Urdu Speaking citizens harassed and kidnapped in Karachi

[Bratva]

i don't want to post long stories but i ask few questions

1) do you even know the pashtun history in karachi? it started with blood shed!

2) do you know who opened arms for swati pashtuns when they found door closed in Sind and Punjab? it were karachi and mohajirs

3) do you know who earned the most during MQM era, it were pashtun contractors

4) do you know what will happen to pashtuns if MQM close its areas for pashtuns? you guys will dye of hunger



pakistan judiciary is a joke and these guys are going on appeal, same happened to MQM in hakeem said murder case, and guess what!, they have been also convicted in a anti terror court who are very much politiciased like military courts

today supreme court rehjected appeal against SHC freeing MQM workers wrongly caught in hakeem said murder case

A guy sitting in UK knows more what's going in Karachi or if Pakistan judiciary is a joke

 

[darkinsky]

A guy sitting in UK knows more what's going in Karachi or if Pakistan judiciary is a joke

have you ever lived in karachi?

well you as well as me are connecting with each other through internet or not, or is it a stone age

have to admit, that was a very dumb comment

 

[kushan]

i don't want to post long stories but i ask few questions

1) do you even know the pashtun history in karachi? it started with blood shed!

2) do you know who opened arms for swati pashtuns when they found door closed in Sind and Punjab? it were karachi and mohajirs

3) do you know who earned the most during MQM era, it were pashtun contractors

4) do you know what will happen to pashtuns if MQM close its areas for pashtuns? you guys will dye of hunger

I dont see it that way, every community is essential and intregral part of karachi. The city doesnt belong to MQM, it belongs to pakistan. It is city of migrants and immigrants, thats why some Swat and tribal IDPs chose karachi.
Its wrong to say that Punjab didnt welcome IDPs. Pindi has large number of pashtuns , it was also favourite destination of IDPs . Pindi is turning into second karachi due to settling of large number of pashtuns

i don't want to post long stories but i ask few questions

1) do you even know the pashtun history in karachi? it started with blood shed!

2) do you know who opened arms for swati pashtuns when they found door closed in Sind and Punjab? it were karachi and mohajirs

3) do you know who earned the most during MQM era, it were pashtun contractors

4) do you know what will happen to pashtuns if MQM close its areas for pashtuns? you guys will dye of hunger

I dont see it that way, every community is essential and intregral part of karachi. The city doesnt belong to MQM, it belongs to pakistan. It is city of migrants and immigrants, thats why some Swat and tribal IDPs chose karachi.
Its wrong to say that Punjab didnt welcome IDPs. Pindi has large number of pashtuns , it was also favourite destination of IDPs . Pindi is turning into second karachi due to settling of large number of pashtuns

 

[darkinsky]

I dont see it that way, every community is essential and intregral part of karachi. The city doesnt belong to MQM, it belongs to pakistan. It is city of migrants and immigrants, thats why some Swat and tribal IDPs chose karachi.
Its wrong to say that Punjab didnt welcome IDPs. Pindi has large number of pashtuns , it was also favourite destination of IDPs . Pindi is turning into second karachi due to settling of large number of pashtuns

i am speechless on you bias towards mohajirs and are even not willing to accept the reality, you are trying to support those who refused to let your people in and cursing those who are your benefactors?

Punjab not to allow IDP camps - thenews.com.pk
​

Dilshad AzeemThursday, May 21, 2009

ISLAMABAD: The Punjab government has decided in principle not to allow camps for the internally displaced persons (IDPs) in the province, The News has learnt.



“The IDPs can cause trouble for the province just like the Afghan refugees. So, we have decided not to permit their entry or setting up of camps for them in the Punjab,” sources in the provincial government said.



However, the Punjab government has formed an inter-provincial coordination committee (IPCC), after consultation with the ANP-led Frontier government, to provide aid to the IDPs at their camps in the NWFP.



The IPCC comprises two members each from the Punjab and the NWFP. “The NWFP members will inform the Punjab government of the requirements of the IDPs.” The director general relief and the district coordination officer (DCO), Attock, would coordinate with the NWFP members of the IPCC as representatives of the Punjab.



“If it becomes mandatory for us to accommodate the IDPs any way, a computerised registration system would be set up to ensure strict check on their activities till their return,” the Punjab official sources said.



As the Punjab describes such restrictions as part of its security policy, the Frontier government believes that such a step would create provincial disharmony as no Pakistani citizen could be barred from staying at any corner of the country.



Director Public Relations (DPR), Punjab, Mohiuddin Wani, while speaking on behalf of the



provincial government, said any final decision about the issue would be taken once the IDPs started migrating to the province.



Responding to a query, the DPR said the Punjab government would welcome the displaced persons whenever it deemed necessary. ìPresently, the NWFP government is absorbing all the IDPs.î



Also, Director General Relief, Punjab, Rizwanullah Baig, said the people of the province were donating generously for the IDPs. ìWe will provide all kinds of material assistance to the displaced persons through a coordination committee.î



However, ANP Vice President Haji Muhammad Adeel said: ìYes, we have heard that the Punjab is not willing to take the IDPs and this step will send a wrong message to other provinces.î Adeel said the Punjab should also declare war on terror as the Frontier province had done. “Punjab Chief Minister Shahbaz Sharif has announced assistance for the IDPs, which is only peanuts in view of the fact that Punjab is the elder brother.”



PML-N Chairman Raja Zafarul Haq, in his talk with this correspondent on Monday, had given “rising temperature” as the major reason for not allowing the establishment of the IDPs’ camps in the Punjab.



A PML-N consultative round held in Islamabad last Monday with Nawaz Sharif in the chair had first discussed to adopt a policy of extending help to the displaced persons while retaining them within the NWFP.

Punjab, Sindh criticised for banning IDPs` entry
​

ISLAMABAD, June 4 The Pakistan Muslim League-Q has criticised the governments of Punjab and Sindh for banning the entry of displaced persons into their provinces.

Addressing a press conference here on Thursday, former Punjab chief minister Chaudhry Parvaiz Elahi, the party's secretary-general Mushahid Hussain Sayed and its NWFP chapter president Amir Muqam said the decision to keep the displaced people out of Punjab would be resisted.

Mushahid Hussain said the international community had ignored the federal government's appeals for financial aid for help about three million IDPs because the government had lost the confidence of donors.

He called upon foreign governments and aid agencies to provide funds to the NGOs working for wellbeing of the IDPs.

Amir Muqam said the Punjab government had failed to keep its promise of providing government school buildings to accommodate about 200,000 IDPs who had entered the province.

He said that if the federal government failed to provide relief to the IDPs it would lose support for the military operation.

He said the government should brief the elected representative of the Malakand region on the status and timeframe of the operation to enable the IDPs to plan their return to their homes.

Chaudhry Parvaiz Elahi said his party had provided relief goods worth about Rs20 million to the IDPs and the process was continuing.

 

[Durrak]

Kitna faltu time hai, haathaon may bhi dard nhi hota

 

[SamantK]

Man, scratch the surface and we see so much hatred against each other.

Pakistanis need to wake up and reform themselves. All this hatred is bad for your country.

 

[Luftwaffe]

lol, this is the biggest lye i have heard for a while

they were not on the receiving end on any given time and the reason is simple, they are heavily armed in karachi, they were infact on the taking end

Deal with it ramu kaka...the current reports only point fingers at mqm now take a BS walk.

 

[darkinsky]

Deal with it ramu kaka...the current reports only point fingers at mqm now take a BS walk.

well there is a reason, that's all political, otherwise its only MQM areas where they don't get rocket launchers as response of cordoning off areas to extract criminals

in areas like sohrab goth, quaidabad, lyari, they get retaliated

 

[Luftwaffe]

well there is a reason, that's all political, otherwise its only MQM areas where they don't get rocket launchers as response of cordoning off areas to extract criminals

in areas like sohrab goth, quaidabad, lyari, they get retaliated

Take a walk nobody care it has been proven nothing political all police/rangers/ISI reports proves about mqm, now stop wasting my time not interested in your replies.

 

[darkinsky]

Take a walk nobody care it has been proven nothing political all police/rangers/ISI reports proves about mqm, now stop wasting my time not interested in your replies.

stop being an annoying bitch

 

[Hyperion]

Not necessarily. We may fight amongst ourselves, however, when faced with an external threat, we all unite to kick them out. What we need is manageable bogey-man. I propose the Arabs, they fit the bill perfectly!

This shows how divided Porkistan is.

 

[Edevelop]

Maybe some Urdu Speakers are harassed in Karachi, let us admit that. However, has anyone considered where all the Punjabis in Sind have gone ? Once they were investors and recognized as the most educated lot. Sadly, not only they have become minorities but victims of target killing and extreme stereotypes.

I cannot imagine Punjabis to have defined areas in Sind like Urdu Speakers , Pukhtuns, and Balochis, nor a presence of a nationalist party. If Punjabis in Punjab have opened their arms to all ethnicities and neglected their language for the sake of Pakistan that tells you they are perhaps arguably the only group which is not hostile.

 

[dawn_news]

Maybe some Urdu Speakers are harassed in Karachi, let us admit that. However, has anyone considered where all the Punjabis in Sind have gone ? Once they were investors and recognized as the most educated lot. Sadly, not only they have become minorities but victims of extreme stereotypes.

I cannot imagine Punjabis to have defined areas in Sind like Urdu Speakers , Pukhtuns, and Balochis, nor a presence of a nationalist party. If Punjabis in Punjab have opened their arms to all ethnicities and neglected their language for the sake of Pakistan that tells you they are perhaps arguably the only group which is not hostile.

There are millions of them in Karachi but they dont need to bark about being Punjabis. Mostly educated alot, for poor punjabi Punjab is better then any other part of country.

Anyway i read somewhere that punjabis supported pathans in 1985 muhajir vs pathan riots.

 

[kushan]

There are millions of them in Karachi but they dont need to bark about being Punjabis. Mostly educated alot, for poor punjabi Punjab is better then any other part of country.
Punjabh
Anyway i read somewhere that punjabis supported pathans in 1985 muhajir vs pathan riots.

It was punjabi-pathan itehad 1987 to represent the interests of both communities, and obviously to counter the aggression and violence by Mohajirs who were also entangled with sindhis in riots.
Punjabis were not responsible for violence, the hostility and antagonism was from mohajir side who were harbouring grievances against them as they percieved that prefrential treatment was given to punjabis by zia ul haq in employment oppurtunities

 

[Jaanbaz]

It was punjabi-pathan itehad 1987 to represent the interests of both communities, and obviously to counter the aggression and violence by Mohajirs who were also entangled with sindhis in riots.
Punjabis were not responsible for violence, the hostility and antagonism was from mohajir side who were harbouring grievances against them as they percieved that prefrential treatment was given to punjabis by zia ul haq in employment oppurtunities

Mohajir didn't even know how to fight. mohajir wear shit and patloon, goes to government job 9 am to 5pm, a mohajir has no time for hating punjabis. It was Ayub Khan who started this bull shit. MQM is no doubt evil but there was no MQM in 1960s when pathans were attacking weak mohajirs. So when mohajirs start fighting back everyone starts calling them traitors.