Can Israel, Palestine Copy India-Bangladesh Land Swap Deal To Resolve West Bank Settlement Row?

[Black_cats]

Can Israel, Palestine Copy India-Bangladesh Land Swap Deal To Resolve West Bank Settlement Row?​

World News
Published on Oct 14, 2023 08:11 AM IST

With the Israel-Palestine conflict back in the spotlight, there is also increasing commentary on whether the India-Bangladesh Land Boundary Agreement can be a model to inspire resolution of the dispute over Jewish settlements in the West Bank. The area was captured by Israel during the 1967 war, and subsequently saw large-scale migration by Israelis, leading to land grab allegations by Palestinians. Watch the full video for more.​

 

[@blue Ocean]

Can Israel, Palestine Copy India-Bangladesh Land Swap Deal To Resolve West Bank Settlement Row?​

World News
Published on Oct 14, 2023 08:11 AM IST

With the Israel-Palestine conflict back in the spotlight, there is also increasing commentary on whether the India-Bangladesh Land Boundary Agreement can be a model to inspire resolution of the dispute over Jewish settlements in the West Bank. The area was captured by Israel during the 1967 war, and subsequently saw large-scale migration by Israelis, leading to land grab allegations by Palestinians. Watch the full video for more.​

Any border issue between any two nations has different historical background than any other such issues.

Why Indian media talking nonsense?

By the way, do some people really know about the root of BD enclaves in West Bengal and West Bengal enclaves lying inside BD?

Since @Black_cats is the initiator of this thread, he is supposed to know it. So, please tell us the BD-W. Bengal enclave issue. Why were there enclaves?

@IndiLite

 

[IndianLite]

Any border issue between any two nations has different historical background than any other such issues.

Why Indian media talking nonsense?

By the way, do some people really know about the root of BD enclaves in West Bengal and West Bengal enclaves lying inside BD?

Since @Black_cats is the initiator of this thread, he is supposed to know it. So, please tell us the BD-W. Bengal enclave issue. Why were there enclaves?

@IndiLite

As I understand it, land enclaves were created mostly through movements of various rivers.

 

[RescueRanger]

Can Israel, Palestine Copy India-Bangladesh Land Swap Deal To Resolve West Bank Settlement Row?​

World News
Published on Oct 14, 2023 08:11 AM IST

With the Israel-Palestine conflict back in the spotlight, there is also increasing commentary on whether the India-Bangladesh Land Boundary Agreement can be a model to inspire resolution of the dispute over Jewish settlements in the West Bank. The area was captured by Israel during the 1967 war, and subsequently saw large-scale migration by Israelis, leading to land grab allegations by Palestinians. Watch the full video for more.​

Completely different issue:

India and Bangladesh: Exchanging border enclaves & (re-)connecting with new citizens | Brookings

For decades, India-Bangladesh relations were marred by the question of a comprehensive settlement of the land boundary between both countries, an important aspect of which included facilitating the belated exchange of border enclaves. These were pockets of land embedded entirely in the foreign...

www.brookings.edu

 

[Destranator]

This is such a moronic proposition that I cannot even be bothered to play the video.

 

[saif]

This shitty idea will not gain any support from anybody.

 

[@blue Ocean]

Completely different issue:

India and Bangladesh: Exchanging border enclaves & (re-)connecting with new citizens | Brookings

For decades, India-Bangladesh relations were marred by the question of a comprehensive settlement of the land boundary between both countries, an important aspect of which included facilitating the belated exchange of border enclaves. These were pockets of land embedded entirely in the foreign...

www.brookings.edu

Brother @Rescue Ranger, thank you for the upload. I went through the Article and found the writer himself has no clue why should there be enclaves in each other's country.

War started between Delhi and Bengal between Akbar and Solaiman. Solaiman was defeated, captured and beheaded by Khan Munaim Khan of Delhi in 1570. But, the Pathan Chieftains of Bengal did not accept the suzerainty of Delhi and this war lasted for about 30 years.

During this long conflict, the King of Cooch Behar invaded and captured a big chunk of the northern Bengal up to the present Bogra District sometimes in between 1580 to 1590.

Isa Khan Afghan attacked the Capital of Cooch Behar and captured it.

Compromise was reached, lands were returned, and border was demarcated. However, time was short for Isa Khan as Portugese and Burmese naval troops attacked his Capital Kotravu during his absence.

So, the status of a few areas could not be finalized at this point. These are the areas known as enclaves.

During the Mughal period, there was no conflicts over them as both Bengal and Cooch Behar were under Delhi. It was the same also during the British period.

But, things changed when in 1947 two independent countries Pakistan and India were created. All those undemarcated areas fell either in east Pakistan or in Indian west Bengal, which have been resolved by Dhaka and Delhi.

@IndianLite

 

[Black_cats]

Any border issue between any two nations has different historical background than any other such issues.

Why Indian media talking nonsense?

By the way, do some people really know about the root of BD enclaves in West Bengal and West Bengal enclaves lying inside BD?

Since @Black_cats is the initiator of this thread, he is supposed to know it. So, please tell us the BD-W. Bengal enclave issue. Why were there enclaves?

@IndiLite

Have you ever done betting on chess! The enclaves are the outcome of those betting. This noble work was done by the Raja of Koch Bihar and the Maharaja of Rangpur.

 

[@blue Ocean]

Have you ever done betting on chess! The enclaves are the outcome of those betting. This noble work was done by the Raja of Koch Bihar and the Maharaja of Rangpur.

What a language from an uneducated stupid!! Unlike you guys, I do not read CHESS history written by some newly educated Historians in Dhaka University with little memory/brain like you who write fictions without reference from authentic old books.

Raja of Rangpur and Chess game is another such story. Ask the fiction writer to give reference to his account.

It was Isa Khan Afghan and Raja of Cooch Behar. Learn history from me.

Go to Asiatic Society in Kolkata and get hold of many old books.

By the way, I understand you never heard there was even a 30-year long Mughal-Pathan war in Bengal from 1570/75 to 1605. Did you ever hear the name of Solaiman Karrani, Taj Khan Karrani or Daud Khan Karrani, the Sultans of Bengal?

How about Lord Khwaja Osman Khan? Do you really know after the defeat and killing of Osman Khan in a 1605 war in Uhar of Mymensingh, Bengal finally lost its sovereignty. I am sure your Class lV knowledge did not even hear about him. But, he was our hero. He was also from the Pathan stock.

Do you know that the name of Isa Khan's father was Kalidas Gazdani a Rajput Baissho/ trader? Do you even know his mother was Fatema Khanam a Lady of Pathan ancestry in Bengal who domiciled here after the 1526 Battle of Panipat?

Emperor Jahangir called him Isa Khan Afghan in his Memoire Tuzukh because of his mother. Do you know Solaiman Khan was the new name of Kalidas Gazdani?

Have you heard the names of Karimdad Khan, Rahim Yar Khan, Anwar Khan of Baniachong or Kutubuddin Majlish? There were more than 22 local Lords at that time whom our stupid call Baro Bhuyyan. Read at least Bahar-i-Stani Gaebi by Mirza Nathan/ Ispahani, a Mughal general. He wrote the accounts of a part of a 30 year long Pathan-Mughal war in Bengal.

Do not you with the knowledge of Class lV ever again come to challenge me on history.

@Rescue Ranger, @IndianLite

 

[@blue Ocean]

https://edition.cnn.com/middleeast/live-news/israel-news-hamas-war-10-14-23/index.html