Would India take Afghan refugees from Pakistan?

[Desert Fox]

Its silly to assume that all Afghans are inherently violent. I for one don't believe in such generalization. So even if some violent Afghans do sneak into India, we have LEA which can deal with them.

We never had any problem with the 20,000 Afghan refugees who are already in India, no reason to think that it would happen in future.

You should accept all 5 million of Pakistan's Afghans as well, that too unconditionally, i'm sure Gandhi will be proud.

 

[Roybot]

You should accept all 5 million of Pakistan's Afghans as well, that too unconditionally, i'm sure Gandhi will be proud.

But what happens to ummah then? and the 'famous' Pakistani big heart?

 

[Desert Fox]

Nation of Pakistan and China are the bff, As a Pakistani try seeking an asylum or heck citizenship for China and see how the strategic ally things works for yourself

Make Gandhi proud, and take all 5 million Afghans in along with their "unique" culture.

You shouldn't discriminate against those poor Afghans just because of their unique culture. That's called "racism" and "intolerance"! As the nation of Gandhi you should follow his teachings of tolerance and acceptance of Afghan uniqueness.

 

[Abhishek_]

Make Gandhi proud, and take all 5 million Afghans in along with their "unique" culture.

You shouldn't discriminate against those poor Afghans just because of their unique culture. That's called "racism" and "intolerance"! As the nation of Gandhi you should follow his teachings of tolerance and acceptance of Afghan uniqueness.

gandhiji is already proud of our non-violent afghan refugees. please continue to enjoy living with the violent ones on your side.

 

[Desert Fox]

But what happens to ummah then? and the famous Pakistani big heart?

Well, we've seen that for the past 30+ years, and now its india's turn to hold the 5 million Afghan refugees.

Though, i will warn that you should create/construct millions of new homes and large communities separate from indian cities since these 5 million Afghans are averse to hindu temples and will be prone to forcing local hindu women to wear veils in order to prevent young Afghan men from having dirty thoughts or from throwing acid on the faces of local indian hindu women. Also, you might have to erect military check posts outside of any girls/ coed schools since Afghans have a very strong dislike of female education/empowerment and they might end up burning down a few schools.

But hey, im sure india would do anything to accommodate!

 

[OrionHunter]

Since Pakistan is the evil behind everything going wrong in Afghanistan while India is Afghanistan's new found love and 'strategic partner' , it seems to be a feasible option to relocate 50% of Afghan refugees to India through the UN lead process.

The Question i pose is, will India be willing to take around 2 million refugees from its 'friend and strategic ally' that it boasts so much about at every opportunity.

I personally have no problem with the refugees, however its time when our burden is shared since we are evil behind the misery of Afghanistan and its 'innocent' regime lead by Karzai.

Vote is open to all members.

Please vote.

Vote? What a stupid question! Makes no sense at all.

C'mon Aeronaut, you're a mod but you keep churning out nonsensical threads like this one. You can do better, I'm sure!

 

[Desert Fox]

gandhiji is already proud of our non-violent afghan refugees. please continue to enjoy living with the violent ones on your side.

Not really, because Gandhi was a simple man and stood up for the common indian and would be proud of india lived up to his vision by accepting all Afghans from all walks of life, especially the common Afghan who makes up the majority (5 million refugees), and not a few thousand Afghan elites who possess wealth.

 

[Cherokee]

Why . It was not India who was fighting JIHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAD in Afghanistan against "Godless commies" looking for dem warm waters .

1 page of discussion and the 'bania's friendship' is already crumbling. I want watchers here....

Bania's friendship is better than mujahideen's friendship . That friendship my friend "explodes" .

 

[KRAIT]

Well, most Afghan refugees in Pakistan follow a hardline Islamic view, so if they go to india you can expect a lot of "firecrackers" going off with public beheadings, forcing hindu women to wear the veil, AK-47 trotting turban wearing Afghans and sharp rise in opium growth and abundance of heroin. Also hindu temples and statues will get blown up too.

As long as they are not causing troubles. There are many Afghans in India.

Veil is prevalent in India. Conversion do take place. One of the reason behind Godhara was the sudden rise in animosity among Hindus and Muslims in Gujarat especially the borderline regions, due to forced conversion of Hindu girls by abducting and raping them and then marrying them, just like the way it happens in Pakistan.
This was the reason the Hindu extremist element got support of locals and few Ministers. They just needed the reason and things got out of bounds very quickly.

Modi was the one who controlled the a more bloodier massacre that could have happened.But you don't know how good Congress is in using Media creating perception.

Many people don't know that in terms of lives lost in comparison to the magnitude of trigger of riot, like burning of train, slaughter of calf etc., Godhara could have result in 2 to 3 times of deaths on both sides. Check the riots in Gujarat post independence.

India is place of extreme paradox. You will see extreme hatred and peaceful coexistence.

 

[Contrarian]

Well, most Afghan refugees in Pakistan follow a hardline Islamic view, so if they go to india you can expect a lot of "firecrackers" going off with public beheadings, forcing hindu women to wear the veil, AK-47 trotting turban wearing Afghans and sharp rise in opium growth and abundance of heroin. Also hindu temples and statues will get blown up too.

@PlanetWarrior @Roybot @KRAIT

You do realize that we have a Government in India?
With all the attendant benefits like Police services of every State.
And that means that any such acts will result in arrest of those responsible.

We have hundreds of Afghans in Delhi itself, not one has committed any such acts.

I think Pakistan should gift Pakistan hating/India loving Afghans to India...only those Afghans who love Pakistan, should be allowed to live in Pakistan. Furthermore dumb Pakistani govt should build a wall @ Pak-Afghan border.

Afghans are not Pakistan's property to be gifted and received as pleased.

 

[Spring Onion]

Failed attempt from Aeronaut to create animosity between Indians and Afghans. Try harder next time!

bwahahahahah why dont you make a successful attempt of creating friendship with them by accepting all the refugees

 

[Cherokee]

bwahahahahah why dont you make a successful attempt of creating friendship with them by accepting all the refugees

Onion Ben , No Thank You . Your country did jihahahahad for ummah you face the consequences .

 

[Srinivas]

bwahahahahah why dont you make a successful attempt of creating friendship with them by accepting all the refugees

India has a history of accepting Afghans for centuries, we call them Kabuliwallah's and Pathans and they are also a part of our society.

Afghans in India - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

[Roybot]

bwahahahahah why dont you make a successful attempt of creating friendship with them by accepting all the refugees

Cause we can see how well that worked out for Pakistan We learn from the mistakes, even the mistakes made by our foes. We don't want to give Afghanistan the sorta "help" Pakistan did.

No one likes to leave their country behind and live as a refugee in some third country. India is doing whatever we can do in our capacity, to make Afghanistan a peaceful and prosperous country, so that the Afghans don't have to seek refuge in other countries. Fixing the root of the problem you see

 

[Spring Onion]

As long as they are not causing troubles. There are many Afghans in India.

Veil is prevalent in India. Conversion do take place. One of the reason behind Godhara was the sudden rise in animosity among Hindus and Muslims in Gujarat especially the borderline regions, due to forced conversion of Hindu girls by abducting and raping them and then marrying them, just like the way it happens in Pakistan.
This was the reason the Hindu extremist element got support of locals and few Ministers. They just needed the reason and things got out of bounds very quickly.

Modi was the one who controlled the a more bloodier massacre that could have happened.But you don't know how good Congress is in using Media creating perception.

Many people don't know that in terms of lives lost in comparison to the magnitude of trigger of riot, like burning of train, slaughter of calf etc., Godhara could have result in 2 to 3 times of deaths on both sides. Check the riots in Gujarat post independence.

India is place of extreme paradox. You will see extreme hatred and peaceful coexistence.

Many? there are hardly few thousands Afghan refugees in India.

Many Afghans specially females Afghan students in India faced harassment at hands of Indian males.

So your godhra example is working anti-clockwise here where Indian hindu men harassed Afghan females

India has a history of accepting Afghans for centuries, we call them Kabuliwallah's and Pathans and they are also a part of our society.

Afghans in India - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

you dint accept them. They brought trade to your land.

So dont twist facts. and spare us of wiki