What's new

Why can’t Chinese companies play by the rules?

VkdIndian

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jan 6, 2021
Messages
3,163
Reaction score
-6
Country
India
Location
India

Chinese carmaker BYD faces Indian tax investigation.​

Why is it that Chinese companies follow rules in their homeland, but want to play all dirty tricks in countries where they do business?

They seem to presume that, they can get away with a murder in the name of free business environment. This is not the first Chinese firm that has come under scrutiny for evading taxes, breaking money related laws etc.

There are multitudes of companies from across the world investing in India and running profitable businesses, but Chinese jokers have made a name for playing dirty.

Now the Chinese bots will cry hoarse for being targeted unfairly. If they really think so, then they are requested to take their businesses elsewhere. We don’t want dirty playing crooks.

Chinese carmaker BYD faces Indian tax investigation.​


NEW DELHI, Aug 2 (Reuters) - Chinese automaker BYD faces an ongoing Indian investigation over allegations that it paid too little tax on imported parts for cars it assembles and sells in the country, two sources with direct knowledge of the matter said.

India's Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI) has alleged that China's largest electric vehicle (EV) maker, whose expansion plans have been hit by fractious relations between New Delhi and Beijing, underpaid tax of 730 million rupees ($9 million), one of the sources said.

Although BYD has deposited this sum after the DRI's preliminary findings, the source added, the investigation is ongoing and could lead to additional tax charges and penalties. The DRI is yet to issue a final notice to BYD, which can challenge the findings.

BYD in India and China did not reply to several requests seeking comment.

India's finance ministry did not reply to an email and WhatsApp message seeking comment.

BYD is facing heightened scrutiny from New Delhi over a $1 billion proposal to build cars locally, amid tighter rules on foreign investment from bordering nations, including China. BYD told its Indian joint venture partner it had considered dropping the investment plans.

Companies from China have come under the spotlight in India since 2020 when border clashes broke out between the neighbours.

Smartphone maker Xiaomi Corp has been accused of illegal remittances to foreign entities in the name of royalties, allegations it has denied and challenged in court.

India taxes imports of fully built electric cars at 70% or 100% based on the value of the vehicle, but levies 15% or 35% on imports of car parts that are then assembled locally into an EV.

Those lower rates, however, are only applicable when parts such as a battery pack or motor are imported, without being mounted on a vehicle chassis.

One of the sources said BYD had not met these conditions, making it liable to pay either 70% or 100% depending on the value of the car.

Neither the time period over which the alleged violation took place nor the number of cars affected was immediately clear.

BYD, which has already invested more than $200 million in India, markets the Atto 3 electric SUV and the e6 EV to corporate fleets and plans to launch its Seal electric sedan later this year.

It has sold about 1,960 cars in India since starting sales in 2022, government registration data shows. (Reporting by Nikunj Ohri and Aditi Shah in New Delhi, additional reporting by Zoey Zhang in Shanghai; Editing by Alexander Smith)
 
Nope, the problem is not in Chinese companies.

The problem is in India politics.

Simply speaking, to punish China.


India needs to change.

To be more friendly and protecting foreign companies who invest in India.

Welcoming them with a red carpet, helping and guiding them, serving them like a customer (the customer is king), making them profitable.

If they need good transportation, you build highways, the world's most efficient seaport.

You know, they bring money, knowledge, technology, and provide jobs to the people.

The last time you remember about India, India is already quite developed as China today.


Years ago, an Indian at another forum says after Chinese workers become expensive, the factory will move to India and at that time India will become the world's factory.

I say to him, it's unlikely, because India is difficult.

Beside India, there's other rivals, like SE Asia.


But USA loves India.

USA has a plan for India, that is why it forced everyone to open factory in India, despite SE Asia is in better position.

It's lucky, use this opportunity well.

Once India is rich enough, just be careful, USA will do anything to limit India growth.

The plan, India can be prosperous and advanced, but limited.

Once the limit is reached, there will be problems for India.
 
Chinese companies just don't build any factory in India. Otherwise you will not only lose your money, also lose your reputation.
 
All major companies in the world have presence in India. An economy of the size of India has to follow international norms of trade practices. Most companies follow the local laws too.
Chinese companies in India need to wake up and follow local laws. If they don’t want to, then they can take their business somewhere else. India kicked out Huawei and will kick out others too if they don’t play by the local rules.

Chinese bots should stop behaving like cry babies.
 
What goes around comes around ? Who is talking about treating foreign companies fairly ?
China is not stupid enough to turn away billions of investment, even they are from US. and BYD is a private company, it learned its lesson, China should ban big investment in India, the money should go to Tibet and Xinjiang, China still has underdeveloped regions.
 
What goes around comes around ? Who is talking about treating foreign companies fairly ?
China has a large number of successful investments abroad.

The problem is India, as far as I know, no foreign enterprise has historically been successful in India,.

Except for the East India Company.
 
Chinese companies should forget investing in India ever.
 
chinese companies play by rules as much as anyone else

problem is terror feudal xi likes to play CEO and interfere with the natural order of capitalism, and thus chinese companies become issues
 
Umm to be fair its the greedy capitalist mindset that is to be blamed...
More than the country..

Same thing Indian IT cos. Did with H1B lottery system..

Indian govt. Straightaway took over Private entities in 80s..

Also its not that Chinese cos. Did with india only..

But Wait and watch .
If ever CPEC is properly audited you will find billions of usd worth of corruption happening there
 
India's development and growth is still largely dependent on China

 
It is laughable to see some jokers claiming that there are no successful foreign enterprises in India.

Probably Papa Xi told them to say so. If they say anything else, they also might loose their internal organs like there Ex-foreign minister recently.
 
It is laughable to see some jokers claiming that there are no successful foreign enterprises in India.

Probably Papa Xi told them to say so. If they say anything else, they also might loose their internal organs like there Ex-foreign minister recently.
A fool's talk in the la la land as usual.




 

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom