What's new

Unauthorised foreign workers

idune

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Dec 14, 2008
Messages
13,663
Reaction score
-40
Country
Bangladesh
Location
United States
Unauthorised foreign [indian] workers

When it comes to unauthorised employment not only in typical business entities but also in a host of other areas, including healthcare services and educational institutions, the onus is obviously on the immigration authorities and relevant law enforcers to make sure that no foreigner is employed without valid work permit, writes Wasi Ahmed
Doesn't it sound a trifle ironical that while Bangladeshi workers in good numbers are staying or overstaying illegally in many countries, there are plenty of foreign workers who find Bangladesh a suitable place to work illegally?

Rough estimate says the number of such illegal workers in various capacities might well exceed four hundred thousand, residing mostly in the cities of Dhaka and Chittagong. Observers say that the influx of undocumented migrant workers into Bangladesh is largely demand-driven, particularly in the export-oriented garment factories. However, it is the lax official procedures and absence of vigilance and monitoring that also add to their growing numbers.

There is nothing wrong in legal employment of foreign workers, and in certain sectors including garment and high-tech manufacturing, Bangladesh does need skilled workers. But except few instances, the bulk of these workers including mid-level supervisors and managers get employed without legal documents. Reports have it that most of them from neighbouring countries enter Bangladesh on visit visas or multiple entry visas with prior arrangement for employment in local business enterprises dodging the law of the land.

Picking up employment on such visas is grossly irregular and punishable under law. Authorities concerned, including the immigration department, haven't done anything noticeable to ensure that only the authorised persons are employed. It is also often alleged that taking advantage of the lax or no vigilance, a large number of unauthorised people are currently engaged in private hospitals, even elementary schools. Not all of them overstay, they go back and enter with fresh visas to continue with what they were doing. Their employers, for the most part, are the main facilitators in their illegal activities.

The media have been reporting on the illegal practice for long. One important point here is that when unauthorised persons get employed by local business and manufacturing houses, they take their earnings through unofficial channels, that too in foreign currency. Over and above, taxes liable to be paid are evaded.

Lately, it has come to light that the National Board of Revenue (NBR) is set to launch a drive to find out unauthorised foreigners working in local business entities. The NBR suspects that a significant amount on account of income tax is being evaded for years by foreigners working illegally in the country. A taskforce has reportedly been formed to carry out the inspection on some randomly selected factories or business premises in the capital in order to collect details of foreign employees and their legal and tax payment status. Beside bringing to book tax evading foreigners, the drive also aims at penalising the employers for recruiting unauthorised foreigners. According to the income tax law, an employer will face a penalty as much as 50 per cent of his or her total payable tax or taka half a million for employing even a single foreign national without work permit from the competent authorities. The NBR is also competent to scrap tax benefits including tax holiday facility for the export-oriented companies, if found guilty of conniving with the foreign workers in tax evasion.

It is clear enough that the NBR is concerned more about the taxes it is losing for years. But when it comes to unauthorised employment not only in typical business entities but also in a host of other areas, including healthcare services and educational institutions, the onus is obviously on the immigration authorities and relevant law enforcers to see to it that no foreigner is employed without valid work permit.

There should have been a data base of foreigners legally working in the country. This, on the one hand, would have facilitated the NBR to remain apprised of their tax payment status, and on the other, ensured their legal stay in the country. It appears that no such functional database exists. Records of work permit are of course available with the Bangladesh Investment Development Authority (BIDA), but these are perhaps not meant for policing.

There is thus the need to move in a coordinated manner. The relevant agencies should team up in an effective way so that they don't run out of required information on foreigners working in the country as well as those being employed in violation of law. Having said this, there is more to the issue that need immediate attention. Quite often we come upon reports of grave financial frauds, and in most cases these are orchestrated by foreigners legally or illegally living in the country with serious criminal track record, collaborated by their local aides. These acts range from making counterfeit currency notes to manipulating ATM money withdrawal system to cheating of all conceivable methods and techniques. A good number of such elements might be hiding under cover of employment.

As for legal employment, isn't it necessary that the authorities check whether the type of job for which a foreigner has been sponsored/employed by a local company is one for which services of an expatriate is absolutely necessary? If the relevant authorities are alert, chances are high that many work permit applications will fail to address this important issue.

http://www.thefinancialexpress-bd.com/2017/08/08/79310/Unauthorised-foreign-workers
 
These illegal indians are source of close to $5 billion dollars remittance to india. Courtesy of Awami league. If Garments export is $30 billion, ruling awami league regime arranged indians to steal $5 billion illegally.
 
These illegal indians are source of close to $5 billion dollars remittance to india.
Rizq is given by Allah. A banda has to work hard to earn his living. Indians are working hard in places where trained BD people are not available, and they are earning their living given by the Almighty Allah. Why do you want to kick at the stomach of some hard working people? Are you a Muslim by heart or by ritual only?
 
Rizq is given by Allah. A banda has to work hard to earn his living. Indians are working hard in places where trained BD people are not available, and they are earning their living given by the Almighty Allah. Why do you want to kick at the stomach of some hard working people? Are you a Muslim by heart or by ritual only?

an indian slave acting as vondo pir (fraud preacher), that suites you well. Just like your political god mother Hasina.

indians stealing jobs from locals - did indians follow religious preaching you want to shelter them behind?
indian did not and does not obey Bangladesh rule and pay any taxes - do you and your god mother preach religious teaching with indians?

These questions expose you as a born awami fraudster.
 
Last edited:
indians stealing jobs from locals

Indians and Sri Lankans are not stealing jobs from the locals. You Mullah guys preach BD people to remain uneducated. As a result, these young guys go to another Mullah country, Saudi Arabia, to work on watering the date trees. The experienced foreigners are employed in those places where the uneducated locals are not employable. BD should get rid of Jamaatis and ritual-loving Mullahs like you who even oppose now the Allah's dictation on the rizq.
 
Last edited:
I thought doctoring titles are not allowed in this forum...... But it's a Indian bashing thread... and OP' s intention is very clear....
 
who even oppose now the Allah's dictation on the rizq.

Here is a sample of fake awami Muslims like yourself, who pray to statue and then make farcical statement about Islam and Allah.

upload_2017-8-9_19-44-49.jpeg
 
Dhaka has a question: what about the illegal Indian immigrants in Bangladesh?
The Bangladeshi government estimates there are 500,000 Indians working in the country.
fd3bc245-5024-46ba-b07a-1e1e3ab3a2e3.jpg

STR/AFP
May 16, 2014 · 06:55 am
Syeda Samira Sadeque
Dhaka has not forgotten Felani Khatun. On January 7, 2011, the 15-year-old girl was shot dead by India's Border Security Force on the India-Bangladesh border in Cooch Behar, West Bengal. She was attempting to return to Bangladesh with her father by illegally crossing the fence. Her clothes had got entangled in the barbed wires. She screamed for help, but got bullets instead.

Felani Khatun's body was left in the open for hours as an example for others with the same idea. Photographs of the outrageous incident made it to the international media and India was forced to set up an inquiry. An internal tribunal of the Border Security Force found constable Amiya Ghosh not guilty. The BSF ordered a retrial.

Felani was one of the many Bangladeshi immigrants who had gone to India with hopes of a better standard of living. She was one of the estimated 1,000 Bangladeshis who have been killed by India’s BSF over the decade.

Bangladeshis understand that India shouldn't allow illegal immigrants from Bangladesh, in a way that no country allows illegal immigration. They accept that India should deport illegal immigrants when it finds them. But they are unable to understand the brutality shown to Khatun. Sadly, hers is not an isolated case. Indiscriminate killing and abuse at the hands of the BSF is rampant at the border.

It is in this light that Narendra Modi's comments about "illegal Bangladeshi immigrants" are being seen in Dhaka. Along with Modi, his fellow Bharatiya Janata Party leader Subramanian Swamy's comments about Bangladeshi migrants have also caused alarm.

The barbed-wire fence Felani Khatun was killed at, is a 2,880-km stretch across India’s border with Bangladesh, built by the Atal Bihari Vajpayee government in the early 2000s. Many Bangladeshis tend to illegally cross the border for a variety of reasons – reasons ranging from the cattle trade to simply looking for better work conditions.

While Bangladeshis acknowledge that neither illegal immigration nor unauthorized cattle trading is justified, they fail to grasp the point of killing these immigrants on the border. Felani Khatun's killing has become a symbol of Bangladesh's loss of trust in India's commitment to justice. The comments of Modi and Subramanian Swamy, one a veteran BJP leader, the other a former cabinet minister, about deporting infiltrators have only added salt to this wound.

On April 18, Swamy had claimed that “one-third of Bangladesh’s population” lives illegally in India, and demanded that Bangladesh should compensate for this by giving India one-third of its land. A few days later, Modi warned that come May 16, illegal Bangladeshis should be packing their bags to be sent back.

Few Indians realise that there are illegal and legal Indian immigrants in Bangladesh too – that is inevitable when you share a border as difficult as the India-Bangladesh one. India's longest border is not with China or Pakistan but with Bangladesh, and right from 1947 it has been a difficult line to seal off. There are too many people whose lives and livelihoods are scattered on both sides. The Bangladeshi government estimates there are 500,000 Indians working in the country.

When it comes to remittances from other countries to India, Bangladesh ranks fifth on the list, according to Silicon India. That $3.7 million a year comes from Indians working in non-profit organisations, the garment and textiles industries.

Yet, the Indians in Bangladesh are not a matter of election speeches here. It is a valid concern if there are Indians who worry about illegal immigrants being a drain on India’s income and resources. But Subramanian Swamy said that allowing these “infiltrators” to live in India would threaten India's secularism. Narendra Modi and his party's manifesto have said that India would be a home for Hindus from other countries. “Where will they go? India is the only place for them. We will have to accommodate them here,” Modi has asked.

India, as any independent nation, has the right to deny “illegal immigrants” from anywhere, Bangladesh or Bhutan. But it is clear that the issue here is less illegal immigrants and more the religion they practice. It seems that the bigger threat to India's secularism is not the Bangladeshi migrants, but Narendra Modi.

The BJP's rhetoric is bad news for those who champion secularism in Bangladesh. An editorial in New Age, a daily newspaper, read: “What the Indian political establishments do not realise is that such election-time political rhetoric by people like Subramanian could give rise to communalistic reaction on this side of the border. If it so happens, and especially given the general displeasure of the Muslim population in India, such sentiment could even spread in some Indian areas bordering Bangladesh like wildfire.”

There have already been attacks reported on the Hindu community since these comments were made. While attacks on temples, looting of houses, vandalism and arson on Hindu property are sadly not rare, it is now feared that there may be a further backlash from the Islamists against the Hindu minority.

Academics and intellectuals have also expressed concern regarding the future of India-Bangladesh relations. The Dhaka Tribune said in an editorial: “To raise valid concerns about illegal immigrants is one thing. To threaten purge-type policies is quite another, and ill befits the putative leader of the world’s largest democracy.”

Mahbub Hassan Saleh, deputy high commissioner of Bangladesh in New Delhi, has reportedly said he does not worry about Modi coming to power. Yet the country's commerce minister, Tofail Ahmed, has indicated that the “illegal immigrants" row may put a strain on India-Bangladesh ties. The future does not look promising.

(Syeda Samira Sadeque is a journalist with the Dhaka Tribune in Dhaka, Bangladesh.)

https://scroll.in/article/664305/dh...t-the-illegal-indian-immigrants-in-bangladesh
 
Indians are basically a group of mean minded and miser type of people. They do not believe in rizq given by Allah. This is why they cry out all the time like Chotolok people. We do not have to become as mean as the Indians. Let some of them work in our factories and send their earnings to their families in India who like others need money. They are contributing to our production of textile, which we export and earn our living.

I have not met any Indian when I visited a Mawa factory, but I met a Pakistani asstt. manager. The factory was happy with his contribution. I think, same is true also for Sri Lankans and Indians. Our garments industry depends upon them for mid level management. We do not have to be as small-minded as the world famous Indians.
 
From what I see here in Chittagong, it's true, the number of indian workers migrating to Bangladesh is growing and they are in millions now. Most of them are laboring for the garments industry while some have taken other menial jobs. I have no problem if these poor people are earning their bread here but I think they should at least take care of their smell to keep the environment fit. You can identify an indian standing a mile away just by their notorious smell.
 
Last edited:
I have no problem if these poor people are earning their bread here but I think they should at least take care of their smell to keep the environment fit. You can identify an indian standing a mile away just by their notorious smell.
It must be horrible for the locals to live near the smelly Indians. I hope, they do not just defecate here and there as they do in their home country.
 
A colleague of my father is from India works as a production manager. He left India(Lucknow) in the late 80's after his father's death as he didn't get along with his brothers. A nice gent. Now married and settled in BD. I'm not sure what's the hate if they contribute to our economy. Indians can blabber as much as they want about Bangladeshis living there but we don't have to do the same.
 
an indian slave acting as vondo pir (fraud preacher), that suites you well. Just like your political god mother Hasina.

People like you and Begum Hasina believe in ritualized activities. People like me believe more in the essence. By definition, you are the one who is an Indian slave because you do not protest when they insult BD. On the contrary, you demean BD existence. You must be a false flagger Indian.
 
you are the one who is an Indian slave because you do not protest when they insult BD. On the contrary, you demean BD existence. You must be a false flagger Indian.
I also noticed, he never protest or say anything against any Indian insult or foul word.But he engaged in a full force to disprove anything positive coming out from Bangladesh.Even things which can't be not related in anyways as AL's achievement.
 
It must be horrible for the locals to live near the smelly Indians. I hope, they do not just defecate here and there as they do in their home country.

Surprisingly, these illegal Indians don't really open defecate here, I guess the companies hiring them have ensured proper training with regards to the cultural differences between Bangladesh and India. However, we must be careful since as the number of illegal Indians grow, they will try to bring their native culture to Bangladesh and start open-defecating everywhere. This is why I guess the entry of illegal Indians must be checked while the legal ones are welcome.
 
Back
Top Bottom