What's new

This is why we can't defeat Taliban

.
.
You need to observe and feel the situation on the ground.... a lot has changed in the last two decades......... most Deobandi's have been radicalized to the core.......... for what once was sole domain of Salafi's, now Deobandis are also key players...... and I'm not talking about baking cakes..........

I am also a Deobandi, what problem have I caused? We use the terms 'Wahabi/Salafi' and 'Deobandi' interchangeably and that is not correct. The element of extremism that we see today has more to do with the Wahabi/Salafi beliefs.
 
. .
You need to observe and feel the situation on the ground.... a lot has changed in the last two decades......... most Deobandi's have been radicalized to the core.......... for what once was sole domain of Salafi's, now Deobandis are also key players...... and I'm not talking about baking cakes..........
....be safe Hypey!

and thank u for always being soft on me!tc
 
.
Deobandis in Pakistan are the root cause of all problems..........
Even dengue and polio? Damn, must be some fine evil magic they've got.
I am also a Deobandi, what problem have I caused? We use the terms 'Wahabi/Salafi' and 'Deobandi' interchangeably and that is not correct. The element of extremism that we see today has more to do with the Wahabi/Salafi beliefs.
I am a ghari-muqallid 'Salafi', I haven't caused any problems either. But yes, the Salafi methodology does unfortunately allow for easier twisting of the religion since it gives more freedom for interpretation. The ideology we call 'Wahabi' is an example of some of this twisting.

Regardless, sectarianism has destroyed us and will continue to do so, Taliban or no Taliban. By blaming one sect for all problems in such blanket statements, we're not doing anyone any good.
 
.
seriously man , Taliban a gaye ....

and i agree with @Jaanbaz failure of Pakistani society , still confused what they want ..

We know who is supporting Taliban, we know which mosques and religious schools are hiding weapons in their basements. We know which certain moulanas curse Pakistan and praise Taliban. Yet we still stay silent.
 
.
Even dengue and polio? Damn, must be some fine evil magic they've got.

I am a ghari-muqallid 'Salafi', I haven't caused any problems either. But yes, the Salafi methodology does unfortunately allow for easier twisting of the religion since it gives more freedom for interpretation. The ideology we call 'Wahabi' is an example of some of this twisting.

Regardless, sectarianism has destroyed us and will continue to do so, Taliban or no Taliban. By blaming one sect for all problems in such blanket statements, we're not doing anyone any good.

I don't understand. Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) knew each and every hypocrite living in Madina yet he didn't apply any takfir on them or that on People of Makkah after the conquering it. . Then why Deobandi or Wahabis does that ? @Zarvan
 
.
I don't understand. Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) knew each and every hypocrite living in Madina yet he didn't apply any takfir on them or that on People of Makkah after the conquering it. . Then why Deobandi or Wahabi does that ? @Zarvan
Those who do all that (fatwa of takfeer etc) are no practicing Muslims (Deboandi, Wahabi are just School of thoughts) in real sense but political mullah. We cant expect nothing from those who don't follow the teachings of their own Prophet (PBUH), who, as you have very correctly pointed out, never awarded the certificates of takfeer to the munafiqeen.
 
.
We know who is supporting Taliban, we know which mosques and religious schools are hiding weapons in their basements. We know which certain moulanas curse Pakistan and praise Taliban. Yet we still stay silent.

yeah bro , our Govt and Law enforcement agencies know everything ... its just they might be afraid of strong public reaction like Lal masjid ... and also dont forget we are hypocrites , first we want govt to take action against these lunatics , than later we criticize Govt for that .. lal masjid operation was example
 
.
I don't understand. Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) knew each and every hypocrite living in Madina yet he didn't apply any takfir on them or that on People of Makkah after the conquering it. . Then why Deobandi or Wahabis does that ? @Zarvan
There is nothing in the Salafi and Deobandi ideologies themselves that allow them to do Takfir. Some people corrupt them to justify and facilitate their own abuse of religion. As for why they do it, ask them, I don't do it and neither do I agree with it.

@syedali73 has explained it precisely. Takfir is indeed a very powerful political tool used by political mullahs.. Some of the ideas that lead to this problem may have once been legitimate religious misunderstandings, but at this point they're almost exclusively used for political ends.

It's beyond a misunderstanding or misinterpretation now, it's intentional manipulation.
 
.
Those who think they can counter Taliban narrative without implementing shariah are living in fools paradise
 
. . .
Those who think they can counter Taliban narrative without implementing shariah are living in fools paradise
''Sharia''
Those who think what the Taliban want is ''Sharia'' are fools themselves.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom