Why the sikhs had no desire for a independent sikh state in the 1940s?

[lastofthepatriots]

Yaar tu menu ban karwayega

Just keep it simple and civil. I am merely making observations. Koi ne ban hunda. Tinu pata Indian avdi takat net te kad de'a.

Are you so scared of Punjab regiment?

Pakistanis are only scared of Allah swt my little Indian friend.

 

[PlugnPlay]

Sardars have been chopping invaders form the west form centuries.. that's why they are hailed as top Indian Soldiers... Indians love Sardars...

The reality is a lot less romantic.

The Sikhs sided with the British during the First war of Independence in 1857, and hence got rewarded for his loyalty by getting hired into the army to defend the british raj.

And when the british left, Those who worshiped the white man, migrated to the white mans land in search of his master.

 

[AnnoyingOrange]

Just keep it simple and civil. I am merely making observations. Koi ne ban hunda. Tinu pata Indian avdi takat net te kad de'a.




Pakistanis are only scared of Allah swt my little Indian friend.

Whatever rocks your boat mate....

 

[ZenBird]

Just keep it simple and civil. I am merely making observations. Koi ne ban hunda. Tinu pata Indian avdi takat net te kad de'a.

I've noticed that a lot of them look up to Rajputs, Sikhs, Jatts and maybe Marathas specifically since they have such a defeated history otherwise. Our simple people are suckers for praise. This is a tactic which Britishers used to great success in WW2 in villages of both Pakistani and Indian Punjab. They called us martial and superior and we picked up guns and fought their wars. Nowadays, Sikh regiments in India are having a hard time finding recruits in Punjab. A lot of Sikhs from Haryana are taking up the slack.

 

[PlugnPlay]

Don't be mad mutthuswami, here have a vada. Are those lines on your head Fair and Lovely?

View attachment 379466

Why do Santa Banta wear a turban ? To hide your "Khali Sthan" ?

 

[AnnoyingOrange]

The reality is a lot less romantic.

The Sikhs sided with the British during the First war of Independence in 1857, and hence got rewarded for his loyalty by getting hired into the army to defend the british raj.

And when the british left, Those who worshiped the white man, migrated to the white mans land in search of his master.

Sikhs have historically fought all invaders..including Mughals... and protected their motherland...

Sikhs, Hindus and Muslims joined British forces in almost equal proportions to make a living out of working for government in power..

Give m a count of peopel from across India moving into Western world for good future.. why blame Sikhs only.

 

[Sugarcane]

Why did the sikhs not have any desire fir a independent sikh kingdom during the 1940s?

an independent sikh state would be independent, not part of Pakistan nor India but could choosh friendship with both

a independent sikh kingdom

Pakistani west Punjab was muslim majority as was Lahore and off limits but a east punjab with a sikh majority after Partition was a reality

Jinnah didnt offer annexation just support for a independent sikh Kingdom

so a independent sikh kingdom
their own government
their own state
their own laws
their own flag
their own identity
their own army with sikh symbols
their own airforce
ruled by sikhs for sikhs

at peace with both Pakistan and india


why choosh minority status with the risk of any flare-up resulting in the minority being pissed on like the sikhs were in the 1980s

the sikhs had a kingdom for a shortwhile in the 1700s this would have been the modern sikh manifestation of that Kingdom recognised by Pakistan, india and even the U.N

plenty of small states have flourished a sikh state could have too, why choosh minority status among 1.3 billion


the above was a reply in another thread but I thought the question deserved its own thread

Sikhs didn't had any capable leader otherwise being in good books of British Raj they could have easily negotiated their share.

 

[ZenBird]

Why do Santa Banta wear a turban ? To hide your "Khali Sthan" ?

Better Khali Sthan in the turban than in your underwear like Madrasis Mutthu. You should really go play jalli kattu in the mud. That bull ain't gonna fight itself.

 

[PlugnPlay]

Punjab, Haryana, J&K, Rajasthan and Himachal people are not bhaiyyas mutthu, now stop trying to get my attention. I'm trying to hold my nose and ignore your stench

Go play some jalli kattu in the mud

LOL..... let me guess. They must be the "Aryan Race" ...... the last resort of the incompetent racist.

Try visiting a barber and taking a bath to get rid of the stench kaptan amrika.

 

[Côôl PôtâTô]

Why do Santa Banta wear a turban ? To hide your "Khali Sthan" ?

Someone has already made passport brah..Even I needed visa & a turban to enter Punjab last year..

 

[ZenBird]

LOL..... let me guess. They must be the "Aryan Race" ...... the last resort of the incompetent racist.

Try visiting a barber and taking a bath to get rid of the stench kaptan amrika.

They are just the "Not A Dirty Stinky Bhaiyya like you" race

 

[AnnoyingOrange]

Sikhs didn't had any capable leader otherwise being in good books of British Raj they could have easily negotiated their share.

On the contrary Sikhs understand that they would not be able to sustain an aggressive Pakistan on the west ..and a small state of Punjab will easily get run over by Pakistani forces.. so they decided to stay with India and support the bulwark against Pakistan..

 

[PlugnPlay]

Better Khali Sthan in the turban than in your underwear like Madrasis Mutthu.

I understand your fascination with my Underwear.

Didn't your "guru" insist that you wear some ? ........ imagine the despicable state of affairs when your 'guru" had to insist that you wear a underwear and carry a comb

 

[lastofthepatriots]

I've noticed that a lot of them look up to Rajputs, Sikhs, Jatts and maybe Marathas specifically since they have such a defeated history otherwise. Our simple people are suckers for praise. This is a tactic which Britishers used to great success in WW2 in villages of both Pakistani and Indian Punjab. They called us martial and superior and we picked up guns and fought their wars. Nowadays, Sikh regiments in India are having a hard time finding recruits in Punjab. A lot of Sikhs from Haryana are taking up the slack.

I don't really hate Hindus, but their nature for whatever reason pisses me off. They are always trying to be cunning and outsmart you, even though you can see right through it. If they could just be banday de putt and stop having an inferiority complex there would be 0 problems in South Asia.

 

[ZenBird]

I understand your fascination with my Underwear.

Didn't your "guru" insist that you wear some ? ........ imagine the despicable state of affairs when your 'guru" had to insist that you wear a underwear and carry a comb

'Nuff said. I'm not going to go into the reasons why our Guru gave us our identity. It will only further humiliate you, my bhaiiyya friend. Now I need to get my beauty rest, otherwise I'll start to look like you. Now go masturbate to some jalli kattu or to Jayalalitha's portrait