What's new

There's no end in sight for China's Covid lockdowns. Here's what you need to know

Get Ya Wig Split

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Feb 22, 2017
Messages
2,585
Reaction score
-2
Country
United States
Location
United States

There's no end in sight for China's Covid lockdowns. Here's what you need to know​

1649272082655.png

Hong Kong (CNN)Millions of people across China's locked-down financial hub of Shanghai have been desperately seeking medical care and basic supplies like food. Parents have been forcibly separated from young children infected with Covid-19. And public anger is mounting, with no end in sight as China clamps down.
Since March, China has battled its biggest Covid wave yet, with Shanghai now the largest hotspot. All 25 million residents are under lockdown, with national health care workers and the Chinese military dispatched to boost the city's response.

On Tuesday, the country recorded more than 20,000 new cases -- far past the peak of Wuhan in 2020, at the onset of the pandemic.

Though this number is still far lower than in many other countries, it's a dramatic spike for China, which has adhered to a strict zero-Covid strategy that aims to stamp out all outbreaks and chains of transmission using border controls, mass testing, quarantines and stringent lockdowns.
The sustainability of that policy is now under question, as newer, highly-infectious Covid variants continue to spread throughout the population.
Here's what you need to know about the latest outbreak.

What parts of China are being hit?​

1649271953785.png


In early March, cases began rising in several provinces around the country including Shandong in the east, Guangdong in the south, and Jilin in the northeast.

By the end of the month, the virus had spread to 29 of China's 31 provinces, according to the National Health Commission (NHC). 90% of all cases identified in March came from Jilin and Shanghai, the two largest hotspots.

Several cities, collectively home to more than 37 million residents, were placed under varying levels of lockdown in March. Many of those lockdowns eased by early April -- leaving Shanghai the outlier, as authorities struggle to get its cases under control.

So far, only two Covid deaths have been officially reported during this wave, both coming from Jilin in March.

What is life under lockdown like?​

Shanghai's measures have been expanded and prolonged as the situation deteriorated.

In late March, the Shanghai government denied it had any plans for a citywide lockdown -- even saying reports were "untrue" and disturbing "social order." On March 27, the government announced it would launch a staggered lockdown, first targeting one half of the city, then the other half.

By March 31, the government had abandoned its staggered approach, effectively imposing a citywide lockdown for all 25 million residents who were forbidden from leaving their neighborhoods except to get tested.

The mandatory citywide testing detected a surge in cases, officials said -- prompting them to extend the lockdown until further notice while they "test more, review results, transfer positive cases and analyze the overall Covid situation."

To enforce these measures and meet the demands of the entire locked-down population, more than 30,000 medics and 2,000 military workers have been dispatched to the city, according to state media and the People's Liberation Army.

But the restrictions have also seen a rare surge of public frustration and criticism toward the government, with residents describing challenges accessing basic supplies like food or medicine.

Anger swelled last month after an off-duty nurse in Shanghai died, after being turned away from an emergency ward at her own hospital that was closed for disinfection. Another Shanghai resident died after suffering a medical emergency in his home before being able to reach the hospital.
"We are not killed by Covid, but by the Covid control measures," noted one popular comment on the highly censored Chinese social media platform Weibo.

There was also fresh outrage over Shanghai's policy requiring all Covid-positive patients to be isolated in facilities -- even young children and babies. One mother told CNN she had been separated from her infected 2-year-old daughter on March 29, and was not allowed to enter the isolation ward to stay with her daughter until a week later.

On Monday, one quarantine center in Shanghai launched a parent-child quarantine area. And on Wednesday, Shanghai health authorities announced they would amend the policy, allowing parents who test negative to apply for permission to accompany Covid-positive children with "special needs." They did not specify what conditions would qualify as "special needs."

Parents who test positive can also accompany their Covid-positive children in quarantine facilities.

What variant is spreading?​

Omicron has been driving this surge, with identified cases showing both BA.1 -- the original Omicron -- and other descendant lineages, including BA.1.1 and BA.2.

BA.2, which was first detected in January, is now the main cause of Covid-19 globally and the dominant strain in the United States, according to the World Health Organization and US health authorities.

Since its rise, international case counts -- which had been declining since the first week of January -- have been rising again.
Studies also suggest BA.2 is far more contagious -- though researchers are still studying the severity of this variant. Some epidemiologists have said its basic reproduction number may be as high as 12, meaning each sick person infects an average of 12 others.
That would put it on par with measles, which also spreads through the air. The basic reproduction number for BA.1 is estimated to be about 8.

Will China stick to zero-Covid?​

As the outbreak has stretched on, experts and international observers have speculated over whether this wave, the more transmissible variant, and China's mass vaccination campaign could bring about the end of zero-Covid.

As of Friday, about 78% of the country's 1.4 billion population had been fully vaccinated, according to the NHC.

Before the outbreak, scientists and leaders had hinted they were re-examining the strategy, with one prominent epidemiologist writing on Weibo in early March that zero-Covid would "not remain unchanged forever."

But that now looks like a distant future, with Chinese authorities making clear they consider the alternative -- the virus running rampant nationwide, potentially overwhelming the health system -- the worse option.

Wu Zunyou, chief epidemiologist at the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention, said on Friday that China would "continue to focus on dynamic zero-Covid policy," according to state-run tabloid Global Times. The loosening of restrictions and opening of borders seen in other countries could "cause many problems such as (a squeeze on) medical resources and rising fatalities," he added.

And on Monday, Vice Premier Sun Chunlan said in Shanghai that the city needed "a more determined attitude, more powerful actions, and more efficient coordination" to achieve zero-Covid.

 
.
Many Americans have normalcy bias. They hate seeing things not normal even if it means not solving the problem. I hear so often "why can't things just go back to normal!"

Chinese have problem solving bias. The appearance of normality isn't important, solving the root problem is important.
 
.
I think zero COVID policy need to be revised. It is no longer realistic to keep it up when rest of the world gave up on containment a long time ago. Even if it could be maintained, the social, economic and political cost is too high. Up to 85% of China's population had two vaccine shots. Why bother if you're maintaining zero COVID?

Get everyone vaccinated with booster shots in a span of 3 to 6 months and impose mask mandate instead.
 
.

There's no end in sight for China's Covid lockdowns. Here's what you need to know​

View attachment 831144
Hong Kong (CNN)Millions of people across China's locked-down financial hub of Shanghai have been desperately seeking medical care and basic supplies like food. Parents have been forcibly separated from young children infected with Covid-19. And public anger is mounting, with no end in sight as China clamps down.
Since March, China has battled its biggest Covid wave yet, with Shanghai now the largest hotspot. All 25 million residents are under lockdown, with national health care workers and the Chinese military dispatched to boost the city's response.

On Tuesday, the country recorded more than 20,000 new cases -- far past the peak of Wuhan in 2020, at the onset of the pandemic.

Though this number is still far lower than in many other countries, it's a dramatic spike for China, which has adhered to a strict zero-Covid strategy that aims to stamp out all outbreaks and chains of transmission using border controls, mass testing, quarantines and stringent lockdowns.
The sustainability of that policy is now under question, as newer, highly-infectious Covid variants continue to spread throughout the population.
Here's what you need to know about the latest outbreak.

What parts of China are being hit?​

View attachment 831143

In early March, cases began rising in several provinces around the country including Shandong in the east, Guangdong in the south, and Jilin in the northeast.

By the end of the month, the virus had spread to 29 of China's 31 provinces, according to the National Health Commission (NHC). 90% of all cases identified in March came from Jilin and Shanghai, the two largest hotspots.

Several cities, collectively home to more than 37 million residents, were placed under varying levels of lockdown in March. Many of those lockdowns eased by early April -- leaving Shanghai the outlier, as authorities struggle to get its cases under control.

So far, only two Covid deaths have been officially reported during this wave, both coming from Jilin in March.

What is life under lockdown like?​

Shanghai's measures have been expanded and prolonged as the situation deteriorated.

In late March, the Shanghai government denied it had any plans for a citywide lockdown -- even saying reports were "untrue" and disturbing "social order." On March 27, the government announced it would launch a staggered lockdown, first targeting one half of the city, then the other half.

By March 31, the government had abandoned its staggered approach, effectively imposing a citywide lockdown for all 25 million residents who were forbidden from leaving their neighborhoods except to get tested.

The mandatory citywide testing detected a surge in cases, officials said -- prompting them to extend the lockdown until further notice while they "test more, review results, transfer positive cases and analyze the overall Covid situation."

To enforce these measures and meet the demands of the entire locked-down population, more than 30,000 medics and 2,000 military workers have been dispatched to the city, according to state media and the People's Liberation Army.

But the restrictions have also seen a rare surge of public frustration and criticism toward the government, with residents describing challenges accessing basic supplies like food or medicine.

Anger swelled last month after an off-duty nurse in Shanghai died, after being turned away from an emergency ward at her own hospital that was closed for disinfection. Another Shanghai resident died after suffering a medical emergency in his home before being able to reach the hospital.
"We are not killed by Covid, but by the Covid control measures," noted one popular comment on the highly censored Chinese social media platform Weibo.

There was also fresh outrage over Shanghai's policy requiring all Covid-positive patients to be isolated in facilities -- even young children and babies. One mother told CNN she had been separated from her infected 2-year-old daughter on March 29, and was not allowed to enter the isolation ward to stay with her daughter until a week later.

On Monday, one quarantine center in Shanghai launched a parent-child quarantine area. And on Wednesday, Shanghai health authorities announced they would amend the policy, allowing parents who test negative to apply for permission to accompany Covid-positive children with "special needs." They did not specify what conditions would qualify as "special needs."

Parents who test positive can also accompany their Covid-positive children in quarantine facilities.

What variant is spreading?​

Omicron has been driving this surge, with identified cases showing both BA.1 -- the original Omicron -- and other descendant lineages, including BA.1.1 and BA.2.

BA.2, which was first detected in January, is now the main cause of Covid-19 globally and the dominant strain in the United States, according to the World Health Organization and US health authorities.

Since its rise, international case counts -- which had been declining since the first week of January -- have been rising again.
Studies also suggest BA.2 is far more contagious -- though researchers are still studying the severity of this variant. Some epidemiologists have said its basic reproduction number may be as high as 12, meaning each sick person infects an average of 12 others.
That would put it on par with measles, which also spreads through the air. The basic reproduction number for BA.1 is estimated to be about 8.

Will China stick to zero-Covid?​

As the outbreak has stretched on, experts and international observers have speculated over whether this wave, the more transmissible variant, and China's mass vaccination campaign could bring about the end of zero-Covid.

As of Friday, about 78% of the country's 1.4 billion population had been fully vaccinated, according to the NHC.

Before the outbreak, scientists and leaders had hinted they were re-examining the strategy, with one prominent epidemiologist writing on Weibo in early March that zero-Covid would "not remain unchanged forever."

But that now looks like a distant future, with Chinese authorities making clear they consider the alternative -- the virus running rampant nationwide, potentially overwhelming the health system -- the worse option.

Wu Zunyou, chief epidemiologist at the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention, said on Friday that China would "continue to focus on dynamic zero-Covid policy," according to state-run tabloid Global Times. The loosening of restrictions and opening of borders seen in other countries could "cause many problems such as (a squeeze on) medical resources and rising fatalities," he added.

And on Monday, Vice Premier Sun Chunlan said in Shanghai that the city needed "a more determined attitude, more powerful actions, and more efficient coordination" to achieve zero-Covid.

One lockdown in shanghai for around 10 days is enough to trigger the propaganda machine. Check the death rate in US, I am. In Shanghai now btw.
 
.
I think zero COVID policy need to be revised. It is no longer realistic to keep it up when rest of the world gave up on containment a long time ago. Even if it could be maintained, the social, economic and political cost is too high. Up to 85% of China's population had two vaccine shots. Why bother if you're maintaining zero COVID?

Get everyone vaccinated with booster shots in a span of 3 to 6 months and impose mask mandate instead.
Disagree. The outbreaks are mainly in Shanghai and Jilin. Which means they are still controlable. China's GDP per capita is 1/6 of US. Population is 4 times bigger than US. And population density is higher than 4 times of US. Lives and medical cost will be huge if giving up zero covid policy.

Omicron is definitely not the last variation. The virus is still mutating. Who knows what monster could be created in the future. China should be patient. Wait and watch closely.
 
Last edited:
. .
Disagree. The outbreaks are mainly in Shanghai and Jilin. Which means they are still controlable. China's GDP per capita is 1/6 of US. Population is 4 times bigger than US. And population dense is higher than 4 times of US. Lives and medical cost will be huge if giving up zero covid policy.

Omicron is definitely not the last variation. The virus is still mutating. Who knows what monster could be created in the future. China should be patient. Wait and watch closely.

At this point, the cost of maintaining a zero COVID policy outweighs its benefits. China cannot go through endless cycles of lockdowns, especially against a variant that is the least deadly so far. How many people will lose their jobs? Be denied access to healthcare? Go hungry not being able to buy food? Zero COVID made sense when the virus was still relatively unknown and much deadlier, but that has changed. Past success does not mean it is suitable for situation today.
 
.
At this point, the cost of maintaining a zero COVID policy outweighs its benefits. China cannot go through endless cycles of lockdowns, especially against a variant that is the least deadly so far. How many people will lose their jobs? Be denied access to healthcare? Go hungry not being able to buy food? Zero COVID made sense when the virus was still relatively unknown and much deadlier, but that has changed. Past success does not mean it is suitable for situation today.
Now many Americans are still dying due to the virus. More people are in hospitals. The virus damages never end. Americans just keep blind eyes on that. But China can't pretend there is nothing happening.

China's policy is flexible zero covid. Lockdowning whole city for small number of cases won't be necessary. Like Beijing did. I don't know how the situation went so bad in Shanghai. Is it because Shanghai is most pro-west city next to Hongkong in China? After this new wave outbreak is extinguished, normal life will be back. Zero covid is short pain. Giving up will be long pain. And probably irreparable disaster.
 
Last edited:
.
Is it because Shanghai is most pro-west city next to Hongkong in China?

Shanghai is much more integrated into the global economy than other cities in China. Eg; Shanghai has the busiest port in the world. If it's disrupted, global trade will be affected along with other Chinese regions which trade with the rest of the world depending on the Yangtze River. Ships will get stuck in the East China Sea. It also a larger share of high value-added foreign investments, eg, Tesla manufacturing. If their business operations keep getting disrupted every quarter, they might move out.
Thus the cost of imposing Covid measures is much higher in Shanghai and they are more hesitant to implement them.

Also, Shanghai pride themselves for having more sophisticated governance and despise the crude measures implemented by other Chinese province which include measures like killing pets or smashing mahjong tables. Earlier they went for '精准防控' like zoning a single bubble tea shop instead of 一刀切 measurements. That level of measures obviously wasn't enough for Omicron.
 
.
What did US and cheerleaders learn from 1 million Americans loss?

Nothing, absolutely nothing.
Since you are in US, you should have known the difference between Americans and Chinese regarding death.

Americans abhor man-made and intentional death but tolerate death by natural causes. This pandemic, though some Americans blame on China, is still largely viewed as a natural phenomenon. Some may at a time blame on the government on inadequate protection but most feels powerless against nature.

Chinese abhor death no matter the cause.

Many Americans have normalcy bias. They hate seeing things not normal even if it means not solving the problem. I hear so often "why can't things just go back to normal!"

Chinese have problem solving bias. The appearance of normality isn't important, solving the root problem is important.
Not really. The whole thing in China is highly politicized. It is not that solving the root problem is important. It is to maintain the appearance of competent ruling (a normalcy bias by China's government).
 
.
Since you are in US, you should have known the difference between Americans and Chinese regarding death.

Americans abhor man-made and intentional death but tolerate death by natural causes. This pandemic, though some Americans blame on China, is still largely viewed as a natural phenomenon. Some may at a time blame on the government on inadequate protection but most feels powerless against nature.

Chinese abhor death no matter the cause.


Not really. The whole thing in China is highly politicized. It is not that solving the root problem is important. It is to maintain the appearance of competent ruling (a normalcy bias by China's government).
I think if death rate is 50% percent, American will change their view
 
.
I think if death rate is 50% percent, American will change their view
Even then, their view may not be going against their government, while Chinese certainly will. When a government reaches to almost every part of people's lives, its responsibility grows proportionally.
 
. . .
What did US and cheerleaders learn from 1 million Americans loss?

Nothing, absolutely nothing.
I am. In shanghai now, first 3 days was a bit chaotic, but now its okay, 10 to 20 restaurants operating within a 5km radius with delivery slower by 1 hour so. I order an hour earlier, food supplies are okay except fresh veges and fresh meat, so I order restaurant bbq.

I think if death rate is 50% percent, American will change their view
I think zero. Covid is a good strategy if you can manage it, to be fair the major factories are all still running and ports are all still running. Both Pfizer and Chinese vaccines are useless against omicron spread, but for severe infection and deaths, both are reporting very low rate, with Pfizer having better efficacy.
 
Last edited:
.
Back
Top Bottom