What's new

What REALLY happened in Galwan those 2 nights, and the Indian soldier's bravery

Status
Not open for further replies.

rent4country

BANNED
Joined
Jul 31, 2020
Messages
1,638
Reaction score
-12
Country
United States
Location
United States
Let me preface this post. I'm not forcing you to believe me, I'm not about to divulge more than I have here. You are free to mock and curse, whatever at me. This a simple post by me- feel free to ignore it.

Hello Indians, this is addressed to you. I know this a tough environment here for the handful left. Frankly, to the few left I'm not sure how you take the incessant religious bigotry, the constant cursing, and bullying in practically every thread that involves India. However, on a personal level, I wanted to let you know that the only perception that matters when it comes to each country, is in the real world. BUT I'm sure you aware of that. From day one here I have always made it clear, you are America's ally and I'm on your side for it. Certainly, no surprise to have American patriots support you given we are stated allies.

Here's something you may not know- this is not just about me- you've probably figured there are some members here having access to some intelligence in their home countries. I'm not claiming to be one, to be clear, but I will note, weeks prior to the Indian counter-attack on the peaks, I posted about establishment 22 and SSP forces for the first time in these forums, as being activated and being accessible. I saw no talk of them or semblance of anyone knowing of their existence by anyone in this forum. As you now know, this an old Tibetian militia group, quite large in numbers, which the CIA formed in 1955. How I knew is immaterial.

I wanted to confirm some insights about those two fateful days and what happened in Galwan, specifically about your soldiers. I get that your soldiers are not going to get any respect here, but know this, there were honorable.
  1. I'll start by stating the obvious. That the border area in and around Galwan is not defined, it's about perception. BUT, not because of any fault of India, rather China that verbally agreed to the latest LAC and what was being patrolled by Indians for many years - yet refused to put in writing.
  2. Both armies have had a baseline understanding of where each patrolled, exclusively. AND in some areas, both armies patrolled the same area, but at different times.
  3. The particular area that saw the big fight had been 'exclusively' patrolled by the Indians for the longest.
A simple yet BIG agreement: Both the Chinese and Indians had worked on agreements that not more than 20 soldiers would patrol at the time, and if a dispute was raised, no more than 20 on each side would be present. They wanted to avoid large numbers in case of dispute and overall to reduce the chances of a misunderstanding and threat. They also agreed that both patrols would be unarmed.

The Chinese backstab:

  1. Chinese plan taking over these Indian patrolled areas had been relatively soon after their post-Doklam embarrassment, they faced (btw, I mentioned that here too several days before it was cited as a possible reason, in any media )
  2. The Chinese army, days before the fateful day, called up an estimated additional 100-150 troops, which was 5-7X of the number of troops agreed to, into the area. These additional Chinese troops came up with bats, Iron rods, sharpened swords to the camp nearest to the area the Indians patrolled.
  3. They devised a plan to ambush and take by surprise, with large numbers of Chinese troops, a small contingent of unarmed Indian troops, and escalate from there.
  4. Unarmed soldiers attacked by large numbers of Chinese troops armed with bats, swords, and sharp objects did not have a good outcome for the unarmed Indian soldiers. But, the Indians exacted revenge the next day when they came in larger numbers and killed an estimated circa 40 Chinese w/ ten's of them injured. The infamous pic of some of the Indian soldiers laying down, captured by the Chinese, was from the first day when they were unarmed and ambushed.
  5. BOTH India and China exchanged captured soldiers from each camp, grabbed from the second day of fighting.

History repeats itself: If this sounds familiar, this what happened to the small team of soldiers at Kargil and how that war began. The initial patrol was ambushed too, but they were each armed in that instance.
 
Last edited:
.
I appreciate the preface to ur post.
I must point out though, that most of this info is already known to most serious followers of this current imbroglio.

I also expect a massive flood upon this thread , of hard working 'comrades' who have been tasked and employ ed for the sole purpose of contaminating the internet bandwidth😂
 
. .
If Chinese soldiers captured how come there’s no pic of chinese pows while there are plenty of pics of Indians surrendering

1601446729441.jpeg
 
.
If Chinese soldiers captured how come there’s no pic of chinese pows while there are plenty of pics of Indians surrendering

View attachment 674758

As I recollect, the pic you show was released by the Chinese right after they saw the video of the Chinese soldier captured by Indians, under someone's shield. Seemingly, both countries have refrained from releasing any pics of a prisoner exchange is my guess.

The bigger question is- attacking unarmed soldiers, with 7X numbers, with bats having nails embedded, with swords and other sharp weapons is mighty brave of the Chinese army. Why then did you have to hide the death of your soldiers?
 
.
As I recollect, the pic you show was released by the Chinese right after they saw the video of the Chinese soldier captured by Indians, under someone's shield. Seemingly, both countries have refrained from releasing any pics of a prisoner exchange is my guess.

The bigger question is- attacking unarmed soldiers, with 7X numbers, with bats having nails embedded, with swords and other sharp weapons is mighty brave of the Chinese army. Why then did you have to hide the death of your soldiers?
There’s roughly equal Chinese and Indian soldiers in my pic. The video with the Indians beating the Chinese soldier was 8:1 odds and was taken before the pic of the Indians surrendering
 
.
There’s roughly equal Chinese and Indian soldiers in my pic. The video with the Indians beating the Chinese soldier was 8:1 odds and was taken before the pic of the Indians surrendering
Nice try. Your "video" in the other thread was another time and place and not this specific episode. Your pic is a cropped version. I ask again, attacking unarmed soldiers, with 7X numbers, with bats having nails embedded, with swords and other sharp weapons is mighty brave of the Chinese army. Why then did you have to hide the death of your soldiers?
 
.
I already see ill prepared undertrained Indian soldiers freezing to death in Himalayas.

China will capture more territory this winter, Indian supply lines are going to be cut in Ladakh.

By next year, India foreign ministry will be defending Jammu and sending out usual hollow threats.

If India makes any stupid move and opens fire on PLAAF, India will lose not only IOJ&K but 7 sister states (Assam, Nagaland, Meghlaya) as well.
 
.
Nice try. Your "video" in the other thread was another time and place and not this specific episode. I ask again, attacking unarmed soldiers, with 7X numbers, with bats having nails embedded, with swords and other sharp weapons is mighty brave of the Chinese army. Why then did you have to hide the death of your soldiers?
It was your army attacking 1 chinese soldier with 8 guys and when the numbers were even your army surrendered
 
. . .
It was your army attacking 1 chinese soldier with 8 guys and when the numbers were even your army surrendered
My army has American soldiers, and our brass would have never agreed to unarmed soldiers patrolling. You may also recollect we come and go as we please in the S China sea.

If you need a reminder
 
.
My army has American soldiers, and our brass would have never agreed to unarmed soldiers patrolling. You may also recollect we come and go as we please in the S China sea.

If you need a reminder
You may have immigrated to America to diddle their cows

but you’re just a surrendering Indian
1601449786242.jpeg
 
. .
@krash :
At what point do Chinese communist posters get requested to add decent -quality posts ?

this thread is polluted by trash posts .
 
.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom