What's new

Will the 'great wall of Jakarta' save the capital from floods?

Reashot Xigwin

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Oct 20, 2012
Messages
5,747
Reaction score
0
Hey I forgot to post this article.

The ambitious $40 billion project will involve a 35-kilometer wall across the Bay of Jakarta in the shape of the mythical bird Garuda


Sam Reeves, Agence France-Presse
Published 2:06 PM, Oct 15, 2014
Updated 2:06 PM, Oct 15, 2014
h_51202723_DB7FBE458997480296A9CD5F44591F23.jpg

GREAT FLOODS. Residents wade through flood water in Jakarta on January 30, 2014. Floods and landslides are common during the rainy season in Indonesia. File photo by EPA

JAKARTA, Indonesia - Jakarta has launched a multi-billion-dollar scheme to build a huge sea wall to combat flooding as the Indonesian capital sinks, but there is skepticism about its chances of success in a country with a history of corruption and failed megaprojects.
The 35-kilometer wall, across the Bay of Jakarta off the city's northern coast, is the centerpiece of a project that will cost up to $40 billion over three decades, and also includes reclaiming land for 17 new islands.

The whole project will form the shape of a Garuda, the mythical bird that is Indonesia's national symbol.

jakarta-sea-wall.jpg

PROTECTION FROM GARUDA. The Jakarta sea wall will be in the shape of the mythical bird Garuda, Indonesia's national symbol, as seen in this screengrab from a video from Berita Jakarta, the official news portal of the capital.

While the aim is to prevent floods, it is hoped up to one million people will live and work on the islands, and help take pressure off a crowded city notorious as one of the world's most uninviting urban sprawls.

Supporters of the project, which officially got under way last week and is run by the Indonesian government with help from Dutch experts, say it is the only long-term solution.

"It's a life-and-death situation," said Purba Robert M. Sianipar, a senior economics ministry official with a key role in the project, adding hundreds were at risk of losing their lives from severe flooding if action was not taken.

However, some wonder whether such an ambitious plan will ever be completed, given Indonesia's bad record on infrastructure projects, such as plan to build a monorail in Jakarta that was embroiled in a storm of corruption 6 years ago.

Chief Economics Minister Chairul Tanjung suggested as much at last week's launch event, saying disagreements with future governments could knock the project off schedule.

Others question the approach entirely, saying the project will not stop the city from sinking, while graft is also a major danger, with officials sometimes awarding tenders to unsuitable firms in exchange for large kickbacks.

Jakarta has long been hit by floods during the rainy season, when tropical downpours cause rivers to burst their banks and deluge inadequate drainage systems, forcing tens of thousands out of their homes.

However in 2007, a new type of flood set alarm bells ringing.

000_hkg10106933_7A5AF5CF44B4428B81EC7DB73F70CD6E.jpg
FLOOD CONTROL. Children play on giant pipes of a flood control station built along a dike protecting the community from sea water intrusions in Jakarta. The Indonesian capital is constructing a sea wall in the northern coastal district. Photo by Romeo Gacad/AFP

Rivers could stop flowing

Slum neighborhoods were inundated when a high tide surged over sea defenses in northern Jakarta, something that had never happened before and which highlighted the severe land subsidence in many areas.

As Jakarta has rapidly grown to a population of about 10 million, increased water extraction for drinking has caused the ground to compact and parts of the city to sink, a problem seen in other coastal conurbations, such as Ho Chi Minh City and Bangkok.

Parts of coastal north Jakarta, which is built on soft clay, are sinking as fast as 14 centimeters (5.5 inches) a year, meaning they could be meters below sea level in a few decades, according to those behind the sea wall project.

"Basically we are pumping ourselves into the ground," said Victor Coenen, from Dutch consultants Witteveen and Bos, which devised the master plan for the project.

The subsidence also means the 13 rivers in Jakarta may sink below sea level and stop flowing, increasing the risk of inundations.

After the 2007 floods – which forced hundreds of thousands out of their homes – officials scrambled to come up with a plan.

It involves strengthening the current, low sea defenses over the next few years to provide temporary protection for north Jakarta, home to more than 4 million people.

Work will then begin on the main wall, which will sit 6 to 8 kilometers from the coast and will be 7 meters above sea level.

Construction of the wall will be finished between 2025 and 2030, while development on the islands – which will have a mix of high-end and low-cost housing – could take another decade.

A huge reservoir will be created between the islands and sea wall, where water from downpours can be stored so it does not flood the city, and into which rivers will be able to flow freely.

Plans are also in progress to slow the land subsidence by providing piped water to Jakarta from other areas and stop extraction of ground water. – Rappler.com

Will the 'great wall of Jakarta' save the capital from floods?
 
Hey I forgot to post this article.

The ambitious $40 billion project will involve a 35-kilometer wall across the Bay of Jakarta in the shape of the mythical bird Garuda


Sam Reeves, Agence France-Presse
Published 2:06 PM, Oct 15, 2014
Updated 2:06 PM, Oct 15, 2014
h_51202723_DB7FBE458997480296A9CD5F44591F23.jpg

GREAT FLOODS. Residents wade through flood water in Jakarta on January 30, 2014. Floods and landslides are common during the rainy season in Indonesia. File photo by EPA

JAKARTA, Indonesia - Jakarta has launched a multi-billion-dollar scheme to build a huge sea wall to combat flooding as the Indonesian capital sinks, but there is skepticism about its chances of success in a country with a history of corruption and failed megaprojects.
The 35-kilometer wall, across the Bay of Jakarta off the city's northern coast, is the centerpiece of a project that will cost up to $40 billion over three decades, and also includes reclaiming land for 17 new islands.

The whole project will form the shape of a Garuda, the mythical bird that is Indonesia's national symbol.

jakarta-sea-wall.jpg

PROTECTION FROM GARUDA. The Jakarta sea wall will be in the shape of the mythical bird Garuda, Indonesia's national symbol, as seen in this screengrab from a video from Berita Jakarta, the official news portal of the capital.

While the aim is to prevent floods, it is hoped up to one million people will live and work on the islands, and help take pressure off a crowded city notorious as one of the world's most uninviting urban sprawls.

Supporters of the project, which officially got under way last week and is run by the Indonesian government with help from Dutch experts, say it is the only long-term solution.

"It's a life-and-death situation," said Purba Robert M. Sianipar, a senior economics ministry official with a key role in the project, adding hundreds were at risk of losing their lives from severe flooding if action was not taken.

However, some wonder whether such an ambitious plan will ever be completed, given Indonesia's bad record on infrastructure projects, such as plan to build a monorail in Jakarta that was embroiled in a storm of corruption 6 years ago.

Chief Economics Minister Chairul Tanjung suggested as much at last week's launch event, saying disagreements with future governments could knock the project off schedule.

Others question the approach entirely, saying the project will not stop the city from sinking, while graft is also a major danger, with officials sometimes awarding tenders to unsuitable firms in exchange for large kickbacks.

Jakarta has long been hit by floods during the rainy season, when tropical downpours cause rivers to burst their banks and deluge inadequate drainage systems, forcing tens of thousands out of their homes.

However in 2007, a new type of flood set alarm bells ringing.

000_hkg10106933_7A5AF5CF44B4428B81EC7DB73F70CD6E.jpg
FLOOD CONTROL. Children play on giant pipes of a flood control station built along a dike protecting the community from sea water intrusions in Jakarta. The Indonesian capital is constructing a sea wall in the northern coastal district. Photo by Romeo Gacad/AFP

Rivers could stop flowing

Slum neighborhoods were inundated when a high tide surged over sea defenses in northern Jakarta, something that had never happened before and which highlighted the severe land subsidence in many areas.

As Jakarta has rapidly grown to a population of about 10 million, increased water extraction for drinking has caused the ground to compact and parts of the city to sink, a problem seen in other coastal conurbations, such as Ho Chi Minh City and Bangkok.

Parts of coastal north Jakarta, which is built on soft clay, are sinking as fast as 14 centimeters (5.5 inches) a year, meaning they could be meters below sea level in a few decades, according to those behind the sea wall project.

"Basically we are pumping ourselves into the ground," said Victor Coenen, from Dutch consultants Witteveen and Bos, which devised the master plan for the project.

The subsidence also means the 13 rivers in Jakarta may sink below sea level and stop flowing, increasing the risk of inundations.

After the 2007 floods – which forced hundreds of thousands out of their homes – officials scrambled to come up with a plan.

It involves strengthening the current, low sea defenses over the next few years to provide temporary protection for north Jakarta, home to more than 4 million people.

Work will then begin on the main wall, which will sit 6 to 8 kilometers from the coast and will be 7 meters above sea level.

Construction of the wall will be finished between 2025 and 2030, while development on the islands – which will have a mix of high-end and low-cost housing – could take another decade.

A huge reservoir will be created between the islands and sea wall, where water from downpours can be stored so it does not flood the city, and into which rivers will be able to flow freely.

Plans are also in progress to slow the land subsidence by providing piped water to Jakarta from other areas and stop extraction of ground water. – Rappler.com

Will the 'great wall of Jakarta' save the capital from floods?

Ingenious! This reminds me of the Dutch Sea Wall in Holland:

This one in Rotterdam:
Rotterdam-Flood-Barrier-537x363.jpg



Dutch Sea Wall:
floodbarrier_netherlands_50553.jpg
 
Giant Sea Wall Jakarta; National Capital Integrated Coastal Development (NCICD)
garuda-national-logo-thumbnail.png

In its quest to enhance flood prevention, foster urban development and - generally - become a more prestigious metropolis, the Jakarta government and Indonesian central government have agreed to start the realization of the National Capital Integrated Coastal Development (NCICD) masterplan, better known as the Giant Sea Wall, located in the bay just north of Jakarta (the capital city of Indonesia). The groundbreaking ceremony for this mega-project is scheduled for October 2014. The Netherlands and Indonesia join hands to construct the project.


Why Does Jakarta Need the Giant Sea Wall?


In recent years, Jakarta has been plagued by frequent floods amid peaks in the rainy season as infrastructure and water management is not adequate, resulting in the temporary relocation of tens of thousands of people in January (peak of Indonesia's rainy season). However, the problem is even more complicated. Jakarta is sinking at a rate of between 7.5 and 14 centimeters per year due to deep groundwater extraction in combination with pressure from high-rise buildings in Jakarta, thus jeopardizing the well-being of future generations, or, at least necessitating the migration of more than four million people as the northern part of the city will be gradually submerged by the sea if no immediate action is taken (the total population of Jakarta numbers around ten million people). In fifty years’ time, the sea level is expected to be three to five meters above Jakarta’s street level. By 2025, increased flooding from rivers is expected as most rivers will stop discharging under gravity to the sea.


The National Capital Integrated Coastal Development (NCICD) Masterplan


The NCICD includes the construction of a giant sea wall just northern of the bay in Jakarta as a measure to protect the capital city against floods from sea. Inside this wall large lagoons will be created to buffer outflow from the 13 rivers in Jakarta (a giant pumping reservoir). This giant sea wall will be built in the form of a Garuda (the large mythical bird which is Indonesia's national symbol) and therefore will become an iconic structure (see picture at the top of this webpage). It will take 10 to 15 years before construction of this wall is realized. In the meantime, existing dikes will be strengthened.

In order to make this masterplan more attractive for private investors, the surface of the giant sea wall will become a center of urban development. Private participation is needed as this USD $40 billion project cannot be financed by the Indonesian government alone. Urban development includes upmarket offices and housing as well as low-cost housing, green areas and beaches. The new integrated city will also involve 17 artificial islands, complete with toll roads, a railway, and seaport, and should be able to absorb approximately two million people. As Jakarta is currently overcrowded and its infrastructure inadequate, this masterplan will relieve pressure on the existing city. The length of the giant sea wall may reach 32 kilometers (from the city of Tangerang in the west of Jakarta to Jakarta's Tanjung Priok harbour).

new-priok-port-location-tanjung-priok-map-indonesia-investments.png



Therefore, the two phases of the mega-project are:

A. Strengthen and enhance the existing coastal dikes along 30 kilometers, and construction of 17 artificial islands in the bay of Jakarta. The groundbreaking of this first phase is scheduled for early September 2014.

B. Giant Sea Wall; a giant dike (32 kilometers-wide) which includes an airport, harbor, toll road, residential area, industrial area, waste treatment, water reservoir, and green areas, on a space of about 4000 hectares.


Involved Parties


The NCICD masterplan is a joint project between the governments of Indonesia and the Netherlands (the feasibility study for the NCICD was largely financed by the Dutch government). The NCICD project is led by a consortium headed by Witteveen+Bos (main contractor) and Grontmij, with subconsultants KuiperCompagnons, Deltares, Ecorys and Triple-A.

The USD $40 billion project will be jointly financed by the Indonesian government, the local Jakarta administration and private investors. How much each party should contribute has not been decided yet. Tenders for the project have not opened yet as the government is still studying the technical aspects of the project (including integration with other projects such as the mass rapid transit and the Jakarta Outer Ring Roads).

Jakarta Propertindo has been appointed to coordinate the reclamation of the 17 artificial islands.

Giant Sea Wall Jakarta; National Capital Integrated Coastal Development (NCICD) | Indonesia Investments

 
Last edited:
Best wishes , auspicious wishes for our good friends in Indonesia !
 
Giant Sea Wall urgent to
save sinking Jakarta: Consultant

Corry Elyda, The Jakarta Post, Jakarta | Headlines | Thu, October 08 2015, 6:19 PM
240287_620.jpg

Headlines News
A water management specialist from Dutch research institute Deltares has confirmed that the National Capital Integrated Coastal Development (NCICD) project, known as the Giant Sea Wall (GSW), will have an environmental impact, but says that land subsidence in Jakarta is a far greater threat and the wall is one of the solutions.

Jan Jaap Brinkman said on Wednesday that the project might affect the Thousand Islands as well as erosion patterns, coral reefs and biota.

However, Brinkman argued that the project was an urgent measure to protect four to five million people threatened by land subsidence that would see their current homes 4 to 9 meters below sea level.

“Everybody keeps forgetting and ignoring the land subsidence, this is the driving force,” he said.

Jakarta is sinking an average of 5 to 20 centimeters per year, with an average of about 7.5 cm per year.

Brinkman added that if the land subsidence continued like this, by the end of the century Jakarta would have sunk another 5 to 6 meters.

Brinkman said the “cheapest and easiest” solution to land subsidence is to stop groundwater extraction. Millions of households, offices, and industries rely on groundwater as the coverage of tap water is only about 60 percent.

“However, if the sinking does not stop, Jakarta has only two options to protect its people,” he said.

He went on to say that they comprised evacuating millions of people and buildings from northern Jakarta to higher ground or enclosing Jakarta Bay with a “good, very safe dike, good very large pumps and a very large lake to store the water: the giant sea wall”.

Recently, the Research and Development for Marine and Coastal Resources Department at the Maritime Affairs and Fisheries Ministry showed that the giant sea wall would have large environmental and social costs, including the disappearance of islands and the damage of biota in the sea. The ministry’s study claimed that it would also destroy the biota in the water inside the wall because of eutrophication process from the pollution of Jakarta’s 13 rivers, and displace thousands of fishermen.

The study was conducted by more than a dozen researchers in 2014 by making a simulation of the GSW. The result was published as a book, Dinamika Teluk Jakarta; Analisis Prediksi Dampak Pembangunan Tanggul Laut Jakarta (The Dynamics of Jakarta Bay; Prediction Analysis of the effects of the Giant Sea Wall Construction), by IPB Press.

Separately, the Office of the Coordinating Economic Minister’s assistant deputy for water resource infrastructure, Mohammad Zainal Fatah, said that he doubted GSW would cause great environmental damage, saying that it would instead have many positive effects.

“The project is urgent as North Jakarta is sinking,” he said.

Regarding the potential for eutrophication, Zaenal said the wall would not be designed like a big sewage pond.

“We will have a water treatment plant that can provide a raw water supply,” he said.

He added that the central government and the city administration were now speeding up construction plans of the liquid waste treatment system.

“We previously aimed to complete the project by 2050 but we are trying to finish it by 2022,” he said.

Separately, Jakarta Development Planning Board (Bappeda) Tuty Kusumawati said that the city administration and other entities would try to minimize the impact of the project on the fisherfolk.

“We will try to alter their profession from fisherfolk to fish farmers,” she said.

- See more at: Giant Sea Wall urgent to save sinking Jakarta: Consultant | The Jakarta Post
 
I thought good drainage system and dam are the keys in flood control?
 

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom