What's new

Sin Tax / Gunah Tax

If it is a sin than ban it totally. Other wise government should consider getting sin tax on prostitution, alcoholic drinks too.
Question, by giving sin tax, will I be acquitted on the day of judgment ????
 
.
People get ill by secondary smoke too - others smoking and someone getting caught in the middle.


If Social welfare is important, then government would ban it.

If Money is important, then the government would tax it.

You are a good man like IK. So I will share good song for you.

 
. . .
Good so it should. Can't afford food but can afford cigarettes. Shame on them all.
a privileged person shaming the poor and destitute......you must be a musalman. Cigarettes are cheaper that food, and people don't smoke to get vitamins they do it to ease the daily grind. I hope you get to live those days.
 
.
if gov want to earn then impose sin tax on below items
masterbation
lies
smoking
abuses (akeely punjab main daily 1trillion galiyaan di jati hain):rofl:
alcohol
hashish
herion
gf-bf
politicians (as they lie 24/7)
passing urine in public
bacha baazi (50% discount to pathan bhais ):rofl:



10 din main 1000bn rupees akhty hoon gay :enjoy:
 
.
People get ill by secondary smoke too - others smoking and someone getting caught in the middle.
how about we stop driving cars, motorcycles, buses because they produce more secondary smoke....next we can shut down the factories and power plants. Taxing in such cases does not help.
 
.
a privileged person shaming the poor and destitute......you must be a musalman. Cigarettes are cheaper that food, and people don't smoke to get vitamins they do it to ease the daily grind. I hope you get to live those days.

No an akalmand insaan telling a jahil how to improve himself. First they take food from the stomach of thier children by spending on cigarettes, then they punish them again when they are forced to beg for money to pay for the heart disease, lung problems and cancer treatments.
 
Last edited:
.
how about we stop driving cars, motorcycles, buses because they produce more secondary smoke....next we can shut down the factories and power plants. Taxing in such cases does not help.

1. Cars, motorcycles, buses - Any actual "Smart City" would have abolished privately-owned transport in favor of public transport. It can be a mixed implementation of buses or Personal Rapid Transit vehicles like Pod Taxis. In either case the propulsion method can be replaced from Petrol/Diesel/CNG to Salt-water ( Ionic Liquid ) as demonstrated in the Quant car. This will shake-up the petro-based world economy.

2. Factories - 3D Printing was meant to remove traditional factories from various processes to make products at personal or neighborhood level. This "make it when you actually want it" approach combined with socialist communes ( "from each according to ability, to each according to needs" ) will create a society where pollution is reduced to a large extent.

3. Power plants - Again, Salt-water-fueled power plants at device level, house level and neighborhood level can replace the current nuclear, hydro, solar, coal, oil plants. Also, this vid from Pakistan is interesting, for it claims to generate free energy.

@Valar.
 
.
Marketing 101...Appeals both sides I hope - Educated for letting go off cigarette as it is getting more expensive and the Mullah who should also be taxed for cussing!
The increase in price of cigarettes no longer affects me as i quit smoking and got insomnia as a result :D

if gov want to earn then impose sin tax on below items
masterbation
lies
smoking
abuses (akeely punjab main daily 1trillion galiyaan di jati hain):rofl:
alcohol
hashish
herion
gf-bf
politicians (as they lie 24/7)
passing urine in public
bacha baazi (50% discount to pathan bhais ):rofl:



10 din main 1000bn rupees akhty hoon gay :enjoy:
Mangoman ki zindaagi mein chand pal khushi key kiyon cheen rahey ho?

20 pack of B&H gold here is £12. Pointless nasty habit. Don't even give you a buzz.
Oh tuadi pen di siri
I used to smoke 4-5 (10 at peak) a day damn it wouldve made my pocket empty in a week or something :D
 
.
Seemingly neither this "Sin Tax" have something to do with Islam nor it is named as by the PTI government, rather it was originated in United States. Some comments in this thread are probably the result of lack of information.


Sin tax

A sin tax is an excise or sales tax specifically levied on certain goods deemed harmful to society and individuals, for example alcohol and tobacco, candies, drugs, soft drinks, fast foods, coffee, sugar, gambling and pornography. Two claimed purposes are usually used to argue for such taxes. In contrast to Pigovian taxes, which are to pay for the damage to society caused by these goods, sin taxes are used to increase the price in an effort to lower their use, or failing that, to increase and find new sources of revenue. Increasing a sin tax is often more popular than increasing other taxes. However, these taxes have often been criticized for burdening the poor, taxing the physically and mentally dependent, and being part of a nanny state.

Summary

Sin tax is used for taxes on activities that are considered socially undesirable. In many cases, sumptuary taxes are implemented to mitigate use of alcohol and tobacco, gambling, and vehicles emitting excessive pollutants. Sumptuary tax on sugar and soft drinks has also been suggested; see soda tax. Some jurisdictions have also levied taxes on recreational drugs such as marijuana.

Revenue generated by sin taxes supports many projects imperative in accomplishing social and economic goals. American cities and counties have utilized funds from sin taxes to expand infrastructure, while in Sweden the tax for gambling is used for helping people with gambling problems. Acceptance of sumptuary taxes may be greater than income tax or sales tax.

Support

Proponents argue that the consumption of tobacco and alcohol, the behaviors associated with consumption, or both consumption and the behaviors of consumption, are immoral or "sinful", hence the label "sin tax". For example, Mayo Clinic anesthesiologists Dr. Michael Joyner and Dr. David Warner support increasing taxes on tobacco and alcohol, with the goal of using tax codes to help change behavior and improve health.

Tobacco and alcohol consumption has been linked to a variety of medical problems. In the United States alone, over 440,000 annual deaths are considered to be related to smoking tobacco. A synthesis of 67 studies found that there was evidence indicating tobacco taxation is responsible for "reducing smoking behavior among youth, young adults, and persons of low socioeconomic status, compared to the general population," although no evidence was found indicating this was true for long-term smokers or American Indians.

Following the medical argument, consumers of tobacco and alcohol cause a greater financial burden on society by forcing others to pay for medical treatment of conditions stemming from such consumption, especially in most first-world countries with government-funded healthcare.

The moral, medical and financial arguments are occasionally considered in contemporary news settings.

Opposition

Sin taxes have been linked to smuggling and black markets of the taxed products.

Critics of sin tax argue that it is a regressive tax in nature and discriminates against the lower classes, since taxation of a product such as alcohol or cigarettes does not account for ability to pay, therefore poor people pay a greater share of their income as tax.

Sin taxes fail to affect consumers' behaviors in the way that tax proponents suggest, for instance increasing smokers' propensity to smoke high-tar, high-nicotine cigarettes when the per-pack price is raised and increasing the rate of people mixing their own drinks rather than buying pre-mix alcoholic spirits.

The government may become reliant on the revenue from the tax and have to encourage "sinful" behavior in order to maintain the revenue stream.

Reference: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sin_tax
 
Last edited:
. . .
finally someone who understands what a sin tax is.


its not a term coined by PTI. please google the definition of sin tax.
My dear u understand it. I underatamd it just look at the title of the thread.....GUNAH TAX.

Hope that clarifies my point.
 
.
My dear u understand it. I underatamd it just look at the title of the thread.....GUNAH TAX.

Hope that clarifies my point.
urdu main kia tarjuma karain sin tax ka? ap bata dein...
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom