Syed Talat Hussain Column on Malala Book

[Malik Usman]

From the day first in these forums i am saying its just west propaganda, which initially they raised to put pressure on Pak Army to attack on Waziristan.. then later they turn this to other way with other objectives..There are many questions if someone just for a second think on them will get the answers...

1 - Nobel Prize....(that prize is given for some extra ordinary struggle for some thing and he/she must have devoted his/her whole life in this).
but in the Malal's case she was no where before Taliban shooted her, and sunddenly she is entitled for Nobel Prize, and What she did in her life extra ordinary...a big question.?
2 -If Taliban shoot a girl that is entitle for Nobel Prize, but if drone kill many children that is called Collateral Damage.
3 - If you read some paragraphs of the book she is talking about Pakistan's Law and mentioning about Gen. Zia and other rules, when she was not even born
and she is just 16 years old, and she knew all Pakistani Legislative laws (Is not someone else is writing all this with her name?)
4 - Why only Malala where are other two girls shooted with her....nobody even knows there name..
5 - Within last 1 month she got prizes and degrees from some west Universities, like it was raining on her..(I must say west peoples just follow what their govt. and their media tell them, and they don't bother any thing else.)

 

[Patriots]

However,I am totally against Taliban's interpretation of Islam.
Right is right and wrong is wrong,whoever dare to mix right with wrong,following the trait of transgressors to justify their own interpretation will rot inside Hell,I assure you that.
Coming to topic,if you want west for not to produce more Malalas in future as you claim,then I suggest you to resolve lapses and diagnose those hidden moles inside your civil/security sectors.
I assure you then no Malala will ever born and will be used as a tool by west if you will succeed to cure those factors and hostile environment which has gave birth to Malala.

I too against TTP version of Islam .........

This is governments responsibility to giving equal opportunities to all segments of society ... I believe that Zia-Ul-Haq had much damaged to education system in Pakistan ... That's why perhaps in some are has been backward ... But if you will see in cities & towns ... Every where girls are going to school as well as they are doing respectable jobs & support to their families ... There is no any reason in Pakistan to be born of any Malala I think so ..........

 

[Patriots]

From the day first in these forums i am saying its just west propaganda, which initially they raised to put pressure on Pak Army to attack on Waziristan.. then later they turn this to other way with other objectives..There are many questions if someone just for a second think on them will get the answers...

1 - Nobel Prize....(that prize is given for some extra ordinary struggle for some thing and he/she must have devoted his/her whole life in this).
but in the Malal's case she was no where before Taliban shooted her, and sunddenly she is entitled for Nobel Prize, and What she did in her life extra ordinary...a big question.?
2 -If Taliban shoot a girl that is entitle for Nobel Prize, but if drone kill many children that is called Collateral Damage.
3 - If you read some paragraphs of the book she is talking about Pakistan's Law and mentioning about Gen. Zia and other rules, when she was not even born
and she is just 16 years old, and she knew all Pakistani Legislative laws (Is not someone else is writing all this with her name?)
4 - Why only Malala where are other two girls shooted with her....nobody even knows there name..
5 - Within last 1 month she got prizes and degrees from some west Universities, like it was raining on her..(I must say west peoples just follow what their govt. and their media tell them, and they don't bother any thing else.)

Malala even talks about Pakistan's nuclear warheads:
'In Washington the government of President Obama had just announced it was sending 21,000 more troops to Afghanistan to turn round the war against the Taliban. But now they seemed to be more alarmed about Pakistan than Afghanistan. Not because of girls like me and my school but because our country has more than 200 nuclear warheads and they were worried about who was going to control them. They talked about stopping their billions of dollars in aid and sending troops instead (I am Malala -PDF Page 89)

 

[Secur]

Second type of extremist like liberal extremist is also not good because we have our own cultural values but our second type extremist are much impressed western culture and be ashamed to be a good Muslim like 'The camel desiring to have horns lost even his ears' ... They want that Islam should be modified whereas Islamic rules couldn't be changed ... According to Quran it has been completed .........

Even though , I myself detest/hate any kind of extremism from anybody . You may want to correct yourself a bit on the " liberal extremist " because they unlike their religious counterparts do not cause any tangible harm to the society and the state - they do not kill people , they do not blow themselves up , they do not force what they follow on others and most of the time , they accept the difference in opinion from others more than fine and do not harass people having different point of views/opinions . What might not be good is certainly still a thousand times better than the former . Therein lies the difference here .

 

[Patriots]

Even though , I myself detest/hate any kind of extremism from anybody . You may want to correct yourself a bit on the " liberal extremist " because they unlike their religious counterparts do not cause any tangible harm to the society and the state - they do not kill people , they do not blow themselves up , they do not force what they follow on others and most of the time , they accept the difference in opinion from others more than fine and do not harass people having different point of views/opinions . What might not be good is certainly still a thousand times better than the former . Therein lies the difference here .

They kill to people ... We can see liberal fascism in Egypt by extremist liberal army ... Kemalists have been murdering to Islamist in Turkey ...........

Furthermore, they do silent conspiracies against Islam & Pakistan ... We have example in shape of GEO group ............

 

[Secur]

They kill to people ... We can see liberal fascism in Egypt by extremist liberal army ... Kemalists have been murdering to Islamist in Turkey ...........

Furthermore, they do silent conspiracies against Islam & Pakistan ... We have example in shape of GEO group ............

Islamist hadn't been so kind to liberals in Turkiye too , my friend . Anyways , I was specifically referring to my own country . Mate , these " silent conspiracies " usually have no proof , you may not like a certain T.V. channel but to declare it western funded and conspiring is another extreme .

 

[Secur]

Yar, seriously @Secur you have to see this! It's amazing!

http://spyeyesnews.blogspot.com/2013/08/tereek-e-taliban-pakistan-ttp-created.html

Yeah some tattoos and random mumbo jumbo about this and that and the article will be defined as " credible " and " conclusively proving " .

Thats what the whole game thrives on , chief .

 

[Patriots]

Islamist hadn't been so kind to liberals in Turkiye too , my friend . Anyways , I was specifically referring to my own country . Mate , these " silent conspiracies " usually have no proof , you may not like a certain T.V. channel but to declare it western funded and conspiring is another extreme .

I was just saying that any kind of extremism is not good whether it is in Pakistan or somewhere else ... Liberals do massacre in Turky of Islamist or same has been done by Islamist both did wrong ... I just gave you example GEO ... You can count to SAFMA too .........

Anyways I must say sober mindedness is the best policy ..........

 

[jaibi]

You mistake liberalism for authoritarianism.

I've personally met many people who believe there should be Sharait, Khilafat and an allegiance within the Muslim world but through consensus and not enforcement. That's liberalism. So really? Authoritarianism, where you force the other on your opinions, the opinions do not matter, really, that's bad. I'm not saying your opinion is bad or wrong, just saying there is not credible evidence for it. Do you get that? All everyone needs is a respect for what they believe in. Over here you talk about something either you become a Kafir/Shia/Anti-Pakistani, that's complete BS, that's what's wrong.

I was just saying that any kind of extremism is not good whether it is in Pakistan or somewhere else ... Liberals do massacre in Turky of Islamist or same has been done by Islamist both did wrong ... I just gave you example GEO ... You can count to SAFMA too .........

Anyways I must say sober mindedness is the best policy ..........