What's new

The U.S. Empire is 'Fraying' and 'Collapsing': Pentagon Study

Banglar Bir

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Mar 19, 2006
Messages
7,805
Reaction score
-3
Country
United States
Location
United States
The U.S. Empire is 'Fraying' and 'Collapsing': Pentagon Study

Report says Washington should consider the "post-primacy" milieu as a "wakeup call".


Published 21 July 2017

A study by the Pentagon,"At Our Own Peril: DoD Risk Assessment in a Post-Primacy World" says the U.S. framework of international order that was established after World War II is "fraying" and “collapsing."

RELATED:
Pentagon Wastes $30 Million on Wrong Afghan Military Uniforms

“While the United States remains a global political, economic, and military giant, it no longer enjoys an unassailable position versus state competitors,” the report claims.

“In brief, the status quo that was hatched and nurtured by U.S. strategists after World War II and has for decades been the principal ‘beat’ for DoD is not merely fraying but may, in fact, be collapsing.”

The study is based on a year-long research and was released last month by the U.S. Army War College’s Strategic Studies Institute to evaluate the Department of Defense's approach to assessing risk at all levels of Pentagon policy planning.

Having lost its past status of "pre-eminence," Washington now inhabits a dangerous, unpredictable "competitive" "post-primacy" world, whose defining feature is “resistance to authority," the document says, conceding to its imperialist nature.

According to the Pentagon findings, the nation's power is in decline because the world that has essentially entered a new phase of transformation, where the international order is unraveling, and the authority of governments everywhere is crumbling.

The report warns that “global events will happen faster than the Defense Department is currently equipped to handle,” and that the U.S. “can no longer count on the unassailable position of dominance, supremacy, or pre-eminence it enjoyed for the 20-plus years after the fall of the Soviet Union.”

It also recounts that competing powers, Russia and China, along with others like Iran and North Korea, have played a major role in removing the U.S. from its position of global “pre-eminence".

It describes Russia and China as “revisionist forces,” who benefit from the US-dominated international order but now “seek a new distribution of power and authority commensurate with their emergence as legitimate rivals to U.S. dominance.”

The U.S. should consider the "post-primacy" milieu as a "wakeup call" and if it doesn't adapt to this “post-primacy” environment, the complexity and speed of world events will “increasingly defy [DoD’s] current strategy, planning, and risk assessment conventions and biases.”

RELATED:
New Star Wars? US House Pushes for New Pentagon 'Space Corps'

The U.S. Army War College study concludes that it's not just the U.S. that is seeing a decline, “[A]ll states and traditional political authority structures are under increasing pressure from endogenous and exogenous forces… The fracturing of the post-Cold War global system is accompanied by the internal fraying in the political, social, and economic fabric of practically all states," it states.

The report suggests expanding the U.S. military as the only option by which it can gain back its stature in the world sphere, and it further demands U.S. military force needs to be powerful enough to preserve “maximum freedom of action”, and allow Washignton to “dictate or hold significant sway over outcomes in international disputes.”

http://www.telesurtv.net/english/ne...-Collapsing-Pentagon-Study-20170721-0024.html
 
.
WTF? Russian power is just a shell of its old self. Name something they suddenly now have that they didn't have before? Now name all the stuff they have lost (Soviet states, the entire Eastern block).

The majority of their Navy are rusting hulks. Their bombers are struggling to maintain their old cold war flight routes. They haven't even put a new bomber design into production since their collapse. In fact they still use turboprops.

Screen Shot 2017-07-22 at 10.17.30 PM.jpg

C'mon this is the 21st Century. What's up with the propellors?

Screen Shot 2017-07-22 at 10.20.54 PM.jpg

Even our old 1955 era B52's can fly faster.
 
Last edited:
. . .
The U.S. Empire is 'Fraying' and 'Collapsing': Pentagon Study

Report says Washington should consider the "post-primacy" milieu as a "wakeup call".


Published 21 July 2017

A study by the Pentagon,"At Our Own Peril: DoD Risk Assessment in a Post-Primacy World" says the U.S. framework of international order that was established after World War II is "fraying" and “collapsing."

RELATED:
Pentagon Wastes $30 Million on Wrong Afghan Military Uniforms

“While the United States remains a global political, economic, and military giant, it no longer enjoys an unassailable position versus state competitors,” the report claims.

“In brief, the status quo that was hatched and nurtured by U.S. strategists after World War II and has for decades been the principal ‘beat’ for DoD is not merely fraying but may, in fact, be collapsing.”

The study is based on a year-long research and was released last month by the U.S. Army War College’s Strategic Studies Institute to evaluate the Department of Defense's approach to assessing risk at all levels of Pentagon policy planning.

Having lost its past status of "pre-eminence," Washington now inhabits a dangerous, unpredictable "competitive" "post-primacy" world, whose defining feature is “resistance to authority," the document says, conceding to its imperialist nature.

According to the Pentagon findings, the nation's power is in decline because the world that has essentially entered a new phase of transformation, where the international order is unraveling, and the authority of governments everywhere is crumbling.

The report warns that “global events will happen faster than the Defense Department is currently equipped to handle,” and that the U.S. “can no longer count on the unassailable position of dominance, supremacy, or pre-eminence it enjoyed for the 20-plus years after the fall of the Soviet Union.”

It also recounts that competing powers, Russia and China, along with others like Iran and North Korea, have played a major role in removing the U.S. from its position of global “pre-eminence".

It describes Russia and China as “revisionist forces,” who benefit from the US-dominated international order but now “seek a new distribution of power and authority commensurate with their emergence as legitimate rivals to U.S. dominance.”

The U.S. should consider the "post-primacy" milieu as a "wakeup call" and if it doesn't adapt to this “post-primacy” environment, the complexity and speed of world events will “increasingly defy [DoD’s] current strategy, planning, and risk assessment conventions and biases.”

RELATED:
New Star Wars? US House Pushes for New Pentagon 'Space Corps'

The U.S. Army War College study concludes that it's not just the U.S. that is seeing a decline, “[A]ll states and traditional political authority structures are under increasing pressure from endogenous and exogenous forces… The fracturing of the post-Cold War global system is accompanied by the internal fraying in the political, social, and economic fabric of practically all states," it states.

The report suggests expanding the U.S. military as the only option by which it can gain back its stature in the world sphere, and it further demands U.S. military force needs to be powerful enough to preserve “maximum freedom of action”, and allow Washignton to “dictate or hold significant sway over outcomes in international disputes.”

http://www.telesurtv.net/english/ne...-Collapsing-Pentagon-Study-20170721-0024.html
someone wants DoD budget increased

WTF? Russian power is just a shell of its old self. Name something they suddenly now have that they didn't have before? Now name all the stuff they have lost (Soviet states, the entire Eastern block).

The majority of their Navy are rusting hulks. Their bombers are struggling to maintain their old cold war flight routes. They haven't even put a new bomber design into production since their collapse. In fact they still use turboprops.

View attachment 413355
C'mon this is the 21st Century. What's up with the propellors?

View attachment 413356
Even our old 1955 era B52's can fly faster.

Russian bomber force is potent. They can fire long range cruise missiles from thousand miles and fly away
 
.
A study by the Pentagon,"At Our Own Peril: DoD Risk Assessment in a Post-Primacy World" says the U.S. framework of international order that was established after World War II is "fraying" and “collapsing."
It is not the collapse of the system per say but the world at large has changed quite a bit. For starters the Asian region has new players and China is the major one which is challenging American influence, both in the political and military spheres. Also it is replacing America in financing projects and building inroads into Africa which is a set back to American dominance. While it has not in any sense negated American influence, it has become a balancing power to it in the region.
Russia on the other hand has made inroads to the Middle East, bringing with it an end to total dominance of the USA in that region. With Syria and by extension thru Iran, influence into Iraq and Lebanon has increased drastically cutting the US influence in the region. With Turkey and Europe having serious difficulties, and Turkish-US relations deteriorating Russia has gained some influence in the region but America again is still a major player in the region.
And on to Europe, with Trump causing alarm bells to ring in the EU, and their leaders looking towards a world where they could not count on total US support. With Merkel going on record to saying that Europe can no longer completely rely on its longstanding British and US allies with the G7.
To close one's eyes to the economic and geopolitical changes of the last few years would be a folly. To say it is the start of the end is a shot in the dark. Only time will tell how things unfold, but the world has changed and things will be much more difficult to manage now. Whether it starts another multi-front cold war or things slowly turn too a more multi polar world is what remains to be seen.
The sky is falling! The sky is falling!
Trump and his hair spray.... The sky died of the fumes and is falling down now....
C'mon this is the 21st Century. What's up with the propellors?
White Swan, underestimate your adversaries at your own risk.
 
. . . .
You are "Think Tank Analyst"?

China is set to eclipse the US as the world's most powerful country by around 2030.

China's future navy doesn't need to show up with 12 aircraft carrier battlegroups, but China will re-invented a new naval warfare mode with the half-submerged battleship that equipped with direct energy weapons. A new powerful railgun with the range over 1000 km that is sufficient to decimate an entire AC battlegroup, and a real laser weapon that can incinerate a group of incoming ICBMs, not the fake one that can barely burn off a small drone.

China got the DC electrical system, it is the key that paves the path toward the futuristic energy weapons, while the AC electrical system is completely a failure and a nowayout dead end.
 
Last edited:
. .
WTF? Russian power is just a shell of its old self. Name something they suddenly now have that they didn't have before? Now name all the stuff they have lost (Soviet states, the entire Eastern block).

The majority of their Navy are rusting hulks. Their bombers are struggling to maintain their old cold war flight routes. They haven't even put a new bomber design into production since their collapse. In fact they still use turboprops.

View attachment 413355
C'mon this is the 21st Century. What's up with the propellors?

View attachment 413356
Even our old 1955 era B52's can fly faster.
The Kuznetsov NK-12 are still the most powerful turboprop engine ever built. So what if B52 is faster? Both are cruise missile launch platforms, so what matters are their missiles.
 
.
You are "Think Tank Analyst"?

China is set to eclipse the US as the world's most powerful country by around 2030.

And you are more of a pro China hyper nationalist than most of the actual Chinese nationalists on PDF.

In your eyes, they're already practically a hyper power that can do no wrong. And the u.s. is practically a third world country with primitive technology.

So not surprised by your usual cheerleading nationalist comment. And that's all that really needs to be said about that.

But hey, I'll see you in 2030 ok? :tup:

But I digress, and don't want to go too far OT.
 
Last edited:
.
This is an Ideal time to be a US ally and friend

No wonder India US ties are booming
 
. .

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom