What's new

This 8,000-Year-Old Rock Art in Saudi Arabia Is The Earliest Depiction of Domesticated Dogs

Saif al-Arab

BANNED
Joined
Mar 26, 2015
Messages
8,873
Reaction score
5
Country
Saudi Arabia
Location
Spain
rock-art-dogs-leasher-header_1024.jpg

(Guagnin et al., J. Anthropol. Archaeol, 2017)
This 8,000-Year-Old Rock Art Is The Earliest Depiction of Domesticated Dogs

Who's a good ancient boy?

MICHELLE STARR
17 NOV 2017
Dogs have been our best friends for a very long time, and now we have the earliest ever pictorial evidence of that bond.

Prehistoric rock art found in Saudi Arabia shows humans hunting with dogs on leashes - and it looks like those pictures could be at least 8,000 years old, making them the earliest art depicting dogs.

If the dating turns out to be accurate, it would also beat Iranian pottery painted with dogs from just under 8,000 years ago.

We have evidence of dog domestication that stretches back for millennia. Fossils that are over 30,000 years old show a breed of canid that differed from wolves, more closely resembling dogs.

The earliest strong evidence for domestication to date is the remains of a dog found buried with two humans, dating back 14,700 years, in Germany.

Fossil records are one thing, but there is a lot they can't tell us - such as how humans interacted with their canine companions.

This is where the rock paintings come in, found at two sites in Saudi Arabia, Shuwaymis and Jubbah. Max Planck Institute for the Science of Human History archaeologist Maria Guagnin has been helping catalogue over 1,400 rock art panels from the two sites, between them depicting over 7,000 humans and animals.

In among the cattle and often obscured by later pastoral carvings, Guagnin discovered at least 349 dogs - 156 in Shuwaymis and 193 in Jubbah.

rock-art-dogs-hunting-equid.jpg
A human and a pack of dogs hunting an equid and its young. (Guagnin et al., J. Anthropol. Archaeol, 2017)

"When Maria came to me with the rock art photos and asked me if they meant anything, I about lost my mind," co-author Angela Perri, a zooarchaeologist at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology, told Science.

"A million bones won't tell me what these images are telling me. It's the closest thing you're going to get to a YouTube video."

Around 10,000 years ago, the two regions were much more hospitable, and humans began to settle there, perhaps after leaving them for a period during which they were too arid to be habitable.

However, transitioning from hunting-based subsistence to farming and raising cattle wouldn't occur until sometime between 6800 BC and 6200 BC - around 7,000 to 8,000 years ago, based on bones found in the region.

The carvings of dogs probably appeared prior to this time - based on the later pastoral carvings and the weathering of the rock.

"The dog art is at least 8,000 to 9,000 years old," Guagnin said.

During the interval of hunting for subsistence, it seems the human settlers hunted with their dogs. The dogs are shown with lines carved connecting them to the hunters - which could be either leashes, or a metaphor for the bond between man and beast.

The dogs are also depicted assisting in the hunt. Three dogs are shown biting the necks and the belly of ibex, as well as the necks of gazelles. Another scene shows dogs surrounding an equid and its young, setting on the younger animal and biting its neck.

Different landscapes also suggest different hunting strategies. The Shuwaymis art shows larger packs, better to drive game into the narrow traps afforded by the sandstone escarpments. The Jubbah art shows smaller packs, better suited to ambushing prey at watering holes.


Meanwhile, the accompanying humans are shown bearing weapons that look like bows and spears.

rock-art-dogs-canaan.jpg
(Guagnin et al., J. Anthropol. Archaeol, 2017)

The dogs are curly-tailed, medium-sized, with pricked ears, short snouts and a deeply angled chest. They resemble, the researchers said, the modern Canaan breed of dog.

These mostly feral dogs are a basal breed, and have lived in the Middle East for thousands of years, although it is unknown whether they originated there or elsewhere.

What's even more awesome is that all of the dogs have individual traits. Some are drawn with spots on their coats, or white patches on the head or chest. Some are clearly male, and all have different tail positions, stances, and coat colourations.

This could mean that the artists carving the dogs were merely trying to depict a broad dog population - but it could also mean that the dogs were specific, individual dogs known to the artists, and special to them.

The carvings tell us a lot about how the humans controlled and hunted with their dogs, as well as about the dogs themselves - their coats and behaviour. Now, they say, more research will be required to search the area for domestic dog remains from the time period.

The research has been published in the Journal of Anthropological Archaeology.

https://www.sciencealert.com/1000-y...abia-earliest-depiction-domestic-dogs-hunting


Cool. Not long ago the Arabian sand cat was proven to be the ancestor of the domesticated cat as well.

DNA Study Reveals Tale of Cat Domestication

Monday, June 19, 2017

DNA-cat-domestication.jpeg

(© Hierakonopolis Expedition)


LEUVEN, BELGIUM—Cat domestication is thought to be linked to the beginning of agriculture, when early farmers first stored rodent-attracting grains. According to a report in Seeker, a team led by Claudio Ottoni of the University of Leuven analyzed the DNA of 200 domestic cats who lived over a period spanning 9,000 years in the Near East, Egypt, Europe, north and east Africa, and southwest Asia. The study suggests that all domesticated cats descend from the African wildcat Felis silvestris, and were first tamed in the Near East some 10,000 years ago. The animals traveled with migrating farmers to Europe, and later spread out from Egypt on rodent-infested trade ships. Ottoni explained, however, that it is unclear whether the Egyptian domesticated cat descended from domesticated cats imported from the Near East, or whether a second, separate, domestication took place in Egypt. Most house cats alive today descend from cats that can be traced back to Turkey, Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, Israel, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, and Egypt. The DNA analysis also revealed that the blotched coat pattern did not become common in cats until the medieval period. Until then, most cats were striped. For more on felines in the archaeological record, go to “Baby Bobcat.”

http://www.archaeology.org/news/5668-170619-dna-cat-domestication

My favorite cat is the Arabian sand cat.



nationalgeographic_2175144-800x533.jpg


Hunting with Saluki dogs in the desert;


Race in UAE (the title of the video is wrong);


They are great hunting dogs and I wonder if those ancient dogs depicted are the ancestors of Salukis? Most likely.
 
. . .
Those aren't 8000 year old.

There's no method available accurate enough to date anything. It's guess work and assumptions.

Intriguing though how life flourished when Arabia was a green jungle not barren desert.
 
.
How was the ecology and environment of the Gulf back then? Was it a desert as it is today?

There is no geographical or historical region called "the Gulf". It's called the Arabian Peninsula and much of the Arabian Peninsula is mountainous and the fertile areas of Arabia are larger than many/most countries of the world. In fact the forrest cover of Arabia is bigger than that of Pakistan for instance. There are even tropical areas of Arabia and we have our own monsoon season that impacts Southern KSA, parts of Yemen and Southern Oman for instance called khareef.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khareef

Topographic map of Arabia:



The only true desert in Arabia is the mighty and beautiful Rub al-Khali (home to the largest sand dunes in the world) but even there you can find lakes in the middle of nowhere.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rub'_al_Khali




Not many millennia ago Arabia was home to one of the largest lakes and highest number of rivers in the world.

Hence why there are 10.000's of wadis (non-permanent) rivers in Arabia to this very day.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wadi

Arabia is the second oldest inhabited place in the world after Horn of Africa/East Africa and played a key role in human history.







Less arid weather and more greenery is just a question of time as per the climatic history of Arabia and the world.

Read this excellent but long article if you want to know more;

http://www.ecoseeds.com/cool.html

Those aren't 8000 year old.

There's no method available accurate enough to date anything. It's guess work and assumptions.

Intriguing though how life flourished when Arabia was a green jungle not barren desert.

Wrong and wrong again.

Yes, you can. Did you read the article?

Areas the size of Pakistan in Arabia are fertile. Educate yourself. How do you think that 80 million people (and quickly growing) can be sustained otherwise? Arabia is not Sahara, Siberia or the Antarctic.

Do you realize that every crop grows/can grow in KSA from bananas to top class olives? Coffee and tea too. What is lacking is better planning, less wastefulness and not enough of trees being replanted since millions of trees have been cut in Arabia since time immortal and this even continues to this day. Combating desertification is possible in the region and Israel has proved it for instance and China is doing it as well. We don't need to or want to turn into a jungle but desertification can be combated successfully and I am sure that future technology will ensure this or large-scale water desalination which KSA is leading in the region at.

Thank God we don't lack space (KSA is the 12th largest country on the planet), sunshine or sea access. Nor do we have a giant uncontrollable population.
 
Last edited:
. .
I am trying.

But you didn't understand what I wrote so I can't blame you for your crude reply.

Giving you a well-meant advice to your inaccurate one-liners is not being crude in my worldview. However if I hurt you somehow I will apologize to you.

Did you know that excellent mangos grow in KSA as well?

There was even a mango festival not long ago.

Some of the 40 different varieties of mango grown in Jazan province:

29oikhj.jpg


C-avnJyXYAIF2MD.jpg:large



C-avnJzWsAAz3cs.jpg:large


C-avnJ0XgAE25pD.jpg:large


5900c88f2c63c.jpg


C-chi4AXcAEfJZx.jpg:large






000-9906754551493554892561.jpg


It's amazing what this ancient and beautiful desert called Arabia has given us.

BTW how were ancient World UNESCO Heritage Sites in the Arab world such as Mada'in Saleh in KSA, Petra in Jordan, the Pyramids in Egypt and Babylon etc. in Iraq to mention a few dated?
 
. .
Giving you a well-meant advice to your inaccurate one-liners is not being crude in my worldview. However if I hurt you somehow I will apologize to you.

Did you know that excellent mangos grow in KSA as well?

There was even a mango festival not long ago.

Some of the 40 different varieties of mango grown in Jazan province:

29oikhj.jpg


C-avnJyXYAIF2MD.jpg:large



C-avnJzWsAAz3cs.jpg:large


C-avnJ0XgAE25pD.jpg:large


5900c88f2c63c.jpg


C-chi4AXcAEfJZx.jpg:large






000-9906754551493554892561.jpg


It's amazing what this ancient and beautiful desert has given us.

I know that Arabia is fertile. No one is denying that.

I am talking about ancient rivers specially those running east from Bahrain. The last polar shift when that happened gave rise to Arabia being almost barren.

As far as climate change is concerned Saudi Arabia is smartly placed but you guys should try your hand at modern smarter agriculture.

As far as archeology is concerned. Saudi Arabia is like a dark continent in itself because of strict regulations.

And you should atleast study that carbon dating is unreliable.

BTW how were ancient World UNESCO Heritage Sites in the Arab world such as Mada'in Saleh in KSA, Petra in Jordan, the Pyramids in Egypt and Babylon etc. in Iraq to mention a few dated?

They use whatever modern technique is available to them.

You can use carbon dating. Or study sediments by drilling.

But all of this is biblical witch hunt.

Tell me something. You come from an oral society. In your folk songs. What is the oldest story available? Like any mention of time period.
 
. .
I know that Arabia is fertile. No one is denying that.

I am talking about ancient rivers specially those running east from Bahrain. The last polar shift when that happened gave rise to Arabia being almost barren.

As far as climate change is concerned Saudi Arabia is smartly placed but you guys should try your hand at modern smarter agriculture.

As far as archeology is concerned. Saudi Arabia is like a dark continent in itself because of strict regulations.

And you should atleast study that carbon dating is unreliable.



They use whatever modern technique is available to them.

You can use carbon dating. Or study sediments by drilling.

But all of this is biblical witch hunt.

Tell me something. You come from an oral society. In your folk songs. What is the oldest story available? Like any mention of time period.

I must have misunderstood your post then or your usual unique jargon on PDF.

Yes, Arabia was home to some of the largest lakes in the world not many millennia ago (Arabia is still home to substantial lakes - KSA is a good example) and one of the largest river systems (see post 5) but climate change (ever-changing) changed that. Not only in Arabia but in much of the Middle East. What "saved" Pakistan for instance (as far as I am aware of Pakistan is mostly arid too and has challenges with increasing desertification as well) was being located in the foothills of the western Himalayas. KSA/most countries in the Middle East from Iran to Morocco do not have such a luxury.

Yes, changes are needed and it is a work in progress. I suggest reading this article below. It is really informative and also relevant for Pakistan.

http://www.ecoseeds.com/cool.html

Actually this is changing and KSA is highlighting Arabia's crucial and long-standing role in human history.

Check this thread below;

https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/one-...nt-tombs-discovered-in-ksa-from-space.443566/

There has been numerous excavations of ancient sites and pre-historical sites in KSA in the past months alone.

Highlighted in international media worldwide.

A Close-Up on Mysteries Made of Stone in Saudi Arabia’s Desert

Structures that may have been created by ancient tribes could only be studied using Google Earth. Saudi officials finally invited an archaeologist to observe them via helicopter.

By Nicholas St. Fleur

Nov. 17, 2017
Image
18GATES1-articleLarge.jpg

A group of 19 "keyholes" at Al Wadi, in the Saudi Arabian desert, observed by archaeologist David Kennedy from a helicopter. Dr. Kennedy took more than 6,000 aerial photographs of these mysterious, ancient structures.CreditDavid Kennedy
For nearly a decade, David Kennedy marveled from behind his computer screen at thousands of mysterious stone structures scattered across Saudi Arabia’s desert. With Google Earth’s satellite imagery at his fingertips, the archaeologist peeked at burial sites and other so-called Works of the Old Men, created by nomadic tribes thousands of years ago.

But he was unable to secure permission to visit the country to observe up close the ancient designs that he and amateur archaeologists had studied from their desktops.

Last month, after announcing he had identified nearly 400 stone “gates,” Dr. Kennedy received the invitation of a lifetime from Saudi officials to investigate the hidden structures from a helicopter.

“They are absolutely astonishing,” said Dr. Kennedy, who recently retired from the University of Western Australia. “From 500 feet, you can see the vital details of structures that are invisible in the fuzzy image on Google Earth.”

ADVERTISEMENT


Over the course of three days, he snapped more than 6,000 aerial photographs, lifting the veil on the ancient wonders.

Image
merlin_130226864_d5c98bf1-11f4-4277-b95f-d21013bedefe-articleLarge.jpg

"Gates" at Samhah, which are more than 1,200 feet long.CreditDavid Kennedy
Since 1997, Dr. Kennedy has studied similar structures in neighboring Jordan from the ground and sky. Many of the stone figures in both countries are in basalt fields known as harrats. The fields often feature dried up lava streams that twist and turn like slithering snakes across the dark landscape.


You have 9 free articles remaining.

Subscribe to The Times

In Saudi Arabia, he explored 200 sites from the air across the regions of Harrat Khaybar and Harrat Uwayrid. The structures he observed ranged in shapes and sizes, which he describes as gates, kites, triangles, bull’s eyes and keyholes.

Of the 400 structures he describes as “gates” that he had identified on Google Earth, Dr. Kennedy studied about 40 from the helicopter and found that the structures were not randomly put together.

Image
merlin_130226906_0556ba6b-fefe-4aec-8a9f-a8bf82676a33-articleLarge.jpg

Gates with a "bull's eye." CreditDavid Kennedy
“We could see immediately they were much more complicated than they appeared on Google Earth,” Dr. Kennedy said. They were not simply heaps of stone.

Rather, each long bar was actually made up of two parallel lines of flat slabs placed on their edges facing each other with small stones filling the space in between.

“They are much more sophisticated than I was prepared for,” he said.

Some gates were larger than 1,000 feet long and 250 feet wide. He suspected the oldest may be about 9,000 years old. Though he is not sure of their purpose, he speculated they may have been used for farming purposes.

Image
merlin_130226873_5838eb72-f3c8-493c-b151-a5d46e6a4beb-articleLarge.jpg

A "kite" structure in the Harrat Khaybar region.CreditDavid Kennedy
Dr. Kennedy also got a closer look at about a dozen of the “kites” that were first discovered in the Middle East by pilots in the 1920s. These are the most famous of the Works of the Old Men, and Dr. Kennedy has identified more than 900 of them in Saudi Arabia’s Harrat Khaybar.

ADVERTISEMENT

From above, they typically resemble kites with strings and tails. They are often very large, with many stretching more than a quarter-mile. Archaeologists think gazelle were corralled into the head of the kite, where the hunters would come out to kill them. Sometimes multiple kites would overlap, so that if the animals got past one funnel they would get caught in another.

“Essentially there was no escape,” said Dr. Kennedy.

The ones in Saudi Arabia looked as if they were better built than the ones in Jordan, according to Dr. Kennedy.

Image
18GATES5-articleLarge.jpg

Left, Dr. Kennedy's helicopter casting a shadow near a bullseye. Right, a Khaybar kite.CreditDavid Kennedy
The harrats were littered with the smaller structures he has named keyholes, wheels, triangles and bull’s-eyes.

Dr. Kennedy said he was surprised at how straight the lines of the triangles and keyholes were, as if the people who made them had picked out specific flat stones rather than random rocks.

Each triangle was isosceles and looked like it was pointing at something. Sometimes they were directed to a bull’s-eye that was about 15 feet or 150 feet away.

There were also several keyhole structures, sometimes lined up together. The heads of the keyholes were almost always near-perfect circles, and the walls were about three feet high.

These structures may have served some funerary or symbolic purpose. Dr. Kennedy did not date any of the structures he visited with radiocarbon testing, but he said that future groups should perform more thorough analysis.

“It’s absolutely vital that somebody follows up with serious groundwork,” he said.

Image
merlin_130226909_215229de-a571-4719-872e-8515edf6d1b4-articleLarge.jpg

Keyhole pendants.CreditDavid Kennedy
Dr. Kennedy was invited by Amr AlMadani, the chief executive officer of the Royal Commission for Al-Ula Province, which was created to safeguard some of the country’s geological, historical and archaeological sites.

ADVERTISEMENT


“Dr. Kennedy has spent many years poring over Google Earth images, and we were able to get him much closer to the sites,” said Mr. AlMadani, who joined Dr. Kennedy in the helicopter and described the experience as exciting.

“Thinking about how life was in the Arabian Peninsula and trying to imagine the way people hunted, lived and buried the dead was very much enriching,” he wrote in an email.

Image
18GATES7-articleLarge.jpg

A bull's eye and triangle formation at Samhah as it's seen from Google Earth, left, and photographed by Dr. Kennedy.CreditLeft, Google Earth; Right, David Kennedy
“Seeing it on Google images is one thing, but seeing it from a helicopter window from 300 feet is a totally different thing,” said Don Boyer, who accompanied Dr. Kennedy.

At the age of 70, Mr. Boyer is completing his doctorate in geoarchaeology and hydrology. “I think I was on a high the whole time. It was just remarkable. You run out of adjectives.”

Image
merlin_130226903_46e7e60a-fe4b-458c-9c9b-c10d0bfa0c6d-articleLarge.jpg

A gate overlain with a bullseye pendant, surrounded by lava rock.CreditDavid Kennedy
Archaeologists not involved in the work called it a step forward in showing the rich and complicated prehistory of the Arabian Peninsula.

Huw Groucutt, an archaeologist at the University of Oxford, said the new images were very important, and that they can help show how human societies have modified the landscape.

“The challenge now is to conduct work on the ground,” he added.

Michael Petraglia, an archaeologist at the Max Planck Institute for the Science of Human History, agreed.

“What is so critical is to do ground survey and detailed excavation work. Otherwise, archaeological sites will often time seem mysterious and enigmatic,” he said in an email.

“Now the big and more difficult task is to document such structures on the ground to examine their function and to understand human life” in the region over time, he added.

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/17/science/saudi-arabia-gates.html

Aside from the discovery that this thread is about.

And the best thing is that this change is supported from the top of the society (rulers). So there are no excuses for cavemen in KSA who believe that history began 1400 years ago.

Well, the answer is found in the article my friend.

Not only oral. Don't forget that the alphabet and writing was invented in the Arab world. In fact the oldest alphabet in the world was found in Sinai (part of Arabia geographically and a part of Asia) which is next to KSA and whose native inhabitants are Semites and nowadays Sinai Bedouins mostly.

You know those peaceful people that terrorists targeted and killed over 300 of a few days ago.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proto-Sinaitic_script

Many aspects of our culture, poetry, clothing etc. date back millennia. As for oldest oral stories, it's impossible to tell in KSA/Arabia or anywhere in the Arab world/Middle East.

As for the oldest oral stories in the world, they are probably found in Africa among the San people our supposed ancestors.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_people
 
Last edited:
.
Interesting, it would greatly help in understanding evolution & migration of humans.
It seems a lot of prehistoric sites lie unexplored in Arabian peninsula. Hope more such discoveries are made and researched thoroughly to get better understanding of our mankinds past.
 
.
Interesting, it would greatly help in understanding evolution & migration of humans.
It seems a lot of prehistoric sites lie unexplored in Arabian peninsula. Hope more such discoveries are made and researched thoroughly to get better understanding of our mankinds past.

I am in complete agreement my friend.

Luckily KSA has stepped up heavily on this front (archaeology, preservation of historical sites) of late and I expect that to continue in the future. There has been tons of positive news about archaeology and newly discovered ancient and pre-historic sites in KSA just within the past 1 month let alone this year. The highly successful Roads of Arabia exhibition that has travelled across the world (US, Canada, Europe, China, South Korea, Japan etc) is also a great step in this regard. I expect MbS to continue this policy.

I hope to see similar policies in other Arab countries, Africa and the world as a whole. We have just discovered the tip of the iceberg IMO. Much more to see yet.

A recent aerial photography taken by a state-employed photographer. A new thing and shows how the government/people in power look at history. Pre-Islamic history is now not an "evil" for many people like it was for many decades. This created a generation of mostly ignorant people in terms of their own pre-Islamic culture and that of Arabs. Even I would say that this extended into Islamic history as well aside from the most major information.

 
.
I am in complete agreement my friend.

Luckily KSA has stepped up heavily on this front (archaeology, preservation of historical sites) of late and I expect that to continue in the future. There has been tons of positive news about archaeology and newly discovered ancient and pre-historic sites in KSA just within the past 1 month let alone this year. The highly successful Roads of Arabia exhibition that has travelled across the world (US, Canada, Europe, China, South Korea, Japan etc) is also a great step in this regard. I expect MbS to continue this policy.

I hope to see similar policies in other Arab countries, Africa and the world as a whole. We have just discovered the tip of the iceberg IMO. Much more to see yet.

A recent aerial photography taken by a state-employed photographer. A new thing and shows how the government/people in power look at history. Pre-Islamic history is now not an "evil" for many people like it was for many decades. This created a generation of mostly ignorant people in terms of their own pre-Islamic culture and that of Arabs. Even I would say that this extended into Islamic history as well aside from the most major information.

Thats great to know.
Given SA's location between egypt and iraq (mespotamia)(which are treasure trove of civilizational archaeology) there is certainly lot more to be discovered.

Its an irony that we are bedazzled by modern western buildings whereas our own ancient archaeological sites lie unappreciated. The above rock cut monument is awesome, to think ancient ppl could do these things with no modern machinery speaks volumes about their ability & imagination.
 
.
Looks so strange how the rock is carved up like cake clean slice thru
snG5MU2oqdVFzpEda3z8dHzOJwrUnFzK8ff6NAs23i4.jpg


This rock looks like it was underwater , only for water to recede , the surface left behind was just a slippery land , and rocks with curved surface.

People decided to carve up the rock as the temperature inside was cooler vs desert heat outside

The documentary claimed there are Salt water channels under the land , and these lie mere 10 meter below the surface land. The water is no drinkable but require cooling down and processing before it can be drank
 
.
Back
Top Bottom