"Taliban desperate for direct flights to India; We want Kandahar-Delhi services"

[ThunderCat]

Where did you get this idea from? Who said they don't love the country that "took" them "in"?

Lots of them don't. Many Muhajir elites HATE Pakistan and prefer India. There's no denying it.

 

[TheSolution]

Lots of them don't. Many Muhajir elites HATE Pakistan and prefer India. There's no denying it.

Maybe the ones who aren't a native ethnicity perhaps.

But Punjabi "muhajirs" fit right in.

Also same with any secular elite, they are more pro-India.

 

[ThunderCat]

Maybe the ones who aren't a native ethnicity perhaps.

But Punjabi "muhajirs" fit right in.

Also same with any secular elite, they are more pro-India.

Nope. Most "secular elites" that are pro-India are definitely Muhajirs and the Sindhis.

East Punjabis, Biharis, Rajesthanis, Gujaratis all count as Muhajirs and the elites amongst these people are commonly pro-India and same for Sindhi elites.

Elites amongst Pakhtuns, Punjabis, Kashmirs & Balochis typically no, unless you count separatists.

 

[One_Nation]

Nope. Most "secular elites" that are pro-India are definitely Muhajirs and the Sindhis.

East Punjabis, Biharis, Rajesthanis, Gujaratis all count as Muhajirs and the elites amongst these people are commonly pro-India and same for Sindhi elites.

Elites amongst Pakhtuns, Punjabis, Kashmirs & Balochis typically no, unless you count separatists.

Why should they NOT be pro India? They came for Jinnah's Pakistan and ended up in a hellhole with no way of going back.

 

[One_Nation]

Well if Karachi can be seen as Muhajir majority why not Faislabad if what you stated is true? Also i many East Punjabis migrants feel affinity with India, then why should they be exempt?

They feel affinity with Sikhs and Indian Punjabis and not India. There is a big difference between the two.

 

[ThunderCat]

They feel affinity with Sikhs and Indian Punjabis and not India. There is a big difference between the two.

I'm referring to East Punjabi Muslim migrants.

Why should they NOT be pro India? They came for Jinnah's Pakistan and ended up in a hellhole with no way of going back.

They came to satisfy their own greed, only to loose it to West Punjabi hegemony, mostly rooted in the armed forces, so they turned into pro-Indian zealots.

They should have gone back a long time ago. But they refuse to go back without taking their host country with them and THAT is the problem.

 

[One_Nation]

I'm referring to East Punjabi Muslim migrants.



They came to satisfy their own greed, only to loose it to West Punjabi hegemony, mostly rooted in the armed forces, so they turned into pro-Indian zealots.

They should have gone back a long time ago. But they refuse to go back without taking their host country with them and THAT is the problem.

Ahh now I can't even make sense of what you wrote (as usual). Hegemony, greed. Where did that come from?
Why should anyone go back if they lost nationality of their home country already?

 

[ThunderCat]

Ahh now I can't even make sense of what you wrote (as usual). Hegemony, greed. Where did that come from?
Why should anyone go back if they lost nationality of their home country already?

Obvious isn't it? They love India and promote it as an example of "progress." They denounce the imaginary "partition." They want more open borders to visit their relatives. How about making the visit one way?

Pakistanis need to protect their country's interests from such people. I am living in Canada and despite loving my nation, do I call for Canada to become a colony of Pakistan?

How do you think other people would react if I proposed that? What if I propagated things in Canada in favor of Pakistan but at the expense of Canada's sovereignty?

When these people get very defensive against American hegemony, do you think they'd accept foreign hegemony?

If you can't make sense of what I wrote, you've got a problem.

 

[One_Nation]

Obvious isn't it? They love India and promote it as an example of "progress." They denounce the imaginary "partition." They want more open borders to visit their relatives. How about making the visit one way?

Pakistanis need to protect their country's interests from such people. I am living in Canada and despite loving my nation, do I call for Canada to become a colony of Pakistan?

Very delusional thinking you got. Most of the country sees India as example of progress. Many of the Pathans, Balochs and Sindhis have the same feelings about creation of Pakistan. I am sure there are more Pakistani Punjabis who regret partition than mohajir Punjabis.
Even if mohajir's pro-India stance is true which I don't think is, this feeling is mutual among all non-Punjabi Pakistanis.
All of them resent Punjab's leadership position in the country. They put more faith in rag tag militias of mountain men than educated generals and politicians from Punjab. Its because Punjabis lack the character and moral strength to be leaders.
This is what makes Indians look better for so many Pakistanis but you are obsessed with a negligible, almost non-existent group.

 

[ThunderCat]

Very delusional thinking you got. Most of the country sees India as example of progress. Many of the Pathans, Balochs and Sindhis have the same feelings about creation of Pakistan. I am sure there are more Pakistani Punjabis who regret partition than mohajir Punjabis.
Even if mohajir's pro-India stance is true which I don't think is, this feeling is mutual among all non-Punjabi Pakistanis.
All of them resent Punjab's leadership position in the country. They put more faith in rag tag militias of mountain men than educated generals and politicians from Punjab. Its because Punjabis lack the character and moral strength to be leaders.
This is what makes Indians look better for so many Pakistanis but you are obsessed with a negligible, almost non-existent group.