Yeap,there is no Qing dynasty anymore,but you should know,the history of Qing dynasty is somgthing special to us,for a person have the ancestors fought and died for this dynasty,this feeling is natural.I have no problem for someone criticize the Qing dynasty,however many of those ultra-nationalists seem only can insult Qing dynasty,think the Qing dynasty only brought bad things to China,I can't accept those
we just want revival han chinese traditional costume, not against Manchu, no need worry about that.
This is hard to answer,the Manchurian language die out is a long history,after 1644,the emperors brought Manchus into Chinese proper everywhere,the Manchus lived with the Han Chinese,and were fewer in numbers than Han Chinese,so many Manchus lost their languages in middle Qing period(the Yongzheng and Qianlong era),to the end of Qing dynasty,the Manchurian speakers are already very few,most of the Manchus just speak the Chinese
You worry too much。 I likeHanfu. But I never anti Manchus. I even oppose the anti-Manchu people. The vast majority of love Hanfu people are not deliberately anti manchus.a little people just send some complaints.国内汉服吧几十万会员，你可以看一下，可有人整天盯着骂满人吗，没有。!最多是有个别人发发牢骚，我觉得这没啥大不了的。所以你多虑了。也许网上有部分人骂满人，我觉得都是些无聊之人，键盘斗士，不乏有别有用心之人，或者是从没接触过满人的人，这其中某些南方地区的某些人较多。现代满汉根本没啥区别，如果真有反满的真的是脑残。而且，现实中生活中，满汉没任何冲突
I already suspected most Chinese here are minorities. Very interesting why they are so disproportionately active here. They are very sensitive special snowflakes that we ordinary people have to cautiously take care of. In case we hurt their ultra delicate ethnic pride we will be called chauvinist. It's ok to trash talk about Han Chinese because the government's governing authority is not from people so majority number doesn't matter such as in a democracy and Han Chinese will less likely demand independence etc while those minorities will, therefore the Chinese government has no worry about Han Chinese but constantly shower favorable policies on minorities in order to appease them. Pretty simple mindset and logic and reminds me of Russians during soviet era.
Every ethnic group has its own tradition, since when wearing Hanfu is anti Manchu? Manchus have their clothing, Uygurs also keep their ethnic heritage as well. According to you, Hans can't even wear their own clothes? Wearing a fking clothes means utral nationalists? You Chinese traitor, get the hell out of here.
@Okemos What do you think?
You can be proud of your ancestors invading China and establishing Qing dynasty but as a normal person whose ancestors were being invaded I'm not so proud. You can have your natural feelings, but would you allow me to have natural feelings too and love our ethnic clothing? You get the picture? I also don't like me or my kids being invaded. I live in the U.S. but that doesn't mean I have to embrace every ethnic on this damn planet as my so called brothers and sisters even though I don't hate anybody. I prefer hanging with other Chinese but that doesn't mean I'm anti Mexicans lol, did I appease you, my dear snowflake?
You can be proud your ancestors fought against Manchu invaders,it's their duty in later Ming-early Qing period to fought againjst Manchus,I'm nothing against it,but the Manchus conquered Hans just like Hans conquered southern minorities,the southern minorities invaded Hans?No,but they were still conquered by Han Chinese,those happed in anciet,not in modern world,so those are normal things.But then again the Qing dynasty became a Chinese dynasty later and the Manchus fought for China,to against the Jungars,the Russians,the Gurkhas,the Burmese and so on,and the bandhits of Chinese proper,many Han Chinese also took part in those actions and part of Imperial Qing army
When has han chinese been bullying southern minorities?
As I said before,those things happened in anciet,we can't use modern values to blame them
