The Shameful state of the Indian Navy

[DarK-LorD]

IAMA US Marine and I trained with Pakistani SSG.I am writing up- my experience as we speak. By the time Reddit verifies my authenticity, I would have managed a couple of 60 page threads on PDF for sure. How about you be US Airforce guy and write up a similar story?

All this SSG-US Marine would be boring.
Best Story would be I am A Chinese Fighter Pilot & I saw 40 J-20's in Pakistan.I can only imagine the celebrations then.I guess it would even be made sticky.

 

[Kinetic]

^^^

Just an update pmukherjee, the "officer's" profile was deleted on reddit.com. There goes the credibility out the window...

Also I was wondering about the "civilian underclass" he spoke of. Is there any truth to this? Do civilians actually live onboard warships? (I thought it was a stretch, but just asking to make sure).

You have put water in their short enjoyment. They cannot talk about IN directly, it is always via.

 

[Abu Zolfiqar]

PLease dont link up to utterly uncredible sources and start bashing the Navy.

You would understand the credibility of the article as soon as you see the other articles on the same page.

Again, any person with a decent knowledge of naval practises can pose as a sailor and vomit any crap. That doesn't make him a sailor.

Infact I would not be surprised if the "USN sailor" actually turned up to be a jealous/jobless Pakistani in real life !

and you sound like a disgruntled, under-employed indian in real life and in cyber-space.

good work

 

[53fd]

I doubt a Pakistani would derail a thread about Pakistan as much the Indians have done here. After all, they were the ones that mentioned Pakistan on this thread in the first place. The first person to mention religion on this thread was an Indian as well. Then they went from 1948 Kashmir, 1971, 1999 Kargil War, to Mukhtara Mian, Asia bibi, to Islam, Madrassahs, suicide bombing; & an Indian member even posted a video about a 2 year old Pakistani girl getting raped, along with another one on Pakistani inbreeding.

 

[Dalai Lama]

IAMA US Marine and I trained with Pakistani SSG.I am writing up- my experience as we speak. By the time Reddit verifies my authenticity, I would have managed a couple of 60 page threads on PDF for sure. How about you be some US Airforce guy and write up a similar story?

He also managed 800 points and approx. 400 replies on reddit. I have to say, I had my suspicions about some of his stories about sandals, civilian "slaves", smelly ship etc. I mean, I'm sure IN isn't up to the standards of USN but he pushed his luck with some of these tales. Had he been a little less ambitious; he might have pulled this propaganda stunt off, who knows...

 

[Roybot]

He also managed 800 points and approx. 400 replies on reddit. I have to say, I had my suspicions about some of his stories about sandals, civilian "slaves", smelly ship etc. I mean, I'm sure IN isn't up to the standards of USN but he pushed his luck with some of these tales. Had he been a little less ambitious; he might have pulled this propaganda stunt off, who knows...

And the moment he mentioned upper caste/ lower caste bs After reading it I had to make sure it didn't originate from ruppee news or something. Cause it had all the usual ingredients.

 

[DarK-LorD]

I doubt a Pakistani would derail a thread about Pakistan as much the Indians have done here. After all, they were the ones that mentioned Pakistan on this thread in the first place. The first person to mention religion on this thread was an Indian as well. Then they went from 1948 Kashmir, 1971, 1999 Kargil War, to Mukhtara Mian, Asia bibi, to Islam; & an Indian member even posted a video about a 2 year old Pakistani girl getting raped, along with another one on Pakistani inbreeding.

Well after all one of Your one's sudden acting ambitions is responsible for this thread.
If You guys are such gentlemen Why did you reply to all this?

 

[Kinetic]

and you sound like a disgruntled, under-employed indian in real life and in cyber-space.

good work

and thanks for proving again in what you are good, 'personal attack'!!!! You cannot post anything better than this.

 

[Kyusuibu Honbu]

I doubt a Pakistani would derail a thread about Pakistan as much the Indians have done here. After all, they were the ones that mentioned Pakistan on this thread in the first place. The first person to mention religion on this thread was an Indian as well. Then they went from 1948 Kashmir, 1971, 1999 Kargil War, to Mukhtara Mian, Asia bibi, to Islam, Madrassahs, suicide bombing; & an Indian member even posted a video about a 2 year old Pakistani girl getting raped, along with another one on Pakistani inbreeding.

There is on old saying : you"re a bigger fool when pay attention to another fool"

So that makes the three of us here.

 

[53fd]

Well after all one of Your one's sudden acting ambitions is responsible for this thread.
If You guys are such gentlemen Why did you reply to all this?

Again, Pakistanis did not start the argument on this thread, neither did they stoop to the levels some Indian members here did.

 

[Dalai Lama]

^^^

Alright guys, chill. You've been fighting for roughly 10 hours now. Let the thread die it's death. I'll be expecting to see a lot of pinkies tomorrow.

 

[DarK-LorD]

Again, Pakistanis did not start the argument on this thread, neither did they stoop to the levels some Indian members here did.

But they definitely started the argument in Red***.

 

[53fd]

But they definitely started the argument in Red***.

No, but it was an Indian that started this thread as well.

 

[DarK-LorD]

No, but it was an Indian that started this thread as well.

He was just concerned about the news.This wouldn't have unless a fake US officer from 24° 52' 0" N / 67° 3' 0" E started this.

 

[blain2]

Let him be.

That's what I actually said. He,whoever wrote this, must be one jealous load of crap and not a real sailor who had written it in an objective way based on real experience.

He is a real sailor for sure and actually a commissioned officer. What he said was factual and to the point. The point about the PN was not being able to produce fresh water on the ships, aside from that there was one other compliment for the PN around one of our crew chiefs (CPO) visiting a USN ship and really knowing the CIWS weapon system well which impressed the USN techs working with him.

At the end of the day, you can make what you will of the comments, however the immediate defensive mechanism that goes up is to be expected. It happened with the LTC Fornoff episode and now the same back peddling. However I can guarantee that if similar comments were made about the Pakistani side, you would be swearing by this chaps' comments.

Obviously his comments cannot be used to generalize the entire situation. So take it for what its worth, it is someone's opinion and that is it. If you like to tout all the praise from all over the world, then be ready for some critique as well without always attacking it as a lie.