a shield that they were using to hide their inferiorities an sexual frustration.