US alone can’t get UNSC seat for India, says Chinese media

[beijingwalker]

US alone can’t get UNSC seat for India, says Chinese media
Saibal Dasgupta| TNN | Oct 21, 2017, 06:11 IST
BEIJING: The official Chinese media said on Friday that the United States is trying to use India as a lever to contain China's growing influence but added that it is unlikely to succeed in its attempt.

The state-backed media was responding to US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson's recent speech in which he talked about rising US collaboration with India while criticizing China for practicing "predatory economics".

In its editorial comment, the hawkish Global Times said, "Since New Delhi is also stressful about its increasing gap with China, it makes an ideal target for Uncle Sam to unite against Beijing."

The editorial said New Delhi should not feel pleased about Tillerson's comments because the US cannot ensure a seat for India at the Security Council all by itself, and without China's consent. Nor would it (the US) be ready to share high-end technologies (with India) because the US is keen to sell goods but not the know-how, it added.

The comments come ahead of Tillerson's visit to India next week, and US president Donald Trump's first Asian tour which will also cover China in the first two weeks of November.

Earlier, Chinese foreign ministry had objected to Tillerson's comments saying he was taking a biased view of China. But the ministry also tried to show it was not unduly worried about improved India-US relations.

"We are happy to see the development of relations between India and the US as long as they are conducive to the peaceful development of the region and enhancement of relations among the regional countries," Chinese foreign ministry spokesman Lu Kang had said on Thursday.

But Lu also advised the US to "abandon its biased views on China and work with it towards the same goal to uphold the momentum for a steady and sound China relations".

Meanwhile the editorial said, "While India looks forward to receiving more US military know-how, the US is simply willing to supply military products. Washington has failed to contain China's growth in the past and cannot succeed in this goal in the future. Such a goal would actually hinder growth for the whole of Asia."
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com...a-says-chinese-media/articleshow/61158894.cms

 

[MultaniGuy]

LOL trust me, China would never allow India into UNSC.

India has two territorial disputes with China.

China hates India. China would not let India in UNSC.

 

[protest]

LOL trust me, China would never allow India into UNSC.

India has two territorial disputes with China.

China hates India. China would not let India in UNSC.

May be not right today. But in a decades time, India will be third largest economy with largest population in the world. China, eventually has to give in.

 

[beijingwalker]

May be not right today. But in a decades time, India will be third largest economy with largest population in the world. China, eventually has to give in.

How do you know? Never say anything for sure until that happens. India's economy declines instead of rising under Modi.

I hope you don't mean PPP, world trade is not done by PPP unless you live only with yourself, in PPP China has been world No.1 for many years already but here in China we don't give that ranking a shiit

 

[Sankpal]

How do you know? Never say anything for sure until that happens. India's economy declines instead of rising under Modi.

Only one - two quarter? Right?
This is short term lost but it will give medium and long benefits for India. Modi decisions will make Indian economy much stronger

 

[rishav]

How do you know? Never say anything for sure until that happens. India's economy declines instead of rising under Modi.

the economy has not really declined , the growth rate has mostly because of reforms . It will soon recover and the growth rate will be back to around 7%

 

[beijingwalker]

Only one - two quarter? Right?
This is short term lost but it will give medium and long benefits for India. Modi decisions will make Indian economy much stronger

Say that when you reach there, no one really believes that except for Indians, there is no sign of any improvement in people's everyday life in India.

 

[rishav]

Say that when you reach there, no one really believes that except for Indians, there is no sign of any improvement in people's everyday life in India.

stop making general comments ! in which parameter there has been no signs of improvement ?

 

[beijingwalker]

Growth numbers don't really mean much, tangible changes speak volumes.

stop making general comments ! in which parameter there has been no signs of improvement ?

India becomes hungrier than North Korea, I don't see that as a positive change.

 

[rishav]

Growth numbers don't really mean much, tangible changes speak volumes.

changes are represented by statistics ! and india has improved , though nowhere near as fast as china

Growth numbers don't really mean much, tangible changes speak volumes.


India becomes hungrier than North Korea, I don't see that as a positive change.

but was india better before ? and take those reports with a lot of salt . by that report even srilanka is hungrier than nepal ! can you believe it ?

 

[beijingwalker]

changes are represented by statistics ! and india has improved , though nowhere near as fast as china

What I mean is you don't claim you will be the third biggest economy in the world while you don't have world class manufacturing, infrastructure and education, your education is also declining, check the world university rankings, no countries can be prosperous without being powerful first in those key sectors.

 

[Sankpal]

Say that when you reach there, no one really believes that except for Indians, there is no sign of any improvement in people's everyday life in India.

No, one believes? I guess, you are referring to pdf members. you can Google and find "what International organisations are saying about Indian economy"?

Indian is developing country and we are working for improvement. It can't be changed in one night.

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

May be not right today. But in a decades time, India will be third largest economy with largest population in the world. China, eventually has to give in.

Even assuming that India's economic growth recovers somehow, what does economy have to do with a UNSC permanent seat?

When China got the UNSC permanent seat in 1945 what do you think our economy was like back then?

 

[Sankpal]

Even assuming that India's economic growth recovers one day, what does economy have to do with a UNSC permanent seat?

When China got the UNSC permanent seat in 1945 what do you think our economy was like back then?

1945, right?
Since the world has changed. UNSC members will have to accept new world requirements sooner or later else UNSC will be useless.

 

[Han Patriot]

1945, right?
World has changed, now. UNSC members will have to accept new world requirements sooner or later else UNSC will useless.

China will just veto it. After the shit you pulled in Doklam, you think it's still the same? Your starvation rates are now worse than before, it did not improve. Even NK & Sudan is better than India