US cannot counter China in Asia without India's support: MK Narayanan

[lasttry]

It is a two way street.

hatred is, but at least we are not some one else's proxy. that much you have to admit.

 

[Kiss_of_the_Dragon]

China will do more to have a friendly India than an adversarial one USA has just raised the stakes in this emerging US China cold war

Really??? tell us what we need to please and have a friendly India ? give up South Tibet or never step into Indian Ocean with our sub

 

[indianBong]

moreover when business is booming with china.... why should we jeopardise that for a cold war like situation????
china is our competitor in geopolitical matter...i.e.to spread areas of influence...thats it... jus bussiness... we should improve relations with all major powers without engaging with any militarily...it will be best for our economy...

 

[Stephen Cohen]

Really??? tell us what we need to please and have a friendly India ? give up South Tibet or never step into Indian Ocean with our sub

Since you are asking let me put out my WISH list

1 Yeah give up South Tibet

2 We want an OPEN declaration about Kashmir being an INTEGRAL part of India
JUST as we say that Tibet is a part of China

3 China should become Pro India rather than Pro Pakistan

 

[Vaishnu]

The ancient Pakistanis ruled Indians from the Taj Mahal for 800 years. With our Chinese nuclear missile help, they will enter Delhi again like Timur the great conqueror. You will woe your ghar wapsi on your minority then.

Learn history ........... It was mughals who had Mongol and Chagatai-Turkic origin. Just posting something to appreciate your Pakistani brother expecting a "thanks "

 

[Stephen Cohen]

never step into Indian Ocean with our sub

No you can keep bringing your subs ; that is not a problem
Your Anti India and Pro Pakistani attitude is the problem

 

[DeathInvader]

Indeed, if you Indians can just do that favor to us to let American use your soil and make sure you pay also their expense as Japan and Korea did

We shall see who pays what. At least China shall pay the most.

giving usa soil to launch attack against china means we should be prepared for retaliatory attack on that base from china.....

And will they have anything left to attack with? U.S is not fool to attack it from one side. And Indian Air Force is not weak that it can't defend against anything that crosses border.

 

[Kiss_of_the_Dragon]

Since you are asking let me put out my WISH list

1 Yeah give up South Tibet

2 We want an OPEN declaration about Kashmir being an INTEGRAL part of India
JUST as we say that Tibet is a part of China

3 China should become Pro India rather than Pro Pakistan

How about my counter offer if you want us to be Friendlier with India,

1-give back our South Tibet
2-give Kashmire back to our all weather friend and make sure you said it right too
3-make sure you take Pakistan order.

You see it's not hard for me to set my expectation very high too...and now we shall see if you Indian are willing to sit and negociate.. Or else what? bring US into the bargain table

We shall see who pays what. At least China shall pay the most. .

care to elaborate? how we gonna pay the most?

 

[Stephen Cohen]

How about my counter offer if you want us to be Friendlier with India,

1-give back our South Tibet
2-give Kashmire back to our all weather friend and make sure you said it right too
3-make sure you take Pakistan order.

You see it's not hard for me to set my expectation very high too...and now we shall see if you Indian are willing to sit and negociate.. Or else what? bring US into the bargain table



care to elaborate? how we gonna pay the most?

Forget It ; Let us continue with the Status Quo

 

[TheMatador]

We removed Rajapaksa Without any Military intervention,All your port city and what not contracts were dissolved. What could you do? Where were the dragon's claw then?

The dragon was in the Maldives but will return to Sri Lanka to remove the Indian puppets by military intervention if necessary.

 

[Kiss_of_the_Dragon]

Forget It ; Let us continue with the Status Quo

you just want us to comply to your request in order to be your friend? this is worst than taxing someone....LMAO there is no such cheap deal.

No you can keep bringing your subs ; that is not a problem
Your Anti India and Pro Pakistani attitude is the problem

and don't talk like you guys don't have any anti-China attitude, I was not born anti-India to begin with.

 

[axisofevil]

Well, pretty much everything he said is true. What seems to be the problem here ?

Never think Russia is our all weather friend. YOu and other Indian posters have a lot to learn. You all are quite clueless to how much emphasis Russia places in their Sino relations over India.


INDIA-RUSSIA STRATEGIC COOPERATION: Time to move away | South Asia Analysis Group

Ancient Pakistan ruled India for 800 years ....


...

...

...

...

Bhuhahaha Bhuhahaha

With nuclear weapons from China Pakistan can enters Delhi ...

And one more thing . No one in India cares about Pakistan nor we looking to have dialogue also. Now which they are asking for many months now . As everyone in India knows the capability of both Pakistan and India . So China can just watch India raise and create more infrastructure all along our borders before you threaten with war if infrastructure work progressed . Now what happend ? When China is invading India We are all waiting with

INDIA-RUSSIA STRATEGIC COOPERATION: Time to move away | South Asia Analysis Group

Forget It ; Let us continue with the Status Quo

INDIA-RUSSIA STRATEGIC COOPERATION: Time to move away | South Asia Analysis Group

hatred is, but at least we are not some one else's proxy. that much you have to admit.

INDIA-RUSSIA STRATEGIC COOPERATION: Time to move away | South Asia Analysis Group

 

[SrNair]

That is a very "Be my daddy" comment. One would have expected a more balanced statement from a former diplomat coming from the country known for its balanced poise within its region.

MK Narayanan was a minor version of Ajit Doval.But his Congress attitude made him insignificant.AFAIK he was just mentioned about Indias importance in Asia.

On topic:He is correct for a certain extent .US began their diplomatic moves around 15 years ago to court us in their camp.But we didnt allow servitude in here.So they loosen their rigid conditions from nuke deal and waiver etc .So after 15 years of efforts they got some support from us.
But still we follow the independent policy.

 

[Luca1]

Lol what's wrong with my comment, I just repeat your Former National Security Adviser said

"US cannot counter China in Asia without India", you Indians must feel really important by now

Some must be as they think US SERIOUSLY need India to counter China. In reality, what India is to US is no different from Australia or Japan are to US.

 

[indianBong]

We shall see who pays what. At least China shall pay the most.



And will they have anything left to attack with? U.S is not fool to attack it from one side. And Indian Air Force is not weak that it can't defend against anything that crosses border.

Are bhai u didn get me.... think there is a war between usa n china regarding taiwan... in that case why shud we give usa a base to launch attack into china... this will lead to retaliatory attack on the base that is on our soil... we will be dragged into war without reason.. coz taiwan is of no interest to india..our airforce army navy are very good very powerful no doubt but why should we enter into a war without any reason??